ASIC Annual Forum 2026

Media content from ASIC Annual Forum 2026 will be added to this page as sessions are completed. You will be able to access media releases, key speeches, photos, audio and other highlights from the forum.

If you wish to contact a member of ASIC’s media team please email: media.unit@asic.gov.au.

Annual Forum 2026: Day 1 program

Session Related links

Opening address by Sarah Court, Chair, ASIC

Full audio (MP3 4.8 MB)

Full video (MP4 167.8 MB)

Speech

Gallery

Keynote by The Hon Dr Jim Chalmers MP, Treasurer of Australia

Full audio (MP3 7.9 MB)

Gallery

Plenary session 1: State of the Economy – the waves of change

  • Sarah Court, Chair, ASIC
  • Michele Bullock, Governor, Reserve Bank of Australia
  • Danielle Wood, Chair, Productivity Commission
  • Leah Weckert, CEO and Managing Director, Coles Group

Full audio (MP3 44.7 MB)

Transcript

Amelia Brace (MC): This session will examine the economic forces and structural shifts influencing consumers, businesses, government and Australia's future prosperity.

Thank you all for your time today.

I really appreciate it.

Governor, I was going to start with a question for you, but I will start with Leah instead.

We're talking about the waves of change today.

Coles, of course, faced its own wave or ripple yesterday with a suspected cyber attack.

Is that just what business is these days and how do you operate in an ongoing environment like that?

Leah Weckert: Yes, so we did make a release to the ASX yesterday to say that we're investigating a cybersecurity incident.

Luckily, our stores and online are still operating and customers are able to keep shopping with us.

And we haven't had any evidence come up in the investigations that we've had a data breach.

But I do think it is indicative of the environment that we are in right now which is the tools that bad actors have available to them, becoming more sophisticated with higher speed.

And so we all need to be working collectively, I think, to be thinking about how do we maintain a good defence for Australia overall.

Amelia Brace (MC): Governor Bullock, I will ask you now, how does the Monetary Policy Board see the balance of the risks facing the Australian economy?

And what are the developments that you are watching most closely as potential sources of disruption?

The Treasurer mentioned oil prices.

What's top of your agenda?

Michele Bullock: A lot of things are at top of my agenda.

So as you know, we raised interest rates

We've raised them five times, 125 basis points since the beginning of the year.

One thing I wanted to make extremely clear is that it's not just a response to oil prices.

We already had inflation above target in the latter half of last year and early this year, and we'd already started raising interest rates before the Middle East conflict started and oil prices started to rise.

They've made it worse.

They've made it more challenging.

We can't offset the oil price rises.

It's quite true that interest rates do not address that issue.

But what we can do with interest rates is we can decrease demand and ease the pressure which is coming from excess demand on the economy.

That's what the interest rate rises are designed to do.

Now in terms of the risks, I think what we feel at the moment is that the risks on inflation are still skewed to the upside.

And there's a number of reasons for that.

The first is oil prices.

The Treasurer referred to our assumptions about oil prices in our forecasts.

And what we do in a mechanical way here is we don't forecast oil prices, we take the futures curve for oil prices.

And that sees oil prices basically coming down.

But one thing we've seen since this whole thing started was that expectations for oil prices to come down aren't fulfilled.

They've just been continually staying elevated.

So there's a risk that even though we are sort of assuming that oil prices will start to ease and that will start to take pressure off headline inflation, there's actually a risk that won't happen.

So that's the first risk.

The second risk is that we do have accelerated demand driven by this AI boom and data centres.

And I know there's sort of a bit of a societal backlash going on here, not just here, overseas as well.

But nevertheless, there was a lot of expenditure going on here.

And this is adding to demand and pressure on resources at a time that we don't really have space to absorb it.

So that's another risk on the upside.

And the third risk on the upside is inflation expectations.

We're getting just these little inklings from our liaison program when we talk to businesses that they're thinking, you know what, maybe 3, 3.5% is the new normal for inflation.

If that gets ingrained in people's thinking, in businesses thinking and consumers and households thinking, then it's going to be much harder to bring inflation back down to target at 2.5%.

Why do we want inflation back down there?

We want it there because when it's down there, when it's sort of around 2, 2.5%, it's in the background of people's decisions.

It's not impacting, at the moment, as you know, everyone is just focused on inflation.

And that detracts from sensible investment decisions.

It detracts from consumers and households being able to make sensible decisions.

So this is a reason we really, so this risk here at the moment is important that we don't have inflation expectations ingrained.

Now having said all that, there are some downside risks that we're also focused on.

One is the housing market.

Now monetary policy does work through housing, partly through housing.

Part of the impact of higher interest rates is it lowers demand for housing loans and it lowers demand for many of the goods and services that go along with the housing market.

The housing market obviously has declined much further than that and partly that will be due to some of the tax changes that are going on, but also just the general uncertainty in the community.

Everything's just AI, geopolitics, conflicts in the Middle East and Ukraine, it's just all very uncertain.

So I think all these things are having an impact.

So that's sort of a downside thing that we haven't forgotten about.

We are watching very closely because that will potentially offset some of those upside risks.

But they're the key things that we're looking at.

Amelia Brace (MC): So a lot of risks from the RBA governor.

Danielle, there are also opportunities though.

Are we making the most of them?

Are we underestimating any opportunities at the moment?

Danielle Wood: I mean probably the biggest opportunity and this isn't a new observation is the potential productivity benefits of artificial intelligence.

The reason economists get excited about AI is it's a general purpose technology, so it has use cases right across the economy.

And when we look at the sort of long arc of history, it has been those sort of general purpose technologies that have driven sometimes decades of economic growth.

One of the reasons we've had pretty stagnant productivity, the Treasurer said the last 20 years, particularly the last decade, where we've been running at about a quarter of our historical average is because of things like sluggish business investment, shifts in the structure of the economy, but also actually because we haven't had the same boost from technology that we have had in previous decades.

So this potentially shifts that curve.

And we've estimated probably conservatively, you could add 4% to labour productivity over the next decade.

That would be a doubling of where we've been.

If it shifts the pace of innovation itself, we could be on a different trajectory entirely.

So I think that is one area.

Absolutely there is risks and I'm sure we'll talk about how we think about that balance, but it's certainly one area when I think about the kind of upside that I would focus on.

Amelia Brace (MC): Sarah, from ASIC's perspective, is there a particular risk or a particular opportunity that you are most focused on, most concerned about, most excited about?

Sarah Court: Yeah, it's interesting actually listening to Danny with the economist sort of view of opportunity.

I sort of think about myself, I'm a lawyer and a regulatory lawyer at that.

So of course, my mind probably inevitably turns to risk.

And I think, just a couple of things, Amelia, I mean, I think one of the things that we're underestimating a little, and Michele's touched on it, I think, in her comments, is just the convergence of risks at the moment.

So my sense is from the sort of conversations that I have with other regulators, and as I said in my remarks, I've just come back from sort of extensive overseas conversations about these things.

And there is a sense, I think, that risks are escalating in a variety of ways.

So the technological, the AI advances together with the geopolitical issues and economic changes.

So it's just a bit of a sense that something is coming our way, but no one's quite sure how it's going to arise and when.

So I think possibly we're underestimating that a little and perhaps also just this speed with which things are changing.

I think we're all business, industry, regulators, policy makers, we're all trying to to get ahead of the wave.

The other issue that came up in some of these conversations, which was interesting because there are issues that we're talking about in Australia, but I haven't heard them talked about quite so much sort of internationally before, and again, without wanting to be completely gloomy about risks, is the significant increase in scams and fraud and economic crimes that are being sort of supercharged by AI tools.

And so while, of course, many of us who have been regulators for a long time have been talking about scams and fraud for years, decades even, just the sheer, I guess, supercharging of misconduct that can be done by increasingly sophisticated technologies that are very difficult to ascertain if it's a fraud or not.

And just the associated potential loss of confidence and trust in the system as a result of that.

So if you don't know who it is that you're dealing with and can you trust a particular transaction.

So that could have a chilling effect.

So look, I might leave it there, Amelia, but it is interesting, I think, just the number of things that are coming together.

Amelia Brace (MC): Yeah, it's all a bit overwhelming.

There's also, of course, the cost of living crisis.

I read this morning that we're in our fifth year, it feels like our 50th, but it is affecting consumers.

Leah, how are you seeing that at Coles?

How is it affecting consumer behaviour from your perspective?

Leah Weckert: We're definitely seeing a shift in how customers think about purchasing decisions and how they spend money.

There is no doubt that households at the moment are under a lot of pressure and they are making different decisions to balance the budget.

So some of the things that we're definitely seeing in our business is, first of all, the things that you would expect around going and looking for specials, using loyalty points to get dollars off their shop.

Trading into cheaper alternatives is a very big theme that we see.

And so that's making decisions, for example, around trading out of a higher priced protein into a cheaper priced protein.

So the classic is sort of steak into mince.

Mince is growing very strongly at every retailer I speak to at the moment.

So spaghetti bolognese is alive and well as a family staple.

But even things like eggs, eggs is actually the lowest cost per gram of protein that we have in the supermarket.

And so, again, eggs growing very strongly.

And many families are choosing to go meat-free a couple of times a week.

So those are sort of the trade-offs they're making to trade into cheaper alternatives.

Many families eating out a lot less, because going out is expensive and it is cheaper to be able to build a dinner at home.

What's really interesting within that dynamic is I think Australians love to preserve their lifestyle.

And so holding onto that sort of treat of a nice meal once or twice a week, if you can't go out and do it, then they try and recreate it at home.

And so within our business, we have many tiers of products.

The value end of our products is growing very strongly, but actually the premium end is growing very strongly as well.

And so like our Coles Finest brand, is our strongest growing own brand tier that we have at the moment.

And that is families finding some of those special treats to replicate those experiences that they're missing out on.

I think the other trend to this sort of AI wave that we're seeing is that customers are increasingly now using AI and digital tools to help them to do their shop.

And so our surveys say that it's about 30% of shoppers now that use a ChatGPT or a price comparison website to actually put their list into each week and work out where is the cheapest place to go and find all the different options that they've got on the list and then they shop around the retailers to get the lowest possible costs that they can for their basket of groceries for the week.

So if you went back five years ago, most shoppers use two to three different grocery retailers to fulfil their needs for the month.

That's up around 7 to 8 different grocery retailers now.

So that shopping around has become a very big part of this.

Amelia Brace (MC): And do you expect that change in behaviour to be structural?

Do you expect people to continue this or will they go back to their old ways when life hopefully gets a little bit easier.

Leah Weckert: Yeah, I mean, it's a great question.

I think habits, once they set in, take a while to shift back.

Interestingly, coming into Christmas last year, where I think we were feeling maybe like the worst of it was behind us and families were starting to feel a bit more confidence we did start to see a bit of reversion in behaviours.

And so families were starting to value their time a bit more and pull back from as much of that shopping around.

So the one-stop shop where I can go and get everything became a bit more popular.

And so I think that is probably a cyclical thing that we'll see shift.

And then I think that trading into cheaper alternatives will shift once families feel more confident as well.

The thing I think is structural here is this use of digital tools to inform their purchasing behaviours.

That is really feeling like it's a very rapidly advancing wave that is here to stay.

Amelia Brace (MC): While we're speaking about consumers, Sarah, what is a consumer harm of tomorrow that concerns ASIC more than what they're facing today?

Sarah Court: Yeah, I think it's so interesting listening to Leah's observations about sort of changes in consumer behaviour.

I think the way that we're looking at it from ASIC sort of through that conduct regulation lens is that there's a few different ways we think about it.

So firstly, we know that financial institutions across the board are thinking about using new technologies and ways to offer new products, new services, new innovations.

And we welcome that.

Hopefully that will improve accessibility for people and help productivity.

But I guess our number one message, and I think I said it in my remarks earlier, is just that with all of those sort of new, exciting, glitzy opportunities, just make sure to keep getting the basics right in serving customers.

So we see that as sort of one of the risks of emerging new opportunities is just that firms can take their eye off the ball and stop just dealing with customers in the way that they've promised.

So that's sort of the first lens.

And then the second lens is, when you're introducing new technologies, and we know that increasingly financial institutions are using AI and other technologies to deliver improved products and services, we welcome that.

But just remembering that the same consumer protection laws apply.

So we have technology neutral laws, you still can't mislead, you still need to deliver what you have said.

I've heard this new term recently, which might be familiar to some in the room called AI washing.

I gather that’s similar sort of to green washing, but it's like pretending that AI is going to deliver some brand new opportunity and it doesn't really.

So just those same laws will apply, Amelia, I think that's really important for people to keep in mind as they're experimenting.

I think a third sort of consumer harm area that we're thinking about and talking about a lot is just liability and accountability for consumers.

So when I hear about Leah's example of people using sort of AI to go shopping.

And I have this sort of image of my AI agent talking to Coles's AI agent.

And just sort of, if something goes wrong, how does that work?

Who is responsible there?

And I think these are deep questions that we are going to need to tackle as we move into the future.

And then my final consumer harm point Amelia is really and it's one that we've been concerned about at ASIC for some time and done a lot of work in and that is just the whole area of financial hardship.

So as consumers and Australians are doing it tough, we know that we've read in the press recently that there are increasing loan arrears and the like in some of the major banks.

I know it's moving up from a small base, but I think we are hearing it is slowly ticking up.

There are a lot of people doing it tough.

There are strong consumer protection laws in this country to look after those people and we need to make sure that despite all of the change and excitement that we continue to make sure that the laws are properly applied to protect those who are the most vulnerable in our community.

Amelia Brace (MC): Absolutely.

Just a reminder to the audience, if you do have any questions for any of our panelists, make sure you pop them in via the app and I will be sure to pass them on for you.

Just moving back to the theme of the forum, the waves of change, I'm interested to hear from all of you what you think those waves are and what you think will have the biggest impact.

Which wave should we be fearing the most or most excited about?

Is it geopolitics?

Is it demographics?

Is it technology?

Is it climate change?

Michele, what are you keeping an eye on in terms of these waves of change?

Michele Bullock: So I do think the technology wave is the one that is, because it brings opportunities, but as we've already heard, it also brings risks.

And so we've got to make sure that we're, I mean, the theme is trying to stay ahead of the wave.

I don't know if we're going to succeed in that.

But from a financial stability perspective and from the perspective of some of the consumer stuff that Sarah spoke about, I think we do need to be very conscious of some of the risks that are coming with technology without disenabling it, without sort of trying to hold it back too much, because it is the hope for productivity.

So we do need to do that.

So I think that's really important.

But my other issue, I guess it's a more general point, would be that ever since COVID, we have had a series of what I would call supply shocks.

They are shocks to the supply side of the economy.

First we had COVID,

Then we had the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Then we had the trade, you might have forgotten about this, we've got a trade war tariff thing going on as well.

We had that and that's still going.

We have obviously now the Middle East conflict.

We've got all these supply shocks, climate change is another one.

They're all hitting and they all hit and then they don't completely go away, they all hang around.

And that makes it very challenging for the economies.

And it's not just us, it's around the world, but it makes it challenging for us.

It makes it challenging for a central bank because we've got to control inflation in the face of supply shocks.

But it also makes it more challenging for others.

It makes it more challenging for governments to deal with all of these shocks that are coming in?

How do they address those in terms of their own spending priorities, their own infrastructure priorities?

One of the things, for example, that came out of COVID and has only been strengthened by issues to do with the trade and the tariffs issues and the Middle East is supply chain risks.

We went through a period up until COVID where the imperative for businesses was to minimise frictions in supply chains.

Just in time supplies, you buy from the cheapest, you produce what you produce most efficiently and you buy from others.

People are rethinking that now.

And I'd have to say, actually, I think the response has been reasonably positive.

We have been very pleasantly surprised, I'd have to say, by the way the world economy and the supply chains responded to the trade issues and to this most recent issue with conflict in the Middle East.

The supply chains have responded, they have worked, and I think that shows that we can learn and we can change our behaviours and the way our economies work a little bit in order to adapt.

So having said all that negative stuff, I'm actually reasonably positive that we will get the benefits of the productivity and that the world economy will manage to adapt.

But it doesn't mean, it's going to be a bumpy ride probably.

Amelia Brace (MC): Danielle, do you share that positivity?

Danielle Wood: I do share the positivity and I think Michele's absolutely right, the sort of AI, geopolitics are the things that are consuming a lot of energy and headspace in policy debates.

But to that broader question you raised, climate change, aging, they're slower moving, but they also require serious thinking and serious policy action.

And so I think we've been talking about both of them for many decades.

We are now starting to see the impacts of both, aging population, demand for services, whether it's health, whether it's aged care.

And the Treasurer is talking about savings packages.

Serious thoughts have to go into making sure that those systems are sustainable in a world where there just will be higher demand.

On climate, we're now feeling the impacts of bigger, more frequent natural disasters, both in a human sense and a budgetary and economic sense.

And so that kind of the path of transition, making sure that we are in a position to move our energy system towards something greener, electrifying our transport fleet, electrifying our homes.

All of those things are actually things that governments have to grapple with while they're dealing with these fast moving changes of AI and geopolitics.

Amelia Brace (MC): Leah, you've already spoken about how technology is shifting for your customers.

We've also just been speaking about supply chains.

What wave is looming large on your horizon?

What are you watching the most at Coles?

Leah Weckert: Well, I would say that all the waves that have just been mentioned are on our horizon.

And I actually think one of the big challenges for business leaders these days is just the diversity of change that you're having to lean into and manage.

And I think there are a couple that are, to Danielle's point, more immediate and urgent that you need to deal with.

The supply chain resilience piece has been an enormous focus for us over the last few years, really since COVID.

I mean, we all remember toilet paper gate during COVID.

We then had issues with oil and wheat as inputs because of the Ukraine war.

And then as we've headed into this conflict with the Middle East this year, I mean, fuel has been the very obvious one.

We have about 1,500 trucks on the road every day delivering to stores and moving between suppliers and distribution centres.

The fuel is a big impact to us, but there are actually a lot of sort of hidden issues in there as well.

So, who knew when a war broke out in the Middle East that we would be wondering, would we have enough fertiliser to grow crops?

Who knew we would be wondering, would we have enough plastic resin to put food into the packaging that it goes to?

And these are really long tail effects that we're having to deal with.

They're putting upwards pressure on groceries in terms of price.

And they're not going to be resolved to the point you made for years to come while we sift through that.

And it is making us think about how do we have to reconfigure supply chains.

So we definitely were in a position pre-COVID where we consolidated behind a single supplier to get the lowest cost on every input.

Now we think about what is the redundancy.

So how do you always have alternative suppliers, which means you have two or three of them supplying every product.

If something happens in a particular geography, if something happens to a particular supplier, for example, a cyber event, that you've got another alternative that you can turn to.

So that's obviously a very big change.

The other one that's really shifting for us quite quickly is the changing customer wave.

So we've talked about demographics.

But we're also seeing medical advancements that are starting to make changes too.

We think the GLP-1 drugs like Ozempic are probably going to be one of the biggest transformations to the food industry that we've seen for decades.

It is significantly penetrating households.

We think it could be as high as 10% of Australian households are already taking a GLP-1 drug and it significantly changes what people eat.

And so we need to think about how does that then change, how much space we give to particular products, what range we have in store.

And then I think there's a couple of sleepers.

So I think the climate change is a long burn.

We track every year how many business continuity incidents we have where we have to do a work around our normal processes because of a fire or a flood or a cyclone.

A few years ago, that was in single digits every year, and now it's pretty consistently in double digits.

And the creativity we have to approach around how do you actually get stock, but then how do you get around the disruption?

So when the Bruce Highway goes out between Brisbane and the northern part of Queensland, we have to drive the trucks all the way around to get to the top, which can take four or five days instead of half a day.

And that's a significant cost and a business interruption that we have to work through just to get basic food supplies to people that live in that part of the country.

And these things are going to continue to get more and more common.

Amelia Brace (MC): And do you find that consumers are understanding of those challenges in COVID, when we weren't brawling over toilet paper, it felt like there was a broad acceptance that sometimes certain products wouldn't be there.

Do customers still have that good grace or do they expect that what they want will be there when they go shopping?

Leah Weckert: I think during COVID, we were all in it together, right, in Australia.

And so there was, I think, a good natured acceptance to could you just buy one packet of toilet paper?

We didn't see it from everyone, but by and large people behaved well.

But I think in general, unless it is a national crisis, people expect products to be in store.

And they expect us as a big business to just find a way to work it out.

And so we are constantly thinking about this resilience piece of how do we have those alternatives so we can always have a great offer for customers.

Amelia Brace (MC): Well, speaking of resilience, I think that is one point of positivity about this whole discussion.

I think humans and Australians particularly are very resilient.

You mentioned toilet paper gate.

I of course remember it, but it's not at the front of my mind.

You move on with your life and you start dealing with the next challenge and the next problem, which is what we were discussing.

Sarah, is there a danger in that to forgetting very quickly some of the challenges we're facing because we're already dealing with the next one?

Sarah Court: Yeah, well, I guess that's right.

I mean, I think it is good that we're resilient and that we move on.

I think one of the things, Amelia, that I think about a lot, certainly since I've been at ASIC and taking up the new role in terms of memories, things being forgotten quickly, is all of the lessons of the Financial Services Royal Commission that we worked our way through five or six years ago.

And that's one of the reasons I think that we talk a lot at ASIC about just that getting the basics right so that the world has moved on a lot since then.

In fact, the financial system in some ways is almost unrecognisable.

But having said that, there are still lessons to be learned and maintained all the way through.

I think one of the other reflections is listening to Leah's talk about what customers are used to and expect.

I think one of the other things that we're thinking about a bit at the moment.

I think that the financial industry is thinking about and it comes back to my sort of scams and fraud point is that we spend a lot of time sort of designing a system to remove all friction.

So that payments can be instantaneous, everything can be very efficient.

Nobody wants to sort of pause for a moment or so as a transaction happens.

I think we are slowly, or maybe not so slowly, moving into a world where consumers are accepting some frictions in the way that they do business.

I know certainly my own bank, when you try to make a new payment, all sorts of things to pop up, say, are you sure?

Are you absolutely sure?

We're going to hold your money for a couple of days.

And I think we now recognise that, that is important.

And if you think about one of the other major waves, that we're facing, we've already touched upon it, which is the sort of the growing cyber related risks from Frontier AI models and the requirement for sort of far more intensive and responsive patching as opposed to sort of, you know, waiting every 24 hours or something.

You know, things might have to happen instantaneously.

I suspect that that's part of a new wave of being as well is that consumers are going to start sort of appreciating that there may not be some things immediately or instantly available as those kind of issues are dealt with on an urgent basis.

So it's almost slightly ironic in some ways that we're almost going, we may by through necessity have to go full circle.

Amelia Brace (MC): Michele, you have a thought.

Michele Bullock: It's an interesting point, both points, and I think what that we're thinking about here now is that risk is coming back into the equation, whereas efficiency was.

But I wouldn't say we're going to go full circle.

I think it's a risk-based approach.

So certainly in the payment system, I think the issue is, yes, frictionless, instantaneous payments, some circumstances perhaps maybe not a good idea.

Other circumstances, absolutely fine.

So I think, and Leah was talking about diversifying a bit.

So you're not going to diversify dramatically, you're going to identify where you think your risks lie, presumably, and you're going to try and adapt to address those risks, but others you might be prepared to take a bit more risk.

So I think it's actually interesting that risk is coming back into the conversation with businesses and their thinking about how to balance that efficiency and risk.

Amelia Brace (MC): Definitely.

We do have a question from the audience.

To get ahead of the wave, should we be seeking to introduce consumer protections before the harms arise or do what usually happens, wait for the harms to happen, then regulate.

The increase in unregulated wage advance is a good current example.

Let's start with our resident regulator.

Sarah, what do you think?

Sarah Court: I think that's the sort of constant regulatory conundrum in a way.

I think sort of our general sense is that the laws that we have as they stand are sufficient to be dealing with these issues.

I mean, it's hard to predict, I guess, what is around the corner, but I think our general sense is that we have very strong consumer protection laws in Australia, both throughout the economy and in the financial system itself.

We've got strong digital laws and we've got strong privacy laws.

I'm not sure anyone would ever say that that job is completely done and new harms will no doubt continue to arise.

But I would like to think that we largely have the toolkits that we need as financial regulators and the question is, how we use those toolkits, making sure that we deal with the right risks at the right time that we use.

And this is certainly something at ASIC that we are wanting to do more and more, which is to use the information, the intel, the data that we already have within our system, but also work with other regulators as well to really get better and this is where we need to use technology tools ourselves and AI ourselves to help detect where are those risks and harms going to eventuate.

I think one of the most common criticisms of ASIC is why did you let this happen?

Why didn't you stop this harm from occurring?

And I think that's a fair question to ask.

Sometimes I think expectations about what we can and can't do are perhaps a little overinflated.

So one of our jobs is to explain what we can do and what we can't do.

I never want to be defensive about that.

I want to say absolutely, we need to, like industry are improving their technology, we need to do the same.

And we've got lots of projects and work underway internally to try to sort of anticipate harm and disrupt it unapologetically when and where we see it.

But for the moment, I think the toolkit is okay.

I mean, it's interesting the sort of the new AI frameworks and whether or not we need, that is a global discussion that's being had.

Do we need new laws to deal with new AI harms?

And that's certainly something that I've heard lots of conversations about.

I think the general approach internationally at the moment seems to be using existing rules and laws.

But I don't think that conversation is finished.

Amelia Brace (MC): And Danielle, from a productivity perspective, when is the best time for red tape to be applied?

Danielle Wood: I mean, it was lovely to hear the treasurer getting excited about red tape up there.

But I mean, I think it sort of, it picks up a little of what both Michele and Sarah were just saying.

Which is essentially this is a kind of cost benefit question.

We would all love to live in a world where risks are zero.

But frankly, the sort of level of regulation and pre-emption you would need to get there would be extremely costly.

I would argue we have seen a very strong increase in regulatory burden across the economy in recent decades.

My favourite stat is from the Australian Institute of Company Directors survey of ASX board directors that show they're now spending 55% of their board meeting time on risk and compliance.

And that is, of course, time they're not spending on strategy and tech adoption.

And so I just think we have to be really wary whenever we're thinking about a new regulation.

Sometimes it will be very appropriate to regulate, but we've always got to be balancing the impact on costs and frankly, the cumulative burden across the economy.

So I think it's really great to see the government focused on this, including going back and looking at some of the things that we have done and thinking about whether they are fit for purpose.

We've got a plug for a PC report coming out on Thursday.

Looking at the burden associated with non-financial corporate reporting, this is things like scope three emissions and gender pay gaps and business reporting times.

We think there are substantial scopes to reduce burden in those areas, but the same will apply across broad parts of the economy.

Sarah Court: I completely agree with everything Danielle just said.

It's interesting though, isn't it, because

I mean, on the one hand, there's the talk about reducing burden, which I completely agree with.

The counterpoint that I think we all are managing, and I think it's one of the things the government is managing, is just community expectations of regulation.

So there is this sort of increasing sense that nothing should ever go wrong.

And then that is what results, I think, in political pressure to introduce regulations, new laws to make sure that that event, whatever the terrible event is, never happens again.

I think it's difficult for governments.

I think it's difficult for regulators.

I mean, when we have new regulations or laws that have been introduced through the parliament as the result of some collapse or some failure or some issue that's gone wrong, then as a regulator, there is an expectation that you use that law.

And I always laugh and sort of say, we at ASIC get criticised more for what we don't do than what we do do.

So that expectation about why did you not intervene here or do this or do that.

So I think it's an interesting conversation that we need to have that on the one hand, get rid of burden.

On the other hand, there are high community expectations about how people will be protected by regulators.

Leah no doubt deals with multiple regulators in different ways, food safety and all those kind of things.

So it's just, it's a little bit of a reflection of the community I think.

Danielle Wood: I totally agree with that when I started writing about this issue.

I went out kind of looking for examples of when there'd been a lot of pressure on governments to stand up and say, no, we won't do anything when something bad had happened.

And it's very hard to find one.

When something bad has happened, it is natural to say, well, what's government going to do about it, or why wasn't the regulator there?

The only really good example I could find was Peter Malinauskas in South Australia, awful incident in the tour down under, a spectator was injured as someone came around the corner, flew over the barrier, and people said, well, we need higher barriers, what are you going to do?

And he said, look, freak accident, awful freak accident, but I'm not going to overreact.

But those examples are hard to find.

Amelia Brace (MC): So you mentioned protections.

We had a question from the audience, which I think is very interesting, in the AI space.

And it's about people who are seeking financial advice, including my husband, from chatbots, the likes of ChatGPT or Claude.

Is that alarming to you, and is there anything you can do about it?

Sarah Court: It's not really alarming to me.

I think it's a sign of the times, and it's something that we are talking about at ASIC a lot.

And again, it's something that is being discussed internationally as everybody's grappling with the same things.

I think people are inevitably going to do this.

I'm glad your husband does, Amelia.

You might want to get a second opinion on that advice.

I think it's something we have to take seriously and think about.

But it's interesting, isn't it?

I mean, financial advice is one part.

We know people get advice on all sorts of issues from AI.

Like the other area I think about a lot is health advice, that there's obviously people using Dr Google on a very regular basis.

I think one of the things we need to talk about or think about as regulators is just to make sure that people understand the limits on advice that they're getting.

And I, and perhaps this is just a sign of my age, but in conversations we've had around the Commission table, I've said, but surely people don't think you just chuck in a bit of financial information and that the advice that you get prompted out of Claude or ChatGPT is going to be the same as going and getting advice from a financial advisor.

But I think our statistics are something like 40% of people under 30 are getting their financial advice in that way.

So I think we have a big job to do to make sure that people understand when they're putting in that information.

Look, there really is no check or guarantee.

There's certainly no consumer protections that apply in those circumstances.

The flip side of course is we do have a challenge with financial advice being unaffordable and unaccessible for a large proportion of people in the community and if they can get some kind of informed information through these tools, well then that's not necessarily a bad thing.

I think that the prospect of ASIC regulating that advice is one that, we're talking about regulation, one we have to think about a lot.

And I think the other issue is there's this really fine line, of course, isn't there, between just getting information, where's the line between information about financial services and financial advice.

I do know that in some jurisdictions they are introducing new kinds of models that would enable licensed financial advisors to provide purely digital advice, online advice, and that that is a potential way to make advice more affordable and more accessible for people.

So particular forms of licenses for that.

But look, I think it's certainly an issue that will be occupying us going forward.

Amelia Brace (MC): Leah, you mentioned consumers using artificial intelligence to shop around.

How do you respond to that?

How do you deal with that as a company, as a business?

Leah Weckert: It's a very good question.

I think obviously, first and foremost, you have to be very competitive on price because that is the hygiene there that throws up this is where to go and buy that product.

The grocery industry in Australia is unbelievably competitive and it has only got more so in the last 12 months with the use of those tools coming into play.

I think the interesting side of this is how do you move past that price hygiene into starting to have points of differentiation?

And so having products which are different to what other retailers have.

having a product that has a particular characteristic to it.

So it might have a particular provenance, it might have a particular taste profile.

So innovation in product we think is increasingly important as we move forward from here because it can be the reason that a customer will pick to shop with you versus not.

And a big part of that is going to be how do you communicate that?

So today when we bring innovation in, we actually really struggle to communicate it to customers because you get a tiny little shelf edge label to communicate it and you get the packet.

But for most people, I've never understood it myself, but it's a chore to go and do your grocery shopping.

I love grocery shopping.

But most people want to get in and get out as quickly as possible and they don't take a lot of time to change their routine.

And so they're not usually be on the lookout for what's the new innovative products that are in the store.

We think there's a huge opportunity with AI starting to be in the mix that our AI agent can actually market to your AI agent and say the reason you should buy these products is because of X, Y and Z.

And we can talk about that it was grown hormone free, it was sourced out of WA and you live in Perth and you like to buy local or it might have a provenance out of Italy if it's a balsamic vinegar or a panettone or something like that.

And so being able to communicate those things, we actually think we're going to get a lot more information across into the decision making than maybe what we do today.

Amelia Brace (MC): Thank you, Leah.

We do have a question from the audience.

The Treasurer spoke about rationalising compliance costs.

For example, reducing the costs for building, running a small business.

How do you balance those reductions against the risks to consumers from lowering standards?

I know, Danielle, you were happy about this part of the speech, but how do you find that balance?

Danielle Wood: I mean, this is the core question when we're talking about regulatory burden, right?

So we have to make decisions as a society about kind of what's a tolerable level of risk.

And as we were saying, those can be hard conversations to have.

But I think those conversations always need to balance that there is a cost to this as well.

And I think if we downplay or ignore the cost of regulation over an extended period, which I think we have, we do end up in a world where it's harder to build things, harder to scale up businesses, and ultimately we have lower productivity which feeds through into lower income growth.

And so, that's the broad picture, that's the world in which we're kind of making these decisions on costs and benefits.

We have lots of cool economic tools and things that we can use to weigh these up.

But I think ultimately it just starts with a discussion about the kind of level of risk that you're willing to accept.

And that will frankly vary across different parts of the economy.

I think all of us might agree that we are not happy with much risk at all.

If we're talking about aviation safety, maybe the optimal level is zero.

As we kind of move out to other parts of the economy, we may be willing to accept some degree of risk.

to unleash dynamism, animal spirits and growth, which actually matters for all of our wellbeing in the long term.

Amelia Brace (MC): Leah, your thoughts on finding that balance?

Leah Weckert: Yeah, so I think good regulation is really important, right?

Because it does keep people safe and it keeps people and industry doing the right thing.

But I think we are at a real crossroads as a nation right now where we have to find a way to unlock productivity.

And so we have to find a way to get time back and innovation back into the system.

And I think there is a lot of low hanging opportunities where we can have good regulation without it being onerous.

And what I'd call out is there are lots and lots of laws that we have in Australia where there is a slightly different one on the same topic for every state.

And harmonisation of those to have a national standard.

So as a national business, you only have to have one set of compliance for that issue.

That should be the place we go first because that is low hanging fruit.

We can have great regulation and we can have less burden for business and achieve both.

And then we can start on some of the harder stuff, which is if we're going to keep adding things on, and it does feel at the moment as a business leader that regulation is constantly incremental, nothing gets taken away to lower the burden, then we can start to tackle that as the next issue.

But this harmonisation piece should be something

really lean into.

Danielle Wood: I mean, worth noting that some of that is underway through national competition policy.

I entirely agree.

I mean, it is wild that we have eight different regimes for labour, for products, for all sorts of things in this country.

Leah Weckert: Let me give you an example.

The container deposit schemes are different in every state.

I mean, this is collecting empty cans and bottles.

We have to have a different set of compliance mechanisms in place for every state, and I have to review and then sign the attestations that all the movements of the cans and bottles.

Me, as CEO of Coles, has been correct that we submit.

Both of those things shouldn't be the case.

We should have a single system and we should be happy with someone other than the CEO of businesses signing that off.

That is not a good use of people's time.

Amelia Brace (MC): Even the sticker on the back of the can lists all the different rules in each state.

Danielle Wood: That's right.

Amelia Brace (MC): While we're speaking about streamlining things, a question from the audience which fits in well, will ASIC consider undertaking a cost benefit analysis on the use of artificial intelligence to create a single coherent and consolidated ASIC regulatory handbook, Sarah.

Sarah Court: Sorry, what was the last bit?

ASIC regulatory.

Amelia Brace (MC): Handbook, yes.

Sarah Court: An ASIC regulatory handbook.

That's probably one I should take on notice.

I think, well, I think certainly we need to use AI to help streamline things without doubt.

I think many of you who've attended the conference before will know that we have had a simplification program underway at ASIC for quite some time now.

We proudly like to say we were sort of ahead of the game in the simplification of corporate law.

And we do know that we have literally hundreds of regulatory guides and instruments and information sheets that we are really trying to streamline and simplify, get rid of duplication and make a whole lot easier to navigate.

It's interesting actually though I was at a... meeting with a whole range of other chairs of regulators in Canberra a few weeks ago.

So not just within the financial system, but across all areas.

And of course, we're all grappling with these issues in a really genuine way.

I think regulators across the Commonwealth, we have heard the government, we've heard the Treasurer, we are really trying to work out how can we simplify, streamline and reduce burden where it has no you know, real material benefit or impact.

And one of the chairs of another regulator was talking about how they had just gone through a big process of simplification and rewriting guidance to make it simpler, much more intelligible.

And there had been a massive backlash from the industry as a result of that because they said, change introduces its own regulatory burden.

So we're actually really familiar.

While these may not have been well written and they might be complex and lengthy to begin with, at least now we've spent all this time getting across them and we know how that they work.

We don't want you to just go and rewrite them and change them all again because then we have to start again.

So I thought that was a really interesting observation.

So we just need to be careful, I think, to not make change for changes sake and make everybody reread and reinterpret all of our guidances, but certainly we need to get a whole lot better in doing things in a simpler and more comprehensive and less legalistic and bureaucratic way so people can understand it.

And I'm very happy to take the AI suggestion on notice.

One of the challenges for ASIC is that We regulate such a broad range of areas, laws, institutions, professionals.

We probably unfortunately need more than just one regulatory handbook, I'd have to say, so we can think about it.

Amelia Brace (MC): Michele, as someone who has attended many of your press conferences, I know that you like economic data, so this question from the audience might be a good one for you.

If you could spend a week living on the average Australian household budget, what do you think would surprise you most about the economy that might not show up in the economic data?

Michele Bullock: So we actually do quite a lot of liaison with businesses, but we also do a lot of liaison with organisations that deal with things like household debt, people who've got debt problems.

ACOS, we talked to ACOS, we talked to a number of organisations, food bank, those sorts of things.

So I don't know if it would surprise me and I actually think that the average Australian household budget is not where we should be worrying.

It's the people who are struggling at towards the bottom end and they're typically renters and they're typically on low incomes.

They're not

They're not people that are on, in an inflationary environment, if you're on welfare or pensions, you're getting indexed.

So the people I'm sort of more worried about are the people that are on low incomes, they're earning low incomes and they're renting.

What would surprise me most, there's a few things I was really interested in Leah's comments earlier about people trading down.

I know from listening to some of these charities and not-for-profits we speak to that issues to do with children going to school without breakfasts is a big issue, which worries me.

I'm conscious as well that what people are doing in order to, so if people do actually have a mortgage, what they might be doing to ensure they continue to meet their mortgages.

And that's often cutting back on things like food.

It might be that they don't meet various bills, including electricity bills and water bills, those sorts of things.

So I don't know if it would surprise me, but they're the sorts of things that worry me.

And the reason, come back to inflation, because that is what I am here to address in my job, that's why I worry about inflation because what inflation is doing is it's putting pressure on households, on families, particularly at the lower end of the income distribution and what they are having to do.

They don't have discretionary expenditure.

They are the ones that are having to deal with the cost of living within a budget and it's a budget of essentials.

So it probably doesn't answer the question what would surprise me.

I guess I've answered the question about what worries me and that's what worries me.

Amelia Brace (MC): Leah, this could be a good question for you from the audience.

Businesses are being pushed to use AI to move faster while regulators want strong governance.

Is there a tension between agility and accountability and are expectations shifting in one direction or another?

Leah Weckert: Yeah, I mean, it's a great question.

And we internally probably have taken a bit more of a, we want to have more of a focus on the risk as we move into this.

So we have had a view that we don't need to be first, but we want to be fast afterwards.

And if you think about things like some of the shopping AI chats that you see on a lot of websites, now, we've sort of stood back almost for 12 months and watched how that's played out because we had real concerns around things like somebody puts in a request of, can you give me something for a recipe for dinner tonight?

I'm allergic to nuts.

And then they get a recipe for Pad Thai, come back.

That sort of thing for us is just a worst case scenario where we give information to customers, we put them at risk.

And so we have chosen to take a bit of a slower approach.

We've actually only just launched in the last two weeks our chat bot.

And we've focused instead of trying to be all encompassing in what it does in trying to actually solve customer pain points, so things like returns and missing items out of online orders because we can have a high degree of certainty that the bot will do that in a good way.

So I do think businesses need to get the balance right on this, which is you want to move and show that you're keeping up with the times and be innovative and give customers more seamless experiences.

But sometimes you do have to have a bit of friction in the system and be a bit slower so that you get the right outcome.

Amelia Brace (MC): Danielle, we were speaking earlier about resilience and it does feel like, well, it's a reality that Australian consumers have spent much of the past decade responding to shocks.

So I guess my question is, when will it end?

When do we move from resilience to renewal?

Danielle Wood: Gosh, I mean, there's a reason I don't do economic broadcasting because it's a crazy game.

But look, I think Michele picked up on this before, we have been in a world of kind of rolling shocks.

If anything, I think it has been, none of them have kind of played out as badly as they could have.

Like it has been a positive to see the way in which businesses have adapted, the broader global economy has adapted.

And I think that probably is a testament to having relatively open trade and free flows of goods, strong institutions, all of those things.

So I think we have a lot of the fundamentals in place.

We can't control geopolitics.

So we are always going to be responding to shocks.

But I think trying to do so in a way that's really sensible and evidence-based.

This is really important when we're thinking, for example, about our policies around resilience.

Where are the kind of insurance policies that we want to invest in in national supply chains, making sure that again, the benefits are greater than the costs, the same when we're thinking about our regulatory regime.

So I think as long as we kind of continue to bring that really sensible measured approach to policy, we give ourselves the best chance of withstanding the shocks that the world throws at us.

Amelia Brace (MC): Looking ahead and when we consider these shocks, these waves of change, I'm interested to hear from each of you what success looks like?

What's the goal here?

Because that might be reassuring to the audience, but also just to the Australian people.

Michele, what does it look like if we get this right?

Michele Bullock: Low and stable inflation, it looks like to me.

I won't get, there's a number of things, but let me, three.

One, if in 10 years-time we've got low and stable inflation and we've got a labour market that has adjusted to the potential impacts of AI.

So that for me reflects my mandate and they're important to me.

The third thing I would mention is resilience of infrastructure.

And this harks back a little bit to the payment system thing.

What underlies the economy, what underlies all of this is the ability to make and receive payments.

And for me, the resilience of that infrastructure, if we can in 10 years' time say, yes, that infrastructure is solid and it passes tests, particularly with issues to do with AI and cyber and quantum, don't forget quantum, then I think for us, for me, that will be the three critical things that we will have to have known.

Amelia Brace (MC): Sarah, same question to you, but I also wanted to pick up on that timeline.

Ten years is a long time for success.

I think Bill Gates said it'll be about 20 years of disruption from AI before we live in the new normal.

Is that realistic and should we be a bit scared of that?

Sarah Court: I don't think we should be scared, Amelia, but I mean, if you think about the pace of change at the moment, 10 years seems a really long way away.

I mean, I think we're dealing with things and thinking about things certainly within ASIC now that we weren't thinking about this time last year, to be honest.

And I think what that suggests is that this time next year, there'll be a whole lot of different things that we'll be thinking about.

But if you look out 10 years and think, well, what does success look like.

I mean, this might be a bit of a utopia view, but it will be that we as a community, as a society, have managed to harness the enormous potential of artificial intelligence in a way that is safe, in a way that has enhanced productivity, and that enables the redistribution of benefits across the society, across our society.

I mean, that's I assume what we're all aiming for.

What we don't want is increased divisions in society.

I think one of the, again, things I've been talking about overseas a lot is financial literacy, particularly as a whole lot of people move into retirement, but the connection between financial literacy and digital literacy and sort of where does responsibility in our community for digital literacy lie?

So in order to take advantage of a whole lot of new technology offerings, we need people who know how to use them, who understand them, that can ask questions of it, that can be sceptical as needed.

So the utopia vision in 10 years is that we've got that right.

That there is a social license for the use of AI and that there's a recognition of the productivity and societal benefits that it's introduced.

But I think we, being candid, we all have a lot of work as leaders in this room to help move us there.

Amelia Brace (MC): Danielle, is there a productivity utopia in sight?

Danielle Wood: I mean, I really hope so.

And I think if we got to Michele and Sarah's utopia, I mean, ultimately, for me, I think the goal is restoring income growth and generation on generation progress in living standards.

So we want to be leaving the world a better place for our kids.

So all of those things, making it easier to build the housing that we desperately need in our cities, making it easier to build the infrastructure that we need, including the energy infrastructure.

And then I think there's a broader, really important piece as well about governments continuing to deliver core service as well, the health, the education, the macro management, because all of that goes to trust in government and faith in democracy and that's going to matter a lot for realising that vision as well.

Amelia Brace (MC): And lastly, Leah, at Coles, is there a finish line?

Is there a goal?

Is there a moment where you know that you made it and you did it well?

Leah Weckert: Look, I mean, I agree with what everyone has said is success here looks like we managed to unlock productivity and as a result, prosperity for our future generations of Australians.

And I think there's three things that really are on my mind, we're going to need to work out how we navigate as we move towards that.

One is I think we need to work out how we have a meaningful role at the table around AI, and that probably means we need to be investing in infrastructure so we can play a role in things like the training of AI models.

The second big one for me is just making sure that we don't allow the fabric of our economy and the organisations, the companies that make that up to become disintermediated as part of this shift.

There is a real potential here for these large technology companies to come in and without much of a physical presence in Australia to extract rents and we do see that disintermediation and the lowering of competitiveness of our local companies and we need to work to make sure that that doesn't happen.

And then the third thing is just people.

This is an enormous change and I think it's quite different to the transformations that we've seen over time.

And we need to make sure that we are building skills and capability in our workforces to be able to adapt to this and make the most of it.

And that's not going to happen by accident.

We have to be meaningful about leaning in and taking the right actions in that and investing in it to make sure that it happens.

Amelia Brace (MC): Absolutely.

Speaking of finish lines, that is perfect timing for the end of our first discussion.

Thank you all for taking the time to speak to us this morning.

I'm sure you'll all agree that was an incredibly insightful way to start off the forum.

Gallery

Plenary session 2: The human face of global disruption

  • Alan Kirkland, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Professor Brendan Murphy AC, Chair, Australian Red Cross Lifeblood
  • Chandni Gupta, Deputy CEO and Digital Policy Director, Consumer Policy Research Centre
  • Dr John Coyne, Director, National Security Program, ASPI

Full audio (MP3 36.3 MB)

Transcript

Mr Hamish Macdonald: You're going to hear from and have the opportunity to put questions to people who have dealt with crisis, acute crisis in really substantial ways.

So the aim of this next session is really to examine the experience of these people through the world of disruption and how well Australia, particularly the economic, the financial regulators respond to major shocks that test things like market integrity, investor confidence and consumer trust.

And I think it's that trust piece that we're probably all acutely aware of.

Just think of the last time that you saw something on the news or in the newspaper or maybe in your social media feed or something that someone sent you on WhatsApp and you thought to yourself, is that real?

So imagine the next big crisis in that context.

I think that's how every citizen will be facing the information that will inevitably come flooding at them.

So we're going to draw on events like, for example, the global financial crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic.

I know we'd all rather forget it, but it is an important framing for this conversation.

Would you please welcome to the stage ASIC Commissioner Alan Kirkland, if you'd like to come up, Alan.

The Chair of the Australian Red Cross Lifeblood, but formerly the Chief Health Officer, Professor Brendan Murphy AC.

Also joining us on stage, the Deputy CEO and Digital Policy Director at the Consumer Policy Research Centre, Chandri Gupta.

Welcome, Chandri.

And Dr John Coyne, the Director of the National Security Program at ASPI.

Would you please welcome all of them?

And by the way, if you'd like to ask a question, you can do so using the app.

We'll get the questions sent up here to us and I'd love to integrate those into the conversation.

So whenever you feel ready, please do so.

I was just thinking to myself, Brendan, it's a little while since I've welcomed you onto any stage or program, which is kind of a good thing, probably for you and us.

It means that we're not mid-pandemic.

But I wonder if, John, if I can start with you.

Crisis. They're coming at us thick and fast.

And I know this morning there was a discussion about the multitude of crises, the poly crisis, if you like.

Do any of them stand out to you as individually the biggest thing to worry about, or is it the lot of them at once?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Look, Hamish , I think we're always looking for this, and it's almost like a hangover to 20th century management.

And that is that if we just look hard enough, prioritise three things, the top three things and handle those, everything will be okay.

I think we've entered a period of what I'd like to say, 3 Cs and three Vs.

And that means that it's actually the system-wide crisis that's the problem.

And that is that we have continuous concurrent and cascading risks, cascading being the hardest for organisations to deal with.

We have a volume, velocity and variety of things coming at us.

And that is sort of affecting us at the macro and micro level.

So if you're in Victoria now, the number of volunteer firefighters is drastically, and SES people, is drastically dropping because they're constantly under this pressure.

So for me, it's that combination of events and that impacts on our resilience, but also impacts on, we can't just concentrate on one thing.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So Alan Kirkland, where does that leave us as a society, as a community?

Is our capacity to respond lowered or are we more alert to the possibility of crisis?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Look, I think there is a real story of resilience.

I mean, you see incredible examples of community and individual resilience, but I think

That's in a context where that sort of sense of polycrisis or overlapping crisis, there is a real human impact or face to that.

So if you're, say, a small business owner somewhere like Lismore or even Taree or Cairns, like in recent years, you might have yourself been put out of your home due to a major flood.

You're living in a community that's still dealing with the impacts of being hit by a major event.

You're in a regional community, which means like an event on the other side of the world, like the Iran conflict, has a particular impact because everybody needs fuel to get around.

If you're buying products as part of your business, the input costs are up because fuel costs are embedded in those input costs and things have to be transported.

So this sense of overlapping crisis, it is something that people are actually living through.

What the way in which that translates into our work as a regulator is in that focus that people are going to get sick of hearing about, which is about getting the basics right.

So, if you're a busy individual or small business owner dealing with all those types of events, then...

you need your bank to be paying you the right interest rate.

You need to be making sure you're paying the insurance premium you're promising, you're getting any discounts.

You shouldn't be being overcharged and you shouldn't have to police those institutions.

So, you know, in that sort of complex environment.

getting the basics right is really, really important.

And then that's even more important if somebody then experiences another significant event and they really need to make a call on their financial institution.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: I've been talking about this with colleagues and some experts in the last week or so because of the Nvidia scandal.

And description was put to me was that businesses are used to at a national security level having governments try and protect them.

But the nature of the threat and the challenge is evolving so quickly that it's actually very hard for governments to regulate, to protect in a way that big corporations might be used to.

You don't necessarily assume that your CEO will be the target of a honey trap, as it were.

So how are you thinking about that balance, that tension between governments and then the private sector taking responsibility or sharing it?

Mr Alan Kirkland: For us it's about clarity of expectations and that's that real focus on basics is part of it.

And in terms of the message for businesses, it is one about resilience.

So businesses need to be actively thinking about the threats that may come at them and the measures they take to protect against those threats, to mitigate the impacts if they are.

are hit by an incident and things like cyber incidents, you've got to think of it as something that will happen rather than something you can stop.

And then making sure they're ready to respond if there is a particular incident.

And it's not just big firms.

I mean, what happened with fridges in supermarkets in Europe recently being dialed up to 50 degrees and a lot of food spoil.

It just shows any business can be hit by one of those types of events and they need to be really alert to those risks.

And often it's really basic failures that expose businesses to risks.

And really having eye to those basic failures is critical.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So that's a really interesting example, right?

Because initially some of the countries in Europe were reluctant to say this is a hybrid threat, this is Russia or this is Iran.

But ultimately they have come out, the big countries like France have designated this as a hybrid warfare tactic.

What happens in that, from a regulatory point of view, in that in-between time where it's unclear?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Well, I mean, for ASIC, in an incident like that, if that happened in Australia, to be honest, a lot of our focus would be on getting out of the way.

So You really want the businesses to be able to be focused on how do they most appropriately respond in the moment, to understand the threat, to mitigate against it, to be communicating appropriately with their customers and stakeholders where they can.

But most importantly, working with the cybersecurity agencies.

And in a way, they will have the lead in an incident like that in Australia.

We'll be wanting to sort of understand what's happening if it's a firm that we regulate.

But in the short term, we're trying to stay out of the way so the focus can be on the right response.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Whoever thought that ASIO

be interested in your fridge.

Chandry, crisis plans, I suspect a lot of people in this room have got them, have looked at them, have gone back and looked at them again.

They may look robust.

Are they necessarily fit for purpose in this evolving environment?

Ms Chandri Gupta: I do feel in this involving environment, we probably need to stop calling them crisis plans and just call them BAU plans because there's a crisis happening all the time.

We are living through one crisis to another.

The other aspect is we've seen our businesses over the last decade really hyper curate sales, like really personalise what you get sold at what time, at what price, yet we haven't seen hyper curation of customer support.

So when crises happen,

that everyone is actually experiencing them very differently.

So if we say we look at the Outlook outage that happened on Friday, for some people it was just a day to do away with emails, but for others it would have been a loss of income.

It would have been a loss of business.

And we at the moment have a very stock standard way that we respond to crises.

It's like a textbook approach of what that crisis would look like.

But when these things happen, we also have to realize because of how high

curated our individual choices are and also how we are experiencing the markets, which again, are so personalized, how what we feel and what we end up experiencing is so different.

And that's one of the aspects we really need to consider.

And I would really like to see businesses lean into what personalized customer support would look like, what personalized hardship would look like, especially in those crises moments, but build those up across

across even your BAUs as well.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So Brendan, a moment ago, Alan mentioned the stepping out of the way in a crisis.

And I think we can all right now conjure examples of various crises where we've seen agencies or politicians saying, I'm stepping out of the way, but it not being obvious who steps in and does stand up.

How do you view that given the experience you had as the chief health officer?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Yeah, look, I think it's interesting to reflect on the crisis plan that we had during COVID.

We had a pandemic plan that was based on pandemic flu.

And I think one of the challenges is that whilst we were prepared for a pandemic,

What we're not prepared for is our leaders aren't prepared for the versatility and adaptability to work in a changing environment.

So a good example, you know, our pandemic plan did not envisage that we would ever close international borders.

The World Health Organization said that was a completely inappropriate thing to do.

Other similar countries said it wasn't.

And our plan said we shouldn't do that.

It was disproportionate.

But We were faced with a situation where the National Cabinet had given me as chair of AHPPC and all the state and territory chief health officers the task to come and give them the best advice.

And our best advice was to not do what the WHO said, to not do what our plans said, but because we were being absolutely killed by importation of people from overseas.

And that situation where we closed the international borders, which we did on Saturday, the 2nd of February, 2020, the decision was made at 9:00.

We did it by 9:00 that night.

And I'm completely convinced that had we not closed those borders, we would have ended up a bit like Italy or New York with very bad outbreaks and thousands and thousands more deaths.

So I think the critical thing about

preparedness and plans is not that it's good to have them, but more important is to exercise them and test them in completely bizarre and unexpected circumstances and to test the agility of leaders to respond to changing information and changing knowledge.

And I think it's very important that you have political leaders.

I've got to say that the National Cabinet

particularly in the first half of 2020, functioned incredibly well, I would bring them the consensus advice and they would say, okay, we'll do it, even if they didn't agree with it.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Can I just pick up on something there?

Because I imagine for the folks in this room, they're thinking about the outcomes for their consumers.

You're talking about a very acute outcome, a possible death, and you're saying, have your plan, but be willing to change it and adapt it in real time.

the process leading to the concluded crisis plan would have been thorough, it would have been diligent, it might have been evidence-based.

What happens if you're then trying to adjust it and change it without necessarily a strong evidence base?

You say you came to them with a consensus position from the health officers, but we don't need to rehash the argument.

There were, there continue to be questions about what the evidence base was for some of that.

So I just wonder if

as a kind of overlay to the thinking that everyone here might be doing.

How could you apply the lesson you learned from that?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Yeah, I think you just have to be completely open to discarding sacred cows.

Even, you know, things were changing so quickly during COVID.

We were learning about this virus.

This committee that I chaired met every single day in 2020, every weekend, every Saturday and Sunday.

And the data and the information was changing all the time.

And you had to be

prepared to pull in the best available data and synthesise.

And you're absolutely right.

I mean, we had public health commentators in the media, some better qualified than others, I'd have to say, even some journalists who thought they were public health commentators.

But they

But some of those well-qualified public health commentators were saying quite disparate things.

Go harder, go softer.

So we had to try and bring about a consensus, middle ground view and get the sensible position and then go to the national capital and say,

this is what we think is the best position, but there's a lot of uncertainty about it.

And when we would show them those pandemic curves, some of them were absolutely terrifying.

They were mind-boggling.

Every ICU overwhelmed, run out of ventilators in three weeks.

We'd say that's very unlikely, but that's possible.

And at the other end, this is happening.

So you've just got to be prepared to change your mindset, change your position, and act on the evidence on a real-time basis.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So, John,

if we're thinking about consumers or a general public, part of the response is always going to be communication and it will be information.

Can you talk about how rapidly the information environment is changing and how much that challenge is different even to what it might have been five or six years ago when COVID started to unfold?

Dr John Coyne: Look, I was qualified and

military capability called psychological operations.

And during the first Gulf War, shaping behaviour was very easy.

You flew over the top of Iraq, the positions, and you dropped pamphlets out and said, tomorrow, take this and surrender, or tomorrow we're going to drop bombs on you.

