26-282MR Full Federal Court dismisses ASIC appeal against former Freedom Insurance director

The Full Court of the Federal Court has today dismissed ASIC's appeal against an earlier decision of the Federal Court dismissing ASIC’s proceedings against former Freedom Insurance director, Keith Cohen, over his alleged involvement in the company’s sales incentive programs.

While finding for ASIC that the sales incentives offered by Freedom Insurance were conflicted remuneration under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the Full Court ultimately upheld the dismissal of ASIC's proceedings against Mr Cohen.

ASIC had appealed the Federal Court's decision, which dismissed ASIC’s claims that Mr Cohen and a former consultant of Freedom Insurance, Robert Oayda, were allegedly knowingly involved in alleged breaches of conflicted remuneration laws, and that Mr Cohen had allegedly breached his directors' duties. ASIC’s appeal against the decision as it related to Mr Oayda was withdrawn by consent on 19 December 2025.

The Full Court’s decision today clarifies the law in relation to the conflicted remuneration regime.

Download

Judgment

Background

ASIC commenced civil penalty proceedings against former Freedom Insurance director Mr Cohen and former Freedom Insurance consultant Robert Oayda in October 2021, alleging contraventions relating to sales incentive programs operated by the Freedom Group between November 2017 and October 2018 (21-279MR).

On 16 October 2025, the Federal Court dismissed ASIC's claims against both individuals (25-238MR).

ASIC filed an appeal on 11 November 2025. The appeal was heard by the Full Federal Court on 26 and 27 August 2026.

Freedom Insurance was a case study during round six of the Financial Services Royal Commission. ASIC commenced its investigation before the Royal Commission's final recommendations.

The Freedom Group of companies entered external administration in February 2020 and were subsequently deregistered.