And the next day B-52 would bomb them, and then they'd do that again, and they'd behave for people who'd surrender.

The information environment now, so when you look at that, it's like the point of trust in the source, the information.

So by the second time you've dropped pamphlets, the person at the other end understands that there's a serious threat and they're going to do something about it.

Fast forward and there's no sense of truth and the speed at which information passes.

And I'm not talking here about shaping narratives on its own.

And the misunderstanding about, so for starters, the irony.

I read quite often, as you will do, why trust someone with a PhD?

The same person then will say they'll trust someone who's a truckie from wherever who has a million followers as a more sensible sense of truth.

We know part of that has to do with the decline in trust in government, but ironically, during COVID-19, the first several months, trust

spiked up.

Secondly is that the nature of algorithms, the nature of online presence is you can hop in and see all these people speaking out about issues, giving a new form of truth.

But they actually don't represent.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So then how do businesses, how do institutions, how do governments...

think about that.

If there's say a whole generation, there's whole demographics now that are more inclined to get their information from social media than from mainstream media or to trust necessarily what a previously trusted business would tell them in a moment of crisis, what's the advice?

What do you do?

Dr John Coyne: The advice is giving information early and putting the precursors around that and caveats around that.

People are looking, so if we look at the fragmentation of the information environment, the reason the extremes get so much attention is because they offer a very, they offer clarity.

So they say, take a complex issue like inflation, they turn around and say, it's government's fault, and then the next thing, so they're giving you someone to blame.

The simple thing that government needs to do is A, and so

with that, they provide the hardest thing for us is being able to, whether it's businesses or whether it's governments, is being able to establish that truth early and being as correct as possible with that and identifying the shortfalls.

And I think this has been often missing where we try to give, you know, we try to give early things.

So, you know, you'll know as a journalist, you know, when we report crimes, so if someone's murdered, it's not alleged murder, it's a murder.

Okay.

If We have a suspect who's been charged.

It's a murder with an alleged offender.

And it's that sort of important clarity that the public needs to have.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: But Chandni, I think statistically a lie will travel about five times faster than a fact in the digital environment.

In a crisis, how do you contend with that?

What are the implications of that?

Ms Chandri Gupta: So when I was hearing John speak right now and I was like, yes, early information, good information, clear information is great.

But there's a real gap here of who will even see that information.

So we've got digital platforms who have very little accountability on what is shown.

So you, again, it goes to that hyper curation of our worlds where you are either shown what is in within your bubble or you are shown absolute extreme to get your extreme reaction.

to things and there is nothing in between.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Okay, so those are the sort of extreme versions of this.

But crises are by their nature quite complicated and a lot of the crises we've been discussing, the answer, the explanation may not be clear.

It may be murky, it may be complicated.

So I'm thinking about bushfires, for example, covered the black summer bushfires back just before COVID, in fact, and there were a lot of stories about arson

and a lot of stories about climate and people describing this as a climate catastrophe.

But the answer from the authorities in that circumstance tended to be along the lines of, we don't apportion any particular event to climate change, but we can say that climate change has created the conditions in which these bushfires have fled.

That's A nuanced response to a very big physical problem in front of us.

And so tweets and stories, misinformation about arson took hold.

So I can think of any number of other examples like that.

How do you contend with that?

The fact, the truth, is often far more nuanced than what the simple answer is.

Ms Chandri Gupta: And I think that that is the issue, that we don't deal with nuances anymore, especially in our online world.

And one of the ways to really help to be able to do that

is to have where there's accountability on the actual platforms that are pushing that information out.

So we've got at the moment, the government's considering a digital duty of care obligation, and it's those kind of levers that we'll see hopefully where you are going to get the right information, the nuanced information early and not have going down rabbit holes that you otherwise don't need to.

There is this tension we have

the moment where everything is put on you as an individual to manage that risk, as opposed to looking at the broader frameworks and institutions that are actually peddling a lot of that.

And actually their frameworks are the ones that are then causing us to see the misinformation for us to react to that misinformation.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Alan, I can imagine, you know, for the sorts of people that are here,

very big consequences if misinformation or disinformation, which is a more deliberate version of a similar thing, if it takes hold.

And think about implications for markets, for systems, in fact.

So how do you think about it in that context?

Mr Alan Kirkland: I mean, I think part of it's about what do we do when we're not in a crisis situation to make sure that we're really well prepared to respond.

So, I mean, ASIC for us, a lot of our focus has been really on trying to make our presence as a trusted source of information as strong as it can possibly be.

So, I mean, I think it's fair to say we've had a much more assertive media stance in terms of mainstream media in recent years, and that's about trying to give people a sense that as a regulator, we will step in and respond to evidence of serious harm and we will talk about what we're doing.

and why it's important and why we're concerned about the conduct that we've seen.

Part of it's then also about reaching people in different ways.

So we've rebuilt our online presence.

We've got a social media team that's doing really innovative things, getting to people through a range of different sort of social media forms on different channels, which again is about just trying to establish us as a source of information.

So if you really need to draw upon that in a crisis, you've got it there to work with.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Can you expand on that a little bit, because I think that's a story that we've seen

with the Reserve Bank as well, Michelle Bullock and others far more out and available in the media.

There's a press conference after each meeting, Andrew Hauser out doing media interviews and the rest of it.

How have you come to the conclusion that you've come to about establishing yourself as a voice outside of a crisis period?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Look, I think there'll be a range of factors that fit into that.

But if you looked at

I guess, measures of trust in institutions over the last decade or so.

There has been a general long-term trend of declining trust in institutions.

And so ASIC as a regulator, we look at that and say, well, we need to sort of fight back against that, right?

To the extent that we can influence that, we need to be building trust.

And that's not just about wanting people to think nice things about ASIC.

It's actually about making the system work well, because for people to participate confidently in markets, they need to have a degree of confidence that

will work fairly and effective regulation is part of that.

So that's been a key thing that's driven it.

But then it is then with a consciousness that when bad things happen, we need people to have a sense that they can trust us as a source of information around what they need to do right then, what information to listen to, and what we might be warning them about in the moment.

Dr John Coyne: Amish, can I just add to that?

I think the other part is that we do run the risk in what we're discussing here to mistake noise for veracity.

And so, and secondly, we're talking about it in an absolute sense.

So we're, so the noise for veracity.

So if, and I don't think there's a magic formula for it, but yes, there's always going to be on every government announcement a percentage of people who will create conspiracies.

There'll be others who won't.

Now we have the ability to sort of amplify that.

And even in your profession in journalism, like we're increasingly saying, you know,

we're increasingly seeing there'll be a news report and then it'll be these comments were left on social media.

Now...

Mr Hamish Macdonald: As in the newspaper will report the comments that were on the social media.

Dr John Coyne: Yeah, and I think from general public and I think in terms of noise and veracity, you know, there's a lot of people who get a line of noisy groupings or will say things, but whether that's representative.

Secondly, is that

it's not as an end state.

It's not like we're going to get 100% of people to listen to ASIC or to listen to government on a certain issue and follow it.

And I think this is in terms of countering these things.

And I actually think, you know, the genie's out of the bottle once the crisis starts.

And so we're doing a lot of work at the moment with

and starting a major project with PMC and so Prime Minister and Cabinet at the federal level and Defence going, how do we build our cognitive security in Australia pre-events, like in terms of crisis.

And I think these are important.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Brendan Murphy, you could understand why if you're in the private sector, a crisis hits your business that you retreat.

that you maybe put out a statement on your website or on social media or you put out a press release, but you don't put your people up to talk.

I can understand the reasons why you might do that.

Is there a risk to that approach?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Yeah, I think there is a risk.

I mean, I think we, again, I'm a bit of a COVID one trick pony at this forum, but during COVID, we were very

very concerned.

All the first ministers and all the chief health officials were very keen to be out there in the public domain responding to questions.

I think the challenge that we had was we had to try and keep the message simple.

I used to have these big discussions with Scott Morrison who would do press conferences together.

And he would talk, give all the description of what happened at National Cabinet.

He'd say, what are you going to say?

And I'd say, I'm going to say one thing, Prime Minister.

It'll be one public health message that those who are listening to the mainstream media can take home, because that's all people could remember.

And I think I'm told that that way of approaching was reassuring to those people who are listening to the public media.

And the same thing was happening in all the states and territories at the same time.

But I think as we've alluded to earlier, there are a group of people who don't listen to the mainstream media and didn't during COVID.

And the social media scourge for us was,

really bad during the vaccination rollout.

And I think the anti-vaxxer movement have a lot to answer for.

We've now, one of the long tails of COVID is the fact that our childhood vaccination rate is now as low as it's been for a long time.

And measles has broken out in America and kids are dying.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Well, I think today, in fact, the United States is being declared no longer to be measles free.

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: It's not a measles free country.

For a first world country, that is absolutely bizarre.

Now that there's failures at the highest political level there too, but I think the anti-vaxxer movement has driven this and we in health during COVID, we decided not to respond to that by

sort of regulation or trying to shut them down.

I just hired a room full of 20 year olds and pushed out good social media.

And we developed a big social media presence that was trying to put the right information out there using all those channels to try and counteract it.

But to what extent we got to them, I'm not sure.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: But the fracturing of the information ecosystem is also leading to fracturing of society, community.

We talk a lot about social cohesion.

Could you today in Australia implement a lockdown?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: I think the likelihood of civil society compliance with the sort of lockdowns that happened in Victoria and some of the snap lockdowns that happened in other states is probably low.

I think people were

quite severely affected by some of those prolonged lockdowns there are generations of kids whose schooling was affected um and I I mean some of them were incredibly well justified I think if Victoria hadn't done that lockdown in the second half of 2020 they didn't have the capacity to bring that outbreak under control they just did not have the public health resources and so that did save lives but then

after Victoria did that and then other states stopped Victorians coming into state, we lost some of the wonderful national cohesion that we had in the first half of 2020 where national cabinet, everyone did the same thing.

And I think people, some states then got a bit frightened that they might experience what Victoria had and we started to see some reactive lockdowns.

And I'm not convinced that people necessarily saw the

a transparent justification for all of them and so I think the community or sections of the community would be much more resistant particularly to prolonged and very restrictive things some of the things that you know in Victoria like taping off playgrounds so that kids people couldn't communicate in playgrounds or curfews or the like are probably unlikely to be complied with okay so.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Chandni, what about individual responsibility?

You were saying, we're in an environment now where the individual's left to figure things out to some extent.

Your suggestion may not happen immediately.

How then does business, how do institutions interact with the reality that we exist with right now, where people are, going wherever they want to seek information, coming up with their own sets of facts, living according to those

sets of facts and values.

Ms Chandri Gupta: One of the things that really at the moment I continue to think about is the fact that we are living in almost a continuous set of micro crises.

So you've got people, for example, millions of mortgage holders, millions of

millions of renters are struggling to pay.

And one thing we don't have in all of this is certainty.

Anyone who's a mortgage holder cannot predict what they will be paying and what that amount will be in three months time, in three years time.

And when we look at a lot of comparable

jurisdictions around the world, they have something we don't have.

They've got long fixed term mortgage rates, they're able.

So there are some really foundational things that give you certainty.

So that gives you then the space to deal with other certainty.

If you ask people in other countries

who the equivalent of an RBA is, many people wouldn't be able to answer.

And then if you ask them when do they actually meet for their monetary policy meeting every month, they wouldn't be able to answer.

But here in Australia, we have millions of people who know the first Tuesday of every month, I will find out whether the cash rate goes up and as a result,

In all of that, will my mortgage payment go up?

It's a real uncertainty that people are living with.

And one of the things we, as businesses and institutions, governments, need to think about is where can you provide really foundational certainty that gives them the cognitive space to deal with some of those other uncertainties that come into play?

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So what's an example of what you're thinking about?

How could they do that?

Ms Chandri Gupta: Well, for one of the things that I've really seen is things, well, one of the examples like for,

I think it's within those particular aspects.

So say for mortgage lending to be able to offer really long term fixed mortgage rates.

So you're able to predict what that looks like.

For renters, renters are living year by year and not knowing whether their rent will go up 10%, 20%.

There's no caps on rent increases.

There's also no, for many states, there's not even protections of what happens of what an eviction might look like.

So it's those real levers that across we actually have as governments, governments have the power to make those adjustments to give certainty in those spaces to then enable where things can go to deal with the other uncertainty that happens.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Okay.

Alan, what happens if we talk about in terms of disinformation, we talk about something called the liar's dividend.

You don't need everything in the information system to be fake.

You don't even need half of it.

But if you have enough of it, citizenry will start to doubt everything that they see.

And I was thinking, reflecting on this in the last week when there was the Microsoft outage and then there was the airlines being grounded in the United States.

I reckon most people in this room at some point would have thought, I wonder if this is connected and I wonder if this is a cyber thing.

I wonder if this is an AI.

you know, breach or hack.

How are you thinking about, I guess, the increasing doubts that we all have, even when it's not necessarily a big crisis?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Look, I think we have to give people more credit than we sometimes do.

So we should not, we'll all see those sort of conspiracy theories circulating on social media.

That doesn't mean that everybody believes them, right?

So people might see them, engage with it briefly, but

Most people do actually have capacity for nuance and they will process information from a range of sources and form their own views.

So I think we need to be conscious of those misinformation threats and preparing for them and responding appropriately, but also not be too distracted by them.

And I think particularly in a crisis situation, what really matters is clarity of messaging and messaging that is really relevant to what people need to know in the moment.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: But if that's the example right,

Microsoft is a big global business.

That was a really significant outage.

Did you hear anyone from Microsoft explain what happened?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Look, I'm not here to defend Microsoft, but in a way, I mean, I think their focus was on this is, to what I saw, this is what's happening now.

This is what's down.

This is what we're doing to restore services.

To some extent, that's kind of what people need to know, right?

I mean, all the pulling apart of what happened and why it can happen in the months after.

I think what people

is how is this impacting me now?

What should I do, if anything, as an individual or as a business?

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Yeah, but I suppose my question is, as that's unfolding, who is society meant to learn that information from?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Look, I think it really does depend on the crisis.

I mean, in a situation like that, there's not a strong role for government to step into that void.

In a situation like a pandemic, there's obviously a strong role for government.

If it's a financial crisis, then various of the financial regulators will play a role.

So I think it really does depend on the situation.

Often it will fall to bodies like ASIC to step in.

But what does really matter is there's still the same principles, simple, clear messages about what people need to know right now.

We can deal with the kind of causes and you know where it came from and how

what could have happened differently in the ensuing weeks and months.

It's really about what do people need to know in the moment?

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So there's a question from Carol Ferguson that I might put to Brendan Murphy.

How hard is it to get the tone right for messages where there are differences in age, ethnicity, education?

So some might be offended because the message is too simple or not understand if it's too complex.

I imagine that's something you would have considered many, many times during the COVID period.

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Oh, absolutely.

And I think specifically

In COVID, a lot of the highest risk communities were exactly those people for whom it was hard to communicate.

And we set up at the beginning of the pandemic a lot of structures, engagement with CALD communities, aged care, disability and First Nations communities and tried to make sure that we would tailor the communication through those mechanisms.

I think we did best

with First Nations because we had an existing environment of trust between the First Nations communities and the Commonwealth Health Department based on many years of trust, which is not something they have with all agencies.

And we were able to use those structures we had to protect our First Nations communities.

And we did very well in that space.

We did less well in called communities because we had to

You had to set up bespoke mechanisms, state and territories and the Commonwealth to engage with specific communities.

There were a lot of challenges in Western Sydney with various called communities that each needed their own bespoke community engagement scheme.

And you have to draw on the resources of those communities to craft those messages.

But it's so much harder to do that in the middle of a crisis

if you haven't established a relationship of trust and communication in peacetime, which is why it worked so well in the First Nations space.

So I think the lesson from that is that looking at those diverse communities, the health system generally needs to have existing mechanisms of communication, which can be used to communicate peacetime public health messages that can be called upon in a crisis.

to take the message, the core message and tailor it and communicate it through the right challenges.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: But John, a lot of those different groupings today might be in closed information networks or receiving information, consuming information even in a different language or in a different platform like WeChat for example.

If you're a business or an institution or government thinking about the crisis moment,

Are you trying to reach out into those platforms and spaces?

Or are you trying to draw those people from those spaces to a central information source?

Dr John Coyne: Look, I think there's two separate issues.

So quite often, and today we've talked a lot, in business we talk a lot about threat, or in business they talk a lot about threat.

So your things, mis and disinformation are two very different things, sometimes have the same impact.

But one is about likelihood and impact.

And the other one is about capability and intent.

So when we're talking about disinformation, we're talking about someone who has the capability and the intent to spread information and do harm or to do something that they shouldn't do.

And how we treat that is very different to how we treat something in terms of misinformation.

So first off, we have to be really

around that, we have to be really quite clear.

And I think this is where also we have to be clear around the difference between risk and threat.

So a lot of the conversation today has been about business risk, which is well understood and my colleagues in the private sector all understand that likelihood and impact or consequence.

If we look at it more broadly,

All our systems, whether it's free markets, supply chain systems, are based on a strategic context that no longer exists.

Or it's certainly, so I call it contested globalization.

So we have systems that are for a different time.

And I think in the same way we're thinking about communication as for a different time.

So you can actually sit there, take, and you'll be a game for me of this.

So the morning after Bondi, the terrible Bondi attack, absolutely.

A journalist got on to one of the morning television shows and I'm not criticizing the journalist, but he said, I don't know how this could possibly have happened.

It's like, this is totally a shock.

I thought all this terrorism stuff was over and done with.

The Director General ASIO for two years had been saying the national terrorism threat level is probable, which is greater than 50% chance of an attack.

And so when I talk to both, whether it's home affairs or the media, it's on both sides.

So first off, we weren't listening to the messages that were coming out.

And on the other side, obviously it wasn't being communicated in a way and still isn't that the general public can understand.

There's things that, and I think you touched on at the start, if we're talking about business and we're talking about resilience in this room and looking back at the previous panel, there's things that corporates can do.

Then there's things that

sectors, industries can do.

And there's just some things that government will need to intervene if we want resilience because resilience has a value.

The same in this communication space.

Some things individual, some things community, some things elsewhere.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: But in terms of describing threat, government agencies, even the politicians will often be deliberately broad and ambiguous about what the shape of it might be, which I wonder about

what that sort of then prepares everyone else for.

If you're making the argument for we're going to spend $300 billion on some nuclear powered submarines because there's an increased threat of conflict, but you'll never really say, because we particularly fear China, and this particularly changes the geostrategic threat in our region if we possess these vessels,

Unless you're going to say that explicitly, it then leaves the community wondering a bit about why we're spending all this money, doesn't it?

Dr John Coyne: And look, Hamish, you know, it was easier.

I was writing and reflecting on this piece that was in the Aus today.

And it's easier if we turn around.

Look, when John Howard told us to be alert, but not alarmed after, so we'd had September 11, then we'd had the Bali bombings, it resonated with us.

And where trust was at in terms of government meant that

we listened again, we said, well, there's something to be worried about here.

We still make jokes about being alert and not alarmed, as in the general public, but it resonated a lot more.

Now, and for a room like this, in the private sector, I sort of sit there and say, look, the China's interesting.

I spent 36 years in national security.

That's all I've ever done.

The last 12 in a think tank.

This is complex.

And the answer to what you're saying,

We want to sell iron ore and we want to sell coal because it's in our national interest to China.

And at the same time, we don't want them investing.

Our Foreign Investment Review Board has said we don't want them investing in critical minerals because that's not in our national interest.

And strategic uncertainty is rising.

So we need to buy capabilities and be ready for a range of contingencies.

Getting that across in a 10 second grab for people who are worried about

feeding their families, paying rent, all these is incredibly hard.

And the end point is not everyone being convinced.

And at the moment, you know, that's where take the Lowy poll and I, so 58% of Australians earlier this year said that, or poll sample said that they believed Australia should get a nuclear submarine.

ou know, another one study by the US study sent out 23% of Australians

thought they had knew enough about why we needed submarines.

So there is some work to do in these sorts of things.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So as you're saying that I'm thinking, in the last couple of years I've been filming in places like Finland, in Poland, in Taiwan, and you have a much more elevated citizenry awareness of threat, but the threat is much more proximate.

And so

Don't we have a challenge in a country like Australia where we sort of pride ourselves on being geographically removed from a lot of the threats of the world, but also I think kind of psychologically maybe pride in our more relaxed attitude, which presumably is something we want to preserve.

We like people being able to vote in their Speedos.

We like not necessarily having armed guards everywhere.

That's a delicate balance to strike in a more risky environment, isn't it?

Dr John Coyne: Yeah, but it's also, I guess, at the national level.

So let's take for a moment.

If I lived in Darwin, okay, I'm used to the fact that at least two or three times a year that when I go to the supermarket, the shelves are empty because there's been heavy rain that have knocked out rail and road.

And the time between that and government intervening to fly stuff in delays.

So I have water at home, I have other things.

The people I deal with in Weipa, in Cairns, Cairns has been hit so many times by Naturally.

So their level of resilience is different.

So I grew up on cattle stations, so it annoys still my wife because I feel that I have to have two things of toothpaste there.

She's like, you can get them whenever you want.

I'm like, no, because we just get flooded in.

We only go to town every so often.

We're sort of losing that in this environment where in terms of that resilience of what we need.

The other part is, the reason I give the two examples of, I guess, of northern Queensland is, you know, if you're living in Finland, you can, to use a famous, almost vice president of the US, you know, I can see Russia from my front porch.

You know, I guess, you know, they're used to having that threat on their border.

Taiwan is used to that.

I think right now we have to understand that the world, we haven't communicated particularly well on terrorism, let alone cyber, let alone climate change.

We're in a very different place.

And that also means, so back to where I started with risk in this room, that also means what you thought once were low likelihood events, but high impact, they're increasing, their frequency is increasing.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So there's a question here from Xian Chin.

What are the panel's view on tighter regulation of social media companies versus maintaining freedom of information and expression?

Alan, I'm not going to ask you to weigh in on the politics of that, but just in terms of regulatory frameworks keeping up with the advancement in technology, I think this is a story that we're dealing with time and time again.

An incident will occur and then government will say, well, actually the laws that we have, the frameworks that we have, don't necessarily

work here, that must be dizzying for someone in a role like yours.

Mr Alan Kirkland: Well, it is.

And look, when it comes to firms within the areas we regulate, financial firms, we've got some really strong core laws that will apply to many forms of emerging conduct.

I think where it's more challenging is where you get firms that aren't automatically captured.

And so social media is a great example.

And I think, I mean, I can sort of to some extent respond to the question from our perspective as a

to disrupt investment scams.

We would say that people are lured into investment scams through social media and digital platforms should be doing more to prevent those ads appearing in the first place, to take them down when we draw them to social media platforms' attention, to be actually out and looking for them themselves and taking them down and disrupting them, to stop taking money from what are obviously scammers, and to some extent the governments recognise that, or to a large

And the government's recognized that with the scams laws that are coming in, which will impose new obligations on those digital platforms.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: When you say it's sort of well set up currently, how far ahead are you thinking?

We had the last year's physics Nobel laureate in yesterday, who's a quantum physicist, and he started talking about post-quantum computing cryptography and how we're going to need totally different

security settings for our financial systems.

Are we thinking that far ahead or are we much more proximate?

Mr Alan Kirkland: Oh no, it's very much part of the conversation.

So as to whether anyone's got really crisp answers to what exactly you need to do, no, but it's absolutely something that regulators are talking about and it's increasingly part of our conversations with the firms that we regulate.

And then I guess for any sorts of emerging risk, I mean, we really think back to who are the kind of key

people in the system that play gatekeeper roles that can help to mitigate risk and protect people from harm.

So that's why you see us looking at the roles of people like auditors, super trustees.

Even research houses, like each of them in terms of trying to, I guess, make sure that there aren't risks that are emerging now that we should be worried about, but also to make sure they respond appropriately in volatile times.

We're really zeroing in on their roles and where we see failures, we're calling them out and where we see serious failures, we're taking enforcement action.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: And are you encountering more

I guess international operations that are less reluctant to engage with what your regulations are here.

Mr Alan Kirkland: That is absolutely a challenge and it is a challenge obviously in the scam space.

I mean it's well known we have quite well organised scam operations being run out of other countries, many of them now in Southeast Asia.

But there are still things that we can be doing onshore and that firms onshore can be doing to disrupt those scams.

It's obviously, again, wherever the scam operation is working from, often the way they get their consumers is through social media.

So there are still things that firms here can be doing to try and protect people and disrupt and intervene.

And we're really focused on what those firms can be doing.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Maybe Chandni, you can address Xianqin's question about title regulation of social media companies versus maintaining freedom of information and expression.

I mean, is that binary even accurate?

Ms Chandri Gupta: Well, it's this feeling of digital platforms for decades now have been basically asked to do your homework and check it yourself as well.

So there's just this big gap in terms of regulation that we've seen in that space where they're not held to account.

So now we're starting to see governments going, okay, we do need to regulate them and it's great to see some of the laws that are being thought about.

I think we need to also even go beyond what enforcement will look like and what does proactive enforcement look like.

So as regulators, then a lot of the harms that happen are harms that happen that you can't just see and report.

They're harms that people aren't going to call the National Debt Helpline or an ombudsman and go, this is what's happened to me.

So we need also to see what enforcement looks like that side.

And then there's the penalty side.

A lot of these digital platforms, they're trillion dollar companies.

It was four years ago, it was reported that Meta had just put aside 3 billion EUR in its budget just to pay privacy fines.

So it's just a budget line item as opposed to...

actually the penalty is going to mean something.

So it's actually the whole ecosystem that we need to be thinking about, regulation, enforcement and then how do we support and what does good resourcing look like for regulators so they can take action early?

Mr Hamish Macdonald: We are going to have to wrap up, but Brendan, I'm interested in your thoughts on this.

It's obviously the tech companies make this argument that it would be suppressing your freedom of expression if we regulate it.

Is that necessarily the case in your view?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Yeah, I think it's a really difficult balance.

my preference always is to challenge misinformation with good information and try and respond by putting the right messages out.

But I think there are some clearly damaging messages that came out there.

And we've had this huge debate in the medical board with APRA sanctioning doctors who've put

things that are clearly non-evidence-based and dangerous on their social media.

And they're going after the individual who's posted that much to the...

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Come on, Cayenne Pep is great, isn't it?

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Indeed, just to ward off an attacker.

So I think we really do need to

I think the sources of good information, health departments and the like, need to step up to the social media challenge by embracing it and putting out their own stuff and challenging it that way.

I think with regulation, I agree, there does need to be some when it's clearly dangerous and clearly malicious.

But sometimes you're chasing your tail and it's sometimes better to attack with good information.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: So if they're flooding the zone, you just flood the zone back.

Professor Brendan Murphy AC: Exactly.

Mr Hamish Macdonald: Okay.

It's been a really fascinating conversation.

Would you please thank Alan Kirkland, Professor Brendan Murphy AC, Chandni Gupta and Dr. John Coyne.

Gallery

Plenary session 3: Unlocking responsible innovation

  • Kate O’Rourke, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Matt Baxby, CEO, Revolut Bank Australia
  • Colin Payne, Head of Innovation, Financial Conduct Authority
  • Professor Nicholas Davis, Co-Director of the UTS Human Technology Institute
  • Christian Westerlind Wigstrom, Treasurer, Fintech Australia

Full audio (MP3 26.3 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: Starting with our panel discussion on ‘Unlocking Responsible Innovation.’ Joining me for this panel will be ASIC Commissioner, Kate O’Rourke; CEO of Revolut Bank Australia, Matt Baxby; Professor Nicholas Davis, who is the Co-Director of the UTS Human Technology Institute; Christian Westerlind Wigstrom, who is the CEO of Redbelly Network; and joining us virtually is Colin Payne, the Head of Innovation at the Financial Conduct Authority.

So while they join us on stage and take their seats, let’s set the scene a little. This session will discuss how innovation can deliver genuine benefits, improve access and support competition, while maintaining confidence in the financial system.

Thank you so much for your time everyone. Matt, we will start with you today, thank you very much for joining us. Can you provide some context for our wider discussion, and tell us about some of the products and services that Revolut has developed for retail customers? And when you step back, what were the key drivers for that innovation? Why did you do it?

Matt Baxby: Yeah, I think there’s probably three drivers from our perspective. First was business model. So if I think about the way Revolut’s developed globally, it hasn’t been a credit-led organisation. It’s been more of an activity-led organisation. And the reason that’s relevant to innovation is we’ve not been able to rely on more traditional ways that banks would typically generate profitability. So it’s not a net interest income, large back books that periodically repriced as a method for generating profitability. We’ve really had to think deeply about how do we engage our customers in a way that they think they’re using the app every single day.

One aspect of that, a good example, I think, is the subscription model that we’ve built. So anyone who’s not familiar with Revolut, we offer paid plans by tier. I guess the real point of difference around that is thinking about that not as a fee that’s paid, but a way of generating value or benefit for Australian consumers. So we’ll bundle benefits into each of those tiers, those paid plans, with things like subscription services, so an ability to learn language through Duolingo. We’ll offer increased FX rates. We’ll offer higher tiers of savings plans. So as I said, that business model’s definitely been one driver.

I think the second would be where there’s been some regulatory change. And obviously over the last 12 months, I think regulation of interchange and some of the changes around that have disrupted the market in a lot of ways. I’d regard that as a sort of fertile ground for a bank like Revolut to really lean in. We talk about playing offence versus playing defence. We didn’t have a large back book of customers to protect the way some other market participants might have needed to. So it’s meant that we’ve been able to really think differently about loyalty. Things like offering reward points on debit as a first in Australia, as an example of that. So market disruption being one of the drivers.

I think the final would be changes in technology. So the way customers expect to deal with their bank, I think, has fundamentally shifted. And that’s led us to think differently about some of the features we bring to market as well.

Moderator: There are those big disruptors and those big technological changes. But Christian, we were chatting before and you’ve said a lot of your innovations have happened behind the scenes, that consumers might not even know that they’re interacting with them.

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: That’s right, and I guess I’m a case in point. Everyone else on here is probably at least given authority by association. Everyone knows who ASIC is, etc. Redbelly might not be on the same list. And that’s because it is happening behind the scenes.

So to give myself a modicum of authority, I’ve just left a business called Manoova that I co-founded 10 years ago. It’s a business that no one has heard of, but 10 to 15% of Australians are transacting with behind the scenes. It’s the kind of business which, if you turn it off today, a surprising large number of people, possibly even in this room, go, oh, why can’t I do this thing that I could do yesterday?

Redbelly is, in many ways, a very similar opportunity. It is engaged in the pursuit of protocol finance. For those of you who have never heard of protocol finance, you’re not unique. But you might remember today as the day you heard it for the first time, and you will think of this in three years’ time, and you say, I was there. It was the one thing that set the scene for the next five years to go.

And here, too, we’re talking about something that isn’t really solving a burning problem. Financial services wouldn’t say, it’s all kaput. It’s all broken. No one can do anything. Who can save us? Oh, thankfully, Redbelly is here. Just like payments wasn’t broken 10 years ago when I started building Manoova. It wasn’t burning. People could make payments, and everyone was happy.

But I use the analogy of horses. In the 1890s, no one thought horses were spent. It took 17 days to get to Melbourne. So what’s the problem? That’s what it takes. But the day before the iPhone, no one used an iPhone, it doesn’t mean there isn’t a market, that there isn’t a better way of doing things. And I find that a lot of innovation here in Australia, as well as elsewhere, is of this sort of almost behind-the-scenes character. Which is obviously quite different from, say, Revolut’s been majestically successful in driving consumer, not just benefits and so on, but the brand. Everyone understands what it is and knows what it is.

To my mind, it’s interesting that when you look at something like the Australian fintech scene, so we’re talking about a scene that maybe punches above its weight in terms of publicity, but people still probably have a vague understanding of what it means, other than, say, Revolut or Wise or a few bigger brands. There’s something like 80,000 people employed directly. And again, if you were to turn off fintech, the next morning, it’s a very different world, a very different world indeed.

So what are we delivering then? Well, in terms of something like protocol finance, it is providing enablers. It’s a way of making sure that lots of things that we don’t think of as necessarily problems, but tensions and frictions. I’m sure many of us, at least the lucky ones, have at some point bought and possibly sold a house. And we’re taking a lot of their frictions for granted because, frankly, that’s what it’s always been like. And that’s always what it is until it isn’t.

And so you send your money, and it’s all of the money you have, and probably some more than all the money you have. And you’re really hoping that the solicitor is going to be there on that day, and you’re really hoping that if it’s a simultaneous settlement, the other bank and the other solicitor is going to be there too. And then it’s all fine most of the time, and we’re happy, and everyone wipes the sweat off.

It doesn’t have to be that. There are solutions to these things that we might not think of as one solution to many problems because they seem so distinct. It seems different to have counterparty risk on the settlement of a house, to having collateral that you can’t mobilise, to not earning interest on your current account. These seem like very different things. Not to mention that most of us, our problems are in terms of, I want to go home earlier on a Friday. I want to go home at four, not at six. Very few people are running around town saying, I need a better level one blockchain. And frankly, no one should have to do that. But it is the solution to lots of things, and it’s happening behind the scenes.

Moderator: Nick, you have a very good vantage point of all of this in your position, both the blatant changes and the behind-the-scenes changes. What have we seen in Australia over the past few years, past five years?

Nicholas Davis: Yes, because I spend all my time in that all-encompassing area of artificial intelligence, I’ll try not to dwell too much on the specifics. But on the consumer side, we are seeing more and more Australians becoming just kind of used to asking a chatbot for advice on different matters. And that’s leaking into financial advice and causing, and I think spurring, many of the banks and fintech providers to try and tread very carefully on what constitutes the type of advice that they are licensed and able to give and what their exposure is as financial licensees.

But then there’s this whole wealth of shadow financial advice happening out there as well. You know, Colin’s on the line with us from the FCA, and the FCA put out a really interesting survey in August this year, saying, I think, chatbots are now trusted by more than half of young investors in the UK, something like 58%, they trust it higher than social media or celebrities and TV ads, etc. There’s this movement there on the consumer side, which I think is challenging in an innovation sense for many organisations in terms of being able to understand how far they can go and compete with those relatively, or currently not outside the law, but certainly in that area of not being clearly able to push on at the moment.

Then the second big shift is this movement from then chatbots to agents. And there, the innovation inside financial services in particular is largely back end. We see some of the biggest banks in the world, particularly JP Morgan is one of the biggest strategic banks, and Bank of America and others, but also here in Australia, really looking at ways for the back end to be much more efficient and supported through agentic AI.

But I think the most interesting story systemically at the moment in terms of how we think about responsible innovation, is when everyone has a personal AI agent that’s acting out in the world and potentially interacting with your bank account or your other aspects of your life. Meta Muse hasn’t launched here in Australia yet. Instinct is available to a small number of people, but there are these aspects of use of AI that I think are really going to push the competition, regulatory, and just some of those responsible questions about how responsible are we being on a systemic level to the movement of money by automated agents day-to-day, and what could that do to prudential as well as scam-related concerns in the economy.

Moderator: Yeah, it sounds terrifying to me. Probably a good time to bring in the regulator. Kate, what role can ASIC play in this? How can you regulate an agent, regulate a chatbot?

Kate O’Rourke: Oh, well, thank you. Hello, everyone. Yeah, thank you for the hardest question. I think that idea of the regulatory frame in which you consider these is both that, well, what have we already got by way of the laws and how might they already apply? So we do have very clear accountability provisions that if there is someone offering a service, it doesn’t matter how or with what technology, that gets you so far.

But then it does get more complicated when there’s that level of multiple agents involved, because then where does the consumer take some responsibility for the instructions that they’ve given or the actions that they’ve taken, or who has given them? Where’s that agent come from? Where’s that party in this equation?

So there’s definitely some regulatory questions to be asked. I think we can use as much as we can. I’m just picking up on what Sarah said this morning; what laws have we already got? Let’s make the most of those. Let’s offer as much certainty as we can, so we can get out of the way of some of the innovation. But then if there are new questions, picking up what Michelle said, let’s be proportionate and let’s be risk-based and evidence-based and try and be connected in how we think about tackling the issues together.

Moderator: Colin, we’ll bring you in now. The UK has had a sustained focus on facilitating innovation in financial products and services. What are some of the most interesting changes that you’ve witnessed for retail customers? And I suppose, how has the broader ecosystem changed?

Colin Payne: Yeah, thank you. Now, apologies, I’ve got a fairly unstable network, so I must apologise if I sound a bit weird, but let me know on the channel. We’ve seen a lot over the last 15 years, and whether it’s data-driven changes like open banking, into open finance, and as was just mentioned, the progress around digital and into agentic AI is probably the most profound shift we’ve seen in a generation now.

And so we are working, like ASIC, very fast to connect across regulators and to ensure we’ve got a really clarified response to these new personal agents. It’s not so much the agents within the firms that we regulate, it’s those who are outside of our perimeter that we’re really focused on. And that, I think, is going to be the major change that we see in financial services going forward.

Moderator: Thank you, Colin. Sorry, Christian, yes, jump in.

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: Well, I think it’s an interesting theme here coming up. Kate mentioned this sort of thing, can we reuse rules, or can we just apply more broadly rules that we already have? I do think, as we talk about responsible and, at some points, regulated innovation, it’s really important to understand, are we just talking about different technology that supports something, a product or a feature or whatever it is, a benefit? Or are we talking about something new in the eyes of the consumer of that product or feature?

I mean, a lot of things can change behind the scenes, and we can have faster methods of doing things, but it doesn’t change the nature and the concept that we’re working on. And I think, as we go through this conversation, I think keeping an eye on that technology agnostic view and just making sure that we know where we have a role to play and where we don’t.

Moderator: This is also, of course, a globally competitive space, so I guess it’s about striking the balance of protecting Australians while not holding back Australian innovators. Matt, I know you operate in the global sphere. How do you look at that or approach that?

Matt Baxby: I entirely agree. As I think about it, I think a local ecosystem and a global platform coming in can definitely coexist, and net consumers should be the beneficiary of that. I guess we see it play up in a few ways, back to business model. I think being part of a group that serves 80 million customers globally gives us a benefit in terms of economies of scale, but as importantly, access to innovation that might be happening in other markets.

If we see something that consumers have gravitated towards in Europe, the UK, Mexico, or any number of the 41 markets that we’re in, that’s relatively easy to pick up and for us to deploy into Australia, and there’s some really good examples of that. An example would be Revolut Air, which is our chatbot that we make available to customers in other markets, not in Australia yet. That provides insights to individuals’ finances based on the patterns we see across their data. And again, that’s a feature that’s really been embraced by consumers in other markets that we think has real application in Australia.

Moderator: Nick, we can’t isolate ourselves here, even if we wanted to, to protect ourselves, because consumers will go where they want.

Nicholas Davis: Yeah, I mean, this is something we’ve been struggling with as a market and benefiting from, but also struggling with in terms of the openness of digital systems is it’s hard to geofence availability of products and services. I’ve been a Revolut user since very early days, because I was overseas and needed a way to access some of the things that then were very rare available in financial services.

I guess when we come to this idea of what does it mean to do it responsibly, there’s a couple of key components. One of them is we want to make good decisions collectively to protect and steward the systemic, the solutions, to make sure that we’re sustainable here in Australia. To protect customers and ensure that we’re able to manage particularly vulnerable customers, and ensure that people aren’t exploited by scams and misinformation, etc. So there’s a whole bunch of really important regulatory, but also just good innovation rules that go on in place of that.

I do think that we have to look at – and I know that this is something that Colin’s looked at a lot – we have to just pay attention to who Australians trust when it comes to these kinds of innovations as well. The Privacy Commissioner earlier this year, OAIC, did a survey that showed that the trust in technology firms in general is falling amongst Australians. It’s down to about 27% if you just ask technology firms.

If you ask, do Australians trust an AI company with their personal data, it’s 4%, 4%. Which is a huge opportunity really for brands in Australia to say, hey, we’re doing the right thing. We are building products and services that actually look after your personal information and do so in ways that can still get you to those customer outcome or still get you to the stuff that we don’t see, but which is hyper-efficient in the back end.

And one more point, just because it’s in the news today, the state of California just put forward an action against Open AI on two grounds; unfair competition and being a public nuisance. Citing in part the Medicare incident earlier this year as part of a pattern of recklessness from an organisation that is innovating and doing so in a way that has real costs, both costs in terms of contravening, deceptive and misleading and unfair competition provisions in Californian law, but also actually creating harm by not managing that innovation well.

That’s an extreme case, but I do think it is instructive that the law provides for all of this. Existing powers, existing laws, nothing in that California state case is anything new. It’s all resting on the expectations we already have in law and in society.

Moderator: OK, with that in mind, how is ASIC approaching innovation? How is the government thinking about this?

Kate O’Rourke: Yes, I’ll pick up on – our Treasurer spoke to us earlier, including about productivity and regulatory burden, but also a more recent announcement from the government has been their financial innovation strategy. So there is a framework in which the government is thinking more widely about financial innovation.

For us at ASIC, we’ve got layers of the way we’re thinking about it. I mentioned earlier that more general way of just recognising in some ways the best thing we can do is get out of – not get out of the way, but be clear, be certain, and give people clarity about the things that we are concerned about, or that we’re not, and also our position on things.

So to the extent we can use our existing laws as much as we can, an example has been we’ve brought some cases to work out are different crypto products, financial products under the Corps Act? And some people might think, oh my goodness, is there anything more technical? But actually it really matters if you are or not a financial product. And so it’s not a new law, it’s an existing law. It’s meant to be technology neutral, but trying to work out what those boundaries are so the people who are in or outside that net have certainty, and others can choose to structure their products. So there’s that idea of just being clear.

And we’ve also got a general mindset at ASIC of trying to be easier to deal with, as well as harder to avoid. But the easier to deal with is the part around just to the extent businesses doing the right thing, going about their business, do need to register a company or get a licence or understand regulatory guidance. We’re doing a better job trying to be easier to understand, find, and so we’ve changed licensing processes and things.

There are some more specific things in financial innovation. So mainly we may use the same laws, but there are some new ones. So digital asset platforms. So this is not about the crypto that sits on them, but the platforms themselves, that idea of custody and some of those quite new risks associated with that. So there is quite a lot of implementation associated with that, and design work on updating our payment systems. So sometimes even neutral, meant to be neutral frameworks end up getting out of date.

And then the last is thinking about our regulatory sandbox. So we had a really good review done, and look, there’s things that can be definitely improved. So we’re asking ourselves who should be able to participate in a sandbox? What products, which regulatory frameworks should they get exemptions from? So some things that really react to some of those observations. So there’s plenty of work being done, but it’s under umbrellas of trying to be certain and easier to deal with.

Moderator: Christian, did you want to jump in?

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: Yeah, I think when I’ve seen the best possible, I guess sort of Team Australia, responsible innovation happening, has been both my 10 years in payments, going to what you said, Kate, and what we’re seeing now, actually on the digital asset side. It is when responsible innovation, I think almost by definition, responsible investment is – sorry, responsible innovation is almost like a collective cluster of innovating. Where in order for some members to be able to move forward for the benefit, it is thought, for consumers and others, we all have to do our different bits of the innovating.

So a commercial enterprise in its own right is probably going to be a really poor regulatory innovator. It might be a really poor innovator of tax rules to allocate finance for investment efficiently. But equally, the ATO might not be great at bringing out new financial products on tech. Like it might be different things that we play, but when we do it together, so I’d say actually a lot of credit here to ASIC, I know it’s running lots of things at the moment, but the Commonwealth Treasury and a few others, it is a real sense of we need to do it together.

There is a lot of consultation. I don’t know if everyone here has been part of them, but they are detailed, and they are multifaceted, and things that one would never have thought about as being even remotely part of it. As a private entrepreneur, you realise, OK, well, this hangs together with that, but it goes the other way too. So sometimes you get all these unintended consequences with sometimes pretty big unintended consequences, but it is not reasonable to expect any one party to have a full view, and it’s only really by coming together.

For me, responsible innovation is almost always anchored in a sense that we together innovate, and that it’s not in competition. I think anytime we start thinking about this as somehow either the regulators win or private enterprise win, we’ve all lost. It’s not the case that ASIC wins, Redbelly loses. In fact, it is both have to win, and that’s easier said than done. But I have seen over the last 10 and a bit years, actually, it’s an impressively large example or number of cases of this, and I think that’s what we can teach the abroad as much as we can probably learn a lot from them as well.

Moderator: We will go back to Colin now, but quickly before we do, just a reminder that you can send in any questions you have for the panel via the app. Colin, you recently wrote about trust, and the fact that consumers are being asked to trust new products and financial services that they don’t fully understand and are not necessarily reliable. What are the consequences of innovation getting ahead of trust?

Colin Payne: Yeah, I did speak about that. I think the problem with technology moving so fast is that it’s inverted that trust paradigm. So where we used to build trust and then release product, now it’s the other way around. We’ve got to work hard to convince and give the consumer the benefit that we understand what’s going on, and that they can trust the products we’re now seeing in the market.

We’ve talked about agentic, we’ve talked about other new products that are emerging, tokenised products. There’s a vast range, and I think that’s the real tricky part for the next couple of years. Because obviously our entire market relies on that trust, and it only takes one pillar to be taken away from that trust that supports financial services and we’re all going to be in trouble.

And it was great hearing that idea of working together. I really believe in that. I think the FCA and ASIC, I mean, we have a very similar approach, principles-based. We’ve actually said we’re tech positive, so we’ve gone a bit further, and we’ve also said we’re going to be the first agentic supervisor. So we’re probably moving a little ahead on some of these areas, but we’ve still got to bring the consumers with us. I think it’s absolutely critical we work globally on this as well. So it’s not just regulators and firms, it’s all global regulators ensuring there’s some interoperability to build the trust in systems that have to be global.

Moderator: Nick, from your perspective in terms of trust getting ahead of us, are consumers the victims of that or are they to blame to some extent? Is there a bit of fear of missing out that means people race into things not really caring whether they can trust it or not?

Nicholas Davis: I think we are all and have for a long time struggled. I think as individuals, as parents, as colleagues, always struggled with this idea that people love using something and yet still view it sceptically. And so that use of it is not necessarily the full picture, nor is the survey or reflection when people think about their best selves.

Partly that is possibly due to a little bit of addiction. I don’t trust that piece of chocolate sitting in the fridge or in the cupboard, but I’ll still eat it because I’m addicted to sugar. That’s something that I think means that pure measures of trust are not always a good insight into the quality of the thing that sits behind it. But it is an indication that some relational property, some element of the way that we’re viewing it is difficult.

And so the way I like to think of it, and I know that Colin, you’ve done some work on this, is for me, think about trustworthiness and try and put a number or a sense of how much this thing is worthy to be trust, rather than just my aggregate probability of whether other people trust it.

And then think about it in terms of three things; will this thing do what it says it does? Is it competent? Then second, is it reliable? Will it do it the same way or similar tomorrow enough that I can start to build my life around it or have it when I need it? And then the third one is, when it’s doing something, are its values aligned with mine? Like, is it actually doing it in my interests, or is it doing it with the view to potentially take something from me, right? And that piece of chocolate doesn’t have intention, but it’s definitely not values aligned, right? Like day-to-day, with me, right? And neither is the company that produced it, possibly.

The point that I’m trying to make here is when we start to think about responsible innovation – and the definition of responsible innovation is generally thought of as thinking about the future, thinking about the collective good and the collective process, and thinking about stewardship and managing common goods, right? And so when we think about trust playing into that, I come back to one of the most powerful ways that I see financial sector organisations, both building trust and building better products, which is really intense feedback from customers and employees, particularly for the larger organisations, launching products for their employees and testing the crap out of them first, and then going out to selected customer bases and testing in and piloting in very useful ways.

That is completely the opposite of most of our customer experience of some of the biggest social media and AI products, because they weren’t there one day, they’re there the next. We don’t feel we have any sense of say into how they operate or what they do. There’s no feedback that we seem to be gaining from in that sense. Nut it’s quite different for many brands where you do feel consulted and engaged, and that is being designed in your best interests, and that is explained well.

So that employee-customer engagement as a structured method, not as a PR aspect, but as an actual listening and innovation process, I think that’s probably one of the most powerful parts of this broader responsible innovation problem.

Moderator: Matt, you’re nodding along.

Matt Baxby: Yeah, I entirely agree with that, creating those feedback loops. I think that the part many of us in the room shouldn’t underestimate is the privileged position we’re in as licensed either banks, or different parts of the financial ecosystem, in terms of what that means in consumers’ eyes. They know we’re being held to a really high standard, and that counts for a lot.

And as I think about trust, I always think about it in terms of almost like Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. The bottom being, is my money safe? The next being, is the organisation I’m dealing with acting in my interests? And then innovation and features that I didn’t know I need are sort of top of the part, but unless that foundation’s really strong, that people feel like their money’s safe, and they’re being treated in a way that maintains that privileged position, that’s a real advantage, I think, banks and others in the financial ecosystem can really take advantage of.

And I think this comes through most strongly as banks think about how they continue to combat scams and their role in the industry as that rolls through, and how innovation can play a role in protecting people. It’s not just about the flashy features that enable me to move money seamlessly. It’s again, that base layer of knowing that my money’s protected and preserving that privileged position that we’re in.

Moderator: Kate?

Kate O’Rourke: Yes, I was just going to come back to a topic we were covering earlier around how do we deal with multiple agents or different parts of, whether you see it as the ecosystem or even a product having different aspects of it from different companies and some of them being offshore. This scams example’s been really interesting as we’ve tried to – I’m looking at Katrina in the front row there – build a multi-party, sort of multi-sector program associated with banks, telcos and digital platforms all being required to be part of this regulatory framework, so we can appropriately combat scams and appropriately hold people accountable if they are.

And it’s really hard, like it’s really hard to have in relation to one incident more than one company that might be responsible for it. It’s hard to have complaints mechanisms, it’s hard to have external dispute resolution, like it’s a challenge, and yet it’s got to be leant into. And I think an aspect of it that’s also hard is that some of the people are offshore. So I really hear Nick about the value of it being really a co-design, almost employees and people involved, but when they’re not in the country that gets tough.

So we can sort of do the best that we can, but sometimes the regulatory issues are new, because of the complexity of some of the intersections between the technologies. Which are wonderful, there’s wonderful aspects that everybody brings, but on the scam side all of that is being misused and supercharged.

Moderator: Christian?

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: Yeah, I think, so as my accent and my red trousers suggest, I’m Swedish, and Sweden is a country that is famous for its innovation as much as it’s famous for its institutional trust levels. So year after year there is a trust in institutions, trust in government, trust in frankly any institution, ultimately boiled down to if someone asks you to do X would you do it thinking it’s in your best interest? Swedes, happy-go-lucky people with blue eyes, we tend to think, yeah, it’s on our best interest.

And what that shows me is partly we’ve had the luxury of a peaceful past, but also that it’s not, we’re not talking about either innovation or trust. I mean, Colin’s sort of inversion here I think is a very interesting one, but what I don’t think it means is that it’s an either-or thing. It’s either we trust and therefore trust equals I know what I’m going into because I’ve done it 100,000 times, which equals let’s not innovate; or we innovate, in which case, oh my God, trust is out, who knows what’s coming my way. Doesn’t mean I don’t do it, the chocolate still tastes great. But I just think it’s important for us that we think of these things as growing together, rather than being in some antithetical relationship.

That brings me to the second point, which is that responsible investment is not – sorry, I keep saying it – responsible innovation is not less innovation. The scam case you bring up, Matt, I mean, again, as my payments say at Manoova, a major thing to be on top of every day, all the time, on behalf of ourselves, our clients and their customers and all the way through.

Responsible investment is also an acknowledgement that not innovating is irresponsible. It’s not, I mean, it’s like the Queen of Hearts problem, and you need to run to stand still. And if you want to move forward, you need to run even faster. This sort of idea that if we don’t do anything, we’re fine, is obviously not true. If nothing else, nothing happens in vacuum, and so we might not be doing anything here and feel safe, but the Kiwis, they’re getting on with it and all of a sudden, they’re going to – the next scam wave or next, who knows, it’s going to come from some other shores.

So I really do think that whenever we talk about this it is a collective, and obviously there is tension. I mean, it would go without saying that ASIC doesn’t look at all innovators and go, oh, thank heavens you’re here. And also not all innovators go, thank ASIC, we love you. And somewhere between those two, there is an understanding of, most of us want the same thing. If not driven by some messianic altruism, then at least by a self-sense of preservation, which is, if we don’t do the right thing, if we cut too many corners, there will be very little of us left. If not now, then tomorrow. Because either our customers are going to find out that if you spend time and money with us, or your attention is on us rather than some other one, you’re going to end up with fewer friends, or less reputable or less money, or something else.

So even in the purest sense of sort of unregulated capitalism over the long term, the ones who do the right thing tend to do better. That’s very long term sometimes. But I think that in there somewhere is this kernel of, we’re in it together, which I haven’t seen really any successful innovation again over the longer term, and there can be lots of victims between then and now, where we innovate together, we probably innovate faster. And again, understanding each other’s roles here is really critical.

Moderator: Nick, how do we strike that balance of keeping up, but also not being sitting ducks when it comes to scammers? How do you decide whether an innovation is needed?

Nicholas Davis: Yeah, look, the two ways that I generally view this is innovation shouldn’t be thought of for innovation’s sake, right? There is a concept of novelty where we are drawn to nice new things that does drive certain segments in terms of, I know my colleagues who work in the beverage industry, there is a drive for a different flavour of a certain drink every cycle, and that novelty infects in fashion and others.

But if we leave that type of driver alone, there’s two big things. One is solving a problem that is very clearly a pain point where it’s the sludge, economists call this sludge. It’s the friction in the organisation or the experience where it’s clearly a net cost. There must be some better way of doing it, but it’s not by and large generating many other benefits. But the challenge with that type of innovation is often you’re competing against lots of stabilising forces that keep that sludge in place. You know, someone likes it or someone’s benefiting from that service.

The other is the type of innovation that I think, Christian, you were referring to, but it’s this idea that there are new things available that we haven’t quite thought of yet, new way to meet our needs. It’s the Steve Jobs argument of, I don’t ask the consumer what they think because they don’t know yet what they need, right? Like, that’s the point. And it’s a really, it’s an arrogant point, but it’s also very true that we can’t think out of our own paradigm often, and having those ideas come in.

But to answer the question directly, Amelia, at the end of the day, I want to be able to look at an innovation and feel like that is doing something that at least diverts and entertains, and probably at best actually pushes the system forward. The nub of that, I think, is the process. And I think the process that we’ve all been furiously agreeing on, but I think is actually a lot harder because I don’t think we have all the venues we need for this, is this idea that we can escape the regulation-inhibiting innovation trap.

And regulation can, and we’ve got to admit it, can inhibit innovation when it is less clear, or when people are genuinely trying new things that just don’t fit into that old paradigm, and they don’t have the safe space to be able to do that. Which is why the sandbox and the review and moving that forward is so important. And it’s also why I think that, to one of the questions that came up earlier on the screen, it’s really good for us to define together, this is just an experiment right now, right? Like we are withholding our sense of that this is not, we’re not trying to do what Uber and others did. We’re not trying to rush so fast at something that it becomes too late for us to unpick it. We are genuinely exploring this as a sector, as a society, as a set of regulated entities to be able to find a better way forward. And then we can go to Colin’s point of what’s the infrastructure that has to sit behind it to make that happen and how we do that.

What I’m concerned about is without that common understanding of the experimentation framework about how you talk to the market, how you talk to customers, where you can experiment, the two types of innovation that we see are no innovation, risk averse; or this rogue, just run at it and hope that we make enough money to solve our legal problems further down the line. Neither of them are really useful ways forward, but finding that sweet spot, not easy.

Moderator: Yeah, absolutely. OK, we do have another question from the audience. It goes back to something that was raised in our first session this morning by Leah Weckert from Coles, actually. She suggested that companies could use their own AI agents to market directly to agents being used by consumers. Would this erode trust? Colin, what do you make of that?

Colin Payne: It’s quite complicated because, I mean, we’re just looking at some of this. I mean, the promotion of financial services, generally speaking in the UK is something that we really take very seriously. So when you’ve got machine to machine as a conversation, how do you monitor that? How do you supervise it? How do you check it’s OK? It’s a very interesting question. I don’t think we’ve got an answer.

I think what was just said about experimenting and having that humility to understand that this is brand new for all of us. To highlight where the potential risks might be, that’s important. So you can clearly see with that use case you suddenly get machines persuading machines. You could get an impact on the system, which is – I heard a phrase yesterday. We’ve all talked about know your customer, KYC, and KYA, know your agent. I actually heard a phrase yesterday, know your swarm, KYS.

And the thing is, when you get a swarm of agents acting in a certain coordinated way, then you could have a real problem. So suddenly you get consumer agents being swarmed by a set of very, very strong financial services models, which are promoting a specific service or product. You can see all sorts of pain in that situation, because the speed of the issue of that instruction at machine speed is going to give you an enormous amount of headaches.

So I think there’s a lot of work to be done around that particular idea of a use case. I’m sure the other panellists have a view. In the UK, the way we’re doing it is setting up the sandboxes you know very well that we have. We’ve got a lab, which is an AI lab, which is very, very capable. We are now setting up agentic sprints with all of the providers of the agents, because we have to go alongside them now on their journey as well. Because actually, they also don’t know what the outcomes are. Even the biggest players on the planet will readily admit that looking six months ahead, it’s a little bit hazy from their point of view.

Moderator: Kate, machines persuading machines. What do you think?

Kate O’Rourke: Yeah, I was really interested when Leah said that earlier. And I think for a lot of us who are possibly less tech than other people on the panel, that idea of using AI at the moment does sort of have that LLM idea of this is the best common information available to this question. Whether you call it a denominator or something, that it’s sort of objectively searching across all of those words and finding the most likely, as opposed to there’s a finger on the scale and they’re promoting a particular answer or particular product in the case of Coles.

So it’s obvious now you think about it. Of course, agents are going to try and sell things on behalf of their principal. But I think that then for me, that question of trust turns to accountability. So we can have that discussion about trusting chocolate, or things that may or may not be aligned. But ultimately, who’s accountable if there is a problem? And that idea of clear mapped accountability.

And so I think if you’ve got agents, and agents, whether they’re a swarm, know your swarm, that’s a scary thing, or otherwise that idea of in a circumstance for a consumer knowing, OK, if there is an outcome that’s problematic, is there someone who is accountable, and who is it and what’s the pathway to it? So that there will be dispute resolution or otherwise. So it doesn’t mean it’s easy, because more than one person might be accountable or more than one company, as I was describing earlier, it can still be a complex answer. But at least turning something as difficult to measure and can change trust into accountability is one way of trying to tackle some of these issues.

But like Colin, I think another is that – and as Christian said – that idea of having to be in it together, that ecosystem and learning and listening and experimenting, I think has to be part of it as well.

Moderator: Matt?

Matt Baxby: I was just going to say, I think clarifying liability is such a key point right now, because we’re not in the AI wild west. We can see with rogue agents, there is a specific element of where criminal and civil law needs to be clarified. But California wrote into its civil code last year in AB 316, just a really simple line that’s saying no one in any civil case can claim the autonomous agent as an excuse. It just basically said that is not a defence to any of the things that we do here in the civil law. In other words, the bot did it, just legally not available. Therefore, the question goes to the next pointier one; well, obviously there has to be someone. Where do we place that?

And in other products, in tech products like cloud, we have a shared responsibility arrangement, which clearly defines who’s responsible for permission control, who’s responsible for base infrastructure, et cetera. I think we are going towards that world, both for consumer trust, but probably more importantly, just for enterprise use and to make sure that it’s not consumers that need to trust these things to benefit us all; it’s all of you. It’s the organisations that make the infrastructure of Australia through financial services and telecoms. It’s that use that’s the most valuable, the rails that we run on. And at the moment, I see most boards very low trust in even what their management are saying, let alone the actual base aspects. So getting this right is really important.

Moderator: Christian, you have something?

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: I think in all of these KY something, we keep forgetting to know yourself. I think it used to be the case that as you walked into the Oracle in Delphi, it said, “know yourself.” And essentially, everything that came after was always a reflection of your own interpretation of something that was appropriately nebulous and interpretable in 1,000 different ways.

We ourselves have a lot to answer for when it comes to the use of these things, using your proverbial chocolate here again. Would we trust someone’s agent talking to my agent? Well, at one level, I have to ask myself, how likely am I to trust myself once I get the advice or the information?

So if I’m telling my agent, go out there, make sure you find good shoes. And then someone who sells shoes finds my shoe-looking agent and then tells me, go buy them. That’s fine. If I think I have it in me to go, I’m not sure high heels is for me. But if I think I will have absolutely no volition, no agency, I’m just going to take whatever comes my way. You know, maybe ask someone else’s agent to do it for you instead. I just do think that we talk about these things as almost external factors, as if there is an inevitability.

And there is definitely a trend, a strong trend, macro trends. It’s very hard for any individual company person, not even countries, to sort of change fundamentally. But behind this, the one thing we do know in any interaction is at least I am a person. I might not know who the other one is, if it’s behind the screen or by now, it could even be in front of me. I don’t know, Nick, are you a robot?

Nicholas Davis: [Unintelligible 00:48:06]. But I do want to take this point offline.

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: But I do think it’s important, because in all of this, we sort of look in every direction and we go, it’s all technology. It all comes down to a biological fact, which is I think at least I am a person. And what do I do with that information? To what extent is that in itself taking accountability for what comes my way? And if I’m going to be an addict in chocolate or red trousers or something else, then maybe I should step out of a certain context. If I think I can handle that, and I can tell, someone can tell me to buy a set of shoes, a pair of shoes, I can sort of make up my own mind ultimately.

Colin Payne: But could I step in? Could I just step in on that? Because it’s interesting. That is true, yeah, you’ve got your human agency. But the problem with the technology is that doesn’t necessarily follow the intent. So I think measuring the intent of the agency is important. And there are many, many examples where the intention has been set, but actually the outcome is very different.

And as regulators, we’re not concerned about regulating people’s choices on chocolate or trousers or high-heeled shoes. That’s your choice as a consumer. But when you want to buy that chocolate and instead you get sold, let’s say a Tim Tam rather than pure chocolate, then that is a concern for us, because your intention was very different to what was delivered. So I think we have to distinguish between the two. That’s why we talk about the intention and the mandate that’s carried with any agent. Sorry to just interrupt you then. It’s difficult being abroad.

Moderator: No, no, that’s fine. We do have a question from the audience which fits in well here in terms of personal accountability and responsibility. It says that most people currently don’t read product disclosure statements, yet innovation is giving consumers access to more complex products while they’re already overloaded. If disclosure isn’t working, what does effective risk education look like now? And importantly, whose job is it? Matt, what do you think?

Matt Baxby: Oof. I really wanted to talk about the last question.

Moderator: You can do that.

Matt Baxby: Look, I think the challenge for the industry, because I think it’s a really good insight in terms of rising complexity and is there genuine understanding, is thinking about different ways to deliver that. So whether that’s during – it’s slightly different to the question that’s being asked, but during a scam event, serving videos up of a similar person in a similar scenario to break the spell of a scam, I think is a different way of educating the consumer than reams of text, or something that they’re just not going to deliver. So I think the challenge for the industry is to think about different ways, the means of delivery of education.

Kate O’Rourke: Of course, regulators do have a role as well. I think that question goes to two things. One, how do you deal with the complexity of a product? But separately, does disclosure as a tool, can that be helpful? So they’re separate questions. I think people can enjoy and benefit from very behind the scenes, unbelievably complex products in the right circumstances. And disclosure doesn’t necessarily need to be about that complexity. It’s about the impact for them, the risks they’re taking. It’s about what that means for them in the circumstances that they might like to do it.

My colleague Alan Kirkland, who’s in the audience here, gave a speech last week to the Ecstra Foundation, and talking about – because they’re financial capability and financial education – about in a world of just high volumes of information, just adding some more isn’t the answer. And we heard in the last session about misinformation and disinformation. You can’t just load it on and expect it all to be able for people to navigate it.

So I think that question of the right information from trustworthy people, but also in novel ways, both from people who are the product issuers but also from the regulator as well. We’ve got our Moneysmart team people as well. They’re really thinking hard about different ways of communicating with people, so that trustworthy information we keep coming back to is available and it’s at the right time and it’s in a format that people can really use.

Moderator: Colin, we’ll come back to you. The Mills Review found that the UK is moving towards AI-enabled, continuous and delegated services. The FCA is now working to implement the recommendations from that review. What lessons can we learn here in Australia?

Colin Payne: Well, I mean, it’s worth reviewing. I mean, the Mills Review was interesting as a point in time exercise. I think what it identified when I worked with Sheldon, we knew that it was going to be difficult to predict more than a year ahead. As I said earlier, even if you speak to the large language model labs, even they find it quite tough to go that far ahead.

But from a regulatory point of view, it was very clear. The idea of tech positivity was valid. So I think someone else was mentioning, if you’re not innovating, then of course you’re missing an opportunity. Similarly with technology; if you don’t view this, as a regulator, as useful technology for you in a world where we’re going to be communicating with machines more and more over the next years, then you’ll definitely be behind the curve.

So we’ve explicitly said that we are going to be deploying agentic supervision, and with an objective to be a smarter regulator at the end of that. So executable handbooks, the lessons we like to share, are very practical ones. My world of sandboxes and scale up units and very practical experimentation, which leads to product being issued, that’s what it’s about. It’s not about proofs of concept and POCs. It’s about getting to production safely and securely.

And I think as a regulator, you need to look at the new technology as an unlock or a benefit to what you do with firms. And I can see a world in a year or two’s time where the traffic, you should be thinking about policy as code. So coding it at the level where actually machine can read it in real time, and always on supervision. These are the kind of areas we are leaning into.

And I think properly, Australia is already thinking that way. So I don’t think it’s about necessarily learning from us. I think it’s about sharing ideas, sharing perspectives. I already have submitted information into the sandbox review. I enjoy being able to share our lessons learned to anyone globally, actually, including obviously Australia.

Moderator: Working together seems to be a key theme. So looking ahead, if we can’t control the pace of this change and consumers seem to want to adopt it, what steps can we take to instil that trust? Get one step from each of you, please. Christian?

Christian Westerlind Wigstrom: Well, I sort of looked at today as first we got the professional level headed panel, and then we got the crisis everywhere panel. And we’re meant to be like the positive outlook panels. Let’s think about something great and positive.

I do think the basics remain important. We change the technology, even for a technology company like Redbelly, we need to be honest about what we are truly changing. Is it conceptual or is it sort of messaging and enablement of something that’s been around for sometimes thousands of years? And so educating on what is, as you said earlier, Kate, what is actually new, as opposed to what is delivering something that we already know in a new way, they are, I mean, similar but distinct, is going to matter.

And then, of course, so education is important. Focusing as regulators, as entrepreneurs, as a society in a privileged position of democracy, focusing on what really matters for people at large, and then having an extra focus on vulnerable groups. I do think we should pride ourselves of how we treat the people who are the most vulnerable, and that goes here too. And a lot of other things can happen, I think, and you’re adults, do this in a responsible way, and then we focus on the people who really need the support.

Moderator: Nick?

Nicholas Davis: I think just building on, going that next practical step on the idea of collaboration, I think we should be building on the great work that ASIC and APRA and ASD did earlier this year in their rounds of industry consultations and engagement on AI. I think we do need, we need spaces in Australia where we can ground what’s happening and coming at us from overseas in Australian data, Australian use cases, context, the value that is actually emerging from the sector and from your organisations, and the governance and risk management principles that are coming out.

During those consultations, there was such a good feeling of larger enterprises and organisations saying, I’d love to talk about this more to support other parts, other segments, smaller, lesser, well-resourced parts of the regulated universe for ASIC and APRA. But actually delivering on that, there’s not that space naturally at the moment. So I think being able to actually seed those in a way that educates and supports the risk and the constraint aspect, but really drives towards the valuable use is probably something that just needs more of us to lean into in structured ways.

Moderator: Matt, where should we go from here?

Matt Baxby: Yeah, I think fundamentally that the innovation curve and AI in particular has the potential to be massively pro-consumer. So access to information, triggering actions against what consumers might otherwise be apathetic, I think has the potential to really create a good.

I think what it relies on, as we’ve talked about, is an approach to regulation. I think I’ve heard the word proportionate a few times. I think that’s really important. Principles-based is important as well, and proactive would be the three P’s that I think are important. And that’s certainly been our experience with the FCA as well.

Moderator: And Kate, what steps can ASIC take?

Kate O’Rourke: Yes, thank you. Colin was being modest; the FCA really is a leader here, and we’ve really benefited from engagement with them, listening from them, following them. And I think one of the things I particularly admire is even though there’s a lot of practical hands-on looking here, there, there’s some real clear lines in there. And one of them is the consumer centricity of things. So picking up your point that just consumers first; who is this for? What is this product? And just having that clarity at the centre of that, I think is really valuable.

Moderator: And Colin, lastly, what would you say are the steps we should be taking?

Colin Payne: I think everyone’s said it. I think the focus on what the customer is intending, what the customer is going to be getting from it, the value is absolutely obvious, to me anyway, of this technology. I think the opportunity for – I look at the vast majority of people who haven’t had the benefit of decent financial advice, for example. They’ve not even had semi-decent financial advice mostly. They’ve been left out in the cold by most institutions, because they don’t have the wealth levels that would make it viable as a business model.

This unlocks that entirely, which allows education to happen at the point of need. It allows support to happen as you’re deploying supportive agents. And I see a time in two or three years where this is just normal. It’s an activity we’re very used to, and the world has changed by then. We’ve got to make sure the bridge to that world of a positive future is protected.

So we know we’ve got to go through a transformation. Transformation is always difficult. They’re challenging. They will be a coming together of regulation and innovation. The idea of an organisation which works for the benefit of the consumer will be supported. We will be down like a ton of bricks on anyone who comes into the perimeter. Of course, we’ll be identifying that.

And of course, what you said right at the beginning, frauds and scams. We will be deploying technologies which will be better than ever. And I must mention Revolut’s Pragma, an example I was stunned by the quality of capability. That pointed to a future which is much, much safer for all of us. So there’s going to be a difficult road ahead for a little while. And then I think we’re going to have those sunny uplands that were once talked about in the past.

Moderator: Well, that is a perfect way to wrap up our positive panel as Christian said this afternoon. Thank you all for your time, I appreciate it. And a reminder to the audience to please rate this session in the app. We would love to hear what you think. Stick with us, though, because Hamish will be back right now with a look at the future shape of markets. Thank you.

Gallery

Plenary session 4: The future shape of markets

  • Simone Constant, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Anthony Attia, CEO, ASX
  • Nick Hughes, Co-Head and Group Country Operating Officer Australia and New Zealand, UBS
  • Alex Vynokur, CEO, Betashares

Full audio (MP3 31.4 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: The focus of this next session is really to examine the implications of developments in things like digital assets, changing patterns within retail participation, which I’m sure you’re all thinking about, AI, growing interconnection of Australia and global markets as well, and it’s a pretty amazing lineup of folks to come and talk to you about that. I’m sure you’re keen to hear from every one of them.

So would you please give a very warm welcome, first of all, to ASIC Commissioner Simone Constant; to the relatively new CEO of the ASX, Anthony Attia, please welcome him. Also here with us this afternoon is the Co-Head and Group Country Operating Officer for Australia and New Zealand with UBS, Nick Hughes; and the CEO of Betashares, Alex Vynokur. Would you please welcome all of them.

Well thank you all of you, and a very warm welcome as well to Anthony, particularly, I know you’re freshly learning about cricket, as I understand it, so I’m sure there’s plenty of people here that can share their wisdom with you as well, but we’re here to talk about the future shape of markets.

In this space particularly, a particular balance being struck or trying to be struck between risk opportunity and trust, I know, Simone, that’s something that you’re thinking about constantly. So in terms of market trust, what’s non-negotiable? And where should we be open to a bit more change, a bit more of the opportunity side?

Simone Constant: I think in order to answer that, we have to step back and think, what are the risks we’re worried about at the moment? Why today has there been so much talk about risk? I suspect, by the way, this is going to be the neither happy nor sad, play the ball as it lies panel, I think.

Moderator: The realists.

Simone Constant: Yes, the realists, if we’ve got the roller coaster of emotions, as was mentioned. So I think if we think about where we are, absolutely, like heightened strategic risk right now. We’ve got the everything everywhere all at once feeling. We’ve got confluence of risks, whether it’s AI, whether it’s cyber, whether it’s what’s going on in capital markets and debt markets, inflation outlook.

We’ve got convergence in some spaces, like if you think about AI, it’s both disruptor and an opportunity provider, it’s perhaps adding to the inflation in terms of its need for capital, but also adding to the opportunity in terms of productivity. And we’ve absolutely got concentration of risk. So concentration in terms of liquidity, concentration in terms of when we think about valuations, and there we also have convergence between risks in public side and private side of markets.

So it’s a lot, and I think everyone in this room is probably tired of having to process, oh, first ever, or haven’t seen this data point since the GFC, or this is the giga number we’ve never seen before. It’s just, it’s so much, right? But I think that means that probably the biggest risk we’ve got right now, which goes to what do we do, is actually that we just let it overwhelm us. Like we can’t let it overwhelm us. This is a room full of financial services people, not only financial services people, but there’s a lot of financial services people. What do we do in financial services? Oh, we look at risk, we understand the risk, we dimension it, and then we look to mitigate and manage it and step into it in a way with operational, good operational practices and sound, resilient foundations.

Moderator: But in that context, do the pre-existing frameworks, standards, even methodology of measurement of risk apply?

Simone Constant: Absolutely. So the answer to what we do and what we draw from is the things we’ve been using and drawing from for decades, when it comes to managing that risk and finding the opportunity. I mean, we need to think about risk as having that return, and Australia’s been really good at this, right? Managing through stress periods and responding with resilience.

Anyone who’s followed the trading in bank securities for the last 10, 20 years can see that actually in periods of stress, when you need resilience, because of the resilient foundations in Australia, actually those securities outperform. They pull away from peers, and the more resilient pull away even further. We’ve got to draw from that right now.

Now, the absolute non-negotiable is trust, but they’re two sides of the same coin, right? Trust is why we’re talking about resilience so much today. Resilience is not just tech, it’s not just cyber and frontier AI, it is old-fashioned fundamentals like liquidity. OK, we can see the tides going out at the moment, that’s liquidity pulling away, so you see what lurks beneath, arguably in plain sight. Attention to liquidity, attention to capital to offset the risks that you’re taking on knowingly, and attention to operational soundness.

And operational soundness, again, is not just tech and platforms and innovation, it’s also picking up the phone when a customer rings you because they need the their death benefits paid, or they’ve got to lodge a complaint. It’s being able to get information with transparency and know what’s going on in their services. That is trust. If you’ve got that fundamental of trust, and those sound practices that really are resilience, then we can stop thinking, oh, how do we survive this, this period of change? We can start thinking about how will we thrive.

Moderator: But for all the talk of these being unprecedented times, there being unprecedented patterns emerging, unprecedented responses from markets in different shapes, are you saying you’re more attracted to what you see even today that is actually following conventional patterns?

Simone Constant: So if conventional practices, or just sound practices, however you want to put it, or getting the basics right, if you follow every one of, even if the emotions were up or down of the panels, what’s been a common thread? Getting the basics right. Getting the basics right, that is what resilience is, which we talk a lot about today, but it is. It is good capital management, good liquidity management, being operationally sound, being transparent and being trusted, right? Being trusted.

With those foundations you can take, we can take risk on with the right practices, step into it and actually Australia can benefit from OK, like the new normal, the normal for longer is change, but we can step into that if we have the sound foundations.

Moderator: Alex, I’m wondering how you’re hearing this and how you have a version of this conversation with investors, for example. Challenges, opportunities, risks, I mean, nothing about these times feel normal. So is the conversation a normal one, or is it a different one?

Alex Vynokur: Yeah, well, thank you firstly for allowing me the opportunity to be here. It’s a really interesting question. So there’s a couple of things that I’ll say. Number one, I think the topic about the future shape of markets is a very interesting topic from my perspective to discuss, because the markets are a place – Australian investors, and we now have over 11 million, I think 11.5 million Australian investors who actually own investments outside of their superannuation, outside of their home, according to the very recently released ASX investor report. That’s about half of our working adult population, basically.

So Australians are more and more turning towards investments in order to build financial security and in order to build wealth. You know, despite the best efforts of our politicians, and we should encourage those efforts obviously going forward, but affordability of housing is going to be a continued challenge. So people are looking towards markets, whether they’re equity markets bond markets, as a way to help them build wealth.

Now, access in today’s world to markets is better than it’s ever been, but access alone does not help people build wealth. What helps investors build wealth is being smart with their money, being able to make good financial decisions. Simple things like spending less than you earn, diversify, keep the costs under control, and really let the magic of compounding do its work over time. The basic things.

Now these things have been the same for hundreds of years. These concepts for the average investor out there, for the 11 plus million Australians that invest, these concepts have not changed, and AI is not going to change them, and the new technological world we’re living in is not going to change them.

Now, what are the opportunities? I certainly think, number one, technology provides an enormous opportunity for Australians to make better financial decisions, and to be better with their money. And I think Colin in the previous session was just mentioning that the access to better decision-making can be improved with technology. It’s not a substitute to an individual receiving full financial advice from a qualified individual financial advisor. I think that’s fantastic. But the truth of the matter is we’re never going to be living in a world where every Australian is going to have the benefit of individualised financial advice from a person.

However, technology is really taking us places now where we actually can create a customised experience, basically, for individuals. So I think the opportunity that technology brings to help the average Australian be better with their money, make better financial decisions, and really take away from some of the emotion, because again, if we take a step back for a moment, I mean there’s a lot of great things about humans that we can do better than machines and better than artificial intelligence, but we all suffer from the fact that we are emotional beings. And the terms fear and greed are often associated with the markets, and those are just human, innate human emotions.

Moderator: So is what you’re saying, this is changing the conversation that maybe a consumer is having with someone that is an expert, because they’re doing quite a lot of research, they’re maybe coming in better informed, or are they just going their own way and saying, I don’t need that?

Alex Vynokur: Yeah, so look, so access to information in today’s world is better than it’s ever been, there’s no question about that. That same ASX investor report actually shows some pretty interesting facts about the usage of AI. So people are actually availing themselves now more and more, and particularly younger people, 30 and younger, are availing themselves of artificial intelligence tools to help them make financial decisions.

Now, that goes into the dangerous territory, right, so when you have unregulated, unsupervised, and to a large extent, irresponsible, generic, large language model providing individual advice, and people are following that advice, that is a problem. But I don’t think we need to live in the world of the extremes. I think there is a future where regulated, accountable, responsible financial services businesses can leverage technology to help the average Australian be better with their money.

Moderator: By the way, I should mention that you’re really welcome to get involved with the conversation. If you’ve got a question, just drop it in via the app, and I’ll put it to the panel. It’s helpful if you’ve got someone in mind that you want to ask it to, please put their name in it, so I know where you’d like me to direct the question.

Nick, it is just the reality, isn’t it, that people are going to OpenAI, to Claude, to ChatGPT, the rest of it, for this information? And as Alex has pointed out, it’s unregulated, sort of unlicensed advice. How is that shaping the way the market works generally, the way consumers are interacting with this?

Nick Hughes: Well, my perspective has probably come more from the wholesale market side, given the client base that we serve. I mean, from an organisational perspective, we have to establish the policies and controls for our own staff as to how they use AI in a responsible way to discharge their responsibilities.

I think this topic of AI is clearly continuing to evolve. We need to have a strong regulatory framework around it. It’s going to work in conjunction with the existing framework, and I think right now ASIC is consulting around digital assets and some other stuff on AI, so that will play through. There’s no question that it can help transform the provision of financial services, if done so in a responsible way.

Moderator: How so? How do you envisage that transformation?

Nick Hughes: Oh, look, I think there’s many applications around thinking through investment options and comparing different investment options, returns on those investment options and risks. You can really, I mean, you can do a lot with it, but at the end of the day, I think there’s still human judgement that is required to go into that.

I know that we’ve got some new products that we’re embedding into our wealth management business offshore that take advantage of AI, and we’ll have more to say on that soon, but when I’ve seen the demos of it, it’s quite exciting.

Moderator: Anthony Attia, you’re almost three months into the role of CEO at the ASX. You’ve come from European exchanges, so I wonder if you could share with everyone here what your observations are about what you’re seeing in the landscape here.

Anthony Attia: Thank you, Hamish, and again, thank you, Simone, for letting me be on stage so early in my onboarding phase. So let me bring you some view or experience from the point of view of Europe. As you know, Europe is 27 countries, 27 capital market regulators, 27 central banks, plus ECB, plus an attempt to have a single supervisory body covering all 27 countries. We have something like 250 trading venues on equities, and so Europe is a difficult, fragmented environment.

But Europe has very strong companies that are looking for financing. The issue with Europe is that we don’t have enough investors. We don’t have pension funds. We don’t have superannuation funds. We have very, very few long term investors that are not American investors. So when I come here, I see an amazing set of assets that create the foundation of a very successful capital market. It’s obviously the depths of long-term investors and superannuations included. I see the 11.5 million retail investors outside super that Alex mentioned. This is unique. This is quite unique.

I see a diversity of asset classes, from equities to ETF to listed derivatives, in particular, the interest rate futures that ASX is managing. I see the promise of more commodities markets and energy markets. All the ingredients combine, obviously, with a very strong regulatory environment that ASIC is representing together with RBA and APRA. I think these are the foundations of a very, very strong capital market.

Now, what I observe as well is that the trends that are being discussed in every exchanges today in the world, they have been discussed as well at the IOSCO conference that Sarah mentioned this morning. The trends are the same for everybody. So we have the cyber threats and the AI threats, obviously.

But we also have the trend that is getting bigger and bigger, which is the fact that capital is mobile. Investors have the choice more and more to invest domestically or internationally. This is true everywhere. Companies have the choice to IPO at home or IPO somewhere else. Collateral has the choice to be deployed at home or anywhere else. These trends are the same here in Australia and everywhere else in the world.

And suddenly, we realise that the competition that we’re talking about is not so much between stock exchanges. The competition is about financial centres. And so what is very important, I think, and that’s the message I want to share today, is that we don’t have the choice, but we are in competition all together with Singapore, with Hong Kong, to some extent with New York and with London. And the only way that we can address this competition is by being aware of it, deciding that it’s a problem that we want to solve. Deciding that we need to be excited and to be ambitious. But also take the measures of what are the strengths that we need to put forward, and what are the modernisation elements that we have no choice but fixing in order to be competitive.

Moderator: So you’ve described features about the Australian market that you think are unique, but you’re saying we’re facing and dealing with the same challenges as everyone else. Do those unique dynamics that you see here shape in any way our response to the global changes that are different?

Anthony Attia: Absolutely. And I think this is a key, right? We need to play with our strength. And everyone needs to play their part, and ASX particularly. So we have a lot of things that are being delivered at ASX at the moment. These things about improving resilience, being out there, being more client-focused, talking about value proposition, but also acknowledging that ASX is not just a cash equity exchange, it’s also a derivative exchange, an energy derivative exchange, and a fixed income exchange too. This is a form of representation of the market that we have here. So playing with our strength is absolutely key.

Now the question is, what is it that we want to do? Do we want to attract more foreign investment? Do we want to bring back the investors, the Australian investors that have been tempted to go overseas? I do believe that we have an opportunity to offer local products for the 15% of retail investors that are investing overseas. I think the environment here is actually better than the overseas one. It should be cheaper, it should be better regulated.

Same thing with the superannuation funds. Do we want them to invest more on Australian companies because it helps creating jobs, it helps retaining the companies here, in particular on the defence sector or sectors that are sensitive? And there’s many more. All these are elements that create a competitive edge for Australia as a financial centre that we should develop.

But there is a moment where we need to reckon that benchmarking ourselves is necessary. How are we perceived externally? Are we perceived as being open to business? Are we perceived as being modern in the way our rules are created? And I’m talking about ASX rules, of course. These are the questions that I’m working with the ASX team at the moment, because it’s exactly that. It’s about the awareness that competition is happening outside our home market.

Moderator: OK. So there’s a question here from Sophie Waller: “What are the best uses of AI in providing advice and what uses likely pose the higher risk for consumers?” I reckon maybe I’m going to split that out and Simone, if I can ask you to deal with the second part of that from your point of view, the risk side.

Simone Constant: Gladly.

Moderator: How are you viewing this? I think part of the conversation in most of these sessions has been about the race to ensure that regulatory frameworks keep up with everything that’s changing.

Simone Constant: And I think my Chair unsurprisingly did an excellent job of speaking in the macro about grappling with the idea of financial advice coming from offshore AI. So I’m just going to find something additive. Something that’s additive that actually has come out in what everyone has said is the need for informed participation.

So at ASIC we have this fantastic piece of legislation that tells us what we’ve got to do. I’ve never had a clearer mandate than at ASIC. And we’ve got to promote confident and informed participation in markets and in the economy by Australians. And what we’ve just heard, by the way, Australians are a nation of investors. They’ve got lots of super, but they also invest, which is fantastic. That’s access and participation.

But that informed part is really important, right? Because before we even worry about the use of AI to provide advice, and we do, we are thinking about that, let’s make sure that the information that AI is using is there and is reliable and is transparent.

And so when I said before this is about having resilient foundations to deal with these risks, I did talk about transparency, which includes good information that’s properly disclosed and available. And a really good example of that is, I reckon if you put the most amazing ChatGPT or Anthropic model across some of the private credit disclosures I’ve read this year, I reckon that even it wouldn’t know what to do with it. Sometimes you need – I spent, I used to be CRO for a division of the giant Australian bank. And actually then we got a man who used to be the GCRO of that bank to try and help us with private credit to start our journey on do we need to worry and what should we worry about?

And when he and I, who’d had an unlimited delegation at Commonwealth Bank for credit, couldn’t understand some of the disclosure documents, and we figured out you need a PhD in corporate finance and then some, right, to understand what’s going on, like simple things, like what’s the liquidity? When can you get your money back? What’s the risk and return of this? Oh, are there conflicts that are being managed here? Then it doesn’t matter what you put across the top to give that advice. Actually, the information needs to be strong.

And it’s a really good example, Hamish, of we’ve talked a lot about I think public side of markets. We’ve looked at private markets a lot this year or last couple of years at ASIC, because they’re growing and we want them to thrive as well, and we focused a lot on private credit. And we come back to fundamentals, getting the basics right. Are valuations right? And we really pushed into that this year, because we did a survey at the beginning of the year about what’s going on. Why do we have to do a survey that showed what’s going on and to worry about valuations? Oh, because there’s not good information at a system level and at the individual investment.

There’s some great products in private credit and some fantastic operators, and groups like the FSC are trying to always raise the standards here. But when the information’s not there and we have to go out and do surveys, and by the way, like we’re announcing today, we’re doing another. So we’re going forward again and putting out a voluntary survey that’ll be open for the next three weeks to find out how has private credit changed this year, and to get that information and see whether those valuation practices, the fundamentals, liquidity practices and the conduct practices. So we put out these 10 principles of private credit done well. Have they been adopted? Because those old fashioned basics, they’re going to be the best way of supporting private credit to not just survive this stress, but hopefully thrive and help build back.

Moderator: But how do you then address the friction that it would seem to me exists when Anthony’s describing the competition that exists with other markets? And obviously we’re also talking about increased access for Australian consumers to different types of markets. And they’ll be operating within their own framework for exactly what you’ve described. They may uphold some of those values. They might have very different sets of values and practices. So how do we contend with that?

Simone Constant: I think it’s a combination of getting those basics right here. So making sure there are the right disclosures, right information, including when there are opportunities to participate in global opportunities. So if you think about SpaceX and the participation in SpaceX, what was really important to ASIC was that the basics, like the information that was given to consumers, meant that they were confident and informed.

And also, just as Anthony said, playing the ball as it lies. So deal with what the reality is of markets today. We have a nation of investors in Australia. They want to invest. That’s great. But the opportunities are global. So we support them into that by making sure that if there’s going to be offerings, global offerings, so that Australians don’t miss out as investors, are they meeting the right information and disclosures that we need them to?

On the flip side, so that’s sort of the equity side, think about debt markets. We are about to become the third biggest corporate bond market in Australia, like Aussie dollar denominated issuance. That’s amazing. Now, that partly came out of Australia responding really well to COVID in that dimension. It also comes out of just changing geopolitics and the importance of Asia. So let’s play the ball where it lies.

How do we keep supporting that, but in a way that’s good for Australian companies wanting to raise finance, for Australian investors wanting access and for attracting global finance? Simple things like interoperability, liquidity. Liquidity is interoperability. They’re coming in. That’s great. And coming through us. They also need to know, though, that when they need that money, they can get it back out. That’s interoperability and operational soundness. So I think it’s a combination of getting those basics right, dealing with the world as it is and knowing we can actually find advantages here, and then responding with sense and market engagement.

Moderator: So Nick, is that how you see it? Or do you hear, say, from institutional investors that are pointing out the way things are done elsewhere or the opportunities that exist elsewhere that may look easier because there aren’t necessarily such adherence to those basics?

Nick Hughes: It’s a good question, Hamish. Look, I think we always have a mind or an eye on what is happening overseas, and benchmarking practices in Australia versus overseas. Sometimes it’s appropriate that we do things in a different way.

I think at the end of the day, what do we want to see? We want, obviously, regulatory clarity about the rules. Interoperability, I think Simone touched on, about our infrastructure connecting efficiently with global markets and avoiding creating a closed domestic digital ecosystem. Obviously, focus on commercial use cases and not just technology. And I guess that’s a comment more around digital assets, that you need to not build it and they will come. I think it’s actually demonstrating you’ve got a commercial use case that supports the necessary investment with an identifiable client need. And then, obviously, coordinated execution between regulators, market infrastructure providers, banks, investors and technology providers.

Moderator: So if we were to imagine a high growth Australian company that was thinking about listing locally, or staying private, or pursuing another path, let’s just assume circumstances hadn’t evolved quite quickly and they were forced to make that decision. Let’s assume they were just thinking about this. What are the main drivers for that decision making?

Nick Hughes: Sure. Let’s assume the high growth company, Hamish, is called ABC Co. Anthony, I think you’ve got a horse in this race, and would be delighted to see ABC Co list on the exchange. I’m sure if Em is here in the audience, she’d say the same about TMX. And Alex, I note your recent comments with Joe Aston about the merits of staying private and at this point in beta shares evolution.

But coming back to the question about what factors do you take into account, there are a number of them. And I’ll just touch on some of them. And this is, firstly, whether you list locally versus offshore. So those factors will include what we call comparable companies. Who are they? Where are they listed? What do they trade on? Which is peer valuation levels. Investor mind share or scarcity. So we’ve got fewer higher growth opportunities available to ASX investors versus some other exchanges. So that can drive increased scarcity and demand from investors.

You’ve got geographic nexus. What is the linkage between this company onshore versus offshore? It’s not to say you can’t list a company which only has a nexus with offshore, but it’s more typical that it’s got a nexus here. That might be management. It might be share of revenue and the likes, ESG considerations, financial disclosure. We’ve got a different regime versus overseas regulators where we’ve got to have verified forecasts in our issuing documents. That’s not the same as some overseas markets. Investor sophistication.

So let’s say ABC Co was a biotech company. We know that you’re probably going to be more likely to target a US listing, given that there’s a larger concentration of biotech specialist investors in the US than there is in Australia. IPO performance. How have recent IPOs performed? Disclosure, compliance obligations and the like.

So there’s a smorgasbord of considerations. And then there’s other factors you need to take into account; whether you want to go or consider a listing versus staying private. Which ultimately goes to the vendor’s objectives around things like liquidity, capital, valuation, their time horizon, risk tolerance and the like.

Moderator: Go for it. I can see everyone wants to get in on this, so Anthony.

Anthony Attia: Look, I just want to use a few examples. So in the UK, post-Brexit, the city of London realised that they didn’t have the natural attraction to be the best at all the criteria that Nick listed. They realised that suddenly the whole market shrunk. And so they had two options. One is to just describe the criteria and say, oh, sometimes we’re going to be better than the US or better than Europe. At other times we’re going to be less good. They decided not to do that, after a painful moment of realising that they would have to change.

So they took all these criteria. And that’s the same story, by the way, in France, in Italy, and in the US to a certain extent. You become a great listing venue when you decide that you want to be a great listing venue. So you don’t look at this criteria from a passive manner. You take every criteria and you decide what you’re going to change in your value proposition in order to be better at attracting companies.

And so you can look at continuous disclosure. You can decide if it’s good enough to attract people or, on the contrary, if it’s repellent. You can look at the ASX listing rules, which is something we’re doing right now because some of them are outdated. You can look at the liquidity on your market. And liquidity, you can also build it by teaming up with market participants and proprietary trading firms. But you need to tell them that you want to attract them.

You can look at indices and comparables. This one is important. So playing with your strengths. So look at the Glencoe dual listing. We managed to attract, thanks to the ecosystem, we managed to attract one of the largest resource and mining companies in Australia because they wanted to be exposed to superannuation funds. So you play with your strength again. Etc, etc, etc.

But the point I’m trying to make, maybe I’m too forceful, is that we’re not victims. We can’t be passive. If we want to attract companies, we need to work together. And we need to look at all these criteria and decide if we want to change them and modernise them.

Moderator: So Alex, is that –

Simone Constant: Hamish, just one quick thing.

Moderator: Do you want to jump in?

Simone Constant: The forgotten voice in this sometimes, we talk about attracting new listings. Can we just, like a shout out to those who stay listed? We have no view on private versus public. We need both. But we also need to face into why do some companies choose to be private? And it’s not just that there’s so much capital on the private side that they offer is there. We’re looking like we’re throwing forward to 2027. We’ve got a group of experts coming out of our financial markets roundtable, and looking at a whole range of issues in debt and equity markets and public and private side. But one of the questions is, OK, so what is that burden of staying listed?

And simple things that might not be that sexy, terms like interoperability and things we’re talking about. Is the reporting burden too heavy? Like annual reports. There’s some people in this room who tell me they’ve gone from that to that to that. Why? When you think about what I just said about the quality of information in some of these lengthy disclosure documents, is it still meeting its purpose?

So I think there’s also some questions to be answered about staying on the boards. And again, not judging those who are private entities. Private capital is great. But staying, not just getting listed, that’s day one, staying listed and making that an attractive place, particularly for small to medium-sized enterprises to get access to capital. Because we do talk about this from an investor perspective often, and we love that at ASIC. But we also have that responsibility to make sure there is an effective and efficient economy where small to medium-sized enterprise have a range of sources for getting their capital.

Moderator: When Anthony talks about looking at what the alternatives are overseas, is that something you do that you’re describing being aware of the global scenario?

Simone Constant: Yep.

Moderator: Are you sitting there and saying, OK, well, if they’re over here, this is what the expectation is if they’re over there? Like, do you run those comparisons?

Simone Constant: All the time. I mean, you heard our Chair say her time is pretty finite. And she’s in a lot of places at a lot of times, or needed. She’s just spent some time overseas listening to her peers, so from Chair down and through all the time. And that’s my point or our point about playing the ball as it lies.

We know that when we all come back from our lovely Christmas break, no one loves it more than me, you’ll be able to stand in Martin Place and look up and not to see the ASX sticker. Oh, there’s NASDAQ 23/5. That’s reality, right? The world is moving to 23/5, maybe 23/7 in time. OK, let’s not be beaten by that. Let’s think about what can that mean for Australia? We’re going to be awake. We’re going to be awake when those markets are operating. How can we play a part in that?

As big giga offerings come to market in the CapEx super cycle that is AI, how do we participate, and actually within the potentially safer confines of Australian, other institutions supporting and playing a part into that? So absolutely, we’re aware of it. We’ve looked at the dynamics and compared ourselves to see are we doing something different? Is our market flatter than others? We’ve come back on the public market side, particularly the equities, and said we’re not that different, but we do have lots of strengths. So including this globalisation can be a strength. We’ve just got to face into it without that emotion and just play it as it is.

Moderator: But institutional safety is part of the sell.

Simone Constant: Institutional safety to promote that confident and informed participation. Not to preserve the rights of institutions per se, just in the same way we don’t want to see innovation for innovation’s sake, but to preserve and support that confident and informed participation, yes.

Moderator: OK, so I’m interested then, Alex, in what you think about that. Because you’re sort of thinking about innovative market dimensions, where presumably the competition is incredibly hot and the alternatives are many. So how are you viewing this conversation?

Alex Vynokur: Yeah, look, I think there’s some really great points that have been raised, and I just wanted to pick up very briefly on Anthony’s point just around the fact that we certainly do not want to be a victim and we do not want to be passive. We really want to chase opportunities, and chasing opportunities in a responsible way is really what innovation is all about.

I mean, for me, I guess innovation, first and foremost, is about outcomes to the customer, to the end investor. Unless it shows up in better returns after fee, lower cost, ability to achieve your goals with greater confidence, innovation is just marketing, basically. So I really feel it’s really important to distinguish between true innovation that moves the dial for the end investor, and marketing fluff. That’s number one.

Innovation is not just about the latest and greatest of technology. Yes, technology is a big part of innovation, but innovation to me also is thinking about how do we improve competition? How do we improve, again, going back to the outcomes of the customer?

We have some great things happening in Australia, say with open banking. Portability of your banking data is already in place. I mean, I certainly feel we need to have portability of your superannuation data, portability of your taxation data, portability of your investment data to enable easy switching, basically, because if investors are able to move, they will move. So removing friction is really important.

I mean, our government has introduced a concept of digital ID. I think at the moment, it’s predominantly limited. In fact, I believe it’s limited at the moment only to government organisations. There’s been an announcement from our Finance Minister that the private sector will be able to participate in digital ID. I think at the moment, every time you want to open a bank account, you want to open an investment account, you want to open a superannuation account, you have to go through a full KYC. That turns off a lot of people, and full onboarding, basically. I think if we’re able to improve portability of your identity and allow people to move their identity with them, it will actually allow people to shop around.

And I’ll tie it back to AI because there was a question that was asked, I think, by Sophie a little bit earlier about what are some of the good use cases and maybe some of the risks. And I just wanted to tie it back to the point that came to mind when the question was asked.

I think for the vast majority of Australians, the usage of AI is not about constructing complex financial plans, basically. I think a lot of it is about getting the basics right. And I believe in the years to come, all of us here will have a personal money coach, basically, which will be an app on our phone. And it will actually help us be smarter with our money. It will identify that you’ve got an account with one of the banks that pays you zero interest, or pays you inadequate interest. And it will tap you on the shoulder and say, hey, by the way, there are three other banks that are offering you a better deal. Would you like me to move that money for you? Would you like to do it yourself? You know, there’s a question at which stage do you allow agents to transact on your behalf?

I mean, that’s a separate issue, and we’ll get there eventually. But what’s undeniable is that AI is going to be making competition as good as it’s ever been. And I’m very excited about that, because I think that the end consumer is going to end up getting a much better deal than ever before.

I think loyalty taxes are going to be increasingly a thing of the past, both in terms of the amounts we’re getting on our deposits, it will also extend to the rates we’re paying on our mortgages, basically, because refinancing and moving or renegotiating with your bank is going to be prompted. And I think that’s the part that I’m actually more excited about, because we’re all busy people. You know, we all have jobs. We all have our lives. We all have our family and friends and everything else. And we all very often forget, or we do not get around, we do not get around to fixing the basics.

So that, for me, is really what innovation is all about. And it’s really embracing what’s in front of us today.

Moderator: Really interesting question from Jared Fitzpatrick. He wants this to go to Anthony first. “What do you see the impacts of and the response to technological developments such as tokenisation, increasingly automated markets and extended and continuous trading?” So, Anthony.

Anthony Attia: Thank you, Jared. That’s a very, very good question. Look, I believe innovation for innovation doesn’t really work with regulated entities and regulated markets. You need to innovate with purpose. You need to innovate in a sustainable way. And you need to innovate to resolve problems, right?

And so for something like 10 years, the fear of missing out around DLT and blockchain was a solution looking for its problem. I think today there is a an interesting shift where tokenisation becomes a mature use case for cross-border trading and cross-border investment. And it’s also an interesting use case for crypto retails who are moving from unregulated crypto wallets, with metals and things like that, into liquid instruments such as equities or ETF.

And so there are people in the past years thought that crypto exchanges would compete against traditional exchanges. That’s not what’s happening. What’s happening is the exact opposite where crypto exchanges become crypto brokers, and traditional exchanges have an opportunity to step up and innovate and capture the flow of these new type of investors, the investors of tomorrow, one would say.

In order to do that, we need to change the way we look at the market model. So we talk about 24/7. We talk about how do we provide liquidity, how do we ensure disclosure obligation with a 24/7 approach. These are open questions. But I do believe that these are the major trends of tomorrow that we need to see, not only because we have great retail investors in Australia, but also because these investors, through tokenisation, have an opportunity to stay in Australia while investing on all sorts of international products. And we don’t want them to go to the US. We want them to stay here. So for me, tokenisation is a great opportunity that we need to see collectively.

Now, as a consequence of that, we will talk more and more about extended trading hours. We will talk more and more about adjusting the trading model to the product. So that’s what Simone was saying about SMEs. So SMEs don’t need 24/7 liquidity. They need auction. They need a price formation that represents the interests of the seller and the buyer. So we need to adjust the market models of every asset class, including ETF.

Moderator: Alex, do you want to respond to this question as well? So that the impacts of and then the response to?

Alex Vynokur: Yeah, look, I think Anthony has covered it pretty well. I mean, I would just say the 24/7 sort of market, I mean, a number of exchanges in the US are already starting to move to 23/5, basically. I think markets are becoming global. And I think, again, I think it’s just the reality that we’re living with, basically. And again, on Anthony’s point, you either be a victim or you embrace the opportunity.

And from our perspective, Australia is really blessed. We’re really blessed as a country with having a very strong financial system. We are on track in the next little while to become the second largest pension market globally. I mean, we have a tiny population. We have a very significant retirement savings pool in Australia. I mean, that is a real blessing for everyone who participates in this industry, because we can leverage that. We can leverage that to our advantage.

We have Asia, a number of countries within the Asian time zone, within our time zone, who are looking for regulated, with strong rule of law, strong markets, basically, to deploy their capital. I mean, there’s no reason why we should not be aspiring as a nation to have a very strong seat at the table when it comes to becoming the place for Asian investors to deploy their global capital.

So I think building really strong infrastructure is crucial. Having a very strong regulatory framework, but also a friendly regulatory framework, which allows Australian financial services businesses to be exporters of their services, not just serving the 27 plus million people that we have in Australia. And I think those are the sorts of opportunities that really excite me for the future. And I think we’re getting the basics right with infrastructure, with regulation, and competitive and ambitious participants in the market.

And the only thing that I have not mentioned that I think is an important part of any conversation on investments, is really an investor-friendly tax regime. Because ultimately, without an investor-friendly tax regime, global capital, which is mobile, which has been pointed out by several participants, is not going to choose Australia.

Moderator: Simone, I think you were trying to get in.

Simone Constant: Oh, no, it was only to support that. Like, I deliberately used the corporate bond market as an example of where Australia is actually really well-positioned and capturing that in terms of flow into Asia. One of the reasons that we’re really nudging for that third place is that flow into Asia, and playing the ball as it lies.

And to just pick up on some of the challenges being given about regulation, we have no glass door about that. We’re facing into that. We’re opening ourselves up on reporting. I talked about that. We’re equally looking at, OK, we have this enormous pot of savings. We’re not just a nation of miners and mortgages now. When it comes to listed, we’re managers and we have our big super funds. How can we find efficiencies and opportunities in collateral management, in liquidity practices, that, with sound foundations, can flow back to those superannuation customers, the members, as long as it flows back. Innovation needs to meet a problem, and in a way that has scalable demand for that solution that flows.

But that superannuation one’s a really good example. We’ve been talking a lot about innovation and some cool stuff like tokenisation and edgy stuff that markets people like us like to talk about. But let’s remember what’s the purpose of that superannuation. Oh, the dignified retirement of the person whose money it is.

We’ve talked about bringing AI and innovation on the liquidity side, on the markets technology side. In super funds, they’re doing a lot to enhance the way they’re managing the assets and investing. We also at ASIC are really looking forward to seeing AI used on that customer and service side. Because actually going back to where you asked me to start, which is trust, a bigger worry for trust, I think of Australians in their superannuation and their part as investors in all of this or actually can I get access to the money when I need it? Will the services come through?

When I ring to make a complaint, will my call be answered and will the root cause of my complaint not be attributed to me as a customer? I mean, two weeks ago, we put out a piece of work that said 60% of the time, a number of funds were attributing the root cause of a customer complaint to the customer. So I think when we see AI being deployed to just make services better for the customers, the investors, the Australians that we want to be confident and informed, that will enhance that trust, and that actually will be an important part of that resilient foundation for all of the other things that we’re enjoying talking about.

Moderator: Do you have a view as to what that might look like? I mean, I can imagine them being deferred to an AI tool, but how would it actually make the customer experience of it better?

Simone Constant: I think what it would look like is at top of house, governance, top of house, understanding their responsibility through to end member, is to make sure that money is kept safe, that the money is there when they need it to be, and they do what they say they’ll do when it comes to service delivery. And actually starting from that proposition, when they think about the best application of AI, not just where it’s more observable internationally.

Moderator: So I wanted to round this conversation out by talking about what might make Australia more attractive in the next couple of years. But there’s a question from William Fowles: “As many markets move towards T+1 one settlement, what levers are being pulled and technologies being leveraged to ensure Australia keeps pace with peers?” So Anthony, I guess that one’s probably for you.

Anthony Attia: Yes, thank you. Look, the US moved to T+1 settlement for equities last year. Europe will move next year with some of the larger Asian exchanges. I believe that the CHESS replacement conversation from the past years created a reason to delay that transformation for Australia. I also believe that today that the CHESS replacement program is well advanced, and we had a very successful milestone earlier this year with the cash clearing.

And so I’m very, very confident that we can allow ourselves to be more ambitious than the initial plan and bring the T+1 ambition forward. So we are consulting the market to make sure that everyone feels comfortable, but we should make sure that Australia is not lagging behind. And so my view is that we should get to it as soon as possible.

Moderator: So I imagine there’s quite a few people interested in hearing that. What do you mean by bring forward? Can you be more explicit?

Anthony Attia: So it’s not so much of a tech problem. The current CHESS system and the new CHESS system can do T+1, and some products do T+1 every day. The big challenge of T+1 that we saw in the US and in Europe is to make sure we have an industry test. So that’s everyone, every participant, every bank test, all the systems, even the smaller one and the ones sometimes that have been forgotten. And so what we’re going to do is we’re going to invite market participants to use the new CHESS system testing campaign to also test T+1, and see whether or not we’re confident to bring the date forward at the latest in 2029, but I still think it’s late.

Moderator: OK. So a timeline there.

Anthony Attia: Yes.

Moderator: OK. Interesting. Nick, anything you’d like to nominate that Australia could do to be –

Nick Hughes: I think when Anthony’s ready, we’ll be ready. I think I would expect it’s going to happen probably within the next three to four years. I think we’ve got to deliver obviously CHESS replacement. I think it’s inevitable. It’s not if, it’s when. And when we look at the other markets moving forward, we create for investors effects and funding mismatches and that’s expensive. We’ve talked about friction costs in the system which we need to address. So we look forward to it in due course.

Moderator: OK. Alex, anything you want to nominate? Something that you think would make Australia more attractive?

Alex Vynokur: I talked about tax. If we’re talking about global, we’re talking about your questions about global capital, I assume?

Moderator: Yeah, I mean, you can nominate whatever you like, to be honest. I mean, if it’s tax, you’ve got the public stage, you’re very welcome to make the case.

Alex Vynokur: Look, there’s lots of things. Look, Australia is an amazing market. It’s a rock solid financial system, and we have a regulatory framework which is actually the envy of most of the world. I think what we do well as a country, I think is combine the ability to innovate but at the same time, not stretch that innovation so far where you end up with a situation like gamified investing and zero day option and highly leveraged, like single stocks. I think we got that balance right.

So for me, for Australian investors, Australia will continue being the home of investing, obviously. Infrastructure is important. We talked about that. I think the tax regime is the one key thing that I would point out.

Financial literacy. I mean, I really, I’ve been talking about it and sound like a broken record, but I think there is still an immense opportunity for us as a nation to improve the levels of financial literacy. I think, again, we are one of the wealthiest nations per capita. We have soon to be the second largest retirement savings pool globally, yet a very significant portion of Australians, the vast majority of Australian adults, have poor levels of financial literacy.

I think putting aside the politics of Trump accounts, which I’m not going to get into the politics of it, but the idea of setting up, for example, a child, every child with an investment account, it doesn’t matter what amount you put into that. I think Americans are starting with $1,000, but getting people to actually grow up with a balance in your investment account. And for people to actually intuitively understand over time as they get older what compounding is all about, I think it’s got a huge, huge sort of merit, basically, to it.

So again, we’ll put the politics aside but I think improving participation in investing is really great, and getting people to experience compounding, I think will have a very positive long term impact on our market and for investors.

Moderator: There might be an opening on TikTok for a financial influencer, Alex, if you’re looking for something to do.

Alex Vynokur: Anytime.

Moderator: Anthony, maybe final thought to you. Obviously we know what your position is on T1 settlement. But anything, now that you’ve been here a little while, really front of mind, top of the list of priorities that you would foreshadow?

Anthony Attia: Look, I probably spoke too much and I expressed a lot of views, but I think what I would love to see is a collective voice, and maybe embedded by the regulators, saying that Australia is open for business and wants to attract more capital and more companies here as well. The messaging to the outside world matters, because it’s about trust. And so if you want companies looking at IPO, or companies looking for private investment for superannuation fund, or foreign retail investors, or foreign institutional investors, they need to know that Australia is open for business and we want to welcome them. That’s what I would like to see.

Moderator: And you think that’s not currently obvious?

Anthony Attia: I don’t think it’s obvious today.

Moderator: Very interesting. Look, it’s been a fascinating conversation. Would you please thank Alex Vynokur, Nick Hughes, Anthony Attia and Simone Constant.

Gallery

Elective session A: The role of codes in improving consumer protection

  • Alan Kirkland, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Nadia Harrison, CEO, Mortgage Stress Victoria
  • David Locke, CEO and Chief Ombudsman, AFCA
  • Angela MacMillan, Group Customer Advocate, Commonwealth Bank

Full audio (MP3 22.9 MB)

Transcript

Alan Kirkland: It would be useful to get some comments from you to really frame some of the discussion. I guess, I mean, not only does that refer to codes in decision-making and disputes when handling complaints, but you also have the role of providing, and secretary for co-compliance for a range of the codes. So just starting with a big question, what are your perspectives on the role of the codes currently playing the system, and how they could help consumers?

David Locke: Well, thank you, Alan. I’ve always been a huge fan of codes, both as a former NGO charity regulator, but also in this role. And I think that, as you say, codes are very important specifically to AFCA, because they’re one of the factors that we have to take into account when we’re looking at what is fair in all the circumstances of the case. But really, codes should be about lifting the ceiling.

So the law really sets what the bare minimum floor is for practice, but codes are really the opportunity to lift best practice across the sector, to actually provide proper commitments to consumers. There’s been a lot of conversation today around trust or trustworthiness, around how we can ensure that consumers in a changing world really can continue to have confidence in the financial services history. Well, this is very much at the heart of it. This really should be around the commitments that industry gives to good practice in their area.

And really, codes are important because legislation is a very blunt tool. It takes you months, sometimes years to get through. Actually, codes have the ability really to be much more agile, much more easily able to respond to issues. And they’re an opportunity for industry to come together and say, look, we’re serious about the professional services that we provide, and we want to do the right thing. We may get things wrong, but we actually want to do the right thing, and we want to provide services that the public can have confidence in.

So I think, from my perspective, when codes work really well, they do that. I think though there has to be, part of the deal with that is there has to be proper oversight, proper scrutiny. There has to be some accountability when people are not complying with code obligations. There has to be reporting on that and transparency around that if it’s to have any meaning.

So I think codes do need to have something [unintelligible 00:02:50] behind them. But I think the function of codes is quite specific, and I think it really does enable us to move beyond minimum standards. So that’s why I think it’s really important. And as you say, we provide secretariat support to the banking code, customer-owned banking code, a general insurance code, the life insurance code, and insurance brokers code as well, and a number of the committee members and chairs of those codes.

Alan Kirkland: I guess your other contact with the code framework, how important are codes in AFCA’s decision-making?

David Locke: They’re really important. So we are looking, we have to have regard to the law, but we look very closely at what the code obligations are as well. You know, what is industry signed up to? What are the signatories signed up to? And also in areas where we’re looking, considering what good industry practices, very much we look to the codes. So they can be extremely helpful really in that context.

But really it’s about industry owning the codes, and having some accountability for those, I think is really important, and communicating that. The challenge with codes though sometimes is that you have inconsistent approaches across different codes, and different protections according to different codes.

So if you look at hardship, we’ve got commitments on hardship in the banking code, which is probably the highest. And then we’ve got the customer-owned banking code, which [unintelligible 00:04:23], and then we’ve got, of course, AFIA’s code in that space as well. So where it sometimes doesn’t work is really where it’s not lifting to the high standard and really got compromise around some of [unintelligible 00:04:36].

Alan Kirkland: So mentioning hardship is probably a great segue to Nadia. I’m interested in your thoughts on that sort of question around, where are codes working well now? Where could they be better, given your role at Mortgage Stress Victoria?

Nadia Harrison: Thank you very much. Just for anyone in the room that [unintelligible 00:04:55] Mortgage Stress Victoria, I will give context. So we are a state government funded community [unintelligible 00:05:01] centre. We support people who are stressed to navigate a path through their housing insecurity. And really, [unintelligible 00:05:10] of our practice, [unintelligible 00:05:13] terminology, is hardship and applying the [unintelligible 00:05:19] to support our clients experiencing hardship.

And if you think of the legislative minimum status on hardship as the bones, the codes really are the meat on the bones of those standards. So on a daily basis, our caseworkers are applying them on behalf of our clients to try and get them through the experience.

In response to the question where it’s working well, where it’s not working so well. So I’d like to just recognise the progress that’s been made, largely driven through the codes, particularly the most recent incarnation of BCOP, the 2025 version, which is a significant step forward.

So they’re operating well when they’re driving a modern, nuanced and sympathetic response to family violence, and we’ve seen really significant progress in that area. When they’re forcing lenders to look at a person’s whole circumstances, not just one [unintelligible 00:06:21] in isolation, and provide a tailored solution, which actually gives them a sustainable pathway into maintaining their housing security and out of their debt situation.

But as David alluded to, you’re really not working well in the incoherency that we see across the sector. So David mentioned we’ve got three codes that apply to the home lending market. We’ve really got four standards, because it’s a category of home lending to which no code applies. And across that, of the three codes that we have, only two of them are contractually binding.

So it should be a surprise to no one in this room that the code that is not contractually binding, the AFIA code, is more difficult to get an outcome. It’s really more accurately described as a statement of aspirations rather than an actually enforceable [unintelligible 00:07:17]. And when you’re looking from the perspective of consumers who are trying to understand what their rights are, understanding the legislative restrictions is difficult enough. When they’re faced with literally different rules that apply depending on who you have borrowed with, it’s quite an absurd situation.

We see consistently through our casework that very similar factual circumstances will get a very different response. And that’s not appropriate, actually, and it actually plays out structurally quite inequitably as well.

So the AFIA code covers non-bank lenders and private lenders. In terms of the breakdown of the mortgages market, ABA members represent about 90% of the market, customer and banks about 5%, and the non-bank lenders and the private lenders about 5%. We’ve got a situation where the cohort of the market, the borrowers that are most likely to need to rely on those hardship supports, are also more likely to be banking with a lender that offers the weaker protection.

So we’ve got in the sector a residualisation actually of protections, and quite an absurd situation where that cohort of people that as I say are most likely to be in need of those hardship supports are more likely to be low income, have a poorer credit history, have less options in the market, and are more likely to have to bank with lenders that don’t offer those same protections while they’re also often paying a higher interest rate because of their risk profile.

So at Mortgage Stress Victoria we call this the lender’s lottery, that you can get different protections depending on who you borrow from. And we’re calling for a standardised mortgages [unintelligible 00:09:22] charter which applies on a mandatory basis, and which at least meets the standards in BCOP.

Alan Kirkland: And does that mean in a way you form the view that – because another path to getting that consistency would be to try and bring the floor up with the worst codes, or the code with the lowest protection. So to work through the various code review processes. Have you made a call that this is a space where legislation is a more appropriate, or some sort of legislative intervention is a more appropriate mechanism to get that consistency of standards?

Nadia Harrison: So the key concept for us is mandatory versus optional. Whether that’s achieved through legislation, regulations, conditions of credit licences, contract terms, as long as it is clearly understood to be mandatory, and ideally consistent as well. We had a big conversation about red tape and efficiency this morning. Optimistic that there could be industry support for a harmonisation of those standards. But on it, we absolutely contribute to the individual code reviews. We’ve contributed actively to the customer and banking code review recently and we’ll also be contributing to the BCOP review.

So absolutely, the codes are extremely important as they are now. We’ll continue to advocate on them individually. But the best scenario, the most efficient and the most consumer-friendly outcome is actually a mandatory mortgages charter, which lifts them all to that standard.

Alan Kirkland: Angela, I mean, often we end up embedded as discussion around what should be embedded in the law, and what more appropriately belongs in codes. Do you have a view on what sort of principles we should be thinking about in terms of determining which sorts of protections should sit in which bucket?

Angela MacMillan: Yeah, look, thanks, Alan. And I should probably preface my contributions to today’s discussion by saying that I’m coming to this conversation with the lens of a Group Customer Advocate for CommBank. It’s a fairly unique role, it’s a fairly unique set of perspectives, as it is for all of the customer advocates that sit in all of the ABA member banks.

It is our role to really amplify the voices of customers and communities within our organisations, and to leverage those insights to help improve products and services [unintelligible 00:11:47] these decisions and processes. So yeah, to come back to your question and to use that lens, I see every day the benefits of codes for our customers. I see in real life the value, not only to our organisation in the delivery of our products and services and how we interact with customers, but also to those customers themselves.

And where I see codes being incredibly effective is where they are, I think to David’s earlier point, where they are addressing gaps, they are adding protections, which may not be evident in legislation or in law, rather than restating what’s already covered by law. The importance of codes to our customers and to consumers more broadly, is that they set those expectations very clearly. They give our customers insights into the standards that they can expect, and that they can rely on.

And in my experience, is the banking code, I work very closely with the banking code, with the advocacy and vulnerability space within CommBank. And what we see there are safeguards and protections that are designed to support consumers, whether they be individuals, small business, guarantors, without restating and duplicating what is in legislative requirements.

And so I think that the codes, not only are they addressing some of those gaps, but we also see where codes are effective in where it is reasonably, where industry is reasonably able to commit to those additional protections or where there is an ability to really clarify what’s already captured in legislation and see that. There’s a number of benefits to code, but I think the critical thing is that we’re not duplicating what is in law.

And I think the Scams Prevention Framework, for example, will be a really interesting kind of test case for that. Because we know that government is legislating a regime that will have quite strong obligations on the banks. Time will tell what might need to be enhanced there, but I think having that delineation between the role of the code and the role of legislation is going to be very critical.

Alan Kirkland: And the codes have an important audience with people working in banks, don’t they?

Angela MacMillan: Absolutely.

Alan Kirkland: It’s not just consumers and people acting for consumers in that environment. It’s actually, I often think about it, one of the most important audiences is actually people working in the financial institutions, really understanding what the commitments are that their company [unintelligible 00:14:36].

On that issue of scams, I mean, it’s an interesting one, isn’t it, because we are moving to legislative codes. Let’s just put that aside, because it’s a very different form of code to what we’re talking about here. But anyway, there is regulation happening specifically on a threat. I mean, would you say up until that point that the code – how would you evaluate the ability, Angela, of the code framework to respond to that evolving threat of scams over recent years?

Angela MacMillan: Look, I think we’re in a position where we are now, where we recognise collectively that more needs to be done, and it does need to be strengthened through legislation. So I know David’s got some fairly strong views on what the future holds for scams, but I think the ability to be responsive, but also to be stronger and more robust, [unintelligible 00:15:29] that we can collectively agree on.

Alan Kirkland: And David, these are interesting questions [unintelligible 00:15:35]. No, no, no, David, actually, I would like to hear your thoughts before I go to a question from the audience. So yeah, your thoughts on how well, I guess the existing code framework has responded to that scam threat.

David Locke: Well, I don’t think it has really. But I mean, I think we have an opportunity really with the codes coming in as part of the [BSPF 00:15:55]. The codes are being used because of the flexibility that that provides. And when you’re dealing with the world of scams, this is ever changing and evolving. This is, as we all know, serious organised crime, being turbo charged by AI and some of the tools that we’ve been talking about today. So actually the ability to be able to change that and develop that as the threat changes, I think is really important.

But what we’ve had to date is different banks investing in a whole range of technology to try and prevent scams and identify scams, but it’s like water. So wherever there’s a weaker link, that’s where the scammers will go, whether that’s on account opening, on mule accounts, or whether that’s really on transactions. So that’s why there’s a need for industry-wide and cross-industry codes really in this space.

Alan Kirkland: And Nadia, just on this question of responsiveness, I mean, you mentioned some areas earlier on where you feel like codes in general have been helpful in relation to hardship, family violence, tailored solutions, tailored to individual circumstances. I guess at the same time, our sort of understanding of the nature and prevalence of issues like financial abuse and appropriate responses to financial abuse has evolved quite rapidly in recent times. I mean, if you take an issue like that, how would you evaluate the effectiveness of the current code framework in responding to some of those issues that we’re understanding in a very fast and urgent way?

Nadia Harrison: Again, I’d start by recognising – sorry, [unintelligible 00:17:40] as people know. Credit where credit’s due, there has been a significant amount of work on that issue. And [unintelligible 00:17:48] but the recognition of [unintelligible 00:17:52] by design as a conceptual [unintelligible 00:17:53], not just to be more reactionary, but actually being about the way which products themselves are enablers of financial abuse. Significant resources, [unintelligible 00:18:04], significant effort has gone into trying to tackle this.

Again, just sort of rooted in our [unintelligible 00:18:13] experience, more than 40% of Mortgage Stress Victoria’s clients are victim survivors of family violence. We know from the evidence that the majority of those will have experienced some sort of financial abuse, but will not necessarily be able to identify that they’ve actually experienced that, is part of the challenge.

So while recognising there’s been a lot of progress, I would add there’s also significantly more work to do. I mean, fundamentally, the mortgage products we have still assume that the interests of joint borrowers will be aligned for the duration of the life. I mean, you just pause to think on that. The opportunities for abuse in that situation; you’ve got ongoing joint and several liability, and an assumption that each individual’s interests are aligned in circumstances where one person is ready to act or act, the other person is immediately on the hook for it. You could argue as coherently, the archetypal model of the married couple getting a mortgage together is an unsafe product, because there’s so much opportunity actually for abuse in that.

So recognising that we’re in that world, there are things that can be done better. So for example, some of the codes now allow consumers, one party to the mortgage, to request that both account holders have to give permission before significant transactions happen. I mean, that’s just scenario that we see time and time again, is a couple separates, he moves out, stops paying the mortgage, and sometimes will clear out significant amounts of what’s in the offset account, or max out the credit card. These are not remote, unusual, unpredictable. These things are happening time and time again. Some of the codes provide an opportunity for one party in that joint mortgage to put some constraints on that, others don’t. So there’s opportunities for improvement.

Another thing I’d flag in terms of safety by design is something that I think the sector should really have a deep look at, is it is our experience that women are more likely to be pursued in this scenario of joint or several liability. The kind of anec-data or the influence, the kind of only logical influence that you can draw from that is that there seems to be an acceptance that women are more likely to be responsive, they’re easier to deal with, they’re less likely to be angry, hostile, aggressive. And so we see that banks are more likely to be pursuing women where you’ve got that joint and several liability. And the bank legally, contractually, they can legitimately go after either.

In terms of a safety by design frame, all home lenders should be doing a deep audit of their practices in that regard and making sure they’re not systematically disadvantaging the female in that [unintelligible 00:21:26].

David Locke: And elder abuse as well. We would see a lot of parents acting as guarantors for business loans. So that’s classic area [unintelligible 00:21:38].

Alan Kirkland: And so I guess, giving you a right of reply, not necessarily on those specific issues, Angela, but if you think from a glass half full perspective, I mean, where would you say the banking code is being most effective at improving consumer protection?

Angela MacMillan: So I think the strengths of the banking code is that it very clearly articulates, as I mentioned before, just the protections that consumers can expect when they interact with us. I think that that strength has been reinforced through, and Nadia touched on this, all the revisions to the code and [unintelligible 00:22:11] last year.

In particular, in my world, the [unintelligible 00:22:17] of the definition of vulnerability and the explicit call out that vulnerability can happen to anyone at any time, and it can be a number of factors that influence that. It can be temporary, it can be permanent, and it can be fluid. And I think in that context, the addition of incarceration as a vulnerability indicator, and I’ll touch on a point that David raised before, and I think that’s been critically important in amplifying, shining a spotlight on the needs of that cohort.

Additionally, guarantors. And given what we’ve seen across the sector, and given the [unintelligible 00:23:01], the conditions of equal protection [unintelligible 00:23:03] has been a very positive step forward.

But I think if you were to look at the code’s obligations in isolation, [unintelligible 00:23:10] story. David mentioned before the ability to galvanise an organisation’s priorities based on what the obligations are in the code is incredibly helpful as well. And so in my world, we very much focus our customer advocacy and priorities on what is foundational within the code, but it’s not where the story ends.

And so a couple of examples of that, given we knew that incarceration was being added explicitly into the code, my team undertook a review, revisited some thematic [unintelligible 00:23:46] a few years ago to really stare into, well, what is the extra care that we have on offer for those customers? Where are the gaps? Where are the opportunities for improvement? So that would be a point that helped galvanise that focus.

Equally to Nadia’s point around, and to David’s point around financial abuse, we have obligations in the banking code around the provision of extra care to individuals who might be impacted by fraud, scams, by financial abuse, people who are older. And so we’ve taken that grounding, we’ve developed things like our Safe Savvy Resource Toolkit, which is designed to raise awareness of fraud, scams, financial abuse amongst older people, and they use the code as a basis.

Equally, when you’re talking about financial abuse, we’ve looked at not only [unintelligible 00:24:43] an organisation, but also how can we elicit the standards of the sector? So if you look at financial abuse, for example, we’ve made our technology to proactively detect the use of messaging in [unintelligible 00:24:56] platforms. We’ve made that technology available across the sector, both domestically and internationally.

So I think there’s a number of ways in which the code has been effective in and of itself. But I think also how it’s playing in the individual organisations in teams like mine is also where all that effectiveness has come from.

David Locke: And I think that other parts of industry have a way to go on some of this, really, to learn from the work that’s being led by [unintelligible 00:25:24]. So we see financial abuse in insurance, we’d see financial abuse in other contexts as well, which you would never classically [unintelligible 00:25:37].

Alan Kirkland: Let me come back to a question I was going to go to a moment ago, and David, I might throw this to you. It’s from Alexandra Hochwarter of the ICA. A little bit of research shows countries with the highest [unintelligible 00:25:48] regulation in consumer codes have the lowest trust in financial services providers, then the inverse is true as well. Those with the least regulation [unintelligible 00:25:57] have the highest trust in financial services providers. Any take on why that might be?

David Locke: I don’t know. I’ve got no idea. I’ve got no idea. I haven’t seen the research and I don’t know what the countries are. I mean, trust varies a lot according to the legal and regulatory environments you have, and according to societal issues as well. I think what you want is industry to be worthy of trust. And what you want, I think, is for there to be high standards of conduct and organisations held to high standards of conduct.

I mean, sometimes regulators see that actually, and I know from a previous life, that actually you would think that when you report more compliance activity being taken, that actually people would then think, oh, that’s good, there’s a cop on the beat, like ASIC that’s actually taking enforcement action.

Sometimes I think what happens is people have thought of financial crime, and then they see more financial crime, and then they jump to the assumption. So it could be that sort of thing, Alexandra, that’s going on in that environment. So we see that with other forms of regulation. But I think fundamentally, we all have a vested interest in the financial services sector, in treating consumers fairly to gain high levels of trust.

Yes, [unintelligible 00:27:29] I was going to make a similar point [unintelligible 00:27:29]. It might be more a story about the regulatory framework regulation than the story about the codes themselves. I think, just from my time of working around the consumer [unintelligible 00:27:40] and internationally, I find there are regions where there aren’t strong consumer protections, there aren’t active regulators. That means you don’t have people sort of taking financial firms to court and talking about it in the media. And I think [unintelligible 00:27:54] that sometimes actually that regulation probably does have an impact on trust. That ultimately, that’s [unintelligible 00:27:59] in the status of a greater good. [Unintelligible 00:28:02].

Nadia Harrison: I’m just drawing on what Danielle Wood shared this morning. She made a comment that we all agree that air safety standards are non-negotiable, and that we have basically zero tolerance for risk in the air safety industry. I know [unintelligible 00:28:20] we’re willing to tolerate a degree of regulatory cost and perhaps less innovation in that field as a result of that.

I think the hardship protections that my team rely on, on behalf of people facing potential housing insecurity and homelessness, should be seen in that context. These rights, these protections are not [unintelligible 00:28:45] hats. They’re not opportunities for best practice or opportunities for business to kind of dabble in charity and stretch the limits of what might be needed. They should be considered non-negotiable.

Actually, when you look at the risk in the finance sector more broadly, one of the most significant risks that we are mitigating against is the potential loss of someone’s housing security, potential loss of someone’s home. So just in response to a kind of implicit comment in that question about the value of regulation and kind of what the cost of it might be, I think it’s really important that we talk about regulated standards. And again, I come back to that point; mandatory standards. These hardship protections that are in the codes should not be considered optional.

Alan Kirkland: And I should say, if there are any other questions, please feed them through and we’ll try to go to some more. Look, I wouldn’t mind to jump into this issue of approval of codes by ASIC. So I mean, obviously the banking code is the only code that has been approved by ASIC today, that’s a topical issue, and insurance, we all know the ICA has been working towards that, and the [unintelligible 00:29:58] submitted a draft code to ASIC for consideration. Kelly explored the issue of potential ASIC approval as part of the life code review.

So I would be interested in some perspectives on the pros and cons of ASIC approval of all entry industry codes. And I might start with you, Angela. I’m just interested in your perspective on what role ASIC approval has, or what impact ASIC approval has had in relation to the banking code.

Angela MacMillan: Yes, I think ASIC’s approval has been critically important to its success. I think what it gives consumers, and banks as well, and likely other third parties that are interested in codes, is really an avenue or proof points around a level of scrutiny has been applied, which has assessed those commitments against consumer protection and accountability standing. And I think that’s really critical for that complement.

If we look at the commitments within the banking [unintelligible 00:31:11], they’re contractually enforceable, they are substantive. They are also, they come with a level of oversight from the Banking Code Compliance Committee, and they also have pathways for address for consumers when things go wrong, including through to AFCA.

So I think when you actually bring those together, the value of having industry accountability for its commitments, I think they have independent oversight of delivery against those [unintelligible 00:31:41]. And then you have scrutiny of those commitments and in [unintelligible 00:31:46]. If you triangulate that, I think that is where that impact of that ASIC approval really comes into play.

David Locke: And the ABA and the banks have recently agreed as well to named reporting in context of breaches and failure to comply, which is a real sign of maturity as well. And it’s a sign of taking the work of the code committee seriously. There’s no point doing this if it’s really just window dressing, and the commitments are not clear and discernible and actually lifting practice.

And the real challenge with this, Alan, is how across an industry do you actually corral the cats really into agreeing something that isn’t a compromise, a dumbed down assessment. And really, I think where we see this successfully working is where you’ve actually got the players really committing to [unintelligible 00:32:44].

The challenge, and I think ASIC approval really puts ASIC’s endorsements and support behind that, gives a lot of added credibility to that. It also means with subsequent use, of course, ASIC have to approve revisions to the code. And we all know how the regulatory pendulum swings. We all know how major financial institutions’ leadership can change and direction can change.

Sarah earlier started the day really talking about how it feels as though sometimes there’s lost memory of the Banking Royal Commission and some of the lessons that came out of that, not just banks, across the financial services industry. And actually, sometimes where we get reviews of codes, it’s not always necessarily moving in a positive direction. I think ASIC approval actually does ensure that really industries move forward with their code. So I think it’s really important, but I understand it’s not easy to get everybody across the page, it’s not easy to corral the codes, particularly if some of them [unintelligible 00:34:00].

Alan Kirkland: And [unintelligible 00:34:01] McCray had a question that’s sort of a bit in that space, which was in a world of voluntary codes, there’s no incentive for fringe codes, that’s [unintelligible 00:34:10] words, not mine, with low standards and no inner monitoring to lift standards. So what mechanism exists to push these to make greater commitments?

So I guess it must be something you think about sometimes from your perspective, David, for those codes or some of those standards might be weak. Do you have a perspective on how people industry might influence those codes to improve?

David Locke: Well, self-regulation is not a right, it’s a privilege. And I think if industry doesn’t actually address those issues, then the consequence is that government will step in. So if really what you have is something that’s window dressing to try and show that you’re really making a difference, but actually it really isn’t impacting, to be honest, the issues that Mortgage Stress Victoria and others are seeing day to day, then the reality is, the risk is, I suppose, to the financial firms that industry will step in and mandate that.

And if we look in superannuation, I would dearly have loved the superannuation industry to come together to develop a code to address the issues around service that have been well-publicised. And I think that would have been a [unintelligible 00:35:28]. That has failed. So now we have a situation where government is coming in to introduce mandatory service standards to superannuation, and I think that’s a missed opportunity [unintelligible 00:35:42] in that sense.

Alan Kirkland: It is an interesting observation, isn’t it? Because I, without having a say in what form those standards [unintelligible 00:35:47], I don’t know why you’d expect, given their title, they’ll be addressing a number of the sorts of issues that are actually addressed through codes.

David Locke: It could be addressed through codes, but it’s whether you can actually get agreement. That’s the challenge.

Nadia Harrison: And that gap that [unintelligible 00:36:03] is alluding to is exactly the reason why we’re calling for a mandatory mortgages charter. Because it does make a difference, the fact that the AFIA codes, protections are weaker, and not contractually enforceable.

And just to add one little fact, colour to that. So I mentioned earlier that the non-bank lenders and the private lenders represent about 5% of the home lending market. That proportion is actually growing quite rapidly. Mortgage Stress Victoria’s eligibility criteria make it that we only service people that are either low income or victim survivors of family violence, often both. Whereas the proportion of the home lending market that is non-bank lenders or private providers is roughly 5%, it’s 20% of our client caseload.

This cohort, the low income people, victim survivors of family violence are over-represented in their reliance on these lenders. So it’s absolutely urgent, actually, that the standards are lifted, and that we do have some sort of government intervention to harmonise and lift those standards.

Alan Kirkland: I thought you might grab that opportunity. Angela, you were talking before about, I guess, some of the different sort of accountability mechanisms. And sometimes this is almost raised as this sort of regulatory burden issue, that you’ve got, obviously ASIC playing its role under legislation, potentially [unintelligible 00:37:26]. You’ve got AFCA playing a key EDR role. You’ve got a code, monitoring or code governance committees. I mean, do you see that as an issue from an industry perspective, that you’ve got these various [unintelligible 00:37:43]? How do you think through that?

Angela MacMillan: So from my perspective, I can see that there are clear faults. And we see at CommBank that each of those entities has got a clear role and a clear set of accountabilities in [working 00:38:00] together to protect consumers.

So yeah, I would say it’s a regulatory burden. If anything, I think it’s incumbent on us that when we are asked for information or reporting that it is accurate, that it is up to date, so that it does help those repressing entities to really understand what’s happening, and to help us identify where there is areas for improvement. So I think we have a role to play in that as well.

That said, I think it’s fair to say that every one of us, as we are navigating this world with tremendous amounts of data and insights and facts and numbers, that we’re all working towards how do we simplify, how do we de-duplicate, how do we streamline, so that we’re actually [unintelligible 00:38:50] on the critical issues that will be most [unintelligible 00:38:53] and most valuable to consumers.

And I know that AFCA, and I know that ASIC, and I know that the BCCC have all been individually and together working on how do they build those relationships between themselves to share information when it’s appropriate to do so. Streamlining request information, streamlining data collection mechanisms. And I know that [OCA 00:39:16] is very happy to continue working with [unintelligible 00:39:21] organisations collectively on [unintelligible 00:39:26] opportunities. ASIC in particular [unintelligible 00:39:30]a regulatory burden, anything [unintelligible 00:39:32] that there have been steps that have been taken to reduce some of the reporting load, which obviously is [unintelligible 00:39:37]. The BCCC updated to their charter last year, introduced seriality thresholds on breach reporting, which doesn’t mean that breach reporting isn’t important, but it means that collectively you can focus on the areas that require the most amount of attention.

And so I wouldn’t say that it’s a burden, but I think we all recognise where we have a role to play in that simplification, that streamlining, that de-duplication.

David Locke: I think it’s great to hear that, too, Angela, because we do sometimes get this noise and there is sometimes noise around us. I mean, we tried very clearly at AFCA to define what our role is, to very clearly say we are not the conduct regulator in this space. Our role is to deal with the individual matters that the regulator is not set up or designing to deal with.

But where we do see systemic issues or where we do see serious contraventions, that it is, of course, to work with the financial [unintelligible 00:40:39] to understand whether that is the case or not. And if it is, then to report those matters through to the regulator.

So we tried very hard around post the 2021 Independent Review of AFCA to really very clearly define those roles. And I think the code committees, they have limited resources. They don’t want to be focusing on matters that ASIC are investigating. They want to be adding value to identify whether there may be thematic issues, or there maybe business issues that actually [unintelligible 00:41:14].

So I think there has been a real effort to do that. But I understand there’s a lot of players, and we’re all talking around issues of non-compliance or issues of breaches. So I understand how there could be perceptions there. But I think from our perspective, we’ve tried very hard to [unintelligible 00:41:34] that.

I’d agree there has been a lot of effort to try and remove duplication. What I would say is sometimes, and this is really industry people in the room, sometimes we do hit barriers where the code compliance or governance committees actually can’t share their level or type of information they ideally need to share with ASIC in order to allow us to identify where their market lies. Those areas of overlap, or to avoid us going out and requesting data that they’ve already got. So I think that’s something where we need to identify those opportunities. If industry sees that, they can raise that. We could deal with it.

Alan Kirkland: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. That’s something that might actually require changes to some of the governance of the documents though, under which those committees work. But I think that’s a conversation we can absolutely continue.

Another question from Drew, actually, who I know is thinking a lot about codes at the moment. Drew, [unintelligible 00:42:22].

David Locke: Drew, you have to keep your hands somewhere over your head. He must be very busy at this conference. I can see Drew on quite a few of the questions.

Alan Kirkland: No, it’s a really good question, actually. I want to start to try and [unintelligible 00:42:31], which is, “Are codes agile enough given the length of time between the reviews and the length of time [unintelligible 00:42:39] take to implement the review recommendations?” I guess, on the other hand, we then have sometimes questions around, is that review coming around too soon, which I know was an issue raised in relation to the banking code. So I mean, I might go to you first on this, Nadia. Do you think that codes are agile enough, given that review cycle?

Nadia Harrison: I mean, self-evidently, sometimes they’re more agile than other times. Yeah, as I’ve said, the grievance we had is in the duplication of them, and the kind of [unintelligible 00:43:12] of different standards or effectively the same.

David Locke: It took 20 years to get [unintelligible 00:43:20]. It took how many decades to take and to get unfair trading practices legislation through? It’s all a question of comparison. I think sometimes they have the potential to be much more agile in trying to get legislation through.

Angela MacMillan: And I think there’s also a role for industry guidelines as well. And often, they are able to be much more responsive and practical, and reflect best practice standards for that time. So I think, yeah, collectively, they all have a role to play.

Alan Kirkland: I wouldn’t own that, in a way, that question placed towards the [unintelligible 00:43:59] code review. I wouldn’t mind asking you for your views around code review processes. I know Peter Kell is in the room who is currently leading the banking code review, and has recently done the [unintelligible 00:44:09] review. The RCA has obviously been through a review process after the last few years. I’m interested in views on what a good code review process looks like. Because there is often debate among stakeholders around how good a code review has been. From an industry perspective, Angela, what do you think a good code review process looks like?

Angela MacMillan: Oh, goodness. Well, the fact that we’re in the midst of the banking code review, my lens means I probably need to tread a little bit carefully here. So look, I think what we see with the BCCC and what we’re seeing with the revisions that came into play in 2025 is that good, wide consultation with various boards and stakeholders, very much listening to consumers, very much listening to community organisations, regulators and interested parties. Which is why it takes longer than sometimes you would want it to take.

So I think that having that very broad consultation period [unintelligible 00:45:20] is very balanced and is then very transparent. And I think that it was a successful review undertaken that led to the 2025 updates. And so I’m pleased to see that a lot of the same practices have being deployed in the past year.

David Locke: Well, I hope not.

Angela MacMillan: Some of them. Not necessarily. No, there are – I respectfully disagree, and I was saying that I think there were some really good consultation practices. I get there will always be natural tension between the interested parties. I think having that open debate and working through those might give [unintelligible 00:46:00].

David Locke: I think it’s a bit of a fail, really, when matters go through to ASIC for approval and they have to do another consultation, because the previous consultation perhaps wasn’t as thorough or as open as it could have been. I think, to be honest, sometimes when I hear “code review,” my heart gives up a little bit. And it should be about actually looking at where we can identify gaps in approved practice. And sometimes the simplification agenda that’s used really can lead to the removal of important protections.

And I think there’s a tension there, Alan. I think there’s a tension where you’ve got contractually portability. And I think the lawyers get involved, and I’ve got nothing against lawyers, I’m an ex-lawyer. But that can lead to, we’ve got to take this as per the code, put it in guidance. We can’t commit to this, if this is going to be contractually enforceable. And I think sometimes it makes it actually harder to get progress on some of this.

So I think what we’ve seen is good independent reviewers appointed. We’ve seen good recommendations. Not always taken forward, but obviously you’re never going to get it [unintelligible 00:47:23]. No party, as you say, quite rightly actually, is going to get [unintelligible 00:47:28] it’s important. But I think there are opportunities to do this a bit better.

Alan Kirkland: And just a final question then to you, Nadia, on that point, what is a good code review process look like from the perspective of a [unintelligible 00:47:41]?

Nadia Harrison: One which meaningfully incorporates diverse voices in a non-tokenistic way. So genuinely engages the individuals that are most likely to be harmed by poor practices. That includes non-English speaking communities, that includes victim survivors, [unintelligible 00:48:03], that includes First Nations community, that includes people who would have been in an [unintelligible 00:48:09] prison, genuinely engages and incorporates their voices. And just completely reinforcing what David said, one that is explicitly ambitious about the change it is seeking to achieve, not one that is used opportunistically to wind back progress that’s previously been achieved.

Alan Kirkland: That sounds like a great note to end on. So I’m going to let you all go. I’m conscious we’re at the end of a really big day, so please thank our panellists.

Gallery

Elective session B: Professional services: building strong foundations

  • Kate O’Rourke, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Ilana Atlas AO, Chair, Scentre Group
  • Peter Achterstraat AM, NSW Productivity and Equality Commissioner
  • Edmund Tadros, Professional Services Editor, Australian Financial Review

Full audio (MP3 35 MB)

Transcript

Kate O’Rourke: Thank you all very much for coming today. We’ve heard a lot about trust today. We’ve heard about navigating change. We’ve also talked a lot about complexity and some of the confluence and challenges associated with the current economic environment. So navigating these changes for companies does need expertise, and often it does need expert assistance from professional services firms. So whether they be auditing firms or legal services or consultancy or otherwise, a really important part of our system includes professional services firms for companies. Just as we need these services even more and more, we have had a series, particularly in relation to audit, of issues or scandals that have shaken the confidence in professional services firms to some extent.

So people disagree about how to characterise those events and that’s something that’s really interesting. But I think it does mean it’s interesting for us at a forum like this, to have a discussion about professional services firms. I’ve been either at or adjacent to ASIC for a long time. I’m not sure we’ve actually ever had a forum session on professional services firms. We’ve certainly talked about auditing and we’ve talked about insolvency and the issues. But actually, the firms is something that’s a little bit different. So thank you for being interested in it, it’s going to be a great discussion. Another possible first is to have a journalist as a panellist as opposed to an interviewer. Maybe not a first, but it's rare.

So a very warm welcome to Ed Tadros who is the Professional Services Editor from The Australian Financial Review. I’m also delighted to introduce one of Australia’s most highly regarded and senior directors. This is Ilana Atlas AO who is the Chair of Scentre Group, a former senior Westpac executive and was also the managing partner of Mallesons. So she’s seen all the professional services firms. Of course, the esteemed Peter Achterstraat AM, Peter is the New South Wales Productivity and Equality Commissioner. But also the former New South Wales auditor general, so auditor squared, and also used to be the chair of ASIC’s Audit and Risk Committee so we know Peter well.

So a very warm welcome to you all. Thank you. We are going to start this discussion by talking about professional services firms at the system level, what role they play, particularly in the current environment where we’re navigating change. We are going to also discuss their contribution to trust in the system. But then we will talk about the pressures on trust, particularly if there’s questions about integrity and reliability of those services, what a breakdown of that trust looks like. Then we will go back to how one restores trust or what that looks like after situations like this. That’s the first area we’re going to discuss. Then we’re going to broach the subject of regulation, because we’re at a regulatory conference. We won’t go too long into it, but just a little bit.

So that’s an opportunity to think about why we are where we are now in the system that we’ve got with professional standards and we’ve got partnerships. But also, what might regulation look like if it were to change. I think most people in the room will be aware that there is discussion about change, there’s consultation on it. So just in terms of administration, we do have a nice screen that tell us questions. If you’ve got questions, please put them through the app. We’ve got team members here who can send them through for us so that you can be part of the discussion. As Hamish said upstairs, it does help if you do have someone you’d particularly like a question posed to, you can say so. Or you can just put it to the panel and we’ll take it from there.

All right, so let’s start at the macro level like I said, on the role of professional services firms in our financial economy. I’m going to start on the demand side, like who buys these services? Companies, directors. So Ilana, as a board director, what do clients and boards most need from professional advisors? What do you look for to have confidence that their judgement is genuinely independent?

Ilana Atlas: Thanks Kate and hello everybody, it’s delightful to be here this afternoon. Thank you for the opportunity in being part of it. Clearly we’re very diverse, this panel. I just thought I’d just explain my perspective. I’ve been a partner and a managing partner in a large, commercial law firm, Mallesons. I’ve been a general counsel, so in that capacity obviously I provided professional services. As general counsel, I’ve bought them and as a company director, I rely on them. I do come at this from a number of different perspectives. I would say over the decades that I’ve been involved with professional services, I would say my experience has been overwhelmingly positive. So in terms of what you need, particularly as a director, I would say there are three, minimum non-negotiables.

One would be capability, that is outstanding technical ability is your expectation from a professional services provider. The second is judgement, so you expect your professional services expert to be able to apply that technical capability to your organisation, to your sector, to your industry. Thirdly and most importantly is integrity. You have an expectation that the person who’s providing you with professional services has ethical standards that are essentially unimpeachable. Why is that important for a director? Directors, we’re accountable to our many stakeholders for the advice that is provided to us by professional services providers, for example, auditors. So that’s why those minimums are non-negotiable.

I would say if you’d asked me 30 years ago what the needs are, they probably would have been exactly the same. I would have said those three things. But I think what’s changed over that period is the landscape. So very much, I would have relied on a partner in a firm, that partner and that partner’s team. I think what’s changed over time is the importance of reliance on the firm, that that partner is part of. For example, when I was at Mallesons, we just provided legal advice. This is a long time ago. We were all essentially paid the same. So it was subject to tenure, but we all got paid the same. What’s happened of course with firms, there’s been such a significant evolution in firms. They’ve got a lot larger, they do different things, they provide different services.

I think what’s occurred as a result and the way they’re renumerated has changed as well, a lot of it is dependent on performance, however that is managed. I think firms have themselves changed. It is I think the right question to ask, as to whether the governance process and systems that guide firms, have actually kept up with the changes to firms themselves. If I think about this, culture is really at the end of the day, what’s most important. Culture to me is a combination of what I call soft wiring and hard wiring. Soft wiring is very much the behaviour, the ethical standards that someone subscribes to and the hardwiring of a governance processes and systems that underpin it.

I can use a partner in a professional services environment who has the highest ethical standards. But if the systems and processes in which they operate aren’t aligned with that, it causes issues. So I really want to know if the incentives within the firm, aren’t aligned with the standards that I think I would expect, that’s of interest to me. Similarly, if the processes around confidential information or conflicts of interest are weak, then that’s important to me. If the firm marks its own homework and there’s no independence in the firm, that’s also important. I think I’d summarise and say the need now, is very much those three things. Capability, judgement and integrity from the individual, and also from the firm.

Kate O’Rourke: Yes, really interesting, and some of those issues we’ll come back to –

Ilana Atlas: Yes sure.

Kate O’Rourke: – in terms of when there’s questions about trust or breakdown. But also when we talk about regulation as well, at the level of the individual or the level of the firm. I’m going to turn to you Peter. This is a little bit more supply side, I hear that you were a supplier as well. But just to draw on your experience Peter, across productivity, audit, board governance, where do you think professional services contribute most to the system? So that contribution of these firms to our whole system, and where do you think some of that trust or that contribution is under pressure?

Peter Achterstraat: Thanks very much Kate and thanks for the invitation to speak. I just want to make it clear, I’m not holding myself out to be an expert on all of this. I’ll give you my experience of what’s worked well and mistakes I’ve made, so I’ll just make that up front. I think from professional services firms and the audit of so I believe, is akin to a professional services firm. The first thing we’ve got to do is understand the value of trust, why it’s important. We all know the equation high trust equals low cost. The higher the trust, the less cost involved in doing things. So where you’ve got a lot of trust, sometimes the deal will be done on a handshake. Other situations where the trust’s not quite so high, then we need more documentation, a lot more documentation.

The benefit of trust, and trust of course is the outcome of good ethical behaviour. Firms with trust and good ethical behaviour, the evidence shows us that they’re more profitable, more productive. Trust and quick decision making lead to increased productivity. So what can a professional services firm, what can they do? Well I think there’s three things we all need to do, building on Ilana’s. The first one is do your job well, technical excellence, the capability. Do your job and do it well, that’s the first thing. Whether it’s well researched legal opinions, whether it’s deep forensic accounting, do your job well, that’s the first thing. The second thing is again, talking about the hard culture that Ilana talked about. The second thing is complying with all the fundamental governance, formal requirements, the legislation, the rules, regulations, the codes, code of ethics and code of conduct. So complying with those.

The first is do your job well, second is comply with all laws. The third and most important is instilling a deep, genuine, ethical culture in the organisation. That is the biggest challenge. If we can maybe use a couple of hypothetical examples on that. They’re hypothetical, right. We know professions when they make decisions, they can look at it from different lenses. They can look at it from self-interest, they can look at it from the client’s interests. They can look at it from the public interest. Of course, the client’s interest is not always the same as the client’s wishes. So sometimes the professional services advisor has got to explain to the client, that their short-term wishes may not translate to their long-term interests.

If we look at those three, the self-interest, the client’s interest and the public interest … if we take a specific example, say we have someone we’ll call a young graduate. Our young graduate works in a professional services firm. The boss comes along and says, “Look young graduate, this client wants evaluation of their business.” So young graduate goes away, does all the work. Works out the discount values, the projected cash flow, all this and comes up with a figure of $50 million. Goes to the boss and says, “Look, I valued this at $50 million. I’ve done all the research, I’ve complied with my technical knowledge et cetera. Number two, I’ve followed all the rules, the APS 110 for accountants, all the ethical standards and I’ve come up with a figure. I think the company’s worth $50 million.”

The boss looks back, “Mm, mm. The client thinks it’s worth $100 million. Have you looked at this website that says AI is going to double the value of all businesses in that sector? Here’s the website, go and have a look at it and come back and see if you’ve got a better answer.” Now I’m not saying this happens, this is extreme hypothetical example. So young graduate goes away and comes back and looks up the website, and sees that the website’s not all that robust. It’s just some sort of a hack where someone’s made a throwaway comment that in this sector, AI is going to double the value. Then young graduate says, “Well if I can rely on that and technically I can, that means the value is not 50, it’s 100. Yeah okay, well look, I’m not sure what to do there.”

I’m not going to give you the answer, but depending on what lens they look through … I’m not saying you should exclusively look through one of those lenses. In fact, you’ve got to look at all of them. You can’t just ignore the client’s interests or wishes and go public interest. You can’t ignore … anyway so young graduate makes a decision. Thinks now what do I do? If they’re looking at self-interest and client wishes, they might say, “Well I think $100 million. I can use these different cash … maybe the revenue’s going to be a bit higher than I thought,” and this, that and the other. If they look at public interest, which means can the public rely on these professional services firms in the future … when it comes out that this figure was not as robust as people say.

Then the public interest might be that there has been a bit of a discount on the trust and the value of this professional, or all professional services people. So the person’s got to look at, the young graduate’s got to look at it from a different set of lenses.

Kate O’Rourke: Thank you. I’ll come to you now Ed. You’ve reported closely on the professional services sector, as the professional services editor from the AFR. There has been a period of significant scrutiny and change. So when confidence in the professional services firm begins to breakdown, what warning signs emerge first? What do you hear, what do you see?

Edmund Tadros: The clearest sign to us, it all comes back to cognitive dissonance. So most of the people working in these firms, they’re no different to journalists. They’re going to work, they’re doing their job and then they’re coming home. What happens is, the further the gap between what they’re told and what the firm says, especially what leaders say and what their experience is … if that gets too wide, then they’ll start to contact us. So really the leading indicator for us is when we start to get people we don’t know telling us things. There’s a range of ways you can do that. That means a couple of things, it means they’ve usually tried internally. They’ve tried with their immediate boss. They’ve tried with their top boss, maybe through a whistleblower centre. They might have gone to regulators. They might have gone to authorities, and the last one they usually go to are politicians.

We’re the last resort too. What it means is they’ve tried all the normal ways, it hasn’t worked and they’ve come to us as a sort of justice of last resort. You can see the volume every now and again just bursts out, and you know there’s something there.

Kate O’Rourke: So that idea of cognitive dissonance is something that is played to you when those people speak to you.

Edmund Tadros: Yes.

Kate O’Rourke: It’s the gap between what their –

Edmund Tadros: The people who complain are never the people you think. They’re usually the ones who are the most focused, rule followers. They see something that really … they’ve been told, “We do X, Y, and Z as a firm.” The leaders are saying that, their managers are saying that, you’re telling the clients that. What they see just gets on their goat.

Kate O’Rouke: Thank you. The follow up questions really about where do you think the foundations professional service firms are under the greatest pressure? Ilana spoke about some of that diversity in activities and the different services that are being provided now. So where do you think the foundations for professional services firms are under the greatest pressure? Where do you think those pressures on the firms are coming from?

Edmund Tadros: I think what’s happening now, if I take law firms because they’re the simplest. They now do consulting which I find very strange, and they do risk management. They go and hire former big four people to do a whole range of things. I always thought the strength of a law firm is everyone roughly understands what everyone else was doing. You might have different content knowledge, but you understand the process. You know what good legal advice looks like. You’re all serving, you’re all servants of the court. What you get at the big four, is they do so many things. Whatever the latest trend is, they’ll jump on it straight away. Within the firms, there’s so many different flavours of professionals. They don’t really understand what anyone else is doing.

I always just think if I look at the big stories that we’ve covered, there’s a risk appetite that’s really different. There’s a relationship that’s really different and most importantly, there’s regulation. So consultants were unregulated, they shouldn’t be, that’s a buyer’s market. They just do what they think is appropriate. Auditors are highly regulated, tax people, highly regulated. They’re very different and so I think internally, it’s like some are from Mars, some are from Venus, some are from Jupiter. They don’t talk to each other. When one section surprisingly does something, it’s usually the consultants who get the maddest, because they’re the relationship people.

Kate O’Rourke: That’s interesting.

Edmund Tadros: They don’t want to go and explain it to clients.

Kate O’Rourke: Right, because you were describing before, that a profile of people who complained were the rule followers.

Edmund Tadros: Yes.

Kate O’Rourke: So it’s the rule following consultants.

Edmund Tadros: Yes. The anger within the firms when these things happen, it’s sky high. We’re reporting it, so we’re agnostic. I’m quite empathetic to it. I’m sympathetic to you go to work and you’re doing your job. Then someone over there’s done something and you’re tarred with the same brush. It’s hard.

Kate O’Rourke: What I’m understanding, to the extent there’s that cognitive dissonance, it’s not between different activities within the firm. It’s what people are saying from an integrity perspective or hardwiring or a soft wiring. That’s the gap is what people are being told, their ways of working and what they’re seeing, as opposed to just having areas of work that are unfamiliar. That’s when the problems … yes but it’s interesting that it can be more pronounced in those firms. Would either of you like to respond?

Ilana Atlas: Well, I think the point is correct. When you have a diversity of different businesses within a partnership environment, it stresses that structure. I think there’s huge strengths in partnerships. I was part of one, and I just think the reliance on each other, the clarity about what you’re trying to achieve, they’re very strong entities. The challenge is very much, as Edmund’s talking about, when you diversify all the businesses, when you have people within the partnership subject to different regulatory regimes … which is obviously the case with auditors and non-audit services, it just creates quite a challenging dynamic. You do need to think about appropriate governance mechanisms for that type of environment.

Kate O’Rourke: I think that idea of where concerns come from, when there are issues, dissonance in behaviours or misconduct, we leave a question mark there … that idea of parliament being a last resort, you being a last resort is something that has been very apparent to us. I think we’re conscious of people coming to us as well as a regulator. I think you mentioned that as well. If we turn into when a firm has been under intensive scrutiny, or has had major issues associated with it, what does it look like to restore trust? It’s a hard road when that’s lost. I think we’ve talked about that in other sessions today. Do you have any thoughts about that road back from when trust is gone?

Edmund Tadros: I think in its own way, Peter obviously provided a best practice. It didn’t look like it at the time. But after they had leadership and everyone was linked in it, they brought new leadership in that was clean, that didn’t have any links to Australia. The first thing they did was get an external investigator to do something, law firm to look at it. Within a couple of months, they had their version of what happened, so they worked out what happened. Then from there, they worked out what their remediation plan was going to be and then they executed against it. If you think of it from when we did the first trench of email stories which was when it became big, to when they started doing the remediation at a large scale, it was about three months. In between, it’s a very unfair process I think.

So the new leader comes in and blasts away entire couple of levels of management. But you just had to start again. What happens if you don’t do that cleanly, you’re trying to change things before you know what the problem is. You’re putting the cart before the horse.

Kate O’Rourke: So that definition or telling the story about what happened warts and all.

Edmund Tadros: Yes and I think it’s very hard to prove to people you’re not going to do something. “We’re not going to do that behaviour anymore,” it’s very hard. It’s easy to say, “I’m going to do X and you can measure me. But I’m not going to do that thing I wasn’t meant to do in the first place.” How do you prove that?

Kate O’Rourke: The negative, yes.

Edmund Tadros: I don’t know how you prove that, yes.

Ilana Atlas: I’d like to comment on that. I think in relation to the missteps within firms, what we found I think is the vast majority in each of these firms are people who are outstandingly good at what they do. So I think for firms in this situation, it is a matter of focusing on those parts of the firm that are actually outstandingly good. Using those parts of the firm as role models, for actually the firm should be. I think it’s just important to get these things in perspective. The second is with clients, clients are your most important asset. I think if you can be upfront with clients, very clear, explain what happened. But also explain what you’re going to do about it, and actually tell clients how they can know that things have changed. Ultimately, that’s what matters to you, the relationship with your clients.

Then I think of course, having independent experts in is important. I think independence within the firm’s important. But I would say those two things are really paramount for firms.

Peter Achterstraat: To restore trust, we’ve got the two sides. We’ve got to make sure that our formal governance mechanisms are there and they’re working, that’s one. Secondly to make sure that the informal, as Ilana said, the cultural systems are there. If we talk at the first one, we all know the 10 items of good corporate governance. Conflict of interest policies, procurement policies et cetera, staff opinion surveys. We’ve got to A, make sure that they exist. This is not negotiable. Do they exist is the first thing? Secondly we’ve got to test that they’re working well. Let’s do a bit of a dry run. Is the procurement working, is the conflict of interest? Are we using the staff opinion survey to predict where there will be ethical gaps? Are we using those? So that’s one set, that’s restoring it purely on a clinical basis.

On the secondary point in relation to the softer, the genuine ethical culture, let’s ask ourselves are we making decisions based on what’s legal and I won’t get caught, versus what’s the right thing to do. Are we looking at just ticking the boxes, or are we asking generally, what’s going to add value. I think Kate, at the end of the day, it’s a question between short term and long term. Many times we think something is an appropriate decision in the short term. Beauty, if that’s going to solve that problem, that’ll bring a bit of revenue in, that’ll get the media … a number of things. Whereas in the long term, you in fact might be digging a hole for yourself. I think to restore trust, we’ve got to focus on the longer term.

Kate O’Rourke: I think that point you made earlier about a client’s wants versus a client’s interest is similar. It might not just be internally generated short-term opportunities, it might be even with respect to your clients as well.

Edmund Tadros: I think there’s lots of perverse incentives at the firms now, because they’re quite revenue driven. I think from about 2012 they became very revenue driven and consulting was responsible for that. Consulting is just a sales function, not regulated, you have to jump on the latest trend and be quite aggressive. What you’ve got at the firms, is there’s the intra competition. So the firms might know what to do, but they’ll look at what other sections of the firm are doing. Consulting’s a bit more glamorous. I think auditing is very interesting, but not everyone might think that. Consulting is a bit more glamourous, they’re a bit taller, a bit better looking, they come in the room, they’ve got better presentation.

Peter Achterstraat: Steady on.

Edmund Tadros: I think the bewildering thing from the [Fins ? 0:27:57.8] point of view is when you do cover these stories, I had this both with [Capium GMPWC ? 0:28:04.4] you look at the risks they were taking versus the return and whether it was necessary. It didn’t add up at all. You just think you didn’t need to do that, you probably would have won the work anyway in all the cases. So I don’t have an explanation for that, but it was people taking risks with a reputation and brand that they’re a larger part of, and with their partnership. Central command doesn’t know about it most of the time. I think that’s it, I think the front page sesh is a bit facetious. It’s more would you tell your client you did this? Would you go home and tell your spouse that, “At work today I did X, Y and Z.” Would they go, “Oh OK.” Or would they go, “Are you sure that’s a good idea?”

I think of it is if you have to ask a lot of people should I do this, you probably know the answer, right and wrong. I’ve seen too many firms with all of these rules, an architecture of ethics, and architecture of this. You sit there going, “I’m not sure if it’s that complicated. You’re all very, very smart people, you kind of should know what the right thing to do is and what not to do.” But I always bring it to the most basic level that I can write in a sentence that my mum could understand me.

Ilana Atlas: Can I just comment just on that? There is an accountability on clients as well, I think that’s important. For example, with audit fees, we really need to make sure we’re pretty clear about the cost of an audit. If a firm is cross-subsidising so that they can tender low on an audit fee, then clients really need to think hard about that. Also, audit rotation, tendering, there are some things that clients can do too I think, to take accountability in this debate. The other is just the importance of audit, obviously audits highly regulated. But as I said earlier, we are reliant on audit. We speak to our stakeholders and rely on the audit. It’s certainly in the client’s interest as well to make sure that audits are performed appropriately.

Peter Achterstraat: I think when Kate when Adam talks about [WIB ? 0:30:26.5], basically knows what’s right and wrong et cetera. When I had a role with the AICD, people would ring me with ethical problems. I got quite a lot of calls. Now basically, the people knew the answer when they rang me. They basically knew to do the right thing was X, Y, Z. They wanted someone to sort of say, “Well it’s OK if you nudge it a bit right.”

Kate O’Rourke: If you do A, B, C.

Peter Achterstraat: They knew the answer already. I think if you ask the question, why do good people make bad decisions, basically there’s a small minority who are doing it for financial gain or short term is very small. There’s others who make bad decisions because they just didn’t think. They just thought well this is what’s happening everywhere and they just didn’t think about it. They’re doing it too quickly. If they step back and take a little bit more time, I know it’s an easy thing to say, take a bit more time. But if they took a bit more time and weighed up all the issues, then they may well make a different decision. But I think basically people know what’s ethical and what’s not.

Kate O’Rourke: I think that was your point as well.

Edmund Tadros: One of the red flags is if you go to a firm, I’m thinking of one firm specifically here. I would go, “Look, I’ve heard X, Y, and Z.” I’d ring them up and send them a bunch of questions. If their first response is, “Oh everyone’s doing it,” first of all, I know I’ve got a story. But second of all, actually they’re probably not because I started going, “Well who?” “Well everyone.” “Do you have any proof of this?” “Well we think everyone’s doing it.” I don’t know if that’s a myopia or what’s going on there, but I take that as a guilty mind anyway.

Kate O’Rourke: We might now move to that question around regulation and accountability. I think Ilana you’ve spoken a little bit about how substantially different the firms have become, in terms of the diversity of services that they have and also, the quite different cultures. I think a few of you have touched on that, within different areas of work. So regardless of the kind of profile of the consultants, that idea of it being less regulated and revenue driven, versus some of the other lines. I think just picking up some of these questions that you’ve raised Ilana as well, is that we have in our professional services firms, rely very heavily on that idea of self-regulation. About being a professional and having standards in the professional accounting bodies or the law society or the other people.

So there are some standards, but it’s self-generated by that group of people and a lot of the discipline associated with it, is similarly done at the industry level. Layered on that, is this fact that for a lot of these firms, that they’re partnerships. That isn’t a governance model that changes decision making and accountability because it’s so dispersed. So we have got this history where I think for a long time, served us reasonably well. But some of the pressures on that have become pretty substantial. We can turn in a second to what might change. We’ve already heard from you, is there anything about either that idea of relying on professionalism or the structures?

Peter Achterstraat: I guess the only reason we’ve got regulation is because self-regulation’s not working. If everyone had a genuine ethical culture and totally transparent and put the public interest first, then there’d be hardly any need for a lot of regulation. But once the world gets more complicated and there is more incentives for people to be putting self-interest or client wishes ahead of the public interest, that’s when we do need the regulation.

Edmund Tadros: I think it’s a bit of a size thing. Law firms are all traditionally still much smaller partnerships. The feedback I get from most of the big four are around 500 plus partners, is unless you are in a management role or in an executive role, you’re like a senior employee. You don’t really have much say in how it runs day to day. So when they go to smaller firms, they get that back, so they feel how it was 10 or 15 years ago. I think it’s a size thing too. At a certain size you are an employee, but with a partner title. I think of places like [Extensia ? 0:34:51.2] which are company structures, everyone’s a managing director. When you interact with those people, everyone is very clear about who’s senior or not, but ultimately you’re all employees.

It’s a very different dynamic to partners. You have this feeling of ownership, but none of the control that would come with a traditional partnership when they were much smaller. That’s my only observation.

Kate O’Rouke: I think as well as size, the difference we see between legal and audit as examples, is also whether the requirement to belong to a professional body is mandatory or not, or whether there’s more than one. In some of the parliamentary hearings that ASIC’s been involved in, we’ve had that discussion around how much weight can you put on the professional accounting bodies in that case? In circumstances where there’s three of them, and you could even belong to none of them. So how much weight can –

Edmund Tadros: The ethics is set up by a fourth body. It’s this very thick, very complicated set of rules, so it makes it difficult.

Kate O’Rouke: Yes I think that idea of a consequence for lawyers, the weight of that disciplinary consequence is a little heavier I think. It doesn’t mean it doesn’t answer or pose some of the same questions we’re discussing. But I think that is a second differentiation in some respects. Thank you for questions starting to come through. I’ll just before we get to them, turn to this question about if the government’s consulting on regulatory frameworks and what they might change. We’ve already touched on some of them, but I might pass to you Ilana. About what you think the key elements of a regulatory framework, or the elements that should be taken into account should be?

Ilana Atlas: I think a challenge currently is just the regulatory regime. For lawyers, you’re an officer of the court, it’s much simpler. I think for the audit professionals, it’s quite difficult. An auditor as an individual is regulated, but the firm’s not. So I think there’s just a clean up that’s required, which isn’t a commentary really on the firms. I just think it’s a commentary on the complexity of how that profession has come to be governed, so I think there’s something there. I’ve always been an advocate for professional services providers to be able to regulate themselves, simply because of the obligations they owe to others. But I can see as for all the reasons that have been said today, perhaps we do need to think about what that might look like. I think independence, an independent board is very important. I think having independent directors who have clout is very important, and having clout in relation to the things that can go wrong.

For example, remuneration conflicts, client confidentiality. There are some things that an independent body can have some clout over. But I’m not an advocate for really hardwired regulation.

Edmund Tadros: May I ask, what do you think of the audit consulting gap? If your auditors are giving you non-audit services as well, is that a good or bad thing? Do you have a view on it?

Ilana Atlas: Providing non-audit services is again, highly regulated. So you know when your auditor is providing it when it’s disclosed, it’s in your annual report. So I don’t know that that’s a significant issue. The bigger question I think you’re asking is do I have a problem if my audit firm also provides others with non-audit services. There are pros and cons with that. There’s obviously a huge amount of expertise that the firms now have outside of the audit function, which you get the benefit of from your auditor. I can see there’s benefit of it, but I can see also that it needs effective governance that a client understands. So you can get as a client, security about the quality of the services.

Kate O’Rourke: The capability, the judgement and –

Ilana Atlas: Yes those three.

Kate O’Rourke: – that integrity. I think one of the questions we’ve been posed is how do you manage the competing priorities in professional services between the profit and then the increasingly less prioritised … I think by profit, I think they mean both consultancy and those lines, and then those ones that are less prioritised on professional standards. So it’s a little bit about parts of the firm, but also about drivers. I think your point around governance, we’ve seen when governance for partnerships is optional, it’s DIY, people do their own. We have seen real diversity in what those boards do and what responsibilities they have.

Edmund Tadros: I think the boards are a problem, because it’s a bunch of external non-partners trying to give advice to partners. At the big four, probably Peter we see as the strongest external board. One of the other firms did one the other day, it’s meant to provide advice. But it has the CEO and the head of risk on it as well, so it’s a body providing advice to itself. I just think clean it up, make them pseudo corporations however that works. Just give them the same standards as a large company, in terms of reporting and ASIC being in charge of them is probably the simplest way. You don’t want to trigger a capital gains thing, everyone will lose their minds. But if they’re just treated like that right and the ABC provides a pretty good model. They’ve got an independent board, independent chairman, it seems to work relatively well.

Kate O’Rourke: What’s interesting on this question, corporates have balance score cards. So they do not reward profit specifically. There is a balance between the different requirements to be successful, which includes the way you go about it. So again, I think this is done in all sorts of organisations successfully.

Peter Achterstraat: With the question it says the competing priority between profit and professional standards. I guess there might be a competing priority between short term profit and professional standards. But I think long term profit and reputational is totally in line with professional standards. I think that if you are focusing on the longer term, then you’ll do that by professional standards. It’s interesting, when I was in the audit office, I interviewed 100 leaders. Corporate leaders and professional service firms and asked them questions about what makes a good firm. I spoke to the premier, the governor, the prime minister and cabinet, all of the senior public servants. The chairs of major corporations and the CEOs, even the generals in the army and Neil Armstrong even.

Kate O’Rourke: Wow.

Peter Achterstraat: [Unintelligible 0:34:51.2] talk with Neil Armstrong. What came through loud and clear with those people, they said, “What makes a successful organisation is one where there’s trust,” as we’ve covered. I said, “Well that’s a nebulous term. What does it mean? How do you show this trust?” Quite a number of them said, “Well a good professional service or good organisation is one where medium level employees feel quite comfortable telling their boss bad news.” They feel comfortable. As soon as they’re in an organisations where they don’t feel comfortable telling the next level up bad news, that’s when you’ve got a bit of a problem. So we’ve all read the book, ‘The Fish Rots from the Head.’ So we’ve got to make sure that there’s a climate where people can tell the bad news without being reprimanded.

Kate O’Rourke: Thank you. I think when you come back to turning that into governance or corporate, that’s the behaviour or the soft wiring that Ilana was speaking about earlier. Do you have a view about regulatory frameworks rather than just practices?

Peter Achterstraat: Yes. Regulatory frameworks, I’ll talk generally and then I’ll come back to the corporate services. I was a bit concerned with all the red tape that local cafes have. Now this is very minor right, and a local café has up to 95 different pieces of regulation they have to adhere to. Fire regulation, food safety, everything. When I went in and talked to the café owners, I went around the state. They were saying, “All these regulations, look I’ve got to keep a record every day about the temperature of the fridge and this, that and the other so the food doesn’t go off. Look, I want to get my customers back, so I’m going to make jolly sure that everything in my place works well. All this extra stuff’s just rigmarole.”

There’s always a small percentage of cowboys that you do have to regulate. But most of them want to do the right thing, because otherwise their customers won’t come back. If you’re not going to have a cleanly place, they won’t come back. Coming back to your question what is good regulation, simple, certain and also balanced, so it doesn’t stifle innovation. We’ve all heard the expression that auditors live in glass houses, you’ve got to be careful. We’ve got to have all this governance. Well I say don’t brick in the glasshouse. What we’ve got to do is, we’ve just got to make sure that we do allow innovation. We don’t just manage everything by Excel spreadsheets. We’ve got to allow the regulations to allow that discretion. So that we can have innovation without people looking over their shoulder all the time, thinking I’m going to get in trouble if I take this risk.

Kate O’Rourke: I think we’ve just had a question proposed to us, I think you’ve answered it without reading it. It’s about how do the idea of new regulation or new controls fit with lowering regulatory burden … or inhibiting innovation is your point … and the analytical frameworks to balance these trade-offs. I think it does behove us to think about well of the ideas being put on the table, including by treasury, which one would be the simplest to administer? Not just administer from the regulator, but for the people who would be … if it’s a licence or if there’s rules around rotation or partners or tendering or whatever it might be. What’s the cost of that transition, what are the benefits? I think we’ve talked about the challenges of the firms.

Edmund Tadros: It would probably help to just have one federal, just one regulator as well. They have lots, state based for the partnerships, there’s tax … so if you just had one regulator, I think it would make life simpler for the firms as well. It does that thing of it’s less regulation, but just more coherent.

Kate O’Rourke: Yes I’m not sure we’re going to take on tax everybody. I’m not sure ATO wants to take on …

Edmund Tadros: [Unintelligible 0:45:55.1].

Kate O’Rourke: But I do take your point around the complexity of dealing with multiple regulators. We’re almost at time. I’m going to see if there’s anything … coming back to the theme of the conference. In terms of navigating change and having the support from professional, high integrity, good judgement, highly capable firms that can help companies and consumers and our market navigate all of these changes … is there anything when you look ahead to five or 10 years, how you’d describe the firms? What do you see, if that’s going to be a successful transition? Do you want to start Ed?

Edmund Tadros: I think now, I think of Instagram, all the ways. If firms have got to prove to their employees that they’re doing what they’re saying and if they don’t –

Kate O’Rourke: This is your dissonance point, yes.

Edmund Tadros: If it gets out, Aussie Corporate is really good but it’s a pain for journos because you sit there and go I have to follow that up now. But the truth will get out and especially if firms say something, there just can’t be a gap between what they’re saying and what’s happening internally. I think of it, I’m one of the kids at work, the journalists are all the kids. The kids will talk if the parents say something and it doesn’t happen.

Kate O’Rourke: OK, good tip.

Peter Achterstraat: I guess in five years time, I’d like to see a situation where people choose their professional services firm on the basis of their ethics and their integrity. That’s the first thing they choose them for, rather than necessarily on their technical skills. I’d also like to see, we all know the Edelman Trust results have come out. They show that the community’s trust parliament, in not-for-profits, in the media and corporate is going backwards, it’s falling. I’d like in five years when they do that Edelman Trust survey, that professional services firms in Australia has the highest rating in the world, in relation to other professional services sectors.

Kate O’Rourke: You’re allowing the other categories to come up as well, the journalists and the regulators.

Peter Achterstraat: Well I didn’t think there was –

Kate O’Rourke: The international comparison is welcome. Ilana, I’ll give you the final word.

Ilana Atlas: Thank you. I’d like to think that the firms themselves have come up with a governance model which gives us the best of a partnership model, together with the best of a corporate model. So that we don’t lose the strength of that partnership model. But I think it needs to be overlaid with much more effective governance.

Kate O’Rourke: Excellent. Well on that note we’ll call time, because we’ve hit the end of our time. So a very big thank you to our panel, very interesting. Thank you all very much again for attending this session. Next is drinks and dinner. Before you do, if you do have a moment if you can just jump on the app before giving us feedback on the session, we’d really appreciate it. If you are attending the dinner, it’s back upstairs on level five. I think the pre-dinner drinks are served from 5pm, so you’ve got a moment to get there. If there’s dietary requirements, then there’s a card system so please look out for that. But thank you again, really appreciate you coming and nice to see you here. Thanks.

Ilana Atlas: Thank you.

Gallery

Elective session C: Financial advice – preparing for the future

  • Leah Sciacca, SEL, Financial Advisers and Investment Management, ASIC
  • Daniel Shrimski, Managing Director, Asia Pacific, Vanguard Australia
  • Xavier O’Halloran, CEO, Super Consumers Australia
  • Marisa Broome, Managing Director, Wealthadvice

Full audio (MP3 20.1 MB)

Transcript

Leah Sciacca: All right. I think we’ve just clicked over 4 o’clock. So, in the interest of keeping us on time we will get started. I think some others will join us. We’ll keep the door open for a little bit but thank you for joining us for this panel session on financial advice preparing for the future. A few housekeeping items before we kick off. If you can just make sure your phones are on silent, please. Also, we have around 50 minutes for this session and, like the other sessions today, we do encourage you to send questions through. They’ll pop up on the screen here, and we’ll look to incorporate them as we go.

So, first off, let me introduce our panellists, who represent some of the key stakeholders in the financial advice landscape and are really well positioned to share their views on the future of it today. I’m joined by Daniel Shrimski, Managing Director of Vanguard Asia Pacific; Xavier O’Halloran, CEO of Super Consumers Australia, and, I learned from his bio, developer of an online chatbot to help younger people engage with their super.

Xavier O’Halloran: I need to update my bio. That was a while ago.

Leah Sciacca: And also Marisa Broome managing director of Wealthadvice, a boutique financial planning practice here in Sydney. So, I was just checking with Xavier and Marisa and Daniel. I think financial advice has come up in just about every session that we’ve had today, unexpectedly. I wasn’t expecting it anyway. But it’s great to round out the day, I think, with a focused session on it. So, just to set the scene a little bit, I think we can all agree financial advisers play a crucial role in supporting the financial well-being of Australian consumers. It comes up in the superannuation context as being particularly important as we have an ageing population making really critical financial decisions about their retirement. Various research over the years highlights that, in addition to financial outcome benefits that can flow from accessing advice, advised Australians demonstrate other benefits, such as confidence in financial decision-making, stronger financial literacy and peace of mind. There’s some research that Vanguard published in 2025. I think it was titled, “Don’t Ignore the Hidden Value of Your Financial Advice,” that goes to that point.

Consumers place a high degree of trust in financial advisers. They trust that their advisers will act in their best interest and provide good-quality financial advice that puts them in a better position. Unfortunately, there have been some recent examples where that trust has been misplaced, and concerning advice has resulted in consumer harm. I think it’s fair to say this is a sector where change is a bit of a feature and that includes a range of legislative reforms over the years and potentially some more on the cards for next year. The size of the sector has also changed and the composition and business models. No doubt you’ve heard from the sessions this morning AI is very much a topic of conversation in the financial advice landscape.

So, I will start with a broad question for each of our panellists. How do you feel about the current state of the industry? Do you still see it as being in a period of transition, or do you think it’s beginning to stabilise and improve? Marisa, you’re at the coal face, so I might start with you on that question.

Marisa Broome: Look, I think we’ve got all the pillars of what a profession should stand by. Despite the way that the standards were implemented when we saw them, we have standards for education, we have a code of ethics, we have an exam to enter the industry. I think that we are in a better position than we were before, and it was stuff that I’d been lobbying for since – I hate to say it, about 30 years. Despite the scandals, the quality of advice we’re seeing from holistic financial planners is absolutely outstanding. We’re still going to see sharks, and unfortunately, we’ve seen some of that, but I think we’re in a much better space. We just need to grow the numbers, and that’s a really big challenge.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. We’ll pick that up in the next set of questions. Xavier, what do you think?

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes, directionally, I think I agree. Like, obviously, there’s been a lot of standards and thought and effort put in by the industry to make this a professional sector in recent years. But I think, you know, events like Shield and First Guardian really highlight that it doesn’t need to be a huge number of players that are doing the wrong thing for the harm to be industrial scale, I guess is the way Sarah Quill would describe it. And, you know, that’s going to continue to damage the reputation of the sector until we can get on top of how to regulate that properly. I think to date, you know, you could probably characterise a lot of the consumer protections as being very focused on individual financial adviser responsibilities and licensees. But within that, we’ve seen some pretty rogue operators still that have caused harm at scale.

I think where we’re starting to shift to – and hopefully not shift back and maybe talk a bit about that with future reform proposals later – but I think where we are starting to shift to is a bit more consumer protection on the gatekeeper side, thinking about what superannuation funds can do to protect people because I think that they’re just in a much better position. So, I’m hopeful, but I think, yes, there’s obviously lots of work to be done to make this a safe market for consumers to engage in.

Leah Sciacca: Daniel, what are your views? Where are we at, you know, with the industry and what are consumers thinking? Or how are they?

Daniel Shrimski: Yes. Thanks, Leah. Great to be here. Great to see so many familiar faces. I mean, I would echo those comments. I think tremendous progress over the past, I’d say, five or 10 years, whether it be consumer protection, trust, I think professional standards, to your point, Marisa, I think they’ve all moved in the right direction. I mean, we certainly have real concerns still that there is a lot of work to do. There is this huge unmet need, obviously, in Australia that we all know about. Not all Australians need full-service financial advice but there is a lot of work to do in terms of meeting that need and meeting it in a way where we can give more access to Australians. Maybe it’s full-service financial advisers, but we can also give them other ways of accessing the guidance and advice that they need. So, I think there’s a lot of work to be done.

I think today, a lot of talk, obviously, around AI. I can already see an AI question up there. That didn’t take long. But I think, you know, we’re excited about it. We’re already starting to do some work with AI in terms of how Vanguard can play. It’s not Australia. It’s the enterprise, just to be clear, in terms of that work. But, I think, as has been mentioned, we need to move forward with caution. I think everyone in this room probably understands the risks and the fact that the fiduciary responsibility is very, very different. But the everyday Australian doesn’t understand that AI doesn’t need to act in the best interests of members or investors. So, I think we need to do a lot of work in terms of educating Australians as well.

Leah Sciacca: Yes, that’s fair. So, moving to access. I think you both mentioned access and affordability. So, in August the Assistant Treasurer, Dr Daniel Mulino, in his Press Club address, argued that consumers should not have to choose between access to advice and consumer protection. Marisa, is that realistic, or is there always a trade-off between making advice easier to access and making it safer?

Marisa Broome: There shouldn’t be a trade-off but there is because of our regulation in many cases. And one of the big announcements that Dr Mulino came out with was the new class of provider. You notice my language because it’s not advice. It’s about providing information. I’m really big on this. We’ve gone through huge hurdles to make advice professional and to now bring in something that is different. In the consumer mind, it might not be seen as any different. I think we need to be very conscious about the guardrails that are in place for those people that are going to be serviced by that new class. There’s no doubt there is a need for it.

We’ve got an enormous underservicing of advice information in the country and we’ve got people now retiring with enormous superannuation balances and often retiring before they wanted to and with debt and mortgages. So, we really do need to, you know, provide them more information and help them make some financial decisions and improve their not just financial literacy but financial capability. But I’m not sure that we’ve actually got the guardrails right and the language right about how you protect consumers in that.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. And Xavier – oh, it’s working now. Which Australians are currently least likely to receive quality advice, and what will happen if we don’t close that gap in the next decade?

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes, I think to widen this out a little bit – and sorry for anyone in the room that’s heard me use this piece of research in the past, but I think it’s really instructive and it helps you understand what the consumer need is. Because there’s the tendency in all these debates, I see it in pretty much every single advice debate, it will be prefaced with, “We’ve got 50 per cent less advisers than we had back in 2018. Cost of advice has gone up. People can’t access it and we need to address that by somehow getting more advisers in front of people.”

Stepping back from that for a second and asking consumers what they actually want, because we went out and did that a few years ago particularly focused on that over 45 cohort as they go into planning for retirement. We found, absolutely, there’s about 25 per cent of the population that want a professional to help them make those kinds of decisions. They skew higher wealth. They’re a bit more comfortable and engaged around financial issues and have, you know, higher degrees of literacy generally. So, for that cohort I think, there’s a, you know, an identified gap there that could be better met with, you know, a professional financial advice class that can look after their needs.

Then the next step down, we see around 37 per cent of the population that don’t trust advisers. They don’t want advice. They only trust themselves with their own money. They don’t skew in any particular demographic direction. They tend to pull on public sources of information that they can cobble together, things like the ASIC Money Smart website, different financial press, things like that to really inform themselves. And then we’ve got the biggest group, the 38 per cent, just completely disengaged with decision-making at all. They skew lower wealth too, so part of that might be rational. They just don’t have a lot of means to manage and so the realistic prospects for a large portion of that cohort, they’ll be largely relying on the age pension when they retire.

So, if you look at those kind of three groups of people, I think you say, “Yes, absolutely. We can do more to service that 25 per cent and make sure that they’ve got access to professionals that can help them out.” But we’re not doing a very good job for the other 75 per cent, those people in the middle. Obviously, with the advent of AI, I think that DIY class might find that that’s a place that they’re going increasingly, and the data seems to bear that out. I think it’s now probably the biggest channel that people are going to for financial guidance in Australia and around the world. But that final group, I think, are the ones that are hardest to crack, really, and I think that’s where we’ve got to think more about system design. Like, let’s not design a system that’s so complicated we need a professional to help us through it. Let’s actually design a system that works.

So there I’m talking about, are we performance testing retirement products? Currently, no. You know, do we have any kind of basic, simple offering or default that we might offer to retirees? Currently, no. Like, these are all things that we do when people are working, but we don’t offer to retirees when the decisions are actually harder. So, I think there’s a system design thing there that, if I was the government, I’d be focusing on that. It’s more people. It’s people who are in probably greater need instead of, you know, continually framing this debate around how we get more advisers into the market and service that 25 per cent that want to use them.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. So, it’s the 75 per cent and, and in particular, that –

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes.

Leah Sciacca: – 38 per cent cohort. So there’s often a lot of talk about the cost of accessing advice and consumers have a view in terms of the cost. But what about the cost of not accessing advice? Daniel, do we spend enough time talking about the cost of not accessing advice?

Daniel Shrimski: I think it’s a great question. I mean, I’d echo Xavier’s comments. I mean, complexity is definitely increasing if you think about more Australians getting into those retirement ages. Some of the tax changes we’ve had around superannuation, CGT. I think the intergenerational wealth transfer is going to create complexity. So, complexity is increasing. People need more support. Some of the research we’ve done, and you cited some of it there, Leah, but only 35 per cent of Australians feel very confident making financial decisions around their affairs. So, when you put that to one side and then you think about that 25 per cent that you mentioned, Xavier, financial advisers, like many organisations, we’ve done research on what is the alpha that advisers actually create? We believe it’s up to 300 basis points per annum if you have a financial adviser and that’s not necessarily one investment versus another. It’s more behavioural coaching, goals-based advice. Marisa, you know about this more than I do. It’s about managing tax affairs.

Leah Sciacca: The strategic components of the advice.

Daniel Shrimski: Yes, absolutely. The coaching as well. And so that’s for people – full-service financial advisers, but not everyone needs that. Not everyone has that complexity. Some people just need a nudge or what we would call personalised guidance. And you think of a 60-year-old who’s nearing retirement that has their whole portfolio in high-growth stocks. The ability to nudge them or to send them personalised guidance and say, “Do you understand – do you know the risk of diversification or the risk of not being diversified?” That can really direct them to behaviour that might help them longer term. Or a 40-year-old or 50-year-old that hasn’t contributed up to their superannuation concessional cap when we have the information that tells us they could. Again, being able to actually give them that nudge, again, would help them make a decision that would set them up for a better financial future.

So, yes, it’s the full-service financial advice, adviser’s alpha. It’s the nudges. It’s the personalised guidance that without that, there is a real cost in it. The difference is Australians aren’t set up for that best retirement that they’ve worked hard for. The other thing I would just say is cash. And I was talking to a gentleman out the side, Min from Monash. I mean, if you look at the financial assets that Australians hold, 24 per cent of them are in cash. Cash is an unproductive asset. If you look at the returns in equity markets over the past decade, Australia, 9 per cent or thereabouts. The US, more like 15 per cent. If you’ve been in cash, you’ve actually missed out. Not to say that’s going to repeat itself, but cash is an unproductive asset. And again, without that advice and guidance, it can lead you to not having an optimised portfolio.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. And on that last point, that’s not unique to Australia. I know there’s other international jurisdictions.

Daniel Shrimski: Yes. I mean, Japan’s at 40 or 50 per cent. They’ve been in an inflationary environment. I think the US is more at 5 to 10 per cent. So we’re in the middle, but I would say 24–25 per cent is still way too high.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. So, that’s a neat segue. I mean the financial advice sector, in my experience, has sort of been built on this concept of comprehensive advice, full financial plans. I think it was described in the earlier session. But are there other ways of providing advice that could help improve access and affordability? I think ASIC’s work in the past has suggested episodic advice, or piece-by-piece advice is something that, you know, consumers are attracted to. Marisa, what do you think?

Marisa Broome: Well, I offer episodic advice because I think it’s a really great way of capturing the younger generation. So, I do generational wealth for families, which again, is a difficult thing under our current code of ethics in the way that it’s worded, but I do look after my clients, their parents who are facing aged care challenges and their kids. And episodic advice very clearly fits into that space of helping the children make their core financial decisions. It’s very difficult to do, though. I’ve got to pretty much tell them what I’m not offering as an ongoing service. Then I’ve got to repeat that on a regular basis, and when they come back to me, I’ve got to collect a whole lot of more information again. So, the actual business model of a holistic, comprehensive financial planner has to be modified to do that. And it’s why so many financial planners are really investment advisers, because it’s just easier to offer that model when our services are in such demand.

You know, I could work 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and still not actually handle all the enquiries I’m getting at the moment. We are just so much in demand and we have to find other solutions to meet that. And episodic is one way of doing it. For me, it’s sensible because I can help the children make sensible financial decisions early that will set them up if they can’t get access to an adviser somewhere down the track.

Leah Sciacca: And that’s more based on where they’re at in their life stage or …?

Marisa Broome: Yes. There are certainly older clients that will come for the same thing. The older clients that are getting closer to retirement that just want to get their ducks in a row, for want of a better expression. Then you’ve got to, again, have a whole lot of disclaimers about what the risks are if you go ahead and implement things without us being involved. But, you know, we are licensed to give financial product advice, and 90 per cent of what I do is actually not linked to a product. Therefore, the advice scope is quite broad.

It can be as simple as simplifying their bank accounts because they’ve, they’ve got 30, and you’ve got to get them down to something that’s easy. It’s linked to product, but it’s actually far more strategic than that about getting their lives to be simpler. Often within a couple, they’ve never mixed their money and for the first time in retirement, they might actually start, you know, mixing and making some financial decisions together. Apart from a house, they don’t might not have anything else that’s combined. So there’s sort of those strategic decisions to make as well.

Daniel Shrimski: Yes.

Leah Sciacca: Mm. So, we have touched on already at the forum today, innovation in the advice space. And so I’m interested from the panellists’ perspective, what new advice models are you seeing emerge and which developments make you most excited or most concerned? Daniel, we might start with you.

Daniel Shrimski: I mean, the first thing I’d say is it’s a bit of a continuum, isn’t it? I mean, the one thing that I think we’re seeing more of, and I think it’s great for the industry, is products that have that, sort of, embedded advice solution within them, whether it be target date funds, diversified funds. I mean, that’s organisations’ best thinking in terms of how to construct a portfolio. It makes it easy for consumers. I wouldn’t say that’s new, but I think it’s something that’s certainly gaining traction. I mean, then obviously the continuum goes all the way to full-service financial advice. I think, you know, a couple of things that we’re keeping our eye on, one would be this targeted support model in the UK.

Again, I’m just learning about it, but it sits in between sort of general guidance and personalised advice. It’s a model where organisations can provide a recommendation related to an actionable solution. It’s actually a small questionnaire that consumers fill out and, based on the cohort, they create an actionable solution that is then delivered to the individual. So, they answer a few basic questions. It might end up that off the back of those questions, it’s found that they have $10,000 sitting in a bank account that could be put to better use. Based on that cohort, there’s a recommendation, and it’s delivered at scale, but to the individual. We think that’s really interesting. You know, and again, it’s a different licensing regime, but it’s a much lower hurdle.

The one that probably – just to the other part of your question, what we’re concerned about, I guess it’s advice-related, and it does relate to investors essentially designing an AI agent to go and transact and do things on their behalf. They go to sleep at night. Maybe they’re trading in a different market. The AI agent is given certain guardrails. Maybe they’re given a little bit of discretion. Wake up in the morning and the portfolio’s rebalanced and different things are done. I mean, there is huge risk to that around bad trades, bad data. You can imagine. So, just given the lack of governance and regulation, that’s something we’re watching, concerned about. I’d say we’re not sort of seeing it done en mass, but it’s something that we’re certainly keeping an eye on.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. Here in Australia or internationally?

Daniel Shrimski: Sporadic. No, internationally.

Leah Sciacca: Yes.

Daniel Shrimski: Internationally.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. No, that’s helpful. Thanks, Daniel. What about you, Marisa? What are you seeing, hearing about?

Marisa Broome: Look, I’m having most new clients that are coming to us are coming with their AI generated –

Leah Sciacca: OK.

Marisa Broome: – financial piece of advice.

Leah Sciacca: Yes.

Marisa Broome: Most of it is horrendously out of date and out of touch and wrong.

Leah Sciacca: OK.

Marisa Broome: The tax calculations in it are horrendous. Give an example. Someone came with some aged care advice that was generated by AI that said the tax consequences would be about $3,000, and our accountant worked out it’d be about $375,000.

Leah Sciacca: Yes.

Marisa Broome: Big difference in – just didn’t pick up one of the nuances. And that’s advice that’s given when people are stressed and it’s urgent. So, when you have big errors like that in it, it can be really concerning. At the same time we are a country not just of low financial literacy, but low financial capability. So not only do we not understand the jargon we talk about as a financial services ecosystem, but we can’t make decisions around it based on that jargon. And I’m really concerned that we’re not doing enough in that space. I know we’ve got Money Smart, and I know there’s a lot of great research, and a lot of the asset managers are doing good stuff, and Xavier’s doing good stuff in that area, but we are still not doing enough to build financial capability in this country.

Leah Sciacca: Yes.

Marisa Broome: So, I’m worried about that.

Leah Sciacca: And just out of interest, your client that hit up ChatGPT or –

Marisa Broome: Yes.

Leah Sciacca: – similar in a so they’re an ongoing client of yours or was it a new one?

Marisa Broome: Those were a one-off client –

Leah Sciacca: Yes, OK.

Marisa Broome: – coming to me in emergency because I’d helped one of their friends into aged care. They came thinking they were –

Leah Sciacca: Had done their research –

Marisa Broome: – fully prepared to make the decision, and they’d done all the research, and I was just there to verify it, and they really wanted to just buy a couple of hours of my time.

Leah Sciacca: Yes.

Marisa Broome: And I, you know, straight away –

Leah Sciacca: It was money well spent on their part.

Marisa Broome: Yes. Yes. Well, we actually had to go through a comprehensive advice model for them. Yes.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. OK. And Xavier, we’re talking a lot about AI, and we’ve heard some examples, including that one. So, for consumers that are engaging with those tools, either for help or information or to answer a question how do they need to be supported to make sure they’re making good decisions?

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes. So, I mean, it’s hard to give a definitive answer because the technology keeps changing at the moment. Like, I think it was only a year ago, if you were using a kind of simple inference model, it can’t count, which is kind of a problem if you were trying to get financial advice from it. That’s obviously changing. It’s getting better at, at more things, and I think the potential is obviously really interesting there. But the thing that kind of concerns me – and let me say, like, I’m not as sceptical on this as most, and particularly most in the consumer sector as well. Like, I maybe I should preface with a positive. Like, when I use it you know, it can have good outcomes, but I’m cognisant that, you know, I have a background and understanding and know how to query and use it properly. I see my parents using it for health advice, and, you know, they get some pretty wacky answers at times.

So, it’s obviously – there’s a whole bunch of consumer understanding of how to use the technology properly, you know, making sure you’re using a high inference level. If it’s, you know, at a lower level, you’re probably going to get pretty dumb answers. I think pretty much everything in superannuation is going to be at that more complex level. It’s going to need it. I mean, there’s a real spectrum. I used it, and I think this is the common question. It certainly comes through in our research. Like, the most common question people want to know is, “How much do I need to retire?” And so, the Actuaries Institute put out a great piece of research unpacking that. It was yesterday, actually. So, I encourage people to go and read that where they tested a bunch of models, just the baseline model against that question, and found a real spectrum of results. Maybe because Grok was one of the models they looked at but, you know, they found that it would sometimes miss out on some information or it’d lead to product advice, which is, you know, problematic, I guess, in terms of the current regulatory regime and the way it’s set up. But they did also find plenty of examples where it gave pretty good advice.

And when I was using it the other day, it had everything on the spectrum of, you know, using the retirement savings targets that we put out as an organisation, right through to some pretty crude rules of thumb around, you know, you should just have 25 times whatever your current salary is, which would lead to massive oversaving for anyone that doesn’t know. It didn’t take account of the age pension, didn’t take account of home ownership. Like, a completely wild – like, I’m definitely not on track under that one. So, yes, there’s lots to figure out there. How to regulate it, I think, is the most kind of interesting question to make sure it actually delivers good outcomes.

Because I think, at the moment, because it is an early-stage technology we don’t know. Like, we haven’t really tested the law around it as much. There was a reference this morning around how the state of California is taking OpenAI to court to test out some of their consumer protection law in relation to the guidance that it’s been giving. I think that’s going to be interesting to unpack as it evolves because I think it is giving financial advice at the moment. But if I’m to focus on the positive, like, how well adapted is the regulatory regime at the moment to AI? Like, it was set up to manage conflicts in the advice industry. At the moment, a lot of the AI models don’t have those conflicts baked into them. That’s not to say they won’t. Like, if we look at the kind of history of similar technologies, like search engines, for example. The kind of gaming and conflicts that were created there led to a pretty crappy experience at the end of the day. I think there’s a high risk that AI could go in a similar direction if we’re not thinking about how to guide it on a better path and making sure it’s continuing to deliver high-quality, independent information.

There’s things we can do without changing laws on that as well. Like, it’s obviously about what it feeds on and the information that it’s drawing on and making sure that all those good, independent sources of information are getting priority. Like, obviously, you know, APRA data on the performance of different investment options and fees. A really important data source. Like, you want to make sure that it’s surfacing that ahead of, say, an advertisement that it saw somewhere else or what some influencer thought was a really good product or some lead generator. So, I think we need to be smart. I think regulators have got their work cut out for them, thinking about how to be smart and be a bit more forward-focused in addressing these risks that are emerging from the technology.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. And I think at one of the sessions this morning, there’s sort of – in addition to financial literacy, there’s a role for digital literacy as well for those people engaging with the tools to sort of, yes, have a cautious –

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes. It’s part of it. I mean, I wouldn’t leave it out, but I would also say, you know, it’s probably easier to make sure, you know – we’re probably going to – we’ve got four major leading edge models at the moment. It’s a lot easier to make sure they’re doing the right thing and keeping a firm eye on them than the billions of people in the world and trying to teach every single one how to be this, like, perfect prompting agent for an AI model. Like, that’s just not realistic, I don’t think. So, you know, keep fighting the good fight on financial literacy. Like, we still do it as a consumer organisation because we think it’s, like, important to get those messages out there, but it is a minority solution to this problem.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. Yes. And while we’re with you, Xavier, you mentioned the complexity and I think Marisa touched on it as well, of the regime and, you know, just the financial framework, superannuation, tax, all of those things. And from a financial adviser perspective, I know there’s a few in the room. We often hear as the regulator that it is complex for them as practitioners as well and a role largely built around compliance. So, what would an advice system built around consumer comprehension look like if we were doing this purely for the consumer?

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes. So, I think it’s the stuff I alluded to at the start. I think it’s about design of the system. Like, the complexity is driven by things like our taxation system is pretty complicated at the retirement phase. Like, other countries do it a lot simpler. It’s kind of silly the way we do it to be honest. The product offerings are, are complicated. I mean, we consistently ask in our nat rep survey, you know, how people assess complexity in different parts of the market, and it’s always an overwhelming majority. It wouldn’t surprise anyone in this room that they find retirement planning just far too complex. So, I think we could, as we’ve done – like, superannuation, which is, you know, the main reason why you get advice, was founded on the idea that people can’t navigate the complexity of saving adequately for retirement. So, we built a default system. Then we just seem to, like, forget that lesson at retirement and go, “Do whatever you want. Here’s your money.” That’s silly. Yes, we could do a lot more on the design side to deal with that complexity.

Leah Sciacca: Make it simpler.

Xavier O’Halloran: Rather than, you know, building in all these different measures on top, like financial literacy and guidance and new advisers and existing advisers and making sure they’re professional. Like, I would start at the system if I, you know, was going to prioritise where you can have most bang for buck as a government or a regulator or a consumer advocacy body, it’d be making sure the system design is simple.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. And Marisa, what’s your take on this? You love the compliance elements of the role?

Marisa Broome: Oh, I just love the compliance. And the reg guides are just so inviting to go through step by step to produce advice. Sorry there. Look, to be honest with you, AI’s been wonderful in my practice. It’s been absolutely a game changer. I, you know, meet with a client with my AI agent sitting in there, it takes all my notes, it helps produce the follow-up, it throws things in my diary, it makes my statements of advice still compliant and you know, hopefully more readable. But really, it’s actually about my relationship and the summary that I can put together and all those sorts of things that make advice something that someone will follow. You know, it’s no point giving them an 80-page brief. I’m better off giving them a one-page and the legislation doesn’t allow me to give one-page. It also means, as I said earlier, we are licensed under Chapter 7 for financial product advice, and that’s a tiny – that’s an outcome. That’s actually not, you know, the strategy and the, and the main reason people seek advice in the first place. So, there’s probably two things there, get rid of Chapter 7 and covering financial planners and, you know, make sure that the adviser does something that’s memorable for the client.

Leah Sciacca: And so in your experience, Marisa, financial advisers are adopting AI and other technologies in their back office to make things more efficient. Does that enable them to see more clients or just spend more time with their clients?

Marisa Broome: For me personally, it takes away the worry that I’m not being compliant in every meeting I’m having with a client because it’s actually picking up if I haven’t talked about a specific issue, and it will then put it in the follow-up email to make sure I’ve covered off on things. And it just covers bases. So, for me, it takes away the compliance concern in the actual time when I’ve got the client so I can spend more time with the box of tissues. Because, really, it’s the human touch that they’re coming to see me for, and they are paying a premium for it because it is expensive to run my business. And, you know, there is demand for my services, and so I’m not wanting to gouge people, but it is, you know, an opportunity after years of struggling that we actually do have viable businesses now. So, you know, there’s a bit of a balance here. I’m not necessarily seeing more people, but I think I’m spending quality time with them. I’m spending more time eyeballing clients.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. No, that’s great. So, Daniel, if we were designing Australia’s retirement system from scratch today would we build it around financial advice the way that it is sort of now, or would we do something totally different?

Daniel Shrimski: I don’t know about totally different. I mean, I think we’d design a – I think we’d probably design a layered system where everyone could access the guidance they needed, the education they needed, the digital support they needed. I mean, not to say full-service financial advice is not important. It will always be important. I think everyone needs something different, though. Everyone has different needs in terms of the level of support they need. I think if we were designing a system from scratch, one of the things that I think we’d do – and you touched on it earlier, Xavier, we need a system where more Australians are engaged. I think it’s one of the biggest issues we have, and we’ve always talked about it.

I’m not sure that we’re making the progress we need to, but Alex talked about it in the session earlier. We’re going to have the second-largest retirement system in the world by the end of the decade. We’ve got the fourth-largest today. We are so lucky for that, but you can have the best system in the world. If you don’t have an engaged population, I think you can lose some of the advantages, and you can find yourselves in a position where Australians aren’t optimised in terms of their financial future. So, I think complexity was just talked about and I agree entirely. If you started something from scratch, you’d reduce the complexity, you’d probably increase the literacy and understanding that Australians have of the system, and you’d actually get greater engagement in the middle.

I think, you know, one of the things that absolutely baffles me, and it’s something that I think we take for granted, but the data shows that 60 per cent of Australians don’t know when they can access their superannuation. So if you don’t know when you can access your superannuation, how do you actually plan for retirement? And if you’re not planning for retirement, how do you have a financial future that, that you’ve worked hard for? And again, some of the basics, I think there’s some real work we can do, reduce complexity, increase literacy, and hopefully you get a more engaged population that leads to better results. So, that’s what I think we’d focus on, or I think we would hope to focus on if we were starting from scratch.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. And Xavier, you know, your chatbot. Getting the younger generation. Is that part of it? Do you, do you agree with, with Daniel’s comment?

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes. So I think, I mean, it’s obviously all the system levels after that I said before, but in terms of the advice aspect, I think, like, where we’ve gone wrong is we haven’t really had much of an idea of what the outcome is that we’re driving towards. And this is probably a problem in every policy debate because, you know, those that have an interest in a particular scenario playing out that are often the loudest voices. And I would say, you know, with respect to everyone who’s a financial adviser in the room, that it’s been a noisy cohort. And I think a lot of the solutions around retirement planning have been pushed by what the needs of the superannuation industry are and what the needs of the advisers are. And there’s been less of a thought about, well, what do consumers actually want? That’s why I framed, you know, the whole debate around that piece of research upfront because we know what consumers actually want.

And, you know, on the advice side, I think the other, the other part of where we’ve gone wrong is we’ve kind of worked within the existing conflicted models and tried to manage conflicts and make sure that we can kind of give some level of quality advice despite these conflicts. I think we’re at risk of going even further down that path with some of the reforms that are on the table at the moment, you know? A new class of adviser and superannuation funds having a bigger role in delivering advice with a kind of lower-trained person that they’re going to talk to. They’re obviously not going to get told some basic things like, “Actually, the performance of these options at this fund are not very good.”

And we measured that. Like, we looked at the retirement products. We, you know, looked at what a typical retiree with a typical balance invested in the range. You know, we looked at all the different kind of growth splits in those ranges of retirement products and ran them through the simulations and found out that there was a range of about $200,000 in difference in retirement outcome between some of the worst-performing products and best-performing products within the same growth asset range. That’s a huge difference for someone. And I just think we’re, you know, blasting right past that by focusing on superannuation funds delivering more advice and how to make it easier for them without doing anything to counterbalance that. Like, we’ve got an ATO tool that compares my super products. There’s no retirement products on there. What are we doing? So yes, plenty of opportunities to get better quality independent guidance and advice in front of people and we’re at risk of not doing any of those right now, I think.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. Quite a few questions coming through the chat. We can only see one at a time but around AI and advice, one of the questions, “So many people would benefit from advice. We accept some human error by advisers. Are we willing to accept risk of coding error if the benefit is good, accessible, and affordable digital advice provided to tens of thousands at scale?” Who’d like to take that one? Any takers?

Xavier O’Halloran: I mean, I can try.

Daniel Shrimski: Feels like it’s in your space.

Xavier O’Halloran: Yes, yes.

Marisa Broome: Well, you’re the one with the chatbot. The rest of us aren’t good at tech.

Xavier O’Halloran: So I think – yes, I think that kind of comparison between what’s currently being delivered by advice models and what AI is delivering, I think, is a good one because I think we are at risk of being, you know, kind of focusing just on the downside all the time. And I would say that’s for both, you know, focusing purely on the bad and, you know, Shield and First Guardian versus the good advice that’s being delivered and focusing on, you know, the dumb guidance that an AI model gave Marisa’s client equally. We’ve got to weigh it up against the positive outcomes. Like, let’s be real, it’s, you know, it’s something that is on demand 24/7 that’s in your pocket that costs you very little, if anything, at the moment. That’s going to open up advice to a whole range of people that would never have darkened the door of a financial adviser. So, I still think the focus and emphasis needs to be on how to make sure it doesn’t have those errors in it. Like, I’m not just like, “Yes, let it rip. Like, it’s better than the status quo.”

And I don’t think anyone is really properly engaged in thinking about that at the moment. Like, we’re not testing the consumer protections around AI at the moment in Australia, and I think we should be. We should be thinking about, you know, regulating the models to make sure that they’re delivering good outcomes to consumers and all the ways that we can help feed it better data. Like, as a simple example, I’m part of an RG 97 review, which is this regulatory guidance that ASIC has around disclosure of fees and costs. What’s really interesting when we’ve been doing some preliminary work looking at the information coming out of the AI models is it seems to draw heavily on what’s in product disclosure statements, which makes sense because they’re everywhere and they’re long. It’s a big source of information. That’s the kind of thing AI will feed on and be good at kind of spitting out to people. I think there’s an opportunity there.

We’ve got this regulatory architecture based around disclosure, which, let’s face it, has never really worked because no one reads the stuff. But now we’ve got these AI agents and LLMs that are capable of reading and synthesising and making it simple for people. I think we’re missing a trick if we’re not thinking about how those disclosure documents kind of talk to machines as much as they talk to humans and making sure that the information in there is really calibrated to delivering good information for the machine to read so that it can simply spit it out to us and help us make better decisions too.

Daniel Shrimski: Maybe just one very, very small add. I just think human at the helm, human in the loop is going to continue to be important. I don’t know exactly where we get to, but I think human judgement is going to be critical. When, if there’s a coding error again, maybe you can’t see it, but people using some basis of judgment and understanding what they’re doing and not just directly taking whatever the AI is giving them and acting on it, I think easier said than done. Again, I think it was a really good question, but human involvement’s going to be important.

Leah Sciacca: As we saw in Marisa’s example.

Daniel Shrimski: Yes, exactly.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. So, is there any particular type of advice or type of scenario, Daniel, that you think that’s where we still need human judgement?

Daniel Shrimski: Yes, for sure.

Leah Sciacca: Or, the converse, like, types of advice that is less likely?

Daniel Shrimski: For sure. I mean, I think AI is going to be – is unbelievable and will continue to be unbelievable in terms of analysing portfolios, risk tolerances, investment horizons. It will do the analysis, the optimisation, all those kinds of things. I think where there are trade-offs to be made, where competing priorities exist, where there’s something emotional in there, maybe it’s a family dynamic, the AI can’t solve for those things. You need the human judgement. So I think, you know, human judgment where it’s a consequential decision, where it’s something that’s not reversible, maybe it relates to retirement or intergenerational wealth transfer, I think human judgement’s going to always be important.

Leah Sciacca: Yes. Marisa, you leaned forward.

Marisa Broome: Oh, look, I just think that – I went back to the box of tissues again. I think that there are a whole lot of decisions that sometimes someone just wants a hand held to help them get over the hurdle, and that might be episodically, it might be a long-term advice relationship. It’s just sometimes they need something different to get them to make a financial decision. And it’s a lot to do with – we’ve had a default system all the way through to their accumulating wealth. We don’t give them a default system to then retire with. So who’s going to help them get over the hurdle? And sometimes there’s a level of distrust with a machine as much as there is distrust with an adviser.

Leah Sciacca: Yes, and it’s the peace of mind as well.

Marisa Broome: That’s right.

Leah Sciacca: Like, we spoke about that at the outset, the value of, you know, human saying.

Marisa Broome: Can you sleep at night?

Leah Sciacca: Yes, that’s right.

Marisa Broome: Yes.

Leah Sciacca: We have another question. “Who’s likely to successfully roll out digital or robo advice? So, these are incumbent advice firms, banks, super funds, tech platforms, others.”

Marisa Broome: Yes, yes, yes and yes.

Daniel Shrimski: Yes. I was going to say all the above. Yes. I mean, one, one thing I think’s important and something we’ve advocated hard for, when we talk about advice and reform, we often talk about superannuation. And certainly we all know $4.5 trillion in retirement funds, one of the best systems in the world, but I think whole-of-wealth advice is going to be increasingly important. Obviously, you’re providing that, Marisa, but as I think of digital advice and some of the things that reform is talking about, more money, I think, is going to flow outside of super, intergenerational wealth transfer. If tax concessions change in super, which they have, and if they continue to change, more will flow potentially outside of super. So, I just hope that, as we talk about these things, it’s more whole-of-wealth because I think to give someone, you know, the right advice, I think you need to factor in all of those elements of one’s wealth.

Xavier O’Halloran: I’ll take the counterpoint because, like, I see all these groups, like, incumbent advice firms, I mean, some will have degrees of independence, banks? Conflicted. Super funds? Conflicted. Tech platforms? Conflicted. I like, “other,” Ri, so – which I think is make – well, I think there’s the kind of accountability on tech platforms that I talked about before to make sure they don’t go down the same path that we saw with SEO, where you end up with an institutified, conflicted service offering that no one really likes anymore. But I would also say I think there’s a role for government in this as well. We’ve already got things like Money Smart. I think, you know, you’re seeing it in your own data with Money Smart. I think all websites are experiencing this. Web traffic is going down, but you’re seeing Money Smart information surfaced in AI, so clearly, you know, it’s drawing from that.

That’s great, in a way. Like, you don’t have a business model that you’re trying to make money out of this thing from, which is the hard thing everyone’s trying to figure out at the moment. So, I would say, you know, again, good quality independent information. I think the Government’s well placed to deliver that. Like, they are responsible for this superannuation system that needs so much advice around it. I think they’ve got a responsibility to make sure there’s good quality information out there feeding into these tools or that they’re even hosting curated ones on things like Money Smart because that is where people want to go. They want that interactive conversation to figure out the solutions for them. So, yes, ASIC’s got an opportunity to be at the front of this big wave of AI. I would hate to see them kind of miss the opportunity and see the conflicted models take over as we’ve seen throughout basically everything in history. Like, it’s a, it’s an opportunity to reverse that for once.

Leah Sciacca: Thanks, Xavier. We are almost out of time. I have one final question for each of our panellists. This is the future of financial advice or preparing for the future. So, “What does the advice sector look like five years from now? What’s changed from where we are today?” I’ll start with you, Marisa.

Marisa Broome: More advisers, and to Daniel’s point, looking at the holistic wealth of a client rather than just super –

Leah Sciacca: More human advisers?

Marisa Broome: More human advisers but more integrated advice processes. It’s the journey of information from day one all the way through to comprehensive advice. I think that there’ll be advice businesses that’ll actually take people through that whole journey.

Leah Sciacca: And Xavier?

Xavier O’Halloran: I think it’s those three cohorts of consumers I talked about at the start and making sure that each of them have a solution that’s right for them. So, I think more work to be done on system design to make it simpler for those that don’t engage, better independent guidance for those in the middle that want to do it themselves, and a professionalised advice industry for the 25 per cent that want a professional to help them out.

Daniel Shrimski: Yes. And I just, I think, totally agree with all of that. More personalisation, more tech-enabled, more accessibility, I think probably becomes less episodic, I think, and just more a continuous cycle. You access advice when you need it in the way in which you think you need it, and that’s across all – you know, it’s the whole continuum that becomes relevant, so.

Leah Sciacca: That’s where we’re at.

Daniel Shrimski: Looking forward to it.

Leah Sciacca: Well, more change ahead for the sector. It is a sector that has undergone significant change and that looks likely to continue. Can I please ask you to join me in thanking our panellists, Marisa, Xavier and Daniel for sharing their insights. [Applause] Please don’t forget to rate the session in the app. It helps the forum team plan for next year. And final message from me, for those attending the dinner, please head upstairs to level five for pre-dinner drinks at 5:00 p.m., 10 minutes from now. If you have dietary requirements, please collect your card from the table. Thanks so much, everyone.

Daniel Shrimski: Thanks so much, Leah.

Leah Sciacca: Thank you.

Daniel Shrimski: That was great.

Gallery

ASIC Annual Dinner

  • Alastair Campbell, Writer, Podcaster, Communicator, Strategist
 

Annual Forum 2026: Day 1 gallery

Opening address and Keynote

Plenary session 1: State of the Economy – the waves of change

Plenary session 2: The human face of global disruption

Plenary session 3: Unlocking responsible innovation

Plenary session 4: The future shape of markets

Elective session A: The role of codes in improving consumer protection

Elective session B: Professional services: building strong foundations

Elective session C: Financial advice – preparing for the future

Annual Forum 2026: Day 2 program

Session Related links

Virtual Keynote + Q&A by Martin Wolf CBE, Chief Economics Commentator,
Financial Times London

Full audio (MP3 13.9 MB)

Transcript

Martin Wolf: Good morning to you. I’m very pleased to be with you. I’m not here for very long so I’m going to get going at once. I have a very short presentation, 20 minutes, to cover the world economy and when I’ve done that I think we’re going to have an opportunity for questions. So let’s go.

OK, I believe you should be able to see this. So, staying ahead of the next wave: that’s what I was told to talk about. I’m going to start with a quotation, it’s a very well-known quotation from, interestingly, an Italian Marxist who was killed by Mussolini about a century ago. But I think he was discussing the 1920s which seems very apposite because 100 years ago the world was profoundly changing and, in my view, the world is profoundly changing again. So the old world is dying and the new world struggles to be born, and we’re in this transition period of very high uncertainty about what follows.

So what I’m going to cover in my 20 minutes, are basically two things: the poly-crisis it’s sometimes called, the interlocking stressors and chaos of today; and then I’m going to talk about the dynamics of the economy because along with the crisis there are also some fascinating dynamics in our system on multiple dimensions which I’ll come to. And then I’ll have a very brief, very brief conclusion.

So, let’s start with the poly-crisis. There are a number of aspects and so I think I’ve got six, and they interlock, but let’s start with geopolitics. First, and I think crucially, we are in the midst of, and in fact we have been in now for about 40 years a shift in the balance of power away from the West which Europe and its offshoots as it were, has dominated the world for the last several centuries. And that period is clearly and unambiguously ending with most of the shift being to Asia, east and south. We see the rise of nationalist populism worldwide, the combination of the two, it’s quite complicated, we won’t have time to discuss in detail, I think you’ve got some of that going on in Australia itself right now. We have, are seeing an undermining of the liberal international order on multiple dimensions with many of its core institutions either dysfunctional, almost completely like the WTO and others like the IMF struggling and the climate discussions similarly struggling to gain purchase on the world.

And, so what we see, the breakdown of the [Kige? 00:03:09] and the West alliance, the malfunctioning, the failure of the functioning of international institutions as I mentioned, and inability to sustain international agreements, and I’ve given you already the example on climate. And we have lost also, we have lost our ability to avoid major conflicts. We have two very significant wars, Ukraine/Russia and US/Israel/Iran going on right now, which I am going to come to.

The second aspect of the poly-crisis is deglobalisation. And here this is a question mark because we are in a period of stress and tension, the tariff war is an obvious example of Donald Trump which represented a comprehensive assault on the principles of the trading system in every way that the US itself created.

I’ve just got time to show you one chart; this shows the ratio of the trade in goods to world GDP. It goes back to 1820, it shows two periods of globalisation, roughly from 1830 to 1900 when world trade grew almost three times as fast as world output. There was then a crash and it basically reversed all that by the end of the second world war. Since then, we’ve seen the biggest globalisation in world history, and this is just one measure. World trade has increased five times faster than world GDP. There were two great upswings; the reconstruction as it were of the Western system after the war and then even more dramatically, the great globalisation of the period up to 2010, roughly 30 years, the opening of China, the opening of the world economy when trade doubled again.

Since the financial crisis, it stabilised and been falling but it hasn’t collapsed. The crucial point to note is trade is extraordinarily high relative to world GDP, it collapses when politics fails; that’s what happened in the inter-war period. And so there’s a big question of what would happen if the trade wars were to spread and we began to see a real collapse of world trade because it has such a long way to fall.

The second thing, feature of our world economy is the extraordinarily high levels of debt. And here I’m just going to focus on public debt, government debt, because I don’t have time for more. Again, I like these very long periods, graphs, graphics. This shows the public debt to GDP, general government debt to GDP of the developed countries, the advanced countries in dark blue, and the emerging economies in light blue. And the key point to note is that both are at all-time highs, pretty close to all-time highs. And remarkably, despite what was basically peace time, the ratio for the developed countries, the advanced countries, is now basically as high as it was at the end of the second world war even though this was an era of peace. And much of that, half of that increase has just been since the financial crisis in 2007. The increase from where it was in the late ‘70s, early ‘80s, well basically the ‘70s, early ‘80s, half that increase was just in the last 20 years and it’s at peak. And for the emerging economies, it’s also at an all-time peak though at a significantly lower level.

So we have a real question of the future of globalisation and of the future stability of global debt. At a time when, of course, interest rates have risen to, very substantially since 2021 which makes of course, debt much more expensive.

The third aspect of this is what’s happened to stock markets. Again, I can’t go through all the detail I would normally do. But this chart is derived essentially from the important work of Robert Shiller who won the Nobel Prize for his work on financial markets and the problems of financial market. And this is derived again from his measurement, his concepts, goes back to 1900 and essentially the dark blue line shows the cyclically adjusted real earnings yield, the earnings yield on US stocks relative to the market value of US stocks. And what you’ll see if you look at the blue line, is that only once in the last 125 years has it been as low as it is now and that was in 2000 after the bursting of the dot com bubble. The previous time when it was pretty close to this was 1929.

So basically, when the stock market looks like this, it’s telling you from a historical point of view it’s going to crash or it’s going to fall a long way. Valuations are extremely stretched.

The other line shows the Excess CAPE which is the difference between the inverted yield that I’ve shown you and real interest rates in the US. And you’ll again see it’s not quite as remarkably low as in previous low but is very, very low. And essentially the difference between the real earnings on stocks and real interest rates is close to zero. There is no equity risk premium in these prices.

Then we have, of course, the war. I don’t have time to go through the implications of the war, the Iranian war, what it will mean for oil markets; I simply don’t have time. But this is a really, I think, fascinating chart. Again, a long period chart. So I’d like you to focus on the blue line and what it tells you is despite this very major conflict in the Strait of Hormuz which is the most important choke point in our world oil markets, actually the real price of crude oil throughout this conflict hasn’t been much above, really rather little above its average of the last half century. So oil prices have remained quite astoundingly low which tells you a lot about the way it’s been cushioned, the flexibility of the economy, the reduced reliance on oil. But it also conceals something important which is quite a few refined products, diesel particularly is a good example, their prices have risen much more than crude oil. So it’s quite a complicated picture, too.

And then, of course, since the COP is going on at the moment, this is to remind us that the temperature at a global level continues to rise significantly above pre-industrial levels. It’s now basically passed the 1.5 degrees which 10 years ago was thought to be the sensible ceiling. I’ve just written a column on this for tomorrow, and it basically argues that we’re clearly going to see it rise towards two degrees over the next 10, 15 years, and possibly on upwards. So climate is another of the big unknowns which is continuing to get worse. And that covers basically what I’m going to say about the different dimensions of the poly-crisis. The political transformation, the stressors on globalisation, the stressors of debt, and of course, geopolitics.

Now, in the remaining 10 minutes or so, I’d like to look at growth which is, of course, the other side, as it were, of the system. And I’d like to just say before I give a little more detail on what I have to say here, there’s one really big point I’d make, or two big points I’d like to make. In the last 70 years, the world economy as a whole has grown faster by a long way than ever before in history. World average GDP per head in real terms has increased five times which is extraordinary and unprecedented. And the second remarkable thing is that it’s been remarkably consistent in every single year, the world economy has grown roughly between two and four per cent except just two years. One was 2009 when it just stagnated; it didn’t collapse, that was the peak of the financial crisis, but it didn’t collapse. The only year of really major shrinkage was 2020, COVID. So what this is saying to us is the world economy is a growth machine, the single best bet about the world economy is that it will continue to grow in the range, probably a bit lower than it used to be, of two to three per cent in real terms. Which means over any 10-year period, it’s going to increase by more than 20%, possibly 25% which is a lot.

Now, what drives growth? Well, there are basically two things; catch up on the productivity of relatively high-income countries, the catch up process has created, opportunities created by how far countries are behind and how quickly they can absorb the technology at the frontier. And China has obviously been incomparably the most important catch up story of the last 40 years, and we’re not going to see anything like that again. But India is growing at six or seven per cent, and the country is as big as China in terms of population and is going to become substantially bigger. So that’s another huge source of growth. And there are other places which have, at least in theory, lots of catch up opportunities; Africa for example, and other countries in Asia. So the catch up opportunity definitely still exists.

And the second driver, of course, is innovation. And we are seeing continued very important innovations and I’m going to cover one or two of them, and I’m only going to cover two, but there are three ones of the digital economy, now AI, the reduction in costs of energy, particularly solar energy with other things no doubt behind it, and of course, huge advances in biological science. Those innovations are going to continue to be transformative. And finally driving this now very considerable degree is the competition between the US and China for technological leadership. And we can see that more or less everywhere.

So, I said I’d say something about the past; this shows this, the real GDP per head in log scale, it’s in 2011 values, that’s what comes, how the Madison project bases its calculations. But basically what it shows is average GDP per head for the world as a whole, that’s the pink line. It’s gone from about 3,000 to about 16,000, so a little bit more than five-fold as I said, over that period. China, you can see moving from essentially nothing to 20,000 which makes it about a third of the US levels, a little bit more than a third of Western Europe, the other big developed region. India is also now growing very rapidly, though not as rapidly as China did, but clearly much faster than the average. And there’s every reason to expect it will continue to grow very rapidly. And I haven’t put in all the rest of the world. But the picture here is of extraordinary dynamism; it’s slowing, there’s no doubt it’s slowing a bit, but not much. And that I expect to continue barring some catastrophe.

Now, in terms of new technologies innovation, obviously the most exciting thing at the moment is AI. I have many charts on this, but I’ve reduced it to one in the end. I’m not going to discuss the bubble, I’ve written columns about this, most recently one a couple of weeks ago. But this basically shows from one of the, from a column on AI, that column that I did, which I took from a fascinating paper from bookings just published. It shows the scale of capital spending in the US on AI on an annual basis compared with the big investments of the past: the railroads, the highways, Telecom and fibre, the canals, this goes back to the 19th century and the great electrification boom. It’s what they are talking about here is a relatively brief period because nobody knows how long this will go on for. But right now, this is the biggest investment boom as a share of GDP in American history. It’s colossal. And it is, of course, driving growth, investment, and it is underpinned by extreme optimism despite recent excitement about the technology and its potential.

My own view is that the profitability is almost certainly overestimated and there will be a correction, possibly quite a big one in the stock market. But at the moment, clearly something very, very big is happening in the optimism about AI and the investment that it is generating.

The second thing, I thought I’d put a chart up, is on renewable energy and the most interesting thing here is the red line from the top down to 2024, 2009 to 2024 which is the latest year I’ve got this number. But basically, it’s showing that the cost of solar [Photovoltech? 00:18:12], a generation plant, largely because of Chinese investment has fallen from $500 per megawatt hour to $60 over just 15 years. And that, of course, is proving transformative; just written a column about this as I mentioned, and this will see almost certainly a continued very rapid growth of solar Photovoltech. In fact, in the last year, electricity installation around the world has been about 60% in renewables. There’s been a really remarkable shift towards investing in renewables to generate electricity, particularly obviously in areas where there’s a lot of sun. And this is for economic reasons, it’s not for policy reasons, even under the former Republican government in Texas there was lots of solar energy because there’s a lot of sun in Texas. So it’s not going to be enough to prevent continued rising climate because that’s a much more complicated set of issues, but this energy revolution is definitely going, in my view, to continue.

I was going to talk about biotechnology, but I don’t have the time, unfortunately. There are two other things I want – well, one other thing I want to focus, which is the US versus China as a driver. And here I’ve got two contradictory pictures; one, this one shows the share of Venture Capital investment in the world up to 2024 again. And you can see that the US is responsible for about half of it. The US is the dominant player in Venture Capital, but quite a lot of that Venture Capital is actually invested abroad but the dominant part, of course, in the US. And it’s one source not, by no means, the only one of the US strength in new innovative technologies.

The final chart, which shows the inverse [pic? 00:20:26] China; I don’t want to overplay what this means; I know there is a question about the quality of patenting and so forth. But when I got this chart together recently, I found it quite extraordinary. These are patent applications from [right over? 00:20:41] the world international property, intellectual property organisation, and you can see that China is now patenting at a rate almost equal to all the other big economies in the world together. It’s an absolutely staggering rate of patenting. And we can see from what’s been happening in China recently that this isn’t all nothing by any means. A lot of very innovative technology is now coming out of China and they are the world leaders in some very important areas including, perhaps most importantly apart from Photovoltech panels, electric motor vehicles. And they’re killing the European car industry as a result.

So the conclusion, it’s a very high-risk world, multiple risks, and I think we can really take for granted lots of shocks in the years ahead. Unpredictable shocks of many different kinds, I think it’s a very safe bet. And obviously one of the big questions that raises for business is how do you hedge against this? How risk averse can you afford to be? What is the balance for countries and companies between trying to defend yourself against these risks when you also then run the risk of losing opportunities? I think it’s a big question, whenever I talk to businesspeople, policy makers more broadly, they’re all wondering about that.

The second big point I make is there are very powerful sources of dynamism which we can see in the economy, the growth engine is almost certain to continue. And a very big point about our world which is different from the ‘20s which I sort of started with because I sometimes think there are obvious similarities, is at that time we were getting leaders and we did for the next 40 years, the major countries who are ideological fanatics. That’s not what we are seeing now; they’re not ideological fanatics. The worst of them are thugs, autocrats, but they’re not fanatics. This is slightly different, possibly somewhat safer than the world that blew up in the second world war, and then there are nuclear weapons which also change this.

So my assumption is that, despite all the risks and the dangers, economic and political, we’re going to stumble on through. And so hiding away from the world is not a rational proposition for most people because it’s not really possible, but above all, it’s probably excessively cautious. And that is my 20 minutes. We will stumble on.

[Applause]

Plenary session 5: Enforcement priorities

  • Sarah Court, Chair, ASIC

Full audio (MP3 13.7 MB)

Transcript

Sarah Court: This is the fourth occasion on which I have announced ASIC’s annual enforcement priorities, but it’s the first time I do so as Chair. It will come as no surprise that my commitment to strong enforcement has not changed. Strong enforcement sets clear boundaries, it provides regulatory clarity, and it demonstrates our commitment to market integrity and the protection of consumers and investors. Yesterday we considered the forces that are reshaping our financial system, and today I want to turn to how ASIC will respond as change creates new opportunities for misconduct.

Strong enforcement requires sound judgement about when and how we use our powers, and those choices matter. An ASIC investigation can affect a firm’s operations and an individual’s professional life long before a court determines liability. The financial and reputational consequences can be considerable, and we never take them lightly.

But ASIC cannot avoid difficult cases merely because the evidence is complex, the outcome uncertain, or an individual may be held personally responsible. Trust and confidence in ASIC, and in turn the financial system, depends on our willingness to act when the evidence supports intervention and on the discipline with which we exercise that responsibility.

Our enforcement priorities matter because they identify where we see heightened risks of misconduct, and where industry should expect particular scrutiny. By publishing them we give boards and executives an opportunity to examine their own practices, before regulatory intervention becomes necessary.

The priorities also hold ASIC to account. Each year we should be judged by whether we did what we said we would do. They guide our attention, but they do not place rigid boundaries around our work, and this year shows why.

When the 2026 priorities were announced, the scale of our work involving alleged confidentiality failures by KPMG auditors was not known. And while we had already identified risks in parts of private credit, we could not have predicted precisely how they would materialise, including through the collapse of the Bathla Group. We have redirected people and resources as those matters developed, and an effective regulator must retain the capacity to do that. Serious misconduct will always attract our attention, whether or not it appears on an annual list.

Now I am often asked how ASIC decides which matters to pursue, particularly where individual liability may be involved. Corporate penalties will not always provide sufficient accountability. Where senior decision makers were personally involved in misconduct, or they turned a blind eye to it, action against the company alone may be inadequate. Our Signo Australia case is a good example of this. Consumers were charged more than $90 million in unlawful fees and given the scale of this harm, we pursued action against the individuals we considered responsible. The court imposed combined penalties of $1 million on the two individuals involved, and we have appealed those penalties as inadequate.

Individual accountability is also an important part of our continuing work concerning the collapses of the Shield and First Guardian Master Funds. This year our action has included numerous individuals we allege were involved in or benefited from that misconduct. But at the same time, ASIC cannot act simply on the strength of public assertion or commentary, however firmly it is expressed. The threshold is evidence. We must establish a case under the law using admissible evidence, and put it before an independent court. Witnesses must be prepared to give the evidence, records must be available, and financial flows may require extensive tracing through complex structures, and the burden of proof is demanding, as it should be.

We won’t win every contested matter. In my view, no regulator should. During the past year, the courts have not accepted every aspect of our cases concerning directors in Star, Nuix and Rex, for example, and certain aspects of those cases are now under appeal. Where a court reaches a different view, we must examine the reasons carefully and consider what the outcome means for our future work. But the possibility of loss should not result in inaction, where the evidence and the public interest support us bringing a case.

If I turn now to our 2026 enforcement, by any measure it has been a significant year. Courts to date have imposed more than $570 million in civil penalty proceedings brought by ASIC, and there have been substantial remediation outcomes and serious criminal sentences. But volume alone is not the measure of effective enforcement. The more important question is whether ASIC’s actions address serious harm, including by pursuing those responsible, and whether we change conduct beyond the individual matter. Our work this year has produced each of those outcomes.

At a time of sustained pressure on household budgets, we have pursued misconduct that left Australians paying more than they should. Our misleading pricing priority led to action against Budget Direct, where we alleged that customers lost online insurance discounts they were promised.

In separate proceedings, aspects of the service provided by comparison business Choosi were found to be misleading, and the court also imposed combined penalties of $55 million against Harvey Norman and Latitude Finance for misleading consumers about interest-free payment arrangements. The court in that case found that sales and commercial interests had been placed ahead of consumers.

Private credit was, and is, a key priority. We identified risks last year and we continue to see concerning practices today. The collapse of the Bathla Group has brought those risks into sharper focus, and we have previously confirmed publicly that our investigations are well underway. We have also seen the risks associated with private credit in our work on Shield and First Guardian, where many investors were effectively funding private credit loans.

But the effect of our work is not confined to court orders. Nearly $40 million was paid back to investors following our review of the contracts for different sectors, and HSBC remediated more than $21 million to customers affected by scams, in addition to paying a substantial penalty for its serious failures.

Enforcement has also changed compliance behaviour. Financial reporting became a priority after we identified significant failures by large proprietary companies to lodge their reports on time. Following data-led surveillance, we took action against 70 companies, including the Visy and Pratt Group, Mecca, Canva, Sephora, Mainfreight, H&M.

In 2027, we will broaden this work across a wider range of entities, focusing on serious or persistent failures in financial reporting, licensing and record-keeping obligations. And that is what clear priorities should do. They should focus our attention on a significant problem, but they should change when the evidence shows that our approach has had an effect, or the risk itself is evolving.

Our work to protect consumers in financial difficulty also continued. We had outcome against lenders including Signo, Green County and Money3. Online retailer Snaffle was fined more than $33 million for unlawful charges under credit contracts, and Westpac was penalised for hardship failures.

In insurance and superannuation, we continued to pursue poor consumer and member outcomes. Hollard Insurance was penalised over its handling of a claim by a Victorian family, while TelstraSuper was found to have failed to respond to about one-third of relevant complaints within the mandatory period. Mercer Super was ordered to pay $10 million for systemic reporting failures. AustralianSuper has admitted failures in its handling of death benefit claims, with the penalty yet to be determined.

Our actions have contributed to improvements in death benefit claims handling across that sector, but there is more for us to do. Outsourcing may change who performs a task, but it does not transfer a trustee’s responsibility for member outcomes. These matters all differ in scale, but each concerns a basic failure to deliver what customers or members were promised. Large financial institutions must have the systems and oversight needed to get the fundamentals right.

Now, auditor misconduct has required considerably more attention than we anticipated when the 2026 priorities were set, and we have seen that audit failures can cause substantial harm. This year we took proceedings against Auditeo, the auditor of the First Guardian Master Fund, alleging serious failures in the conduct of that audit. We have also commenced proceedings against BDO Audit and its director, and we continue to investigate certain KPMG auditors.

Our enduring enforcement priorities also produced significant outcomes this year. Most notably, record penalties of more than $300 million were imposed against collapsed contracts for difference issuer Union Standard, and its former authorised representatives, for systemic unconscionable conduct. Their business models deliberately targeted inexperienced and vulnerable people, and used aggressive sales tactics to pressure them into highly risky trading.

ASX admitted its statement about progress on the CHESS replacement project was misleading. Binance was ordered to pay $10 million for onboarding failures, causing millions of dollars in client losses. We pursued continuous disclosure and directors’ duties matters, with significant cases against Star, Nuix and Rex directors, all of which were determined and are under appeal, and we commenced new proceedings against the former CEO of the Super Retail Group.

Our dedicated insider trading team has continued to progress significant matters. As an example, former investment manager Rodney Forrest was resentenced by the full Federal Court to a prison term of more than five years for insider trading and procuring others to trade in Platinum Asset Management shares.

And systemic compliance failures by large financial institutions also remained a focus. Large penalties were imposed against Macquarie for misreporting short sales; HSBC for scams-related failures; and Westpac for breaches of its hardship obligations. And then just last week, we commenced proceedings alleging that tens of thousands of CommBiz customers had been overcharged millions of dollars in undisclosed fees, and we took further action against Macquarie, alleging systemic failures to ensure customers received clear statements about their welcome interest rates.

And finally, few matters better demonstrate the breadth of our enforcement work than our response to the collapse of the Shield and First Guardian Master Funds. It remains one of our largest and most complex enforcement cases. To date, we have launched 27 investigations and commenced 19 Federal Court proceedings against 38 defendants. More than $420 million has been returned for approximately 4,000 affected investors. Our action spans advice firms, licensees, lead generators, superannuation trustees, auditors, responsible entities, and officeholders.

The collapses expose issues beyond those two funds, including conflicted advice, weaknesses in trustee and managed investment scheme governance, and failures by auditors and other gatekeepers. And these investigations have shaped several of the priorities I’m announcing today.

So turning to 2027, we have nine enforcement priorities grouped around three areas; protecting vulnerable consumers and small businesses; lifting standards and accountability across the financial system; and targeting serious misconduct and holding wrongdoers to account. And while these groupings provide a clear structure, the issues overlap. A single matter may involve consumer harm or weak governance, while also requiring action against individuals.

Our first priority is misconduct that compounds cost of living pressures, with particular attention to banks, insurers, and superannuation trustees. We will examine pricing promises that are not delivered, discounts that are not passed on, improper fees, poor claims handling, and failures to provide hardship support or other entitlements.

Our second priority concerns predatory practices that are targeted at consumers and small businesses who are experiencing financial difficulty. The focus will include harmful debt collection and debt management practices. Financial difficulty does not diminish a person’s entitlement to lawful and fair treatment.

The third priority is harmful financial advice and lead generation models. We will examine the commercial arrangements driving recommendations, referrals, and product distribution, and we will act where those arrangements place commercial interests ahead of clients. This work will complement the government’s reforms to the regulation of financial advice and lead generation.

Our fourth priority concerns consumer harm arising from poorly implemented technologies, including AI and automated systems. We spoke yesterday about the significant changes we are seeing across the financial system as new technologies and artificial intelligence become embedded. Consumer protection must keep pace with the development of this new technology. And while artificial intelligence, automated decision-making, and chatbots may improve the delivery of financial services, they do not alter a firm’s legal obligations.

The ability to obtain human review is particularly important where customers are making a complaint, responding to a scam, pursuing an insurance claim, or seeking financial assistance. And we will focus on poorly designed or inadequately supervised systems that produce misleading information, make inappropriate decisions, or prevent customers from accessing effective support and assistance. The technology may be new; the responsibility is not.

Our fifth priority concerns misconduct in private credit and managed investment schemes. Our attention will focus on disclosure, governance, conflicts, and valuation practices. These firms must uplift standards and improve their governance and conflict management arrangements. They need to ensure their disclosures are transparent and their valuation and reporting practices sound.

Our sixth priority is auditor and professional gatekeeper misconduct. Auditors and other gatekeepers of the financial system see information that investors and markets do not. We rely upon them to test what companies and funds report, and to challenge it where necessary. Where they fail in that role, the consequences can extend well beyond the individual engagement. And professional gatekeepers are those whose work gives investors, creditors, or markets confidence in information they cannot test for themselves. Their legal duties differ, but their position of trust carries particular responsibility.

Our seventh priority is holding to account those responsible for the collapse of the Shield and First Guardian Master Funds. This work is unfinished, and its scale and complexity will continue to demand substantial enforcement attention. Investigations continue, and further civil or criminal action will be considered where the evidence supports it.

Our eighth priority concerns failures to meet financial reporting, licensing, and record-keeping obligations. Our focus is not on isolated administrative errors that are promptly corrected. It’s on persistent or serious non-compliance that undermines transparency, impedes effective supervision, or raises questions about a firm’s ability or willingness to meet its obligations.

And our ninth priority concerns exploitation and misuse of ASIC’s corporate registers. Businesses, creditors, and the public rely on these registers to identify companies and those responsible for them. A Western Australian man was recently sentenced to more than five years’ imprisonment for fraud and dishonesty offences involving the misuse of our registers, and we will target deliberate conduct intended to facilitate unlawful activity, misrepresent corporate affairs, or obscure ownership and control.

Now, these priorities do not define the boundaries of our enforcement work. Alongside them sit our enduring priorities, and these include misconduct that damages market integrity or affects First Nations people, serious governance failures, and systemic compliance failures by large financial institutions. Conduct carrying a high risk of significant consumer harm also remains an enduring focus.

And the examples I’ve outlined show what these commitments mean in practice. Union Standard, ASX, and Binance reflect our continuing focus on market integrity. Signo and our proceedings against the Aboriginal Community Benefit Fund illustrate the importance of individual accountability where vulnerable or First Nations consumers are harmed. And the outcomes involving Macquarie, HSBC, and Westpac show that systemic failures by large institutions will continue to attract serious consequences.

The consolidation of earlier sector-specific priorities does not mean that banks, insurers, or super trustees will receive any less scrutiny. Serious member service failures by trustees will continue to attract our attention, and financial markets should expect us to pursue insider trading, market manipulation, and serious continuous disclosure failures.

Annual priorities concentrate additional attention where the risks are changing, but enduring priorities make sure that serious misconduct does not become less serious, simply because it no longer has its own line on our annual list.

Now, announcing an enforcement priority does not create a presumption that every failure will lead to litigation, and nor does the absence of an issue from the annual list prevent ASIC from escalating it where the circumstances require. Our response will depend on the evidence, the seriousness of the conduct, and the harm caused or likely to result. And we will distinguish an isolated failure that is identified and remedied promptly from misconduct that is extended, repeated, or systemic. A firm’s response will matter. Effective remediation and genuine cooperation will be relevant, as will any failures to address known risks brought to the attention of senior leaders.

Now, in closing, as the Chair of ASIC I remain firmly committed to enforcement that is strong, visible, and consequential. Our 2026 record demonstrates substantial outcomes against the priorities that we set. It also shows where work remains unfinished, and where the risks have changed.

The priorities for 2027 identify where greater scrutiny is now required and where industry should expect us to act. Where firms make genuine efforts to comply, ASIC should be easier to deal with. Where serious misconduct occurs, those responsible will find us harder to avoid.

Thank you.

Speech

Gallery

Plenary session 6: Meet the regulators

  • Sarah Court, Chair, ASIC
  • John Lonsdale, Chair, APRA
  • Gina Cass-Gottlieb, Chair, ACCC
  • Brendan Thomas, CEO, AUSTRAC

Full audio (MP3 34.4 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: This session will explore how Australia’s regulators operate separately and in alignment, how they work together, where their responsibilities intersect, and the challenges and opportunities that they see on the horizon.

Thank you all for your time this morning, we appreciate it. Gina, the ACCC is of course always focused on protecting Australians from harmful products and practices. But I suppose looking ahead at the next year, your priorities, what do you see as the greatest pressures emerging, and how is the ACCC anticipating that and planning to respond?

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: Thanks Amelia. I always start with fundamentally the incredible strength for the ACCC in a combined mandate of protecting both competition and consumers. Because competition, everyone in this room knows, delivers choice for consumers, higher quality services and products, and in addition, lower prices.

It is also the case that when consumers trust in the marketing claims that are made to them and in the value of the products and services that they acquire, that that trust underpins their ability to confidently engage in markets, to make purchases, make choices, and indeed to support competition on the merits.

We are seeing very significant changes, looking at Martin Wolf’s description of profound changes in our markets, particularly through the expansion of digital services across every sector in the economy. That provides both the opportunity through innovation for incredible growth and increased productivity, but also challenges which threaten consumer trust.

If I look for you at where the expanding set of digital technologies across the economy, including now, with the very evident benefits and uncertainties arising from AI, where does it affect risks? It affects existing risks to consumers and competition. It can make scams, misleading claims and manipulative design interfaces easier and more rapid to create, almost instantaneous, harder to detect and more widespread. It can also strengthen the dominance of existing firms in markets across the AI supply chain, and their capacity to self-preference their services against those of smaller competitors.

In each of these areas, it is critical for regulators to be seen to be monitoring, to be at the front of understanding these impacts, and to provide safeguards so that Australian consumers have the confidence to engage and to take up these opportunities. I want to give you two examples of the range of the ways in which our intelligence, our surveillance investigation and enforcement action has already operated in relation to AI to seek to underpin competition and consumer protection.

The first was the action that we took against Microsoft Australia and its parent corporation, Microsoft Corporation, for allegedly misleading approximately 2.7 million Australian customers when communicating subscription options and price increases after it integrated its AI assistant, Copilot, into Microsoft 365 plans. After we took that action, which is still before the court, Microsoft offered to Australian customers of the personal and family plans the choice to continue to receive the bundled Copilot, or to remain on their previously existing plan without Copilot at the original lower price. This allowed not only many families who took the option to reduce the price they were paying, but also the greater freedom to choose between competing AI assistants.

The second one is the anti-competitive conduct matter against Google, where a pecuniary penalty combined with changes to contractual arrangements, opening up the capacity for other pre-installation and defaults on Android phones, work together to help create greater opportunity for competing search providers to reach Australian consumers at this critical time, with the deployment of AI-enhanced search and now agentic AI.

From July 2027, we will have a new protective tool when the new unfair trading practices prohibition, a principles-based legal tool in the Australian consumer law to tackle manipulative practices in digital markets, will commence. This will cover the use of all technologies, including AI. We are soon commencing consultation on the guidelines across business, small business and the consumer stakeholders, and we look forward and I look forward to engagement in relation to that.

Moderator: A busy year ahead. John, a key theme yesterday was getting the balance right. APRA has highlighted the need to strengthen resilience against these geopolitical shifts and the changes in technology. How do you do that while continuing to support competition, innovation and productivity?

John Lonsdale: Well, thanks, Amelia, for the question. Good morning everybody. I mean, that is the key challenge in front of the prudential regulators. So we are charged with keeping the financial system safe in a world where risk is increasing, but we also want to do that with as small a footprint as we can. So this is a regulatory efficiency issue. So risk up, but less regulation. How do we kind of square that?

So start with the good news on safety, which is the key mandate. The financial system is very strong. You can look at all the key financial metrics, I think will tell you that, the classic ones. Where the risk is really increasing is in this bucket of non-financial risks, and geopolitical is the key one that has turned the dial up.

There are elements of that that you can see. We have conflicts around the world. That feeds into the global economy. We have got heightened inflation. All of that feeds into regulatory settings and the entities that we regulate. So you can see that.

Then there are the more disguised varieties like operational resilience issues, cyber, and AI is almost in its own bucket. So there is a lot of work happening on all of that. Geopolitical; for the first time we put out very clear expectations this year on what we are expecting and we are supervising against that, and we did that also on cyber this year as well. So all of that is in the safety bucket and we are stress testing the system, not just individual industries, but across the system to provide us with that assurance.

Getting the balance right, that is what we like to call the other element. I just want to be clear what it is. It is not about cutting safety standards. We are not about doing that. As a mid-sized economy, we need unquestionably strong safety standards here. It is about can we do our work better?

I said to the Treasurer last year we would deliver nine things, eight of them we will do by the end of the year, things like faster licensing, simpler rules, we are doing all of that. I think we have done some really good work with New Zealand in harmonising global prudential rules, and that is delivering real benefits to the banks. And we will complete our work on reducing risk weights for business lending and infrastructure lending this year, as well as a range of other things we are doing. So there is a lot happening in that space.

Moderator: Thank you. Brendan, speaking of getting work done, your focus is on your anti-money laundering regime. How difficult is that in this new complex environment, risk-focused environment, and what will success look like for you?

Brendan Thomas: Yes, as people know, the money laundering regime changed quite significantly in the middle of this year, where a whole range of industry sectors that hadn’t been subject to money laundering controls previously are now subject to money laundering obligations. In particular those involved in real estate transactions and the creation of company structures and corporate person arrangements.

Australia had had, I say, a swinging open door for illicit finance in those sectors for a long time, and we at AUSTRAC had seen significant amounts of money being laundered in the Australian real estate market, for example. I often quote one example of when I first started in this role of seeing one family with links to the Interpol Red List who bought $700 million worth of real estate in Sydney in one series of purchases over a week, and the purchases stated occupation was a housewife. No requirements to ask any questions about where the money was coming from.

That changed on the 1st of July this year, where those involved in real estate transactions now have anti-money laundering obligations. And for anybody that’s involved in those industries that’s been getting ready for those reforms, I just want to say a big thank you on behalf of AUSTRAC. The level of engagement of what we call the Tranche 2 industry sectors has been quite significant and quite extensive, and the take-up of those money laundering obligations in the first 140 days, really, since they have commenced, has been incredibly strong.

But what success looks like for that in the future is a couple of areas. One is we’re using the information that we get from those businesses to break up organised crime networks more effectively in those areas I’ve spoken about. But also those businesses are understanding illicit finance risks to their own businesses and starting to shut those out.

And we’ve seen that happen progressively in other parts of the Australian economy, in the banking sector, in casinos, in gambling, we’ve seen that, but that’s followed very heavy enforcement action from us. Hopefully we don’t have to take that in this area, but we will if we need to, there’s no question about that.

But we’re already seeing benefits coming from those businesses coming under money laundering obligations. We’ve had more than 1,000 reports coming out of those businesses, and some of them have been quite significant, highlighting illicit finance going into Australian real estate purchases. We’ve uncovered money laundering networks that we otherwise didn’t know about. We’ve seen the flows of illicit funds coming from Southeast Asia and the Pacific into Australian real estate markets through reports we’ve got from real estate agents and conveyancing businesses. We highlighted one significant international money laundering network that was completely blind to law enforcement prior to that report.

And on the company structure side, we’re getting very significant and valuable information about how organised crime networks are moving money through company structures, particularly money resulting from the illicit tobacco trade in Australia. And it’s given us a much greater insight into how they’re structuring and organising their businesses, and that information has gone to police, and police and law enforcement are using that already in enforcement activities. So there’s already significant benefit coming from that.

Still a long way to go in terms of maturing that engagement and making sure businesses understand their risk, and are focusing on risk. And also a lot of work for us to do to understand the illicit finance risk in those sectors so that we can best inform industry where to focus its effort, and what kinds of controls are most effective in reducing illicit finance in those businesses.

Moderator: Thank you. Sarah, as a journalist, I’ve seen firsthand the work that ASIC does in terms of your enforcement priorities. We’ve just heard a lot of them in your address. Specifically when it comes to scams and other forms of financial harm, what will you be focusing on next year and what will it mean for consumers? What change will they see?

Sarah Court: Yes, I mean we did quite a lot of discussion yesterday about scams and I think Gina has also mentioned just the significant changes to scams, their industrial scale, the increased sophistication as a result of AI. And I think what we’re really focusing on, Amelia, and working closely with the ACCC and the other national anti-scam centre regulators, is we do a lot of work educating consumers in terms of protecting them through the Money Smart website. And then one of the challenges with scams is that the traditional enforcement approaches don’t really work. It’s very hard to ascertain where scams are originating. Usually it’s outside of the Australian jurisdiction, of course, and so the real regulatory tool dealing with them has to be one of disruption.

So we spend a lot of time and a lot of resources taking down investment scam websites. We spend a lot of time alerting consumers whenever we become aware of a potential investment scam website, which goes onto a list. I had a look at it last night. There’s nearly 5,000 different entities that are listed on that site. So our real work in relation to scams is about disruption.

And then, of course, we’ve got the new Scams Protection Framework that is coming into play from March 2027, and that is really going to mark a very new approach in Australia. It’s interesting, I mentioned yesterday I’d been spending some time overseas recently. People are really watching what Australia is doing in relation to scams. Is this new framework going to make Australia just a harder target for scammers? And that’s, I think, what we’re all trying to do. We’re trying to deter scammers from targeting Australians, and the way to do that, I think, is by having these strong frameworks.

Moderator: Thank you, Sarah. We do have a question from the audience, and if anyone else has anything they’d like to ask, please do submit the question via the app. This is a question for you, John. Yesterday there was a discussion of individuals giving AI agents access to their bank accounts. Has APRA been doing work on what the prudential risks associated with this might be?

John Lonsdale: The answer is absolutely. I mean, AI is such a big issue, (a) for productivity, but (b) on the regulatory side. And there’s probably three key areas we’re focusing on AI. So one is we know our entities are using it. We are technology neutral in the way that we think about it. We don’t say, don’t use that model, use this model. It’s up to them as to what they use, but we want to make sure that they’ve got the appropriate governance and controls in place.

And when we did a thematic review earlier this year, what we found was concerning, and we have set out some expectations in April. We’re now supervising against that, so that’s point one. If you’re using it, you’re a bank, you’re a super fund, you’re an insurer, make sure you’ve got the governance and controls that you need.

The second really concerning place that we’re looking at is how can AI be used or weaponised against the entities that we’re regulating? And we’ve had years of open source software being employed. There’s a lot of patching going on at the moment, but it’s very, very difficult. I was in the US last month talking to global banks. The amount of money, the amount of resources going into this is enormous. So there’s a big issue here for us, because not everybody can employ those resources. So that’s a really big thing.

The third element, I’d say, is third-party risk. So we published something, a system risk outlook last week. One of the big things in that report is we’ve got about 100 material service providers that are third parties. Most of those are unregulated, and most of those are domiciled overseas, and so how should we think about that as a system? We’re saying to entities, you need to be thinking about the governance and controls in place, but we are working collaboratively.

In fact, all the people here are convening public-private type sessions with banks, super funds, insurers, third parties to really understand these risks and better share information. So it’s not just on the regulatory side we’re taking action, but we think it’s a public-private partnership that can actually help lift standards as we go forward. So a lot of work in this area. Thanks for the question.

Moderator: Brendan, there is a lot of interest from the audience, and I guess more broadly, on these AI agents, but AUSTRAC draws on financial intelligence to identify emerging threats. Is AI agents what we should be focused on, or is there something that we’re underestimating or putting too much focus on in the current environment?

Brendan Thomas: Yeah, we’ve done a crime assessment of the use of agentic AI in money laundering in Australia. We’re not seeing the use of agentic AI being reported significantly in Australia yet. We are seeing some trends of it internationally, and particularly with the movement of large cryptocurrency scam funds through Southeast Asia. There’s certainly no question that agentic AI is being used to launder those funds very quickly through different digital currency exchanges, and then back out into the regular financial industry.

But as John said, we’re working very closely with major financial institutions in Australia and globally around the use of artificial intelligence in financial crime programs. More and more, we’re seeing big financial businesses shift what were traditional rules-based transaction monitoring activities to more behavioural-based activities using greater levels of artificial intelligence.

It’s giving some significant benefits. One is it’s reducing a lot of the noise that was otherwise in the system and the false positives that were coming through. It’s starting to pick up greater avenues of behaviour in criminal activity. We’re using it in partnership with data we’re getting and testing with some of our big banks, which is highlighting sophisticated money laundering networks and the nodes of those networks in literally days, where it was almost impossible to pick those up through individual reporting before. Some really powerful analytics coming out of the use of AI on major data sets across multiple financial institutions.

But we certainly are seeing AI being used across the criminal network, particularly in the creation of synthetic identities, documentation fraud. We certainly saw it in the work we’ve done earlier in the year around mortgage fraud, where people are using artificial intelligence to defraud systems. I know some of our overseas counterparts in Europe in the banking sector are seeing that incredibly significantly.

But the use of AI also gives us the ability to start to think differently about how we might regulate some of these businesses faster, on a larger scale, and in a way that’s much more intuitive than we were able to do before. So there’s a lot of benefits there.

But from an organised crime point of view, we are starting to see, we’ve certainly seen in Australia and the growth in our region of what we call crime as a service, where people, organised crime groups will specialise in a particular type of activity and sell that activity to other crime groups. And we are starting to see on the dark web, people selling AI services to organised crime groups. That is, I’ll design a bot for you to go and commit the scams that you need to commit. And there’s certainly a growth of that regionally and for that take up in Australia also.

Moderator: Yeah, it’s just incredible. We’ve heard from each of you the individual priorities of your agencies. But as John alluded to before, you also do work together. Sarah, how important is that collaboration, but also while I guess maintaining your individual mandates and decisions?

Sarah Court: Yeah, look, I think it’s very important. Excuse me, just give me one second, Amelia.

Moderator: It’s contagious.

Sarah Court: It is. Don’t sit too close. Look, we work extremely closely together. All of the regulators up here and also with the RBA, of course. And I think part of the question, Amelia, is about how do we collectively maintain trust in the financial system? And I think it has to be through working collectively.

It was interesting, reflecting on some of the panels yesterday, where the attraction of Australia for capital investment, the issue that was being talked about was the fact that we have strong regulations, strong regulators, and a well-functioning financial system. And I think that’s something that we need to cherish and to keep working at together.

And then I think in terms of our individual mandates, I think I can speak for all of us by saying that we’re all acutely conscious of our statutory powers and obligations. And maybe, Amelia, I should just stop talking.

Moderator: We’ll let you have a rest. Well, Gina, I’ll follow up with you. There has always been, I guess, a little bit of a blurring between responsibilities. I know sometimes I’ll call someone and they’ll say, no, that’s not us, that’s not us, it can be quite frustrating for a journalist. How is technology, I guess, further complicating that and blurring that boundary further?

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: There is no doubt. I mean, we have been looking at the question whether a product enhanced by AI is a product or a service, because it is still the case under the Australian Consumer Law that there can be different rights, different remedies, and different obligations if it’s a product or a service.

So that is just looking at one fundamental way that it introduces a question, often as between the separation between the important consumer protection roles of both the ACCC and ASIC. If you have a product combined with a financial plan, then it can enliven both sets of jurisdiction. What is really important is that each of the regulators here are working together to both share information, understanding challenges and risks, but also to find solutions. I’ll give a small number of examples of those.

First, recently, the ACCC provided approval to a project of the Australian Payments Network, informed by work that has been taken by APRA and ASIC, looking at the cyber risks to share information, to share understanding of risks and how such risks can be met. So that is an interim authorisation. It is enabling a pilot, and then with the benefits of the pilot will be the chance for it to expand.

In addition, as Sarah has been noting, there is incredibly important collaboration happening between the ACCC, the National Anti-Scam Centre, ASIC, ACMA, AUSTRAC. And in that, I’ll just give a few examples.

So it firstly involves capturing intelligence, sharing it, and the National Anti-Scam Centre shares it both manually and with APIs, and we are now shifting to real-time sharing with ACMA and ASIC, and we are building such connections with broader stakeholders. It also enables some areas of entities that are not currently regulated under the Scams Protection Framework, such as cryptocurrency exchanges and super funds, to be able to be provided with this consolidated intelligence to expand across platforms and challenges the disruption that occurs.

And then I think a beautiful example, frankly, are the fusion cells that have existed between the regulators and the private sector, looking at romance scams, currently scambling, the scam-adjacent gambling risks that occur, but also in the first one in investment scams and also in employment scams, which has worked also with digital platforms, banks and telecommunications companies to bring together consolidated information and set up engagements that have persisted to help recognition, identification of risk, disruption activities, and ultimately prevention activities.

Moderator: Thank you. Speaking of dual responsibilities, we have a question from the audience for both APRA and ASIC. So John, we’ll get you to answer this one: “Can industry expect meaningful regulatory support for growth, productivity and efficiency-improving measures through APRA and ASIC’s new Statements of Intent? Will both agencies take a more active role in this as part of their mandates?”

John Lonsdale: So the short answer is it’s part of our mandate. So this is what we do. Sarah can supplement my answer. So we’ve got a new Statement of Expectations. I’ll just give you a sense of the challenge here, which goes, I think, to one of your earlier questions.

So two new clauses. So one clause said we want you to lean in more to efficiency and productivity in how you think about regulation, and see whether you really need all that regulation. That’s the gist of it. Another clause, we want you to look really closely at AI and promote really hard the safe use of AI, more regulation, potentially. So this is the conundrum, I think, before us.

And so what are we doing? We’ve set ourselves a target. We’re not interested in lifting the bar on regulation. We’re trying to be neutral here. So we’re looking very hard at existing rules and saying, well, look, as things move, can we reduce regulation in some ways? And we’re doing that on some risk weighting elements.

On the other hand, where we see risk, particularly on the non-financial side, we might lift safety standards on that. So it’s constant. It’s evolving. We’ve got a long list of things, as I said before, that we’ve said to the Treasurer that we’re delivering on. That is happening.

But I think the other part that Sarah touched on before is how we work together. And a big insight from the Royal Commission was we want the twin peaks, but the twin peaks have got to be closer together. And I think you are seeing that in the work that we’re doing on enforcement. We’re actively talking about who will take the case, who will lead it. And Shield and First Guardian, I think, is a really good example of that happening. As well as running active sessions with the private sector on how we can make things better; we want to hear. If there’s rules out there, if we’re collecting data in multiple ways, we want to hear that. So don’t be shy in telling us, which I know you won’t be.

Moderator: The theme of the forum is staying ahead of the next wave. And a big wave that is coming our way is, of course, the drawdown of superannuation, millions of Australians accessing their savings. Brendan, how concerned is AUSTRAC that retirees could be targeted by bad actors in the years ahead?

Brendan Thomas: Yeah, we are concerned about it. We’ve done a financial crime risk assessment of the superannuation industry, which is, or superannuation generally, which is available on our website, and developed some specific guidance for the industry about how it might develop controls to limit its exposure to financial crime risk.

But the risks are certainly there. And we’ve seen it in a number of ways. We’ve seen some very small, very small occasions of criminals actually drawing down on their own super funds to fund further criminal activity, which is an interesting thing to see, not often, but we’ve seen that a little bit.

We’ve certainly seen cases where individual fund holders have been defrauded. One case in our financial crime guide shows where an overseas organised crime group hacked into an individual’s personal computer, and from that hacking got access to that person’s superannuation details, followed that person on social media, and waited for that person to leave the country. And when they did, impersonated that person to their superannuation fund, and requested a release of funds from that fund. Thankfully, that person noticed that from overseas, and the bank had also noticed an anomaly and frozen the transaction. And that was the case of a number of systems working together to block that. But there’s certainly increasing activity happening there.

We also see, as Gina was talking earlier about scams, older Australians being targeted for cryptocurrency investment scams. We’ve focused very heavily on that, particularly the transition of cash to digital currency through ATM machines, which you might have seen the parliament pass some legislation this week, which should give the Minister some powers to outlaw high-risk money laundering activity with that particular channel in mind. But we’ve certainly seen millions of dollars leave Australia out of super fund investments and into cryptocurrency schemes.

The other area that is kind of a sleeper is not so much the older group who are coming to maturity now, but the younger people who may not be paying attention to their super balances. I don’t know how many 32-year-olds regularly check their superannuation balance; I’d suggest not many, and therefore perhaps not noticing if they’re suffering frauds in those superannuation balances. But as that grows, and as sophisticated criminal groups internationally understand the value of that, we’re going to see more exposure. And we’re working with the industry to understand the nature of that risk, and to work with them to develop guidance and controls that might be able to prevent and limit that risk.

Moderator: You’ve prompted me to check my super balance this afternoon. John, from your perspective, focusing on superannuation, what are you most concerned about in the years ahead?

John Lonsdale: Well, superannuation is just such a big topic for us. Like I start with a really important point; it’s approaching $5 trillion in total, most of that is APRA-regulated. It’s largely unleveraged, and it will soon be the largest part of the financial system in Australia. So you just pause on that for a minute. I mean, that is unique globally.

And so we have been spending a lot of effort actually understanding what that means in the totality, making sure that the linkages, how the whole system would perform under stress is understood, not just by the regulators, but actually by the participants themselves. So that has been a really important piece of work. And I’ve got to say, it’s a real strength of the Australian financial system. Leveraged system in the banks supported by an unleveraged system in superannuation, very, very strong.

At the member level, we’re also charged with making sure that trustees are operating in the best financial interest for members. And retirement as we age in Australia is a really big issue. We’ve got a retirement income covenant that both APRA and ASIC are administering. We’ve made our expectations very clear on that. And to be frank, people expect when they retire that the money that they’ve accumulated is going to be there. There’s going to be a sense of investment governance around it. They will get their money seamlessly, free of scams. So if that doesn’t happen, then financial detriment can happen. So retirement’s a big focus for us.

Investment governance, a big focus of work for a number of years, more recently on platforms. And when you think about retirement, we want funds to really think about the different appetites that retirees might have, which might well be very different for their savings in retirement. Liquidity is another big issue that we’re looking at as well. So there’s a whole range of issues on the retirement side, big.

Moderator: Yeah, it is. Thank you for that. We do have a question from the audience: “With the SPF framework to come in very soon, with rules and codes yet to be finalised, how does ASIC and the ACCC assess industry readiness, given the tight implementation period and your thoughts on how to approach regulatory supervision and enforcement?” Gina, what’s your take on that?

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: Thank you. It’s a very important question. As Sarah referred to earlier in her speech, we are soon to come to March 2027 when all the obligations will come into place. We are aware of the challenges that some members of industry, particularly smaller participants, are facing with the timing.

What, first of all, I think is really important to say is that with every piece of new regulation, there is a bedding in time. It is important for it to start, for the regulators together to give really clear guidance, and we can then work through a period in which industry participants are ensuring that their systems are in place. But we think it is important that it starts March 2027.

In addition, we are working on a statement that will be very clear as between ASIC, the ACCC and ACMA about what are the specific scope, and earlier on, Amelia, you were talking about the blurring of the boundaries, the specific scope and roles of the three regulators, including where we are going to delegate certain of our powers to the sector-specific regulators, so that we make clear which sectors and which regulator each members of the industry are likely to be dealing with.

In addition, we have had a very good first testing, because the first time was the coming in and membership of the relevant three sectors into AFCA membership to support external dispute resolution, and we have had a strong take-up, and the ACCC has been monitoring and would enforce. But of course, the financial services sector is already members. The important question was, would telco and digital platforms join, and in large measure, and the largest digital platforms, have. So it is the right foundation going into March 2027.

Moderator: Shifting back to artificial intelligence, Brendan, we have been speaking about the balance, getting the balance right. There is this AI arms race at the moment, and as a result, financial crime controls are having to become more sophisticated in response. So how do you ensure that you can disrupt criminals without unnecessarily excluding legitimate consumers or placing burdens on lower-risk businesses?

Brendan Thomas: Yeah, it is the constant challenge, I think, in regulation generally, money-laundering regulation specifically, about how do we make sure that the controls are proportionate and that they are focused directly towards the risks that we want them to focus on.

Certainly, greater technology, a use of technology gives us a better understanding on the nature of those risks. So the technology being deployed in financial businesses and our own artificial intelligence use in data is giving us a much more specific focus of where money-laundering risk exists, both in terms of the criminal environment, but also in terms of where controls are being breached and how criminal organisations are working in between those controls, for example, to try and launder money. So the use of artificial intelligence in data and analytics is giving us a much greater understanding of it through that environment.

But working with major businesses to understand the use of artificial intelligence and to help guide that use is making sure that the controls that are in place are much more targeted, much more directed than they otherwise would have been. And the legislation that passed the parliament at the end of 2024 and that came into effect for existing regulated businesses in the AML world in March this year put a much stronger emphasis on risk. That is, businesses understanding their own risks and having a very strongly defined risk assessment, but it also provided a range of provisions around low-risk kinds of transactions and low-risk customers. Which again provides the statutory basis for businesses to target their financial crimes much more specifically around where those risks are.

And we’ve been engaging with industry much more about focusing more heavily on risk, and less heavily on those areas where the risk doesn’t exist. And certainly we’ll be doing that much more throughout the course of the next year, and not only looking at how businesses are managing their illicit finance crime risk, but how they’re taking a lesser approach to those areas where the risk is lower, and a much stronger focus on client needs in those areas.

Moderator: Gina, with all this change, it does weaken a consumer trust. How important is it to maintain competition in this environment, but also visible enforcement? How important is it that you are seen to be taking action when it’s required?

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: There was a really, I found, interesting, spurring comment last night in Alastair Campbell’s presentation, which was what can most significantly undermine the trust and the underpinnings of markets, and in fact all conduct that we are relying upon, is if the population, the community feels that it is weighted against them, that it favours the largest or the best position, positioned, as distinct from being fair, objective, transparent and enforced in a proportionate way.

Every regulator here is a critical part of the support of the communities and businesses trust that our regulation is in place, targeted to the right harms, where there are market failures, implemented in a proportionate way and in an objective way that allows businesses as well as consumers to have confidence. These are aspects that are really critical at this time of profound change.

We are wanting to also show that for the very largest global companies that are in a truly necessary position in a digital platform sense, that the ACCC has a strong record of taking actions where necessary, and securing settlement and change behaviour also where necessary in the interest of Australian businesses and Australian consumers.

We continue to have very significant actions against Microsoft, Amazon and Meta in relation to our allegation about allowing the proliferation of scams in the social media properties. Each of those show that the right regulation is in place, not for the sake of having regulation in place, but in order to deliver better outcomes and strong fundamental underpinnings for markets and the Australian economy.

Moderator: Another question from the audience; I like this one: “With regulators increasingly being asked to do more, how do you decide what not to do?” Sarah?

Sarah Court: I’m not sure I can even try, but I’ll give it a – no, I don’t think – I think you might –

Moderator: We’ll move on.

Sarah Court: I have to concede defeat.

Moderator: How do you decide what not to do when there’s so much going on?

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: This is a really difficult question, including because we and our teams get very invested in the work that they’re doing. However, it is always the case that we must prioritise. We are informed firstly by the deep set of engagement that we have. We last year had over 115,000 reports to our info centre that come from across the economy and mainly from consumers. We have detailed engagement together with stakeholders, together with other regulators, both domestically and internationally. For that, we prioritise where the greatest harm is likely to be, and we then do restrict our effort and in some cases cease doing activity.

Very importantly also, we have done a review in the manner that John was referring to before of the areas where we are the regulator to cover competitive questions and aspects. In telecommunications, for instance, we did a review and ceased regulation in various areas where we considered it was not necessary, reduced the regularity of that regulation, ceased gathering information and shifted to a full consultation on what we should do. The critical answer is it’s all dependent on our assessment of harm, and on whether we need to continue to target particular areas and particular risks.

Moderator: John?

John Lonsdale: Well, I think it’s a great question because we don’t often talk about what we’re not doing. We’ve got to keep the system safe in APRA. We have a prioritisation session, lots of them in fact. But the important thing that I think has moved in recent years is that’s constant. We had a discussion yesterday at the board on, OK, we’ve got the corporate plan, what have we got to reorient here? What are we seeing? Put more resources in here. That is happening all the time. So the agility and the prioritisation I think is really important.

We’re an island a long way away, but it doesn’t mean that we can’t be connected. So as Gina said, we’re always talking internationally. I’ve just come back from the US, I’ve come back from Europe, we’re watching the risks out there. Those risks can become our risks, and it’s being open, I think. So it’s not all about domestic issues, it’s about international issues and how that contagion can feed through. So I think it’s being curious, and it’s being a bit humble on what can happen and trying to be prudent. That’s what we try to do.

Sorry, and one other thing that’s very important, I think. You are seeing, I think from all regulators, but I’d speak on behalf of APRA, much more transparency in what we care about and what we don’t, we care about less. And you’re seeing that in the press releases, you’re seeing that in the corporate plans and the annual reports. And I think that does hold regulators more accountable, but it also makes clear to the community what we’re doing.

Moderator: I think Sarah spoke to this in her address earlier. These are our priorities, but just because you’re not one of them doesn’t mean you’re off the hook, everyone’s on notice. Brendan, is that the same approach from you?

Brendan Thomas: Absolutely. I mean, this is a constant question, I think, for all regulators. For us, it’s a question that we’re asking ourselves almost every week. How do we set a clear set of priorities, but how do we maintain a level of agility in the organisation so that we can respond to new and emerging threats?

I think as Sarah mentioned earlier about ASIC’s enforcement approach, it’s very similar to AUSTRAC. We have probably the heaviest level of enforcement we’ve ever had in our organisation. But if you look at it, it’s broad, it’s across multiple industries, but it’s very specifically targeted towards identifiable financial crime threats and where we’re really trying to shift the dial on a particular channels dealing with threats or a particular industry sectors dealing with particular threats.

And so we focus very, very strongly on where we see the greatest level of harm, and we try and shift our resources to focus on that harm in a way that’s going to lift the bar of everyone’s ability to deal with controls around reducing that harm in a particular sector or a particular industry group.

Moderator: Another question from the audience, this time regarding crypto ATMs. It says, “They are a clear scam vector and there’s undeniable evidence that there’s no legitimate use case. What more can regulators do to just ban these machines causing harm, particularly to older Australians?”

Brendan Thomas: I’m happy to take that one. You might have seen the Parliament passed a change to our legislation this week, and that change gives the Minister for Home Affairs the power to put controls or prohibit high-risk money laundering risk sectors, and the Minister’s been very clear about that power being first used in looking at this particular sector specifically.

We focused very heavily on this particular area for the last 18 months. Our intelligence area identified a significant amount of illicit finance flowing through these cryptocurrency ATMs, and particularly where there’s a vector where people can move cash into other forms of activity there’s a greater money laundering risk, and this is one that’s very specific.

We think they’re particularly used for scams, for money laundering, for the purchase of large narcotics from overseas crime networks, and we’re focused very heavily on every business that’s involved in providing ATMs in Australia. And I won’t go into too much detail on the work that we’ve done, but there were 10 businesses providing these services, there’s now only three, and they’re reducing significantly. But the parliament has just given the Minister Home Affairs specific statutory power to deal with this particular threat.

Moderator: Looking ahead, thinking about these, staying ahead of the wave and the theme, I’m interested to hear from each of you if there is one change or one step that regulators, industry or government should make now to maintain confidence through the next major shock. Gina, I might start with you.

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: What I’m going to take up, and I’m going to cheat, I’m sorry Amelia, but speak about two. The first is that all new regulation, and indeed all new business plans, should have underpinning it a consideration of how to maximise competition and contestability. If we each keep that front of mind in a principled sense, we will maintain what is the key driver of innovation and productivity, which is competition.

But the second is transparency, transparency and transparency, which is critical for government, for regulators and for key, frankly, the governance mechanisms of major corporations in Australia. Because when the community as a whole has the chance to really understand what we’re doing and why, and why we consider it produces better outcomes, we are going to have more confidence and a better debate where there is a contest and differences of view.

Moderator: John?

John Lonsdale: Well, I’m a big believer in getting in front of the issues. That’s good when you’re a safety regulator. So I think you ask yourself the question, assume we have a shock, and what is it that we and what is it the entities wish they would have done? So I think facing that question, for all its uncomfortableness, I think is really important.

We are going to have shocks, we are going to have problems. So assume we’ve got the problem, how do we make sure that we’ve got service provision happening in the community. You’ve got the problem, can people withdraw money, can people make payments, can people receive their superannuation benefits or get insurance? So I think it’s facing into those issues more, and the answer is not more regulation, it’s not only for government, it’s not only for the private sector, but it is this team working together collaboratively to do it. So that would be my one thing.

Moderator: Brendan?

Brendan Thomas: Yeah, I completely agree with what’s been said. I think the other thing we need to focus on is forecasting risk, and understanding where that shock’s coming from and what the consequences of it might be, and what we can do to better prepare ourselves and the economy more generally to be able to manage those kinds of shocks.

I think we’re getting, all of us, across the board much better at analysing our own data and engaging with industry to understand trends as they’re emerging. And to put that together where we can forecast what future risk and future shocks might look like, and then work together to better plan amongst ourselves and also with the broader economy about how to manage those kinds of shocks collectively, prospectively.

Moderator: You’ve all discussed what you can do, but what can we do? What should consumers be doing to prepare for these shocks? You mentioned awareness, just knowing what’s happening with your super. Is there any other steps that the public could be taking? Gina?

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: We always want to be careful. We want to give consumers and the public as much information and guidance as possible to assist decision making. We also do want to though always say that the responsibility sits with business and the suppliers to not be misleading, regardless of whether it continues to be a human sales assistant or an AI chatbot sales assistant.

So undoubtedly we are all doing as much work as we can, informed also by consumer representatives, to give consumers more information to be better informed. But we also know not all consumers actually are sophisticated, and that is why it’s important that businesses sit at high standards to protect and to continue to deliver to against their obligations.

Moderator: Yeah, it can be hard to keep up. But John, is there anything that the public can be doing to make your job easier at the moment?

John Lonsdale: Well, just buyer beware. Be aware of the risks. I mean, be prudent. If something looks too good to be true, just ask, yeah.

Moderator: And Brendan your take?

Brendan Thomas: Yeah similar. I mean one of the things that does worry me a little bit is how willing some members of the public are to turn a blind eye to financial crime when they see it. I mean the example I often use is the growth of illicit tobacco in Australia. All of that money is going to the same people that are supplying drugs and doing other organised crime activities. Yet millions of Australians are prepared to buy cigarettes from those people. Thousands of real estate agents are prepared to lease shops to those people. There’s a lot of the economy that’s turning a blind eye to what is serious criminal activity, and it would be great if they didn’t do that.

Moderator: It certainly would. We do have time for one last question from the audience. John mentioned that many of the material service providers are not regulated. Are there any plans to bring any of these into the regulated environment, especially given the systemic risk that many of these represent?

John Lonsdale: Well big issue. I think the first point to make is this is an issue that’s broader than the financial sector. We’ve got a dozen critical areas in the economy. Financial services is one of those. So these issues present in others. It’s an issue for government in terms of what the rules set that would apply. So that’s the first issue.

But in terms of what APRA is doing, we are doing a lot. Certainly I would say we’re on the edge of our mandate on what we’re doing. So we are, as I said, convening meetings not just with the entities that we regulate, but we’ve got third parties in the room. We’re dealing bilaterally with the significant third parties. We’re asking them about what their risk settings are, how they’re providing the service. We want to be convinced.

Some of those are easier to handle, to be frank, than others. I think if you’re a big offshore hyperscaler, Australia is just one of a number of countries and you’re not domiciled here. So there’s a whole gradation of difficulty around that, but it is an area that we are pushing into hard.

Gina Cass-Gottlieb: Amelia, I might just add, because there’s a spectrum here and I understand very much the reason for the question. So there are certainly, particularly in a financial services context, specific regulated entities working upon licence obligations and a whole set of frameworks. What has come through the scams, for example protection environment, is the recognition by government that there are multiple channels for these risks to reach consumers, and it has expanded out from financial services to telecommunications and also to the digital platforms as well. So there is that thinking happening and there is always the capacity to expand it.

You then have, particularly in the Competition and Consumer Act, across the economy regulation that applies to every business that does any business in Australia. And the High Court has made a marvellous decision, in the context actually of the Ruby Princess case, that any foreign corporation, even if the contract is made offshore, and the customer in that case was actually an offshore customer who suffered a failure under the Consumer Law in Australia, the High Court said regardless of offshore domicile, regardless if it’s a hyperscaler, which happens to be structured and based in other parts of a jurisdiction, for example, the law applies.

The Australian Consumer Law applies to protect people operating within Australia, and consumers within Australia, and that the High Court said it not only applies as a matter of law, it sets the standards for business conduct. So I have no doubt about the jurisdiction that applies to every entity as expressed under these general principle prohibitions under our Act.

Moderator: Thanks Gina and thank you all for your time this morning. It’s been interesting to hear your priorities for the year ahead and I look forward to being here next year and we can see how things have changed. It’s changing very quickly out there.

Thank you also to the audience for sending in your questions. Please do rate this session on the app, we do love to hear your feedback. It’s morning tea time now so please make your way out to the foyer when you can. We’ll be back here in about half an hour’s time for a fireside chat with Australia’s Solicitor-General Dr Ruth Higgins, so don’t miss that. We’ll see you soon.

Gallery

Fireside chat

  • Dr Ruth Higgins SC, Solicitor-General of Australia

Full audio (MP3 11.5 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: Please take your seats when you get a moment. We hope that you enjoyed your morning tea and that you are ready for this next session. I am very excited about it because I am about to welcome to the stage Australia’s Solicitor General, Dr Ruth Higgins. As I said to her just before, she is an incredibly impressive woman. Ruth took up that prestigious role in June, becoming the first woman to serve in that role. As Solicitor General, Ruth is counsel to the Commonwealth, providing advice on some of the most significant and complex questions of law facing government. Ruth has had a distinguished career at the bar, practising nationally across constitutional and competition law, class actions, corporate criminal law and corporations law. Ruth holds a PhD from Oxford. She was called to the bar in 2006 and took silk in 2017. She is the immediate past president of the NSW Bar Association and, relevant to this audience, was a part time member of the Takeovers Panel for a few years. She brings breadth of experience to this role and a unique perspective on the law, our institutions and the challenges they are navigating. So, it brings me great joy to welcome Ruth to the stage. [Applause].

Ruth, it’s wonderful to have you with us. You are relatively new to this role, as I just said. It involves being the second law officer of the land, advising on and appearing in matters that raise novel or difficult points of legal principle of particular significance to the Commonwealth. Was that an aspect of the role that particularly appealed to you?

Ruth Higgins: Yes, the opportunity to appear in Australia’s apex court, instructed by practitioners immersed in constitutional doctrine and arguing cases on novel and difficult points is an almost irresistible prospect. Beyond that, many of the issues to be considered by the Solicitor General, whether it’s in advice or appearance work, are issues that have real and immediate effects on the lives of Australian citizens and non-citizens. That imbues the work with an additional dimension and that is the practical reality of laws working on the lives of people is manifest every day. That, in turn, emphasises the practical as opposed to merely theoretical importance of each arm of government operating with in proper constitutional limits with faithful obedience to the law.

My work at the private bar involved cases of that kind. And not only cases in the High Court, in which I appeared, like NZYQ. Cases involving privacy, whether they were for the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner or for private entities, such as in the facial recognition technology case. It also involved pressing immediate issues of that kind and so, too, as this audience knows well, to cases involving director’s duties and consumer competition matters. But the difference in the role of Solicitor General is that almost all of the work I am asked to do is of that kind. There’s also a stream of international work appearing for Australia in investor state disputes and in international tribunals such as the ICG. Being able to do that work is a wonderful opportunity and a genuine privilege.

As you mentioned, I completed a doctorate about 25 years ago, or a quarter of a century, more alarmingly. That was on the topic of the conditions under which the State’s claim to a legitimate monopoly on the use of coercive force can be justified or, conversely, when we as citizens have a moral obligation to obey the law. That topic is surprisingly adjacent to much of the work that I’m now doing. I’m fascinated by how legal actors understand themselves and their actions and limit those actions according to law. So, to adopt T. S. Elliot, I suspect I’ve arrived where I started and have an opportunity to get to know the place for the first time.

Moderator: Well, we spoke about your experience when I introduced you. You have spoken about, I guess, some of the key differences in the role but I wonder how you see the work of this role being different to the advocacy you’ve done in the private bar.

Ruth Higgins: Yes, aspects of the exercise of advocacy are essentially the same. I believe very strongly that advocacy is a craft or art in its own right, which can be studied in its own right. It’s both a technique and the development of correct judgement. Forgive this classical Greek reference, but in his rhetoric, Aristotle defines rhetoric as being able to see the available means of persuasion in each case. That must proceed by reason and it must be informed by its audience. That much, I think, is universal to all advocacy, be it directed to a judge, be it directed to a board, be it directed to a gathering of the members of a company or otherwise, you have to understand the available means of persuasion for that audience.

Continuing on the slightly pretentious Aristotle theme, he made two other observations, which I think are deeply true about advocacy. The first is that character is almost the most authoritative form of advocacy and that character can’t be subordinated to reason because it’s so profoundly tied up in the work of advocacy. And secondly, that character is action. I think those two observations helpful mark a difference between appearing at the private bar and appearing as Solicitor General of the Commonwealth. Character can’t be manufactured and if I’ve learned one thing from being in court, it’s that because of the urgency of the thought involved, people cannot avoid being who they are. Under that much strain, people will be themselves.

That takes on a different aspect from appearing as Solicitor General for the Commonwealth, because it means appearing on behalf of the legal person of the Commonwealth or one of its emanations as the repository of significant powers under the constitution or a statute. In each appearance, being responsible and accountable for the lawful exercise of that power and, I think makes quite a different demand of character. It requires a coherence of character over time. There are some more day to day differences between appearing at the private bar and appearing for the Commonwealth, again, which all regulators here – Sarah and others – will be well familiar with. In the role of Solicitor General, policy considerations and the operational landscape that inform your instructions are markedly difference to work at the private bar. Clients will often have to balance a range of complex policy considerations, some of which are legal and some of which are not, when considering how to instruct you and the scope of your instructions.

A second issue is that much greater consultation is necessary, particularly if a particular matter has the potential to have whole of government implications. Take, for example, what does carrying on a business mean? That’s maybe in 100 or more Commonwealth statutes. There are questions that will have ramifications across the board. The third day-to-day difference, I think, is that institutional considerations have to be taken into account when developing the Commonwealth’s submissions on a particular issue. As to the last of those, the Commonwealth, again, as many people here will appreciate, is a very distinctive litigant. In one sense, the instructors that represent the Commonwealth as a litigant and the legal teams which advise them are custodians of legal policy positions and interests, which are rooted in a very long history and will persist long after they have left the roles and long after individual personnel have changed.

As a consequence, any position adopted and advanced by the Commonwealth in litigation will usually be attended by a long and very carefully considered policy analysis, which requires it to take both a long-term view of the broader policy and the submission its advancing in particular case. Now, plainly, that is a very good thing. The Commonwealth can’t responsibly have an atomistic focus on success in any one case. It has a profound responsibility to the courts to develop coherent and intelligible legal principle, particularly in respect to the constitution. That’s embodied in the model litigant principle, which many here will also be familiar with. By extension of the position of the Commonwealth, as an individual advocate, I have a peculiar duty to help the Court resolve the issues it confronts according to law.

Moderator: So, there are a lot of big differences, as you just explained. But are there any aspects of your practice in the private bar which you hope to carry through to your work as Australia’s Solicitor General?

Ruth Higgins: I mean, my success rate is the first one. But, more seriously, I have two priorities in that respect. The first is that I’m keen to appear in any matter in any court in which it is appropriate for the Solicitor General to appear. Be that first instance or on appeal or in the High Court. I have a great affection for first instance work. The traffic of argument and cross-examination and forensic decision-making on the spot are never more intense than in a trial. The sense that you’re involved in a contest of law but also a contest about the human condition is never more apparent than there, when you’re just looking someone in the eye and cross-examining them. You have the very serious responsibility of seeing that what they’re saying is not the truth.

I have accepted a first instance appearance for early next year in an important constitutional case that challenges the validity of a Commonwealth law of real significance to the present Government. Much of the complex legal argument will turn on factual findings made at first instance. So, I mean, my practice at the bar taught me such respect for the responsibility of practitioners in establishing facts and judges in finding them because most cases are won by the facts. Similarly, so much critical law is made by intermediate courts. I appeared in an intermediate court last week and will continue to do so as appropriate. There are frequently matters in intermediate courts which will either resolve there or raise novel questions of law that seem reasonably apparent will end up in the High Court.

The second and perhaps more personal aspect of my practice at the private bar that I hope to extend to my practice as Solicitor General is my conception of how teams best perform. I believe strongly that teams of any kind, counsel teams, sporting teams, corporate teams, whatever, perform best when there’s a sense of collective responsibility and shared adventure. There is a thing you’re trying to achieve together, i.e. the outcome, in which you may succeed or fail. But there’s another thing in which you can always succeed in the doing if you embark on it with diligence and joy. So, I try to emphasise the importance of collaboration and encourage contribution by all members of each team I work with. People do better when they feel responsible, I think. Much of the work we do, and will almost always do for the Commonwealth, is difficult and inherently weighty but it’s also a great blessing to be allowed to do it. I think that should bring a kind of serious delight with it. So, I’m hoping to bring that to the role.

Moderator: Yes, it’s a good attitude. Looking ahead, what are some of the legal issues or challenges, which you believe are likely to be significant from a Commonwealth perspective over the next few years?

Ruth Higgins: The first issue, which is not confined to the Commonwealth or, for that matter, Australia, is I think nonetheless very pressing. It appears that there are reduced levels of community understanding of and confidence in many institutions in civil society and in the administration of justice. Taking just as an example of that, the 2026 Edelman Trust Barometer observed what it described as an emerging trend of trust amidst insularity. What that meant was that the shared institutions, which had formerly bound communities together, are being displaced by narrower local circles – which is a kind of tangible and immediate relational community – while exposure to different political views is diminishing. It found also that the Australian income divide had more than doubled since 2012.

This, I think, is the most alarming proposition that high and low income individuals now inhabit different institutional realities. That is a concerning trend and one which is likely to undermine the perceived legitimacy of key civil institutions. Immediately connected with that, as far as it affects my day-to-day practice, are issues concerning the scope of power of the respective arms of government. That’s chapter three issues, the scope of the judicial power, questions as to the separation of powers and parliamentary privilege and the like. As I indicated, those issues and the principles that underpin them, I think, go to the heart of maintaining public confidence in those institutions. Those delineations must be clear and they must be principled and they must also, I think, be better understood by the members of our community.

Another significant issue about which I’ll obviously see very little, I think will be the scope of Commonwealth legislative power to regulate emerging technologies.

Moderator: Well, that brings me perfectly to my next point. You were speaking about public confidence and trust and that has been a key theme of our discussions here the last two days. One thing that is challenging that is the rise of artificial intelligence. It does make faster and more efficient decisions on the one hand but it also makes errors harder to detect and accountability less clear. So, as AI is likely to become more a part of decision-making, both in government and the private sector, are there any potential pitfalls that you think institutions need to be mindful of in its uptake?

Ruth Higgins: Yes, I have so many thoughts about artificial intelligence. Let me confine them. Can I say at the beginning, I think humanity is so important to law. I think the judgement of one human on another human is such an important aspect of the legitimacy of law and the expansion and encroachment of artificial intelligence into law, I think, we’ll have to bear that steadily in mind because questions of legitimacy, I think, are tied to questions of humanity. But can I focus on far more determinant current issues?

The first and very interesting aspect of AI relevant to law is that it is driving an increase in self-representation in all courts, including superior courts – including the Federal Court, the Court of Appeal, everywhere. The growth of generative AI models has made costless or low cost, “legal assistance” – and I put that avowedly in inverted commas – readily available. The University of NSW Law School recently undertook research, which found that there were 84 reported cases of generative AI in Australian Courts since ChatGPT had been launched in 2022. Three quarters of them, or 66, involved self-represented litigants. The attraction of that resource, in fairness to those litigants, is obvious when one considers that legal services are typically expensive, major Western democracies are enduring persistent high cost of living crises and that the structure and strains upon the funding of legal aid services has reduced the prospect of qualified assistance for many, many matters.

Now, none of this is intended to criticise self-representation, which is a fundamental, if defeasible, common law right but I think this trend towards increased self-representation has two consequences. The first is that AI frequently generates nonsensical submissions. The Court of Appeal of NSW has been called upon to discuss this twice recently. One example is May v Costaras [2025] NSWCA 178, where the Court said, with all due respect to the litigant who likely didn’t understand by necessity that this was nonsense. It is nonsense and litigants can’t be blamed for thinking AI is assisting them because they don’t have the legal expertise to look at what is generated and appreciate that it makes no sense. In fact, it’s impeding their prospects of success.

But I think a second concern is that increases in self-representation are increasing the volume, the quality and quantity of demands on the core system and all participants in a way that might be harmful for the administration of justice. The second, and I think legally but also practically, very interesting aspect of AI is that the nature of administrative decisions and administrative decision-making is changing and evolving in the context of automated algorithm driven systems. That’s raising quite basic but very important legal questions as to what constitutes a decision and the extent to which a human mind must be involved in any meaningful sense for a decision to be classified as such.

Questions of that kind have been coming up for at least 10 years now but recently in eSafety Commissioner v Baumgarten [2026] FCAFC 12, the Full Federal Court had to consider whether and how the subjective intention of a decision-maker as to the exercise of a power was relevant to determining whether a decision had in fact been made in the purported exercise of power and was therefore within the review jurisdiction of the Administrative Review Tribunal. Now, for those who are interested, the Court held that the intention or state of mind of the repository of the power was not determinative because a purported exercise of power may be sufficient for there to be a decision in fact. And for that decision then to be capable of affecting rights or interests in a way that the Federal Merits Review Legislative Scheme intended could be assessed by the Tribunal.

So, the potential impacts of this upon administrative decision-making, I think, are very clear and other related, really interesting questions arise. In 2022, the Full Federal Court separately considered in Commissioner of Patents v Thaler [2022] FCAFC 62, whether a device characterised as an artificial intelligence machine could be considered to be an inventor within the meaning ascribed to that term in the patent sect or whether an inventor had an essentially human component. Adjacent to all of those observations, I think, are the recent events both locally and globally, including Robodebt and the British Post Office scandal demonstrate how dangerously alienating it is when individuals are subjected to depersonalised and additionally malfunctioning systems. That, again, is a question tied to legitimacy.

The third issue, I think, is that it will be imperative, and this flows from the second, to ensure adequate oversight of the use of AI. Public confidence will be undermined if institutions use AI without ensuring that all aspects of the process it’s undertaking are free from error and bias and the like. I think that the fourth and last is that it will be important to avoid overreliance on AI technologies. That is in part because of my beliefs about the essential humanity of law but recent events have also pretty emphatically shown, with the Outlook outage and the grounding of planes in the United States, and as of today, Apple being down, that aspects of our current economy and culture have a radical degree of digital dependence. Systems and processes can be brought to a sudden standstill in circumstances where we don’t diversify our operational avenues.

Moderator: It’s just incredible. We were hearing yesterday about people turning to artificial intelligence for financial advice. Now, they’re using it for legal advice as well and showing up in court. It’s amazing how quickly it’s moving.

Ruth Higgins: Yes, and I think in the context of legal advice, something that saddens me deeply about that is the circumstance in which that individual finds themselves is quite forlorn because they don’t have the resources to get legal advice. They think they’re getting legal assistance from a generative AI model and then they stand up in the Court of Appeal and are told kindly by kind judges – not attributing any of the blame to them – that it’s generative nonsense. There needs to be a process of civic education, I think, also for litigants, to say, “Don’t rely unquestioningly. Sense check it at some point with some human.”

Moderator: Yes, I mean, they’re doing themselves the ultimate injustice by doing that. Look, moving towards wrapping up now, unfortunately, but an observation, people sometimes observe that judges’ careers on the bench can be marked by changes in their approach and views. So, something about the nature of the role and the effect of the institution has an impact on them. Do you anticipate that your term as Solicitor General will change the way you conceive of and practise the law?

Ruth Higgins: Five months in, I suspect the answer to that question will only be discerned in the doing, to be frank. But, as I mentioned earlier, I studied philosophy of law in my PhD and have long believed that legal practice and legal theory are involved in a kind of continuing conversation, such that the things you think about affect the way that you act. As a result, I think that focusing principally on constitutional law and focusing on that through the lens of the Commonwealth, is likely to inform how I conceive of the law. It throws into sharp relief the practical reality that I referred to at the outset, that the law’s practical working in the lives of people is manifest every day. Law is ultimately about the exercise and control of power. The role is also, I think, likely to affect how I practise. The burden of my work will be appellate argument and that calls for slightly different skills in first instance work. But, as I indicated, I plan to keep my hand in first instance and intermediate work as well.

Moderator: Well, Dr Ruth Higgins, it’s been a wonderful opportunity to hear about your approach to this new role this morning. We appreciate you taking the time and we wish you all the best with that success rate. Please thank the Solicitor General of Australia. [Applause] And my co-MC, Hamish Macdonald, is standing by now for our next panel session, which will be looking at supporting resilient, effective and innovative operations. So, Hamish will be with you shortly.

Gallery

Plenary session 7: Supporting resilient, effective and innovative operations

  • Simone Constant, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Christine Holman, Non-Executive Director
  • Hamish Hansford, Head of National Security, Department of Home Affairs
  • Craig Drummond, Chair, Transurban
  • Jarrod Nink, Managing Director Australia, Equinix

Full audio (MP3 34.7 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: The next session, plenary number 7, if you’re looking for information in your guides, is all about supporting resilient, effective and innovative operations. Obviously as Australia’s critical infrastructure and essential services become more interconnected and tech dependent, operational resilience is increasingly important to maintaining trust and continuity. And certainly this morning when I arrived at work and all of the listeners were getting in touch about their Apple Pay, it was a good reminder of how quickly this is all moving.

We’ve got a really fantastic panel lined up for you to talk this morning, but to begin this conversation you’re actually going to hear from just one of the members of this discussion and that’s Christine Holman. So she’s going to deliver some thoughts, some remarks to I suppose open up the conversation, and then the panel will join us on the stage to expand on that.

For those of you who don’t know Christine Holman, she’s an experienced Non-Executive Director. She’s got broad leadership experience across technology, digital transformation, communications as well and consumer facing businesses. Her board work has included listed and private organisations. She’s got a focus on governance, strategy, risk, culture, organisational resilience, as you might imagine.

Now Christine brings a practical perspective to this conversation on how boards oversee complex operating environments and make investment choices under uncertainty. So to begin this conversation would you please welcome via the screen, Christine Holman.

c

Christine Holman: Thank you Hamish. I hope you can hear me. Good afternoon everyone, and thank you ASIC for the invitation to speak today. I am so sorry I can’t be there in person. In fact I’m speaking to you today from Melbourne courtesy of telco networks, data centres, power and platform providers, all working concurrently, that none of us actually control directly. We might take them for granted, unless of course they fail.

Only last Friday a Microsoft outage took down Outlooks and Teams around the world. For most of us an inconvenience, perhaps the day off, but few parts of our critical infrastructure would have escaped it, because so many now run on the same everyday tools. Parts of our wholesale funding markets, for example, still rely heavily on email and manual processes, and the same handful of global technology providers increasingly sit beneath our banks, brokers, super funds and market infrastructure itself. So perhaps a good place to start is what happens when critical interconnected market infrastructure does fail.

A year ago in Chicago CME Group, one of the world’s largest exchange operators, suffered a trading outage lasting more than 10 hours. The cause was not a cyber attack, it was a cooling failure at a third-party data centre. A single operational dependency such as a cooling failure disrupted major global markets.

Serving on ASIC’s inquiry into the ASX with Rob Whitfield and Guy Debelle over some nine months reinforced a different but equally uncomfortable truth, which is; serious infrastructure weaknesses accumulate over years through decisions about governance, investment, organisational capability and supervision, not just technology failures. And this is not just a financial markets problem, it applies wherever essential services depend on complex interconnected systems.

So my focus today is on two obligations we share. The first one is to restore confidence in the critical infrastructure we have, and the second is to establish a credible path to the infrastructure our markets and economy will need. So how do we do this? Well, I thought I’d draw out five lessons from the ASX inquiry and from international developments over the past 12 months.

The first lesson is that global benchmark has moved from having rules and controls to proving – proving – that critical services will withstand disruption and recover safely. In other words, we’ve got to stop confusing activity with progress. The question for boards and regulators is no longer, do we have a recovery plan? It should be, can we demonstrate safe recovery under extreme but plausible conditions with data that can be trusted, and can the market rely on the result? That starts with three steps; know what you’re protecting, agree which services must not fail, prioritise, prioritise those the market and the country cannot do without.

It is surprisingly easy to look in the wrong place. In fact, much of the public attention on the ASX has focused on CHESS, but Austraclear operating on a platform dating from 2006 settles more than 80 billion a day and underpins Australia’s wholesale debt markets, which funds our banks, governments and companies. Every organisation has an Austraclear, which is a critical system everyone relies on, but too few people discuss.

Find your Austraclear, rehearse recovery, not just response. If your board has never worked through a realistic crisis simulation, please do one now, then repeat it at least annually, if not twice a year. And importantly, test the outcomes, not whether everyone followed the script.

The third party concentration is a systemic risk, and that is the second lesson. On the 18th of November last year, Europe’s financial supervisors designated 19 critical technology providers for direct oversight under the Digital Operation Resilience Act, also known as DORA. In July this year, the UK designated AWS, Google Cloud, Microsoft and Oracle as its four critical third parties for direct oversight. Australia does not have, yet, an equivalent. No financial regulator can directly designate and oversee these providers.

Should Australia follow the EU and UK approach to direct oversight? Well, my answer is yes, starting with few providers whose failure would disrupt the whole economic system. Build on CPS 230 and our existing SOCI laws, but not a parallel regime.

And I think we need to remember that overseeing providers does not dilute the accountability of the firms that rely on them. Map your dependencies beyond your own organisation, including fault parties. Put data centres, telcos, energy providers and critical vendors in your exercises. Test that alternatives work, not just simply that they promise they will work. And their recovery plan should be part of yours.

The third lesson is that modernisation and innovation must go hand in hand. Market-wide change succeeds when responsibility is clear, milestones are credible, and difficult decisions are properly sequenced. Take settlement. The US moved to T+1 in May 2024 on a date set by the regulator, with close to 95% of trades subsequently affirmed on trade date. The EU and UK are moving towards T+1 in October ’27, and Australia remains on T+2, while CHESS release two is targeted for 2029.

Just to be clear, I’m not arguing for an arbitrary Australian deadline. I’m asking for a public decision point. Who determines readiness, on what evidence, and with what assessment of liquidity costs and system-wide dependencies? The same discipline applies within organisations. Set a target date to modernise critical legacy platforms, or plan their retirement and don’t wait before it’s too late. We saw some of this unfolding in the US airline systems over the weekend.

I’m often asked, how is a target state even possible when technology and market needs are changing so quickly? My answer is always the same. And that is, a target state defines what a critical service must be able to do. That is, it must recover safely, it must connect reliably, and scale and innovate as markets evolve. So in short, hold the destination, but redraw the route as necessary and invest in the capability to deliver it. That means experienced leaders and a deep bench of technical capability.

The ASX inquiry identified diminishing technical expertise and declining vendor support for legacy platforms. When knowledge becomes concentrated in too few people, it creates operational vulnerabilities and makes independent challenge harder.

But modernisation is not simply about fixing yesterday’s problems, which brings me to innovation. If I may say so, innovation tends to often be overused as a word or a phrase. Real innovation means anticipating what markets and customers will need next, while understanding, managing and pricing the risks and opportunities of change and the trade‑offs.

The DFCRC’s review of ASIC describes how tokenisation, new markets, architectures and AI are reshaping the boundaries between trading, clearing, settlement, custody and record keeping. These are potentially fundamental changes in market structures, not simply technology upgrades.

Central banks are actively shaping this future. The Eurosystem’s Pontes now delivers a pathway for tokenised transactions to settle in central bank money. Australia’s project Acacia has explored the potential of tokenised wholesale settlement. Notably, fixed income was the most important common use case, as I understand it, consistent with international experience. That should not surprise us. The wholesale debt market is central to funding our economy, yet the infrastructure beneath it rarely gets the attention it deserves.

However, the test for deployment must remain legal certainty, reliable settlement assets, interoperability, demonstrable benefits for market users, and dependable operational infrastructure. We cannot allow the need to remediate today’s infrastructure to become an excuse for neglecting tomorrow’s markets. Equally, we cannot pursue tomorrow’s innovations on foundations that are not resilient. That is the discipline, modernisation and innovation demand.

My fourth lesson is that commercial ownership of critical market infrastructure requires public interest stewardship, and no ownership model has a monopoly on good outcomes. Again, the ASX inquiry showed what happens when persistent underinvestment in core technology compromises resilience. Some will argue that this is inevitable tension for listed companies. Shareholders expect returns now, while critical infrastructure requires investment that pays off over decades.

But where monopoly services providers sit alongside competitive market participants, governance must confront the conflict transparently. True open access and interoperability, fair pricing and sustained investment in shared infrastructure must carry weight alongside the interests of shareholders. If you run a critical service Australians cannot do without, you are a steward, not just an operator. That responsibility cannot be delegated or traded away. Strategy, capital allocation, executive remuneration and shareholder returns must reflect that stewardship.

That brings me to boards. Frankly, the buck stops with us as directors. Boards need sufficient understanding to challenge assumptions, and sometimes I would argue that in most cases the devil is indeed in the detail. Seek second opinions and commission independent assurance from people who know how these systems operate, and bring real capital allocation discipline to the resource entrusted to us.

And the final lesson is that systemic resilience requires collective action and clear accountability, which essentially is about leadership across the system. As Hamish Hansford, whom you will hear from shortly, has put it so well, security shouldn’t be a competitive advantage. It should be a shared mission. A shared mission is not a shared excuse. Operators cannot hand their own responsibilities to government. Those licensed to operate critical services must demonstrate that they meet the obligations attached to those licences.

Equally, the ASX inquiry found that regulatory supervision practices had not delivered the desired outcomes. That criticism matters, because effective stewardship requires accountability on both sides of the supervisory relationship. Since then, and to the credit of government and the regulators, a great deal is underway. The risk now, however, is not inaction. It is fragmentation, with important initiatives moving at different speeds under different regimes, and no one accountable for the whole. And those who would attack our system will look precisely for these gaps and the weakest links.

The next task is to connect these efforts through an accountable national approach built on three things. First, a national blueprint which sets out what critical market infrastructure must be capable of over the next decade, the critical services that cannot fail and the disruption tolerances we can accept.

Second, we need explicit ownership of the decisions that fall between regulatory regimes. And finally, recurring Australian exercises that test the whole operating chain, including telcos, data centres, cloud providers, against extreme but plausible scenarios. The ultimate goal is recovery that is safe, coordinated, credible, and practiced. And importantly, the findings of those exercises must change investment decisions if needed, and supervision, not simply produce a report.

In closing, stewardship of critical market structure must be understood and demonstrated. Market infrastructure must be resilient, it must be governed in public interest, and continue to evolve to meet the changing needs of the market and economy.

This benchmark poses four tests for regulators, infrastructure operators, boards, and market participants. First, can our critical services today withstand severe disruption and recover with verified data integrity? Are shared third party and cross market dependencies really understood, tested, and effectively supervised? Are investment priorities, infrastructure reforms, and accountability arrangements aligned with the long-term interests of market users and financial stability? And is modernisation supported by transparent decisions, appropriate sequencing, and credible execution capability?

Australia held approximately $4.77 trillion in superannuation assets as of 30 June 2026. For those savings and for the international capital we seek to attract, trusted market infrastructure is an essential condition for confidence. It is not the only condition, but it is an indispensable one. They say that where there is a will, there is a way. Australia has never lacked the way. We have the talent, the capital, and the institutions. What we now need is the will, shared across government regulators, operators, and the market. 30 years ago that kind of shared will made our settlement system world leading. Parts of it still run on that design today. Let’s find that will again together, not just to catch up, but to lead. Thank you.

Moderator: Well, Christine’s given us plenty to talk about now. Would you please welcome to the stage our panel, Simone Constant, ASIC Commissioner; Hamish Hansford, who’s the Head of National Security at the Department of Home Affairs; Craig Drummond, the Chair of Transurban; and Jarrod Nink, the Managing Director at Equinix. Would you please give them all a very warm welcome.

Simone, I know you’re pouring a glass of water, but I do want to start with you, if that’s OK. There was a really interesting point that was made just then by Christine, that we need as a nation to agree on what must not fail. At the moment, do we?

Simone Constant: Agree on what must not fail?

Moderator: Yes.

Simone Constant: I think we do. I think we actually as a nation really understand critical national infrastructure. I mean, the number one message, I think, from Christine’s message then and that ASIC really reinforces, and I’m sure you’ll hear from Hamish, is that it’s very clear when it comes to critical national infrastructure who those entities are, and what they need to do.

I mean, what they need to do, it’s not as complicated as we might make it. It’s not about needing to be in glass wing. This isn’t just all about cyber. It’s not all about AI. It’s about having, firstly, at top of house, that critical national infrastructure mindset. Even boards representing shareholders, as Christine said, start from the perspective of that responsibility that you have, which is how they earn their money, having that responsibility, and make decisions that way.

Secondly, get the basics right. It might sound boring, we keep hearing it here, but resilience, as we heard from Christine, it’s not just about tech or mythos. It’s actually about capital that’s sound, liquidity that’s available if there’s a shock, tech that’s integrated and runs with consistent outcomes, and effective decision-making within that.

So one other thing I’d say is actually I think we do know in Australia, Australia is a nation-building nation, right? We really do build and deliver infrastructure. And what Christine’s message is, is that resilience shouldn’t be seen as a tax. It should be seen as an investment. It’s an investment in the base case years. It’s how they earn their returns if you run infrastructure. But it’s also the base, and that’s what she was challenging us to. It’s the base in a crisis or a stress, which is what we keep hearing we’re in the last two days. It’s the base to thrive. It’s the trust foundation to thrive.

And I’ve heard that in Christine’s speech. Last night in this room, there was some people who run very important infrastructure here saying, if we invest and have that resilience, we can actually win in whatever crisis is coming and win the decade. That’s long term thinking, which I think Australia in infrastructure does have.

Moderator: I don’t want to overstate what Christine was saying, but I thought she was also raising a challenge to boards to say, question yourselves about whether you are taking yourselves seriously enough as a critical part of our ecosystem here.

Simone Constant: Yes.

Moderator: To me, that would infer that not everyone that is in that list necessarily sees themselves as part of that picture.

Simone Constant: I think that’s absolutely fair. So whereas you ask do we understand at ASIC, do we think as part of this national system, we know what critical infrastructure is and what the expectations are? It’s absolutely fair that there’s inconsistency, and that’s what concerns us, in terms of how boards – and just to reiterate, we communicate to boards on this, because this has got to be top down, top led, in how they see that and how they show up.

One of our number one concerns at the moment is that, yes, there’s a lot of awareness about resilience as a thing, but there can be both confusion about what resilience is. As we keep saying, it’s about a lot more than just your tech or your cyber.

And also the concern is that awareness doesn’t flip into action. So we’ve tried at ASIC to be quite practical in the way we communicate broad or deep or the way we respond. An example is Christine worked with us on the ASX inquiry. One of the reasons that we did something different that we’d not done before in calling the ASX inquiry is because the resilience challenge is there, there were new challenges, but they were critical in terms of infrastructure. We needed a new approach.

So we called the inquiry. It diagnosed a range of problems that really go to resilience. And even in our regulatory response, we did things like imposed a capital overlay, which we’d never done before, because these are new challenges that require new responses and new thinking. That’s our challenge to boards, right? You don’t have to have the perfect tech or the perfect access. It’s about the way they’re taking the decisions.

Moderator: So Hamish Hansford, I wonder how you view this. Department of Home Affairs, you’re looking at national security risks and exposure. Are there businesses, big businesses, are there people in this room that may not be taking this seriously enough?

Hamish Hansford: There sure are. And I think we start from the premise that for the last half decade, Australia has been mapping critical infrastructure, looking at the main suppliers. And to answer your first question, we now have 220 systems that fundamentally run the country. We’ve declared them, we’ve regulated them, and we’re one of the few countries in the world that has done that mapping and actually set up a regime to bring them together to collaborate. We met last week, we meet every quarter. And so at a macro level, we’ve identified what’s important.

But equally, in every boardroom and in every company and in every government agency, we can always do more. And I think the challenge that we have is, given how quickly the threats are moving, there is no chance that regulation can keep up with the pace of the threats. Which gets to the point of regulation is the base and really the things that you must by law do. But the best boardrooms in the country are thinking in a much more curious sense about what’s possible.

And they’ve changed the dimension, not from saying that risk and security are add-ons, but they’re actually fundamental enablers. I kind of think of it like, why do race cars have exceptionally good brakes? It’s not so they can go slower, it’s so they can go faster, they can dive into a corner at record speed and tap the brake at the last minute. And so actually making a business or a government agency much more productive requires us to think in a completely different way, and to be much more curious and get ahead of the threat.

Moderator: One of the things that I think has been interesting about the conversation in the last week, since the news of Jensen Huang at NVIDIA, has been about the relationship between national security and the commercial sector. And the point’s been made to me a few times that in the United States, big businesses are used to government taking care of national security threats. But up and down the supply chain, now we can see that there’s risk and exposure, and that’s forcing quite a complicated conversation about what the responsibility is of private business in that national security realm. What’s your view of where the responsibility sits?

Hamish Hansford: Well, our view is that it is always a shared responsibility, and what has fundamentally changed is companies like NVIDIA are now the size of some nation-states, and have the tools that once were vested in offensive operations in governments. Those tools are now in the private sector and have immense power.

And not only do we start from the premise that every security issue in a company can then have ramifications for the nation, if you change the scale and size and potency of the tools that are being developed globally, it changes the security dimension and dynamic. And so it is absolutely imperative for not only the private sector to get involved in security issues by protecting themselves first, but actually thinking about the contribution that each individual action has to a nation and to broader security.

Moderator: But isn’t something like espionage the responsibility of government?

Hamish Hansford: Espionage is a responsibility from everyone who has something to protect. And so if you have commercial secrets, if you have the blueprints for an infrastructure asset, all of those things are commercially sensitive. But if you had a blueprint given to an adversary, they know exactly the way in which to attack your infrastructure asset or business. And so it forms part of the nation’s security. And everything that you hold commercially sensitive can be used by an adversary to attack not only a company, but equally to undermine our national security.

Simone Constant: I just wanted to really reinforce that. I mean, obviously, Hamish and I have different professional responsibilities, but both within the Commonwealth. He’s talked about from the national security responsibility, but also as a director of a company. When I spoke about resilience shouldn’t be seen as a tax, it’s an investment, it’s an investment in base case conditions in terms of protecting your licence to be earning that revenue, that licence that allows you to operate that critical infrastructure.

Also, in a crisis situation, and at the moment, we’re seeing some real disruption of big companies, if you’re the resilient one that has all those foundations, like protects your information, knows how you take decisions, thinks about insider threat, then actually you can pull away, you can thrive. That’s directors meeting their responsibilities to shareholders in meeting their responsibilities to the country for the infrastructure. They’re not misaligned.

Moderator: Craig Drummond, I’m interested to hear how you’re hearing this conversation. I know Transurban is big, not quite as big as a nation-state, like some of the businesses we’ve been discussing, but how do you view the descriptions that you’re hearing that the regulation is the baseline, that there’s opportunity there to go beyond that?

Craig Drummond: Hamish, we always start with the customer and the consumer, and what are their expectations of us as a business. It goes from there as to the sort of priorities we have in the boardroom. There’s been a lot said about cyber, and cyber is on every – I’d be pretty confident saying every ASX 100 would have cyber as a standing agenda item, and every director would be not the first, but maybe the second to ask their CISO and others, have you got appropriate resourcing? Have you got the appropriate resourcing? Are we patching?

All of those issues, but a lot of it comes back also as a board to, because we’re part time, not full time, we’re there for a governance role, it’s the quality of the reporting, it’s the quality of the people, it’s the quality of your first line, your second line, your third line, your external reviews, and then the quality of your board. So is your board remaining current, up to date, capable?

There is no such thing, for example, if we’re talking about cyber, as a technology director, in my view. Every director around that room has an obligation, as they do on the financials, to understand to the best of their capability what sort of questions and where they should be probing, and indeed probing the Chief Executive whether he or she have got the right people on their team, not just technology, it goes to other operational risks. Then you go back to prioritisation.

Moderator: Can I just pick you up on that though, because you’re sort of talking about quality of people and what that brings to the conversation. We heard from Hamish an argument that there’s no way regulation can keep up with the pace of the change and the evolving threat. Simone was making the point though that ultimately you’ve got to get back to the basics here.

We are in a world though where the existing frameworks, the legislative frameworks, can’t necessarily be applied to the technology that’s in front of us, and through which the threat is being delivered. So how can you possibly be certain at a board level that you’re on top of it if governments can’t necessarily be on top of it?

Craig Drummond: I think the first port of call is, as I said, I go back to the capability and quality of the executive, and that’s the first port of call. I go back to the capability and quality and readiness of the board. I go back to the type of conversation we’re having. I go back to the budget.

Because one of the challenges that I think about and we worry about is you look at the world and the challenges that we have in the world at the moment. Efficiency and resilience could be seen to be at times in conflict, and that would be a disaster obviously for, we’re talking about infrastructure, and that’s not the way we think, but I’m thinking about the broader economy and looking how challenging it is.

Are all corporations, all organisations, government, every government’s under financial stress and pressure as well, are we doing the requisite investment? It therefore comes back very clearly to prioritisation, and are you making the right judgements? And that is about having the right people around the room, both an executive and a board, and making those key decisions.

Moderator: So that’s an interesting binary you’re setting up. I don’t know whether you mean it to be a binary, but efficiency versus resilience,, and Jarrod that’s something I wanted to ask you about, because it came up in Christine’s remarks. Innovation, and whether both the consumers are ready for that, whether that creates risks and dependencies within supply chains, this must be hard to grapple with I imagine.

Jarrod Nink: Yeah look, thanks Hamish. As a provider of critical infrastructure services in Australia for the last 25 years, it’s something that, and it goes back to Alastair’s comments last night, where if you have trust you have nothing. And you need to make sure, we have lots of legislation, you need to make sure that as a minimum compliance is addressed, but that doesn’t get you trust. It’s how you evolve that, it’s how you go above and beyond to maintain customer trust for some of the most critical workloads across government and businesses in Australia.

So does that mean we can’t innovate? No I don’t think so. Because a kind of a quick history lesson on Equinix; we were formed about 30 years ago, when we were trying to solve a problem where all of these telco networks were in different places, and to connect into an ISP, you then had to go to the telco, open up access, go into their facility, move the services back to your facility, and then connect to businesses.

And Equinix founders went and said, well, why don’t we locate in a central, independent, highly secure, highly connected environment, and that formed this co-location model. And then from there banks came in and said, oh, look, this is interesting, because we want to come together and be closer to stock exchanges. And then clouds came in and said, look, we want to be close to where financial transactions are happening in our enterprises workloads are happening.

So we had this this legacy of innovation and thinking about how we can deliver services that increase visibility for our customers, security for our customers, recovery in the times of outage, in terms of portability of workloads across different geographic locations. So I think while at our core, essential, sorry, critical infrastructure providers need to make sure they maintain that trust, but you achieve that through new services as well.

Moderator: But if the consumer doesn’t have trust in the innovation because it’s happened too quickly, or it’s proved to be likely to fail, you’ve got a problem don’t you?

Jarrod Nink: Absolutely, yes. So when I think about innovation that increases opaqueness of what’s going on behind the scenes, or adds too much complexity, or is just difficult to audit, those sorts of innovations don’t stand up to that sort of scrutiny.

Moderator: Hamish Hansford, I noticed in preparing for this that I think you’d warned not very long ago about our reliance on Microsoft Outlook, for example. How many weeks ago was that?

Hamish Hansford: It was in August on a podcast for InnovationAus, yes.

Moderator: Yeah, OK. Do you want to say I told you so, or –?

Hamish Hansford: Well, you can always be prescient, can’t you? But I think we’ve looked across the economy, and actually there’s about 10 to 15 companies, multinational companies that fundamentally run Australia. Microsoft is one of those, which is why we’ve gone about saying we need a digital resilience agreement with each of those companies, and we’ve got one with Microsoft and we enacted it on Friday, and we were prepared for every eventuality, and I think it’s going to be the future.

Moderator: You were?

Hamish Hansford: We were, yeah.

Moderator: OK, can you explain what that looked like in practice?

Hamish Hansford: The digital resilience agreement we have with Microsoft is not only an annual dialogue about what happens if something goes wrong, who do we contact, what are the procedures for the economy. And what we wanted to do is put Australia at the front of the queue to be able to deal with Microsoft so we’re an easier customer if you like, but equally to be able to respond quickly.

And so we stood up our national coordination mechanism very quickly on Friday, we understood what was happening in Microsoft, we were very much connected into their operations room, and were working with them in a collaborative way. That’s the way that we’d like to deal with any crisis in the economy.

Moderator: OK, that’s very interesting to hear, and that worked effectively on Friday did it?

Hamish Hansford: Well obviously Microsoft had some pretty significant challenges, but we recognise that that’s going to be the future of disruption in the economy. We’re going to have to move from a situation where we’ve effectively relied on 24/7 availability for a whole lot of services, given the pace of frontier AI and the vulnerabilities they’re finding. You saw a couple of weeks ago we took down websites, patched them and put them back up. I think this disruption is going to continue over the next 12 to 24 months.

Moderator: So Simone, we’re talking about that in the context of trust, consumer trust. Something I would observe is that in a lot of these recent cases the explanation is pretty mundane. Whether we’re talking about airline chaos in the United States or Microsoft or other recent examples, the public doesn’t seem particularly convinced.

Simone Constant: Yeah, actually that sounds like a simple question but there’s a lot in it.

Moderator: Yeah, OK, I want to hear what you think.

Simone Constant: So one part of what we’re hearing, what you and I are hearing, including from private operators, private sector operators, is probably what we’d like to hear at ASIC, which is trust is that currency that customer facing businesses need in order to keep earning their revenue and delivering for shareholders. So that’s a big part of our message, and if innovation is done wrongly, and certainly if resilience is disrupted and shown to not be there, that trust is lost. So that’s part of the message. Where you’re talking about the communications afterwards.

Moderator: Well, not just afterwards but in the middle of it?

Simone Constant: Well, in the event. Interestingly, one of the things that we say, because you’ve been asking the question, but how do you keep up, right? Because innovation is changing, the technology is changing. When we say get the basics right, one of the things we say is we’re not going to sue you because you had an incident, because you got disrupted. What we might take an action about is if you didn’t prepare for it, if you didn’t think about it, if you didn’t do your best to have sound capital and tech programs that can respond, but also the right decision-making, and the right crisis response plan that you’ve tested. And as part of that, those communications, have you got the communications?

And I think people have been, like it came up yesterday as well, Alan said it, Commissioner Kirkland said it, humans are incredibly resilient and understanding when they need to be. Look at COVID, look what we all did in the ultimate crisis. We were all doing very different things. I went and ran education services for a few months, like we all did different things to respond.

People will be understanding if they’re told the truth, they understand why, and it’s clear what the prioritisation approach is, and that actually their highest and most important need by the private sector or the public sector is indeed being put at the centre. And that’s the nature; honest, transparent communications that think – and we heard customer centric already today – that think about what those customers need most of all. That’s part of the communications, if that’s the basis of it, and it’s honest, then that’s what we ask for.

Moderator: I imagine what you just mentioned there might be a pretty common fear; are we going to get sued by ASIC, are we going to get taken on by ASIC? How much does the inclination to protect as the thing’s unfolding, presumably as it’s happening, you don’t know what you didn’t do, what you did do, you don’t know whether it was your fault or someone else’s, how much does that instinct to protect the institution, shape the way in which they communicate and be honest in the moment?

Simone Constant: Yeah, it’s a challenge. It’s disappointing when that overwhelms I think the right customer centric response and approach. I think it’s dissipating. I’ve been in this job for three years, I saw more of that when I first came into the role. And it’s disappointing when you see law firm websites that will say, oh, if you had a crisis event, first thing you do is call us. Probably no. Like that’s important alongside all the other things you should be doing, including thinking of your customers.

I think there’s a trust that has built, a level of trust, the collective responsibility that’s built across the system. We’ve done a lot of work at ASIC alongside APRA and Home Affairs and ASD and others to work particularly across financial services, and bring together round tables and have open discussions about these things.

And I think that’s important Hamish. Because when you actually have these crises, whatever it is, like if it’s a guilt crisis in financial markets, or a health crisis in COVID, or it’s a cyber crisis with outage, so there’s not going to be a perfect playbook. It’ll come down, do you have the information, do you have the right decision-making. And now unfortunately with frontier AI, sometimes decision-making has to be machine speed to keep up, so do you have the right delegations?

And do you have that communication? So we talked about communication with customers. It’s also communication with regulators and with folks who are reliant on you. So we need to keep developing those muscles, we need to see them in those BCP plans, and we need to see, we want to see directors thinking about things that way. As long as they’ve got a clear governance structure and escalation decision-making framework, they understand priorities, they understand the critical services that people just want to know are going to be back up when they can be, then we don’t fault that.

Moderator: Craig Drummond, I don’t know whether you can take your Chair of Transurban hat off for a moment. In a crisis you’re responsible for a piece of critical infrastructure, what’s the best case scenario response, what does it look like?

Craig Drummond: Well, I think the challenge is working out exactly what the issue is. I think the best response is over-communication, that’s the starting point. Over-communicating with all of your government stakeholders, your regulators, if you’re listed, your market, whether it’s ASIC, ASX. All of that communication, I think under-communication, and I understand why it’s sometimes complex because you probably don’t know the core of what you’re actually dealing with, so you’ve got to be very careful as well.

Because class action is clearly a very, it’s a prominent landscape for class action activity in the marketplace. So I understand from a director’s point of view why they are very careful, but equally you can be careful and still communicative, particularly with your key government and regulatory stakeholders and I think that needs to be an immediate –

Moderator: What about with the public?

Craig Drummond: Sorry?

Moderator: What about with the public?

Craig Drummond: Well, I think you always put, as I said before, you always have to put your customer first in all of those communications. But you equally don’t want to mislead your customers and cause unnecessary panic. So there is a balance, it will depend on the circumstance. But I think the core message is over-communicate.

Moderator: Interesting. Jarrod, how do you think about that?

Jarrod Nink: Look, I think in terms of what Christine said earlier about being a steward as a critical infrastructure provider is really important. You’re not just an operator, there’s a wider obligation. And my practical advice to probably everyone in the room is practice it, so you can have the world’s best plan for crisis management, and I’m not joking, I did not stage this, I’m actually off to a crisis management exercise this afternoon.

But practicing. The risks evolve over time, they’re going to continue to evolve over time, they’re not static, the risks we face today and going forward. You can have the best plan unless you practice it and evolve it for what’s temperate at the time, you’re not going to be able to stare into that kind of crisis as well as you otherwise could.

Moderator: I thought it was interesting when Christine was mentioning that, and she talked about continuing to do crisis simulations, and not assuming that because you’ve got the backup that it will work, actually test that. But how do you do that in an environment where in the last 24 hours we’ve been talking about rolling crises, poly-crisis, multifaceted crises? How do you do the crisis simulation in a way that doesn’t just take up your entire calendar, but deals with that poly-crisis nature of the world today?

Jarrod Nink: Yeah, that’s a big one. So there’s lots of things, like how do you equip your crisis management team with the right tools, because it could be a certain provider is out, and do you have multiple connectivity options for the crisis management team to come together?

It’s about having the right operational staff who can lean into if it’s a technical issue or a cyber issue, how that works, how that’s been diagnosed. And then it’s things like having really strong links into the relevant government agents to be able to call them from speed dial to kind of update them on what’s going on in the crisis. And then bring together whatever learnings you can from industry but from other government departments and intelligent sharing, that’s another key one with critical infrastructure providers, being very open to sharing best practice on what’s working, what’s not.

Moderator: Amongst each other, or you –

Jarrod Nink: Amongst each other, yeah, and that happens, I think that happens quite well in Australia with the information sharing that happens between government and critical infrastructure providers.

Moderator: Hamish Hansford, what would help you deal with a crisis better in terms of your interactions with people who oversee critical infrastructure?

Hamish Hansford: Well, if the first phone call people are making is in a crisis, that’s the starting point. We’d much rather engage collaboratively, do exercises, think about best practice. And the government is using its convening power so much more than we ever have to convene industry in small group sessions, in trusted information, sharing networks, in exercises. We’ve held a number over the last fortnight. So actually having that dialogue and engagement up front is so much better than coming to a crisis and you’re making a phone call.

And it’s helpful on both sides because we better understand infrastructure, and they better understand who in government can help during a crisis. And we can work through all of the situations. I remember in one particular exercise a company turned to me and said, “Who do I call to pay the ransom?” And I said, “Well, you’re not going to pay the ransom are you?” and they said, “We’ll just call the PM” And so trying to work through those issues in the middle of an exercise is so much easier than dealing with it in real life, and I think that’s got to be the mantra.

Moderator: Can you expand on that a little bit? Because I mean it’s often a point of friction that we hear about, that some businesses do want to just go and pay the ransom and deal with it, and governments have a very different view of that, in fact I think the law does, so has our collective understanding of our approach evolved, do we agree on this?

Hamish Hansford: Well I think we start from the premise that if you pay a ransom you’re paying a criminal, and you’re enriching a criminal enterprise that will only get more sophisticated, which will make the attacks worse. So we’ve dealt with so many companies who don’t pay a ransom, and immediately it is much more difficult to work through the challenge, they might have locked up systems or data. But ultimately you build a higher level of trust I think with customers, with government, if you go through that process and actually say how do we not pay criminals, and how do we work through the issue in a much more methodical way?

Moderator: But are there instances where paying the ransom makes the problem go away quite quickly?

Hamish Hansford: Well, obviously if you pay a ransom you can have systems unlocked. But we’ve seen so many examples of double ransom, where people pay money and then get double extorted. And so there is no guarantee that by paying a criminal they’re going to actually help you, and maybe that’s the nature of criminals. They don’t really agree with our rule of law do they?

And so we’ve set up a ransomware reporting regime and unfortunately we’ve had 200 reports where 35 companies or businesses have actually paid the ransom. And so we’re trying to get to the bottom of what does that look like, how do we think about getting and really looking at those factors that led people to pay the ransom, and really working through that methodically.

Moderator: So does calling the PM work?

Hamish Hansford: Well, I’m not sure if that’s a great strategy.

Moderator: Simone, there’s such a kind of array of things that I imagine keep everyone awake at night worrying about. Of the kind of threat spectrum, what is it for you that at the moment is weighing most heavily?

Simone Constant: Well, I think about our responsibilities in probably three buckets. So I think the first bucket would be more broadly across the economy, so because we are the conduct and companies regulator more broadly. So that’s why when we communicated about frontier AI we wrote an open letter across the economy, to boards across the economy, because it’s got to be driven from the board top down. But in that broader setting the concern would be it’s a broad church, there’s a lot of inter-reliance and how quickly will we move from awareness to action and not have that kind of learned helplessness, government help us.

Coming down though to where it’s more acute, what worries us? Well, across the financial services sector where we sit alongside APRA, and to some degree RBA, there’s been excellent momentum, also need to turn it into action. But there and probably most acute, and I’ll turn to ASX for example and market operators in a moment, the concerns there are probably more specific.

That point about like resilience is not a tax, it’s an investment, if companies are not, and financial services companies are not making that investment when the times have been good or benign. And at the moment we were talking yesterday in a different capacity, right, about the tide going out, the liquidity tide going out, and there’s a bit of stress and there’s not as much money around, goodness knows what we’re going to see that lurks beneath when it’s harder to get that investment. I’m not saying that that is a particular issue for broadly in financial services, but that if there has been underinvestment then goodness knows there better be quick move to action.

And then finally of course ASIC has lead responsibility as regulator for market operations financial markets infrastructure. As Christine said, that is critical markets infrastructure. So if ASX and its peers do not have the right capital to absorb loss, do not have liquidity there, if there’s an incident they need it, they don’t have the right tech that’s integrated and they don’t have sound governance and operational risk management practices, including good decision-making and the prioritisation that Craig said, that would literally keep me up at night, and it has. We had an outage, we had an outage pre-Christmas nearly two years ago. It absolutely kept me up all that night trying to work through it, because that’s the nature of critical infrastructure.

Moderator: I just wonder if you could, I want to pick up on something you said just then about writing to the boards after the OpenAI breach. The government conducted their short sharp review, and at the end of that concluded that the existing legislation couldn’t be applied to what had occurred. How then as a regulator are you communicating with boards in a context where it’s precisely what Hamish described earlier, where the regulation isn’t keeping up with the reality on the ground?

Simone Constant: I think it’s slightly easier for us, because a lot of the laws we’ve got are good laws for what we need. So what do I mean by that? You look at directors and their responsibilities to shareholders. As we keep saying, I think everyone has said from different perspectives, being responsible to your shareholder, if you’re critical infrastructure, means maintaining that licence and it means coming through and doing the right thing by customers. In the base case, keeping your licence by doing the right things and being resilient, when there’s a crisis coming through and communicating and putting the customer at the centre.

On the other hand when we think about investment or what I just spoke about then, concern about is there enough investment, is there the right investment in resilience in financial markets infrastructure? We have a lot of powers. We used them recently for ASX inquiry, diagnosed a range of problems, and to be fair to ASX they made commitments to address them and we put a capital overlay on. We put a $150 million capital overlay against those integrated plan of operational commitments to be resilient and strong.

So yes there are challenges, and I’m sure my colleagues or peers on the panel will talk about those. But there are some very good and strong laws, and to just really reiterate there are some really excellent directors and some companies here who are really grasping it within the laws we have.

Moderator: But you’re putting a lot of pressure on the individuals that are on the boards right. Are they reasonable in thinking, well, hang on, the government’s scrambling here to get the law to keep up with the unfolding threat, and yet we’ve got the regulator pushing us to say you can’t let your shareholders down or your consumers down.

Simone Constant: I don’t think it’s appropriate for ASIC to comment on government policy on AI more broadly. All we can comment on and all I’m commenting on is our powers and responsibilities with markets infrastructure, and our powers more broadly in financial services and in corporate governance. And in that remit it actually gets better all the time. In the same way customers are beginning to understand there will be outages in this digital age, we’ve seen that, we also see faster responses from directors, and all different, not just banks who’ve been doing this for a while.

When I first turned up as an ASIC Commissioner I put out a report about scams and fraud and cyber risks in super, and saying, look, here’s some lessons we’ve done some testing, you should learn some lessons quickly from banks, because you’ve got some real vulnerabilities. It didn’t get well received. This is nearly two years ago. It was, oh, we’re not banks, we’re super.

OK, there was an incident a couple of months later which showed that they did have their challenges. But fast forward a year on and actually that industry and the directors in that industry say, please can you give us more, please can we be part of the roundtables, how can we learn from banks and government? I think in the corporate sector and in the financial services sector amongst board tables and executive leadership teams there’s an understanding that these are their core responsibilities to customers and company.

Moderator: I think this session is going to give a lot of people a lot to think about. So I’m kind of curious, Craig Drummond, what you think about in terms of unseen dependencies. Where’s the exposure, what’s the stuff that maybe isn’t talked about as much?

Craig Drummond: Well, I think COVID taught us a fair bit. We weren’t thinking about supply chains to the extent that we should have been. We weren’t thinking outside financial institutions, which have had great supervision from APRA around third-party dependencies. I think non-bank, non‑financial institutions have had historically less thought and given less thought to third-party dependency. And I think COVID was a huge wake-up call for non-bank financial institutions, or non-bank institutions like large public companies that haven’t had that scrutiny.

So I think that’s been a massive, as I said, a massive wake-up call, and we’re not quite at the standard of the work that financial institutions do on scrutiny of third-party, but gee it’s changed a lot in my observation. But that remains I think one of the bigger vulnerabilities in the community, is reliance and over-reliance on third-party institutions.

Moderator: Are you agreeing, you observed that that has changed substantially since then?

Simone Constant: Well, it’s no accident that today we invited a data centre to be on the panel to be able to speak for themselves. They’re not a financial services institution in the traditional sense, but goodness we’re dependent on them. As are government. Government are dependent on them as well.

It is a really important question we are looking at closely alongside others in government, alongside industry third parties. Christine gave a view, she gave a view what she thinks should happen there. Third parties are to some degree within remit already, caught by laws, caught by SOCI, and Hamish can talk to that. But absolutely within the Council of Financial Regulators sphere, that third-party dependency is something where we are really thinking about, is there going to be evolution there?

Moderator: Hamish do you want to try?

Hamish Hansford: There’s no doubt that supply chains and third-party risk is increasing. But what hasn’t changed is the fundamental premise that what materially makes a business function, that hasn’t changed. and the very first kind of thing I think that people should be asking is, to what extent do I rely on third-party, and how do I put in layers of mitigation?

We saw during the CrowdStrike incident for example that people were reaching right into the heart or the kernel of organisations. How did that happen? How did people let that happen? How might that be configured in a different way? So I think there’s multiple ways to think about the supply chain, not only as a material supplier, but how are they deployed in an organisation? Who are the people that run it, and how do I mitigate, and what are those layers of mitigation?

Moderator: So that obviously requires some fairly focused work in the aftermath to make sure you understand what’s happened, right?

Hamish Hansford: Well, that’s the worst case scenario. The best case scenario is a risk mitigation strategy isn’t just a perfect bow tie sitting on a shelf. It’s actually been operationally deployed and tested, and so where the fault lines are and what happens if something goes wrong. I think people should ask the fundamental question about, what would happen if this didn’t exist? This could be a material supplier, a person, or indeed an organisation itself.

Moderator: I wondered, given that we were talking before about organisations sharing intelligence and information, obviously you were talking about the desire to have the conversation well ahead of the incident occurring, are organisations then asking you to be more transparent with them about the nature of the threat?

Hamish Hansford: Yeah, absolutely. And we have had so much demand, a bit like Simone, going out and talking to boards and organisations. We’ve cleared private sector entities to come in and give them a threat briefing. We did that last week. We brought ASIO into our Critical Infrastructure Advisory Council last week to talk about the threat. We are doing everything we can to try and communicate the key threats for business.

But equally organisations have a really good understanding about risk in and of themselves, and so it is always an understanding about together what does risk look like? And in the last month I’ve published a Critical Infrastructure Annual Risk Review, which puts out here are the key risks that we’ve seen in the last 12 months, and I’d recommend that publication for everyone here.

Moderator: Given your record with Microsoft, anything you want people to particularly look for in that report?

Hamish Hansford: Well, headlines are AI fundamentally changing the way we think about risk, moving from risk as a concept to operational implementation. And then we have a bunch of information about supply chain interdependency. They’re the things that we’ve really got to grapple with.

Moderator: It’s been a bit alarming but fascinating to talk to you all this afternoon. I know everyone wants lunch so that’s about to get underway, but would you please thank Simone Constant, Christine Holman who was here earlier, Hamish Hansford, Craig Drummond and Jarrod Nink.

Gallery

Plenary session 8: Discussion in the boardroom – a director’s perspective

  • Kate O’Rourke, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Paul O’Malley, Chair, Commonwealth Bank
  • Naomi Edwards, Chair, Australian Institute of Company Directors
  • Rebecca Maslen-Stannage, Chair and Senior Partner, Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer

Full audio (MP3 47.6 MB)

Transcript

Amelia Brace: Good afternoon. I hope that you enjoyed your lunch, welcome back. We are now going to start our last session of this year’s forum, it’s certainly gone quickly. Let’s not waste any time and get straight into our next panel discussion which is titled, ‘Discussions in the boardroom, a director’s perspective.’ Joining us is ASIC Commissioner, Kate O’Rourke, Naomi Edwards, Chair of the Australian Institute of Company Directors, Rebecca Maslen-Stannage, Chair and Senior Partner at Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer and Paul O’Malley, Chair of the Commonwealth Bank. The panel will discuss what strong board leadership looks like in times of stress, including how directors test management assumptions, maintain trust with customers and the market, and support accountability and high standards of governance.

Thank you all for joining us this afternoon, we know that you’re busy and really appreciate it. There’s been so much discussion already ahead of this panel. I thought it might be good to focus in on this board perspective and get a take from each of you, on what you think the global and macro issues are, that boards are currently focused on. Paul, we might start with you.

Paul O’Malley: Sure. It’s getting the balance right today where there is so much uncertainty. If you look locally first, cost of living crisis, uncertainty around technological change. Then as you look more broadly, as AI develops, cyber security issues, geopolitical focus where we’re evolving back into political blocks again. Or geopolitical blocks for those of us who are younger in the 60s, 70s and 80s when you had the Berlin wall. It broke down. We’ve had 30 years where globalisation has been a real positive and now there’s a real question mark. So as a board, how do you take that totality of the challenge of doing what the company has to do well, call it the basics. But it’s more than the basics because most companies are very complicated and there’s a lot to run.

But if you take CBA for instance, I’m going to just make sure I get the facts right, we process 25 million payments a day. We block 52,000 payments for suspected fraud and we reclaim about a million dollars day from money that’s been scammed. We settle 600 homes. We lend daily, $135 million to business. But we also support customers on a typical day, with about 500 tailored payment arrangements. So the job of running a business in Australia and getting, and I’ll call those the basics right, involves technology, people, understanding customers, meeting all of our requirements. Whether it’s our own requirements or external requirements, it’s an incredible focus for a board. You could get lost in just focusing on that. But you must focus on it, because you must do it really, really well.

Then you have the geopolitical focus and we’re very lucky to have directors from Europe on our board. They talk about resilience which I know was talked about earlier, with the Russia Ukraine conflict which is real. The resilience of a business or an industry where there are institutional attacks on infrastructure within a country, the interaction between company leadership and company boards, regulators and the political and public service, all of those politicians, public service is absolutely necessary. Without all aspects of a country working together, resilience can’t be dealt with. We’re talking about how to do that better and from a financial institution perspective, CPS 230 I think is a very good thing. How do we broaden that, how do we actually run crises exercises to deal with that? That’s something that the board talks about.

Then business model, business models change. Banking, it used to be a hundred per cent physical. We’d go into a branch. We’d have our passport, we’d either deposit money or take money or ask for a loan. Today 90 odd per cent of customers want to engage digitally. They want the option of going to a physical branch and particularly in regional areas. So you’ve got that balance of how do you actually meet your customers where they want to be. But also, where society wants you to meet those options. We’ve also got the ability now through technology for companies to set up in one jurisdiction and operate in another jurisdiction, without a physical presence, without a tax base.

So how do we think about business models going forward. From our board perspective, we’ve looked back 30 years as to what’s changed. It’s incredible and we’re trying to forecast forward 30 years. We struggle with 24 months, but forecasting forward 30 years as to how one prepares a company to focus on that strategic change, when there is so much at play. I’ll just finish on the perspective is, one can’t get it right. So then you come back to really simple things like have you got the right balance sheet, have you got the right financial settings, have you got the right risk settings. Most importantly, have you got the right people and are you developing the right people. You can’t do anything without good people with the right values, behaviours, the right frameworks around them and the right development.

So it’s never been more difficult. The very last point is things are changing at a speed today that is unfathomable. If you take frontier AI models, what they’re able to do today versus six months ago, versus 12 months ago, is incredible. So as you forecast forward 30 years, we’ve got to forecast for six or 12 months to make sure in particular with cyber, that we’ve actually pivoted the organisation to focus on a risk that one might not see. But if you don’t protect against, we’ll absolutely see. So really complicated for boards, really complicated for regulators, politicians and public servants. It is not easy at the moment. Working together I think will get us all a better answer.

Amelia Brace: Yes, the pace of change is incredible. Naomi, from a company director’s perspective, what do you think is top of the agenda at the moment?

Naomi Edwards: Thank you Amelia. Well as it happens, we released our Director Sentiment Index last night which surveys our 55,000 members. It was very interesting and this won’t come as any surprise to those of you who were here yesterday for some of the sessions. But not only was the sentiment the worst on record, it had fallen by 18 points down to minus 42, in terms of views about the external environment, which is where it was until three months into full national lockdown. So all that’s saying is directors are not immune to the things that are affecting the rest of the societies, as they shouldn’t be.

There were some very interesting positive things in there though. So with regard to AI for example, previously when we’ve said what actual productivity are you seeing in your companies? People were talking about pilots and individual productivity. This year, so just out yesterday, we had that 48% of directors are saying that they have experienced a productivity uplift in their company in the last 12 months, as a result of AI. They talk furthermore, most of that was about reorganising and reshaping the way processes work, as opposed to redundancies or other things. So we’re definitely seeing that starting to buy which is really positive.

On the other hand though, it is a saying, they’re very aware that the social licence around the use of AI is low and probably falling I’m sure. We’ve had the discussion about how Australia has the highest uptake of AI. While simultaneously on a scale of OECD countries, being the most sceptical and the most concerned about corporate usage of it. So the challenge that directors are saying is, we need to be developing an AI strategy and driving that productivity growth. But in a way that is appropriate and respectful of a public that is highly sceptical about it. If I quickly say the third thing that’s new on the list of issues that directors are worried about … this is a new thing as opposed to, the old things are all about regulation and cyber.

But the new thing is political, national political risk. It’s about the fact that there is emerging very rapidly in Australia a disrupter politic approach. Consumers and Australians, our fellow Australians have record levels of pessimism. When you combine a record level of pessimism with a disruptor approach to politics, you start to get political risk back on the risk agenda, which it may not have been for decades. Because crazy stuff can start to happen in that environment, that can profoundly damage businesses, so business understands. I just saw some polling out that across all four political party voters, so whether you’re One Nation, Green, Liberal or Labor, you now believe that business profits are outrunning community growth.

In other words, you believe that price inflation is being driven by big business charging too much. So you’re not buying or understanding all of the things that we all understand, about supply chains, oil, insurance risks, blah, blah, blah. That’s a high risk thing. So we’re talking about how do we connect with our customers, with our community. So that they understand that the success and growth of the business community actually leads to their success and growth. At the moment, I think a lot of Australians have lost that belief and that trust in that compact.

Amelia Brace: It’s really interesting, a well-timed survey for our discussion today. Rebecca, a real mixed bag of findings in that survey, how does that compare to your experience?

Rebecca Maslen-Stannage: Well it’s fascinating because we did a survey of ASX 200 shares and asked them what’s on their mind. Interestingly, 58% of listed ASX 200 shares, so the most prestige group … I’m not saying how Paul answered this, I’m not sure. But 58% said they would give up their listed public board, if they could be in a prominent, private capital board instead. The reason is, what’s on their mind, when you hear Paul step through what just CBA has on its slate, your average Ned, might have say three or four boards. They’re asking can I possibly do that? Can I actually apply enough time to the growth and productivity of the company in future that’s essential, and make sure that I deal with all the compliance, all the community expectations as Naomi has pointed out.

In a way that I’m not going to be publicly criticised for, with proxy advisors ready to pounce and criticise if directors don’t get that right. So it’s almost this sense of it’s so important that we grow and that we’re productive, but a concern as to whether that is achievable and acceptable risk level. That’s where we’re finding in some director’s minds.

Amelia Brace: From a regulator’s perspective Kate, what do you see as the greatest priority or concern from boards?

Kate O’Rourke: I might just pick up on a couple of the points made and then add to them.

Amelia Brace: Of course.

Kate O’Rourke: I think that point that Paul made about just how important it is as we’re tackling such levels of uncertainty and change, that public/private coordination and engagement with politicians, regulators, policy makers, I think that’s such a good point. In some ways it’s an irony that at the political level, there is the kind of disruption that Naomi’s describing. At the policy regulatory level, we’ve never had a great appetite to have that collaboration. There really is a strong sense certainly and we feel it at ASIC, but we see our fellow regulators take that same approach. We heard from Hamish before for the National Security that APRA and ACCC would say the same. Unless we’re talking about these issues very collaboratively and actually thinking about them as a system, then we’re not going to get very far at all.

So it’s good that we’re doing it at that level, but I absolutely take the point that if there’s a level of scepticism or distrust or disruption at a political level, then that complicates that joint effort. I think that’s one thing to think through about what we can do. I think that question also about the speed of change, one of the sessions some of you came to yesterday. One of the electives was about professional services firms and the sort of assistance and guidance of expertise in our system, so that’s one thing to draw from there. But the other is that idea of how companies or partnerships are set up helps in how things are governed, or how things are considered. I just think that when it’s so hard and we’re moving so fast, the board structure is actually really good, because it is a group of people trying to grapple through these issues.

We talked yesterday about how you transplant board-like structures on partnerships. Not for everybody I know as an area of interest, but it is quite interesting that that is harder. Whereas I think when I look at how boards problem-solve, the idea of discussing things and coming to a collective, certainly we feel that in the commission when we’re talking about difficult issues. So I think that structure in some ways serves us well. We’ve got a good framework, it doesn’t make any of the particular issues more difficult. In terms of the actual content, the only one I’d add that has a little bit yesterday come through, but not yet mentioned, is in relation to climate risk. We heard from Leah Weckert yesterday from Coles about how frequently for Coles, their business continuity plans are being activated.

It will depend on the sector, it’s not a universal thing. There’ll be plenty of sectors for whom that’s less of an issue. But I think that transition of something being almost in principle, we should have more about climate in strategic thinking or risk management to actually in practice, for a lot of companies it’s very real. We’ve similarly heard that as we’ve started to review all of the sustainability reports that some companies give us. We hear on one hand, reporting burden and I think we might come back to that. But on other hand, some companies saying it actually has really prompted a change in a strategic sense, about how we think about those longer term, less immediate, but longer term risks as well.

Amelia Brace: We will continue to speak about risk management. But just a reminder to the audience, if you have any questions, please do submit them via the app and I’ll get to as many as I can. When it does come to risks, there are so many and they are changing so fast. Rebecca from your perspective, I wonder is there a template? Is there an approach that you can have in your pocket when it comes to identifying risks, escalating them and managing them?

Rebecca Maslen-Stannage: I think it’s probably two key things. One is as Kate said, the board is a good structure to do this because you’ve got management very focused on delivering the strategies and the next milestone. You do get that broader experience at board level to think about what’s on the horizon a bit more. The guidance from the courts is the job of a director, is to take that real holistic look. Applying the director’s other skills and experiences, maybe what they’ve learnt on other boards to take that big picture look at what really are our key risks. What are our existential risks that we should be spending our time on. What might management not have focused on, but that the board can bring to the table.

I think the other really important thing for the board, this is perhaps primarily falling on the chair, is to have those discussions with particularly the CEO and the management team, about what do I expect you to escalate to me and what’s our respective roles. I know you’ve heard a lot about cyber. But one question that I’ve found when I’m speaking with boards about cyber, what would happen if you had an incident, how actively would the board expect to be involved? If you ask the same question of management, there’s this big gap because the management team generally tends to think the board will just be a little bit involved. But the board’s perspective might be quite different. The more you can have those discussions around in different situations, how would we interface ahead of time for better.

Amelia Brace: So there’s some situations where things need to be escalated to the board. Naomi, when should the board be leading the way though, and what practical steps are helpful from the board in terms of leadership?

Naomi Edwards: I think if you’re talking about a crisis, Rebecca’s exactly right. It’s incredibly important that your plans articulate very clearly the different roles. You don’t want to be figuring that out on the run. If there is that perception gap, you’ve got to nut that out pretty fast because that’s crazy. We saw it with the Microsoft over the weekend. All of my boards let me know eventually, what was going on and what they were doing. But that was the agreement and the agreement was that they would actually run and start solving whatever needed to be solved, before they spent time bringing the board in. So that articulation of roles, you’ve got to nail that down.

Then secondly, in terms of practising doing that, the guys this morning talked about an annual business continuity planning exercise. I don’t even think that’s enough now, because that’s pick one scenario and spend a day thrashing it to death. That’s not really going to be the scenario and things are just coming so fast. I actually think you need quite frequent, but small exercises where you go, “OK this has gone down. Let’s actually stand this up. Can we get the data, can we pay the claimants, can we do this, what’s our crown jewel, is it actually working. So smaller and more frequent I think is going to be really important.

Amelia Brace: Paul you alluded to this before, what the Commonwealth Bank does in one day. But there’s been a lot of discussion throughout the forum about getting the balance right. I wonder how do you get the balance right of your day job, making sure that’s being done well, meeting near term market expectations. But also preparing for these risks, making sure that you’re doing these preparedness meeting often and that you’re ready to respond.

Paul O’Malley: Yes, I don’t think you ever get it right and that’s really what keeps you humble. In today’s world where there is so much change, the more I learn about AI for instance, the less I understand and the more things are moving. Rebecca, I was in the 42% who said it’s an absolute privilege to work in a public company and the scrutiny is good for your soul just as a perspective. It is important and just on that, working for a company that’s got good purpose and good values is rewarding, even if the day to day is hard. Having good people who are committed to the community is great. Just from a CBA perspective and it comes into resilience, what’s good for Australia is generally good for the bank. What’s good for the bank is generally good for Australia.

So self-interest is a wonderful thing, it’s great when self-interest actually is aligned generally with the national interest, so that’s a real privilege. In terms of resilience, back in the days when mobile phones weren’t that prevalent, which is not that long ago. I got a phone call at 2 o’clock in the morning from one of our industrial site managers in a previous job I had. That said, “No one’s been hurt.” Which I was still asleep, I thought that’s great. “The flames are 200 feet in the air and there are 85 fire engines on site.” It was when do I start ringing people to let them know, the operational teams had been running resilience exercises all of the time. The most dangerous thing that happened is the firies all turned up and were so excited to get close to the fire, one of the fire engines burnt down.

Then when I was driving into the office at 5am, I turned on the ABC news and said, “There’s been a fire at the facility and the cost is about $30 million.” I thought it’s only three hours old and the media already has the right answer. After months of work, they got the number right, it was $30 million. So it’s interesting with resilience how quickly the information is available and needs to be available to customers, employees, stakeholders. Our learning from our rehearsals which have to be real is, it’s no longer a company contained exercise. It’s got to be broader and cyber is one, but national resilience, there is a role for everyone. Politicians are under pressure, they need to know the answers, so we have to respect that. Regulators need to be informed, the media’s got to be kept in the loop. Customers, employees want to know.

So one of the biggest learnings beyond that which is mentioned is just the need to practise the communication real time. I mentioned speed before others have mentioned it, is there’s no ability today to stop and go, “Just give me five minutes.” You actually have to keep communicating in an evolving manner where you might not have all of the facts. My learning having run a company for 10 years is, the first responses to what went wrong is invariably wrong. Sometimes you have to ask five questions and wait five weeks to actually get to the bottom, but that is not the expectation. So there’s the crisis of dealing with the issue, but there’s the crisis of maintaining trust and transparency to the community, which is just more and more difficult every day, the more we exercise internally, but also the more we exercise with external stakeholders.

If you come right back to the board, the more you tell your fellow directors not to hassle management, communication has a particular path it should follow, the more we can let management get on with the fix. There’s a lot there, but the expectations today are as hard and as high as they’ve ever been. But they are the expectations and we have to deliver against them.

Kate O’Rourke: Yes I was just going to jump in support of that, some observations from the work that we’ve done as part of the Council of Financial Regulators. So that’s ASIC, APRA, RBA, Treasury and we’ve done it very much in partnership with industry, particularly in the banking sector in this case. So this is scenario testing, maybe not quite as frequently, but that idea that if you leave coms till last, you’re really in trouble. It’s got to be at the beginning, in the middle and the end what the messages are. Even if they’re wrong at the beginning, what does that evolve to. We talked in some of the earlier sessions about transparency and that sense of integrity of being honest with what’s known at the time.

But the other thing that’s been really complicated is when that communications channel is muddied by mis or disinformation. So whether it be fakes of people giving the updates or partial truths so that it’s really misleading, what information is shared. Then you get to this question of well who is a trusted voice, who can speak. Even if it’s a company issue that’s very specific, your point around connecting into the wider community who will be expected to have a view about it … or may indeed be the answer, in terms of supporting, a calming of the waters in particular circumstances. So we have been working on protocols on disinformation and things like that. I think unless you do see it as a joined up problem, I think that it gets harder.

Amelia Brace: A question from the audience, it’s quite a timely one given that we have seen a number of Australian companies announce job losses recently, being quite blatant that they are in relation to artificial intelligence. How are directors challenging managements plans to employ AI? So that the potential cost to a company’s human capital is given the consideration the community expects, given surveys, say community things, companies are putting profits ahead of people. Rebecca, did you want to weigh in on that?

Rebecca Maslen-Stannage: I think this one is a real challenge because companies do need to be productive. But Paul you’ve given me a fascinating stat earlier on this I think, that how long it took for even computers to be productive. That might be relevant here.

Paul O’Malley: In parallel with this session, CBA has its Accelerate AI conference on next door. It’s a really good juxtaposition, because there’s so much uniformity of content between the two forums. There’s a where would the future be, but where are we today. I think the comment was made earlier that where there’s uncertainty and not clarity, then everyone feels a little bit as to are they at risk, is their job at risk? To the core of the question, is when people’s jobs are at risk for whatever reason, that’s actually all that matters. That’s a really important perspective for each individual that companies understand, that if any individual jobs at risk for whatever reason, it’s actually important to acknowledge that and to communicate that.

I often give an example, I was in the steel industry for a long time and this was before my time in the steel industry. That the Port Kembla Steelworks used to have about 25,000 people working there, this is in the 80s. They had two very expensive steel making blast furnaces and they made about 2.5 million tonnes of steel. Today 4 million people use one blast furnace to make 3 million tonnes of steel. At the time, that was really disruptive, it was driven by global forces and automation. Automation in industrial processes was a really scary thing, because it was going to change jobs. If you go to Port Kembla, the Illawarra, today the steelworks is less of an employer, but a substantial contributor to the community.

The University of Wollongong has actually grown and is a fantastic educational institution in the same environment. Global employment, Illawarra employment has actually increased. Whenever you have a structural shift, it is uncertain and it causes uncertainty. I don’t think to be frank in the first instance, it’s got anything to do with profits. There is a global phenomenon occurring with a new technology, and we’re not sure where it’s going to take us. A stat in the adjoining conference from an economist was that computer use became more broad scale or widespread in the late 1980s. It was 15 years before it really delivered any productivity improvements.

There are J-curves, so Danielle Woods talked about J-curves in this space. None of us know how this is going to evolve. We have to be transparent and say there will be changes. We have to prepare our employees by investing and supporting their skills and their tasks. We have to be transparent with the entire community. But if we don’t capture and evolve and disseminate or diffuse the ability or the benefits of AI across the broad economy in Australia, we’ll have failed. But if Australia doesn’t understand, learn, take steps to embrace, the world will actually evolve and take it and effectively compete with us. So it’s one of those real challenges where we’ve got to respect the individual. We’ve got to be transparent that we’re not quite sure what’s happening, but there’s going to be significant. But the world’s moving ahead and we can’t feel isolated.

There’s a very clunky example, but it goes back to when Australia was a group of colonies and we built different gauge railways to protect our own little ecosystem. How well did that work out? It’s not quite the same. We’ve got to have the respect, there’s going to be change. But it’s happening and we’ve got to participate knowingly. One last thing, Australia’s got so many good things going for it, how we look after our people with health and education is one of them. We’re very lucky that we have that as a starting point. We’ve got to own that, maintain it. But we’ve actually got to move with where the world’s going, because we don’t want to lose our ability to invest in Australia.

Amelia Brace: Naomi, your thoughts?

Naomi Edwards: I would totally agree with everything Paul said. I think the other thing, it’s really important for a board to be very clear with their executive team. That if any AI implementation use case comes up, that either has a high values or ethical component, all of that is going to lead to for example, an entire process being replaced within a team. That that actually needs to come to the board because I do think that thing that Rebecca was saying, that the board is a forum whereby you get that kind of voice of all the stakeholders, the community being asked. I think it needs to be brought to them. I think there should be times when the board says actually we’re not ready for this, because we haven’t brought the teams on the journey. Or there’s a risk that this is actually not going to be a fantastic experience for the consumer.

The actual worse thing you can do is unleash some AI bot or whatever, that is a terrible experience for the customer. Then all they’re going to think is I’m doing it tougher and I think you’re making more money, even if you’re not. And you’re giving me these horrific processes and products to deal with. So you have to make sure your product is working. I know on one of my boards which is a life insurer, our staff get incredibly excited when there is an AI application that is going to drastically improve the customer experience. That’s just a win-win, because you’ve got your staff really keen to roll that out and you’ve got your customers winning. So go hard on those use cases.

Amelia Brace: Another question from the audience, it’s been suggested that in a crisis, directors should get on the front foot with communication, despite it potentially being wrong. For a listed entity, how do you balance this approach against the continuous disclosure obligations? Now as a journalist, I do like to get information very quickly, particularly if I’m on the air. I do prefer if it’s accurate though. Paul I think you mentioned this before, the pace and the expectation of information, particularly in a crisis. What would your response to that be?

Paul O’Malley: I would call Rebecca first and get the right advice. This is where transparency has got to be as accurate as it can be. So as part of crisis planning exercises, we have continuous disclosure policy, we have continuous disclosure committee. We test information we had that might be market sensitive and material. In a crisis, that has to be an ongoing activity. Transparent communication is better than wrong communication. When you don’t know, that is fine from my perspective to say you don’t know. Then when do you actually ask for a trading pause, until you’ve actually got that information, like actually workshopping when you might take the various steps that are available to a board, are really important.

I think you can’t knowingly put out wrong information, that’s wrong, so transparent and uncertain is fine. Trading halt is an option until you can understand, but absolutely getting the right advice and having the right experts in the room is very important Rebecca.

Amelia Brace: Let’s ask the expert, Rebecca.

Rebecca Maslen-Stannage: Well, what I’d say is people have this incredible urge to overpromise in that situation, to say everything’s under control. You’ve got to signal that when it is appropriate to communicate, because ASX in their guidance has a really good example in the guidance note, about you don’t have to communicate too early. But when you do, you’ve got to accept that you can only say what you know. It is perfectly to say this is what we know at this stage. We’ll let you know when we know more. I think in the past, we probably tended to hold off on communication. Now there are a bunch of reasons to get on the front foot and do that earlier. But that doesn’t mean you give certainty that’s not there.

It is more acceptable, both from a legal perspective and a community perspective to say I’m really sorry this has happened. We’ve got this much detail. That’s all we know at the moment, but we’ll tell you more when we know more.

Amelia Brace: Naomi from your experience, it might be acceptable to say I don’t know. But do people want to say that, are they comfortable saying that?

Naomi Edwards: I’m not going to name names, but we’ve actually seen some masterclasses in the last six months of what I think has been some really good crisis responses. Where basically the companies have said, “Something’s happened, but as of yet, I don’t know what and I will update you in a couple of hours.” In a couple of hours, we had another update. I think in that case, I think we all know the one I’m talking about, it was actually managed really well. I think that boards and their advisors have learned from some of the examples we had last year, where there was not enough communication. But the masterclass communication this year, they haven’t spelled out the specifics. They’ve actually said, “We will update you when we know more.” So I think we’re getting better at it.

Kate O’Rourke: I think one of the other things that we heard yesterday that’s relevant here, is that idea of what’s the perspective of the communication. That question of what would my customers need first or what information. So it may not be the whole story, the cause or the consequence, or the $30 million, the estimate or the impact. But that lens being who’s going to be … whether it be customers or community, going to be most immediately affected and what do they need to know. That priority is a topic in amongst all of the other things. That consumer centricity I think is something that helps people accept that there won’t be a full range of information and that they might need to wait.

Amelia Brace: We have been discussing balance a lot as I mentioned earlier. Something that came up also yesterday was the risk of regulating to a point where it stifles innovation and us being competitive in the global market at the moment. I’m curious as to what you think about getting the balance right in terms of both of those. Naomi what do you think?

Naomi Edwards: The AICD has been incredibly public about our view, that at the moment the regulatory settings in Australia are hurting productivity. We’ve also been public in acknowledging that ASIC and APRA have made some really fantastic steps towards addressing this, as indeed has the treasurer and others in the statement of expectations and so on. So our members are telling us that they have seen progress in this area. But we have quantified with Mandala economics that there’s still progress to go. It does feel to us that there’s been a shift in the tenor of the discussion in the last 12 months, in that we feel very aligned with regulators. I think a lot of companies are saying this, that the will is there. Therefore, what we need to find is a way through some of the morass.

Every single regulator that the AICD talks to says to us, “Bring us specific examples, we want to sit down with boards and work through.” Indeed, we heard from various of your colleagues today and yesterday saying that they were keen to hear that. I think that there’s actually real progress about the need to have deregulation. It’s not a big end of town thing. We all know the café with the 31 bits of regulation, but there’s even other things. A health insurer who wanted to launch a new product, we have a case study about this. The product was a hundred per cent designed ready to go, and then sat for two years between two regulators arguing over a piece of jurisdiction really. So we’re still sadly seeing that, but I think that there is a coming together now of the importance around innovation.

I just want to publicly thank ASIC for that, but we think there’s a job of work to be done. That said, it’s not an excuse to do nothing. There has never been a more volatile time than now. What the AICD says to company directors, your job is to make sure that the heightened level of volatility is not paralysing initiatives and growth. Yes, the level of risk associated with every new project is growing, because volatility has never been higher. So you might have to open your [scapa ? 0:39:32.1] type jaws a little bit, but you have to make sure that you are not paralysed in this environment. With all the regulation in the world, boards still have control over their destiny and our role is to drive that growth.

I think directors are actually confident at the moment that we can do that, and that we have a proper environment with regulators who’ve come at it. The issue is with consumers and Australians in bringing them along and having them feel that they can trust us.

Amelia Brace: Kate I’ll give you an opportunity to respond. Is progress being made and is it happening fast enough?

Kate O’Rourke: Thank you and thank you very much Naomi for recognising that alignment of intent, with respect to identifying which parts of the regulatory frameworks … there’s many of them and they all overlay, are the ones that are not efficient, not effective. We want to maintain the protections, whether they be consumer protections, market integrity or otherwise, but to do it as efficiently and proportionately and as risk based as possible. So that was a joint exercise. We might administer them or we might craft them and can therefore change them. But understanding how they’re particularly annoying or how they’re not helping is a discussion rather than that. So that discussion is happening.

I think we’ve been talking about this through the lens of regulatory simplification since this conference two years ago. So it has been a couple of years, and we have heard a good mix of things that are very practical that we’ve been able to act on at ASIC. But they’re quite specific, electronic signatures instead of wet signatures, emailing your stuff instead of posting your stuff, so those sorts of thing are micro. I think we have heard including with discussions with treasury, I think there’s treasury people here, a continued open door. Our treasurer said it yesterday, what are those next, bigger, chunkier … we’ve had some good ideas coming through. But I think that idea of looking for the bigger changes that would make a more impactful reduction remains an open discussion.

I think to your question, there’s definitely further to go and there’s an interest in hearing what they might look like. Our perspective’s always going to be how’s that more efficient, but doesn’t diminish the kind of protections that are important.

Amelia Brace: A question from the audience that draws down on this further, I saw a report last week that most directors believe they spend too much time on risk and compliance, and not enough on strategy. What should management do to help boards with this? Paul, what’s your take on that?

Paul O’Malley: I think boards have to spend the right amount of time on the right areas. If I go back to the Royal Commission into the financial services industry and the prudential inquiry into CBA by APRA, the CBA board spent a lot of time, and the appropriate amount of time, resetting our risk frameworks. Getting the governance right, logging the lessons learnt, and making sure that our remedial action plan was undertaken appropriately and we took the business forward. We were somewhat lucky that it was a relatively benign economic time in which to do that, so small mercies. In our induction that employees come through when they join the CBA now, there are a lot of videos and documents to learn.

The most watched video is of CEO Matt Comyn testifying to the Royal Commission, which from a lessons learnt perspective, is actually a really good thing to share those lessons learned. Over time, the strategic risk we think, I’ve talked to it earlier, is as intense as it has ever been. The strategic risk to the economy of Australia, the strategic risk from both cyber security and AI opportunity. So in many respects, I look at all business as risk, I look at compliance as a ticket to the game that we need to be as accurate on as possible. If we have compliance errors, we need to find them, fix them and bear the consequences.

So I actually think that compliance is fundamentally important to getting the business right, so it takes whatever time is required. Risk at the moment captures the whole of business. I think one can look at short term today risk, but I think boards have to be looking at strategic risk at the same time. The big challenge today is the cost of focusing on the obvious, you can price. The cost of not solving problems that are unseen, you can’t price. But if we don’t focus on strategic risk today, and if one talks to the whole structure of the Australian economy, we don’t build enough houses. We need to build more houses. I think less talking about regulation and more talking about what are the specifics that can increase the supply of housing and reduce the cost of housing.

If we can’t home our youth or have the compact of changing from older Australians to younger Australians, we’re failing Australia. So I think about risk more as opportunity and setting targets to solve. If I left all of us with one answer today, if it costs $500,000 to build a 100 square metre home, how do we make it $400,000. Instead of making it an 18 month process, how do we make it a nine month process. Ignore all the regs, if that’s the objective, I think we could solve a lot of today’s problems in Australia from a housing crisis. You only need two metrics and they’re the two metrics.

Amelia Brace: Another question from the audience, we’ve just got time. How do boards cope when a crisis leads to dissension? Does the role of the chair become so difficult that decision making is difficult? Or does the chair need to make a majority decision and sell it to the board as a whole? Rebecca, your thoughts on that?

Rebecca Maslen-Stannage: Well the word dissension, I’ve got to start by saying disagreement is not a problem. That is actually very healthy and helpful, so there are different perspectives and it is hard to come to a decision. That does not make it a bad decision, that means you’ve probably got a better decision. You can have board dissension for perhaps two different reasons. Sometimes there really is a fundamental clash on the board and that’s very hard to manage. Outside that context, I do think it’s up to the chair to sort out disagreement on the board. It might be that further engagement’s needed for the time different perspective. But you wouldn’t want just group think particularly in a crisis. If someone has got a strong counter view, it’s really important to listen to it and think about whether it’s valid.

Ultimately you’ll come to a majority decision if you have to act. But try to bring everyone on board by engaging with that person, can be really important.

Amelia Brace: Naomi, did you have thoughts on this question?

Naomi Edwards: I think the role of the chair can be quite lonely, especially in a crisis. That said, I do think that if a board is cohesive and over time, the chair has come to build their influence with their colleagues through being a good collator of a joint decision making process … I think that will stand them in good stead. I think if you had all of the board not happy with the decision and a chair trying to sell something to them, I think that’s not what the job of the chair is. The chair is first amongst equals. So the chair’s job in that delicate dance … it’s hard and it needs to be done fast. But is actually to get all of that wisdom on the table and get the best solution that you can as a group. So I think if it’s a matter of just the chair losing the support of their colleagues.

The other thing is, it’s incredibly, because the whole beauty of a board is that it’s not the smartest person in the room. It is the wisdom of a group and how does the chair actually bring that out in a time of crisis, which is why humble chairs are the best chairs. I love humble chairs because they bring that group out. Rather than in a panic situation, psychologically an arrogant chair will just go to their own opinion. A humble chair will stick with the process of the group.

Amelia Brace: Paul I’m sure that you are a humble chair. Have you had to deal with a mutiny and how did you do so?

Paul O’Malley: I think it starts with the board succession having the right directors and really working on that. I think that’s an ongoing role with the right directors, people are coming to do … my favourite part of the whole Corporations Act says directors have to work in the best interests of the company. If you get the right people around the table, they all want to work in the best interests of the company. Diversity of perspectives is critically important and constructive challenge is really important. So whether it’s the chair of committees or the chair of the board, but the directors collaboratively create the ability to have constructive challenge. To be frank, if there’s a substantive difference of view at a point in time, then it’s not time to make the decision. It’s time to actually reflect and consider. Sometimes a pause is actually the most constructive thing that can be undertaken in any discussion.

But my experience is if you work hard on the right succession, if you got the right people and if you put the company first … the company is not just shareholders. It’s absolutely employees and staff and the community. My experience is that most directors actually come with that approach. I think autocratic chairs are absolutely the wrong answer. Sometimes I think the chair should be last among equals rather than first among equals. People want to be heard, whether it’s management or whether it’s the board. They need the opportunity to put their perspectives on the table, so that they individually can be doing their role as a non-executive director.

You put all those things together, you end up with better decisions, more thoughtful, you understand the downside risks. You can reflect back in time and say we made a mistake because we might have misallocated some of what we heard and we underestimated some of the counter points. So that’s all part of a good learning experience.

Amelia Brace: Thank you so much to each of you for your discussion this afternoon, taking us inside the boardroom. It has been a really interesting insight. A reminder to our audience to please review this panel in the app, we’d love to hear your thoughts.

Paul O’Malley: We did really well everyone.

Amelia Brace: I will now hand over to Hamish for the next panel which will look at growth opportunity and risk in private markets. Thank you again.

Gallery

Plenary session 9: Private markets - growth, opportunity and risk

  • Simone Constant, Commissioner, ASIC
  • Mike Dorrell, CEO, Stonepeak
  • Richard Brandweiner, CIO, Future Fund

Full audio (MP3 28.8 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: We’ve got a really fascinating discussion to share with you now, and we’re particularly keen to get your questions for this session. A really interesting collection of voices in an area that I’m sure a lot of you are interested in. I know that because it’s come up so many times over the past couple of days.

So obviously private markets are growing faster. It’s a growing part of the financial system, both funding and the investment mix. This session, the aim really is to examine the forces that are shaping private markets, particularly with a focus on private credit. We’re going to look at the benefits, potential benefits, risks as well associated with that, including issues related to transparency, valuation, liquidity, conflicts of interest and retail investor exposure as well.

So as I say, if you’ve got a question, please get in with it early. And if you’re directing your question to a particular one of the panellists, please just let us know in the text, so I know who you want me to put that question to.

Joining me on stage for this discussion is Simone Constant, the ASIC Commissioner, who’s back with us again. Richard Brandweiner, who’s the Chief Investment Officer at the Future Fund, recently in that post. And Mike Dorrell, who’s the Chairman and CEO and co-founder of Stonepeak. Would you please welcome all of them to the stage.

Well, thank you very much, all three of you. Good to see you again, Simone. So obviously, we’ve all got different experiences, past, present, in relation to private credit. I’m just interested in through the cycle, through crisis, what you’ve learned, what you can share. I’ll let you go, Simone, first, because I know you’ve already mentioned it a couple of times over the last couple of days. I know it’s an area of particular interest to you. Give us the wisdom up front.

Simone Constant: Wisdom. Well, I think the first thing you learn in a crisis is there is no wisdom. It’s just kind of what you do and how you respond. And certainly no crisis repeats the same way, but there’s definitely repeatable lessons. And I think we’ve been hearing that, right?

So repeatable lessons, as might pertain to private credit, I think the first one would probably be you never really appreciate the fundamentals, we keep talking about getting the basics right, until you’re in a crisis or a stress. And so in private credit; valuations, is the stuff worth what you thought it was? Liquidity, like returns are great in the good times, but the fundamental thing is, is the money there when you need it and when you’ve promised when it’s in a stress time? And credit risk management, like concentration. Concentration risk really ratchets quickly if you’re in a stress or a crisis situation.

But I think probably the other two lessons you learn are, for all that credit is the ultimate financial risk, it’s the one you probably worry about. Even when you’re looking after market risk like I have, you worry about credit risk leading in. Actually, it’s usually non-financial risk that manifests as financial risk in credit.

Moderator: What’s an example of what you’re thinking about?

Simone Constant: Yeah, so bad conduct makes bad loans, which makes bad outcomes in a stress. And that’s why at ASIC we focused on our 10 principles of private credit done well. And what does bad conduct look like? Everything from not having the information to know what you’ve got where if you’ve got a stress, to you haven’t told investors really what the risks are in what that portfolio is, and everything in between.

And then that probably leads to the very final thing, which is, for all that I just said, no crisis repeats the same way, and different products are different. There’s definitely some red flags that you worry about. Like if you see a lot of conflicts of interest and a lot of related party transactions, and particularly if you see conflicted rent, for example, you worry. If you see an area where it’s said to be too complex, let’s not talk GFC, let’s talk about – because I think these guys can talk GFC. Sadly, I was there too, I am that old. But let’s talk Royal Commission, which we’ve talked a bit about.

In the Royal Commission, one thing that I banned when I was CRO for a division of a bank was using the word complex. Because if people are using the word complex, at best it’s an excuse, but actually at worst it’s a fail. And complexity goes to disclosure in a crisis, with disclosure –

Moderator: As in you think it’s being used to –?

Simone Constant: To hide. It’s certainly not a reason, and at best an excuse, but it’s usually a fail. And a fail, what does that look like? In private credit, disclosure is really important, but it has to be effective. So if you’ve got a really long document, like we talked about yesterday, that’s like 400 pages, but even the Group Chief Risk Officer of CommBank and three AI tools can’t make sense of it, that’s not effective disclosure.

Equally, if you’ve got a document, you’ve got a private credit fund and it has all these things about what the risks are, but it doesn’t say, oh, well, this is all dependent on, and assumes the price of property is only ever going to go up, and that we’re only ever going to refinance in benign conditions, that’s not effective disclosure. So those simple red flags, in my experience, having sadly seen a few, they do hold true.

Moderator: But are you saying if you’re seeing those red flags, you’ve got to think out everything else that might be possible because you’re seeing that? Is that catastrophising?

Simone Constant: I think if you’re seeing those red flags, be careful going in. I think if you’re seeing those red flags, make sure that you’ve got good information and good practices. And where there are those red flags, get onto those really quickly if there’s a stress. Because in a stress, sadly, people will act quickly and in their own interest. And if you don’t have that information and if you don’t know where your collateral is, and your valuations are off and you don’t have the liquidity to cover, very quickly a stress becomes that crisis.

Moderator: It can unravel.

Simone Constant: Yeah.

Moderator: Richard?

Richard Brandweiner: Well, look, it was a horrible panel to be selected for. It brought back a lot of horrible memories from the deep recesses, a lot of scar tissue.

Simone Constant: Old people minds.

Richard Brandweiner: Yeah. Well, it was almost 20 years ago that I took over the management of my first private credit product. It wasn’t called private credit back then. It was called the monthly income fund, one of the oldest managed funds in Australia with the organisation I was working for at the time. And you might remember the old mortgage funds. A lot of people relied on them for income. My mother was an investor in them. They were a huge part of the ecosystem.

And when the government put guarantees on bank deposits, these were seen as shadow banks. There was a run on them. They were forced to shut during the global financial crisis. Ultimately, there was a mismatch of liquidity. So the underlying loans were completely illiquid, but the terms of the offering was daily liquid back in those days.

But when I dig deep, there are some really interesting lessons that even you might not be aware of, Simone, that have gone with the mists of time. So the big one was about the returns that you see in private credit land. So what was happening in the lead-up to the global financial crisis, which is exactly the same thing that’s been happening over the past few years, is a wave of money going towards private lending. And when there’s a mismatch between the demand and supply for capital, that has implications. And so what was happening was that the lending standards were becoming borrower-friendly rather than lender-friendly.

And for a conservative lender, as we were, that means you just can’t maintain the same quality of lending. So you stop lending. So if you stop lending, you build up cash and your returns fall. So the funds that maintain the returns look great, but what’s happening is the actual terms and conditions of the loans are actually shifting increasingly towards the borrower rather than the lender.

And in fact, in Australia, we were lucky. We were a few years away from that becoming quite a serious thing because the low-doc loans, the terms, the conditions were actually worsening by the day before the GFC actually hit. So that was number one.

Number two was the mismatch in liquidity. So ultimately, these were illiquid assets, and we were offering liquidity. But the important point was different types of investors were coming into these vehicles with different objectives and different goals. And that’s where you get a problem.

And that’s why the target market determination is so important actually. Because when you get people using it as a cash account versus people that have strategic cash holdings in their fundamentally different objectives in the same pooled vehicle, and that’s where you get an issue where the underlying liquidity is different from the structural liquidity.

And the final thing I just want to say is those funds back in that time were all dollar unit priced funds, so the income accrues outside of the fund and then gets paid as a dividend or a distribution. Many of them today are that as well. And that makes it very, very opaque and very different from what you see in any other type of managed fund.

Because what ends up happening there is that it can look absolutely fine until it doesn’t. So it was always described as picking up pennies in front of a steamroller. Very difficult to look through, which is some of the work that you’re doing at the moment is to try and improve that transparency.

But as you know, this isn’t an area that Australia is very comfortable with. We’re an equity centric culture. You still can’t get the 10-year bond yield from the AFR newsletter in the morning. Please, if someone could help, that would be great. And so our understanding as a system of the look-through risks is actually very limited.

Moderator: So those dynamics you were describing, different people coming with different objectives, wouldn’t that always be the case?

Richard Brandweiner: Yeah, it is always the case. The problem is when there’s a mismatch of the underlying asset liquidity and the structural liquidity at the headline level. If you all had similar objectives, that wouldn’t be an issue. Which is why institutional investors are fortunate that they have separate accounts, so they’re not co-mingled with other investors, so you’re not exposed to that challenge.

Moderator: OK. Mike, your lessons, please.

Mike Dorrell: I’m a bit different from Rich. I’m actually very excited to be on this panel.

Simone Constant: Me too, Mike.

Mike Dorrell: Thank you for having me, by the way. I love being here.

Moderator: They’re just vying for more generous questions.

Mike Dorrell: I’ve got to know Simone a little bit over the last 12 months, but I know Rich really well.

Richard Brandweiner: That was before the global financial.

Mike Dorrell: Yes, well before. He and I were the one and two of absentee at University of New South Wales Finance School, and so I think neither of us were quite sure whether we were going to turn up today, but we’ve finally found ourselves together.

There’s so much you learn in a crisis. It clearly splits or distinguishes really well between high-quality assets and businesses and low-quality assets and businesses, and it clearly makes you think awfully quickly about liquidity, because all of a sudden, there isn’t any liquidity. So if you’re relying on borrowings or if you’ve got refinancings coming up, you’re in big, big trouble, whereas you might not have even thought of that as an issue for the 10 years before that.

But the thing maybe I’d highlight, is I think rather interesting, is that when the crisis happens, we’re never shocked at where it happened. You will look at a chart and say, it was obvious that this particular part of the economy was overheated or overvalued or what have you.

So, for example, the last crisis we had, of course, was the global financial crisis, and if you’d looked at house prices in the US and, I suspect, in Australia, house prices to median income, they were at absolutely crazy levels, levels they’d never been at before. And everyone could see they’re ticking up and up and up and up and inevitably when that’s happening, it’s somewhat because there’s generally some new financing technique or there’s a bunch of funding going into that area, and so we could all see that that enormous amount of capital is chasing a particular thematic.

So in the GFC, it was all, house prices never go down, was the US thesis, and so let’s just keep putting more and more lending into that space, and we can’t lose money because it never goes down. And of course, you see the house prices tick, tick, tick up, up, up, up, up, and then it’s difficult. Because if you’re the CEO or senior management or the board at Goldman Sachs or Morgan Stanley or you name your bank, you can sit there and say, we can see housing markets are overcooked. What are you going to do? Are you going to be the one who stops?

Normally, if you do stop – like there was a great interview with Jeremy Grantham who, I don’t know if you guys have ever read Jeremy Grantham’s stuff, they call him a permabear, but he’s one of the smarter commentators, I reckon, on financial markets. He gave a great interview recently about his experience of actually doing what he would call the right thing, so seeing markets overvalued and pulling back, he said he lost all his clients. Because he pulled back two or three years before the peak, and all the clients leave as they’re missing out on the last two or three years of great returns, and then when the whole thing crashes down, everyone crashes down together, and so there’s some safety in doing the same thing as everybody else.

But all I’m saying is that we all know where the next crisis is going to come from. It’s almost inevitably going to come from a combination of interest rates that have gone up enormously, and I think in Australia, that puts the property market at great risk, and we’re already seeing a little bit of that.

Then the unbelievable flows of capital going into AI-related stuff. Look, I might be wrong, but I suspect we’re going to look back at some point and we’ll have gone through a dot-com type correction, and we’ll all say, of course we knew it, but it’s easy to say that. It’s another thing to sit on the sidelines for the two or three years when it is very heated and it’s exciting, and you’re getting fees and people are throwing money at you, etc, so that’s maybe something I would highlight.

Moderator: And if that happens, the scale of it in comparison to previous ones?

Mike Dorrell: Jeez, I think the scale would be rather large, I would think. Just in the top five hyperscalers in the US, their budgets for AI next year are in excess of $1 trillion. The amount of CapEx going into AI, at least forecast to go into AI the next couple of years, it’s bigger than any capital program in the whole history of the world. It’s bigger than the railway CapEx, it’s far bigger than the fibre CapEx that was associated with the dot-com era. So that usually gives you an idea of how big a –

Richard Brandweiner: Issue.

Mike Dorrell: – drop back down, we may have. There’s a lot of debt involved as well, there’s a lot of cross-company investments and borrowings and stuff, and so it just smells like something that we’ll all look back and say, it was obvious. But I don’t know if it’s this year, next year, the year after, and so it creates a little bit of a conflict in your brain, but in your organisation.

Moderator: Drop back down seems like diplomatic language, given what you’ve just said.

Simone Constant: Hamish, I should be clear, this is not ASIC saying there’s a crisis in private credit.

Moderator: Got it.

Simone Constant: That would be headline grabbing and unhelpful. But this is ASIC saying we watch these things, because private credit is absolutely in a test.

Moderator: You’ve put out a discussion paper in the last 18 months, five reports, obviously something you’re thinking about a lot. I don’t know how many people in the room have read all of those things, but maybe it’s helpful, just in terms of steering the discussion we’re having, just to outline the balance of opportunity and risk as you see it, and the appropriate regulatory response to that.

Simone Constant: No, thank you, actually, because that’s the kind of question we wanted. I know you’re not a to-script interviewer, but actually it’s just a good opportunity. I tried to share a message yesterday that with resilient foundations, you can build back better, build back strong. If we’re going into a crisis, as one of the big chairs in a big company said last night, win the crisis, win the decade.

Actually, our work around private credit has been – because we are worried, like some of the stuff Mike was saying, I’m sitting there thinking, yep, yep. Some of the stuff Rich was saying, like, yep, yep. That’s why we’ve been looking at private credit. But we really need private credit, just like we really need private markets. When we say private credit done well is great for the economy, we mean it. It’s great for investors. We want to see investors getting access to this type of product, but it’s really good for people who need capital. Particularly in that SME land, it’s getting harder and harder to get capital. We’re all talking about the tide going out, and there not being liquidity, and there not being capital available.

Actually, the work we’ve been doing to understand where there might be harm, first and foremost, yes, it’s to get ahead of where there might be investor harm. We’ve seen, you heard Sarah’s enforcement speech, private credit being at the heart of Shield and First Guardian, for example, really rams that home.

But also, we’ve been doing this work so that we can set – when we put our 10 principles of private credit done well, and we’re coming back to them with a survey, imminently to say, if not, why not have you adopted them? Along with what’s going on with liquidity. When we’ve done these things, it’s been to try and encourage industry and, as I keep saying, pockets of industry like the FSC and some great practitioners in private credit have picked it up, to level the playing field.

Because something Mike said there was really important. I have been a fund manager, by the way, a long time ago. Rich has as well. Mike still is. He’s actually done reasonably well out of it, you might have noticed. It is hard to be the only one pursuing that good conduct. When you’re in a really hot market, it can feel like not a level playing field. What we’re trying to do, in part, is level the playing field, because there’s some really good private credit funds and people who want this industry to have trust.

Moderator: I do want to get to the regulatory response. Because you’re describing the noise, which obviously we’re all aware of, descriptions of tide going out. How much of the growth of private credit is driven by where we’re at in the cycle, and how much of it is a structural change in your view?

Simone Constant: It’s another good question. You have been listening. It is absolutely both. The cycle we can’t fix. We did say when we started this work nearly two years ago, I said on record one of the real worries is when the cycle turns, we’ve never seen private credit tested when it’s at this scale and this level of interlinkage. But the structural parts, so much of that come back to that conduct. The way things are underwritten, the way fees are structured, the way disclosures are, the way valuations are, the way liquidity is managed and credit risk is managed, all those fundamentals. They are the structure.

When we talk about structural, that’s actually about the way it’s done, the conduct. Our hope – hope for the best, prepare for the worst. Our hope is that over the past year to two years when we’ve been having a lot to say and doing all this surveillance and showing how it can be better and shining a light on practice, that firms have gotten better and better and we’re going to get that level playing field. Because that will deal to the structure. I always say the only real defence against the challenge that’s going to come are good standards, and that’s what we’re talking about, good standards.

Moderator: We’ll come back to the regulatory response then, because I can see Richard’s trying to get in.

Richard Brandweiner: Can I just say, I think there are some quite substantial structural drivers for the growth though, outside of just the attractiveness of the returns. The bank regulatory, the Basel III and now the Basel IV has removed the banks from much of this lending. So there’s quite a bit of supply that’s effectively coming out of that. The hybrids, so bank hybrids which have historically been used by retirees for income, that market has deteriorated, so you’ve got people looking for income.

And then the platforms. When I was – 20 years ago, you couldn’t have private market assets on wealth platforms. Now they sit comfortably on them. So the whole system has evolved that’s facilitating it. So I think it’s very structural. I think it will continue growing. And my understanding is that the Australian lending market is far less private credit than Europe and the US, so there’s a lot of potential there for continued growth.

Moderator: So Simone, regulatory response, that was the part of that question we didn’t get.

Simone Constant: Not evading it; we’ve been really clear. First we came out as you said with a have a look, is there something to worry about? We got experts to do it, former Chief Risk Officers of banks, and they said yep, there’s something to worry about. Part of it was across a couple of years we had a 500% growth rate, which is like kind of, you worry about that. Part of that is concentration to property, which is the tangent to – rich is right, we have less maybe than the US has, but it’s a lot more, it’s a lot broader church, that concentration to property.

Mike Dorrell: More real estate, yes.

Simone Constant: And Mike even said, worry about the real estate. So we had a look at what to worry about. And then we’ve done two really comprehensive surveillances, and we’ve identified both what good practice is, and given examples of bad practice. In the most recent one we identified only two of 24 funds passed on the full economic benefit of the loan to the people who put the capital at risk. We identified that in one case one private credit fund was charging four times the amount of fees of what they disclosed. By the time you took into account things like default interest, I mean, I find that one a bit odd right? You write a bad loan and the investor takes a risk, and then there’s default interest because it didn’t go well, and you take a big clip for that. Things like that we’ve been calling out.

And we’ve been saying, we’ve been really clear that by this time now, now, like a year ago, we said this time next year, here’s your 10 principles, if not why not I’m putting them in place? Because we will ratchet up from surveillance and scanning to stop orders, which is compliance work, and firms who have had those in the main have responded really quickly, addressed issues, which is good.

We’ve had industry step in and develop standards, the FSC and now some of the other industry bodies. There is now no excuse. So now we’ve been really clear, Sarah said it this morning, front and centre on that slide even was private credit enforcement. We’re moving to enforcement including court-based enforcement investigations in 2027.

Moderator: OK, that’s a very clear message.

Simone Constant: Yes, and we’re handing it to industry. We’ve done so much work and we’ll put out some reg guidance, which we’re about to. We’ll keep doing the survey. We’re about to put a survey out to show what the baseline is. Because many in this room want information about what’s really going on, like we need information, so those things we’ll keep doing. But we are saying to industry, we’ve spent a lot of time on this, now do your thing, do well, and then you can build back better into that structural space.

Moderator: When you say many in the room are wanting more transparency, is there an explanation for opacity if people are saying we don’t understand, we can’t see? Is that an excuse for –

Simone Constant: For the investors trying to understand it? Yeah, for sure it’s an excuse, that’s definitely a reason. I wasn’t exaggerating when I gave the example that the former Chief Risk Officer of CommBank read a few disclosure documents and said to me, “I can’t understand it,” and got three AI models to try and understand it, and they came up with three different answers.

So on the investor side for sure, and that’s what we’ve been driving into, this concept of effective disclosure. Sitting within that, really interesting, usually folks will say, no more regulation, no more guidance. We’ve now got industry who have done some good things with their standards. But we’ve got industry coming to us and saying, can you please tell us what liquidity should mean, and even what valuation should mean.

Now we’re not necessarily convinced we’ll consult on these things, because we’ve been saying, we don’t want to add to reg burden, we want to see you get it right first. But that’s quite interesting when I say a lot of people in this room – it’s often industry, particularly the good private credit funds, or the people needing those funds, like for their capital, that are saying, keep going.

Moderator: OK, interesting. So Mike, talking about regulatory frameworks, I’m kind of curious how you observe comparisons, contrasts between the US and Australia on that score.

Mike Dorrell: I’m not sure how much strict regulation there is of private credit at least in the US. I mean, there’s various avenues for private credit in the US, there’s really three avenues I guess. There’s what they call BDCs, which won’t mean anything to most people in this audience. But BDCs are just a listed, publicly traded credit vehicle, a little bit like an income trust I suppose, where you’ve got to pay out more or less all the cash flows.

But the US has very, very tough regulations for raising private capital from retail investors, like really strict. And I don’t know the history of it, because these regulations go back to the, one’s called the 40 Act, there’s another called the 39 Act, so they go back quite a while. But what presumably happened is a whole bunch of retail investors had a very bad experience at some point, and the US felt the need to regulate very heavily.

And so for years and years and years, the private equity industry did not tap into retail money, it was just thought of as being too hard. And there was really two exceptions to that; one is REITs, so raising retail money through a REIT which is a, I forget what we call it in the US –

Richard Brandweiner: A real estate investment trust, so that’s a REIT.

Mike Dorrell: A REIT, yes, I know what that is, but what do we call it in Australia?

Richard Brandweiner: A REIT. It’s still a REIT.

Mike Dorrell: Sorry about that.

Richard Brandweiner: It’s an A-REIT in Australia.

Simone Constant: He went to one more finance lesson than you.

Mike Dorrell: We were laughing last night that we call a cinema, a cinema, and the US wouldn’t even know what that was, it was a theatre, but anyway. So you can do it through a REIT, and so there’s been a lot of money raised from retail investors through privately traded REITs in the last decade.

And interestingly that’s hit a big brick wall recently, because interest rates went up so much that property is on the nose, and so these REITs are kind of stuck. They’re supposed to be semi-liquid meaning you can get your money out each quarter, but they’re limited as to how much money you can get out, because these are private assets. And so they’re stuck, you can’t get your money out of the privately traded REITs at the moment because property is having such a tough time, so that’s one category.

The second category that does not have the strict regulation is credit, particularly through what they call these BDCs, which again just look like REITs but for credit. And so a lot of money was raised quite quickly over the last five years or so through these BDCs, and that’s been a very successful product in terms of both capital raising and returns for quite some time. And then just recently they hit a bit of a brick wall, because an awful lot of lending in those BDCs is to the software companies.

And it depends whose numbers you believe. If you talk to the BDCs themselves they would say 15 to 20% of their loans are software loans. But then the Wall Street Journal did a big front page article on it a month or two ago, and they said if you really dig into it, a lot of the other categories are really software companies is more like 30%. And of course I’m sure a lot of you are aware of this, but what’s happened with the advent of AI becoming so good at writing code is the software companies have been hammered. So these BDCs have been through a very, very tough time as a result. They haven’t had defaults, I don’t mean that. But their share prices have been hit quite hard and their inflows have stopped, and so they’ve had to shut down people exiting.

So BDCs is one avenue, and they are not all that regulated. They do report quarterly because they’re listed companies, just so they report like any other listed company, but there’s not a whole lot of regulatory requirements on them.

The two other avenues are one is the insurance companies. So this is a massive thematic in private markets in the US at the moment. The biggest private market players are going and getting associated either buying or investing in or partnering with insurance companies, life insurance companies. Because what happens is retail investors go and sign up for life insurance or some annuity product, there’s obviously a huge amount of premiums that the insurance company gets from that, and a lot of those premiums are invested into credit.

So what happens is the private equity firms may go and buy an insurer. They then have that insurer essentially invest in their private credit funds, and then they go out and lend through those private credit funds. So that’s the second avenue. That is very highly regulated in the US, but it is very difficult to appropriately regulate life insurance. Because you think about what’s happening; there’s a lot of competition to write life insurance tickets.

It’s a very generic product. Your only barrier to entry really is capital to be able to write life insurance. But you don’t make a payment often for 20, 30 years. So there’s a lot of pressure to write low premiums, and you really don’t know your risk adjusted returns for 20, 30 years. So that’s where regulators are looking hard at the moment in the US, less at the private credit aspect of that, more at the actual life insurance aspect of it.

The third private credit avenue is just going and raising essentially private equity to sell funds from institutions, but instead of doing private equity you’re doing private lending. That’s, I mean, the SEC regulates it. But I guess all I’m saying there is it’s not like there’s some grand rules that you can take from the US and plonk down here in Australia.

Simone Constant: Although interestingly their disclosures are much better than ours. So we’ve always said when it comes to what we might see as law change that’s in the information set would be we’d like to see more information. It would be helpful, especially in this sort of environment. We’ve always said we want to live within the frontier that’s set by the US. The value of some of that quarterly reporting for example, it would be pretty helpful right now versus what we have in Australia.

Moderator: So that component of it is a template at least?

Simone Constant: Yeah, I mean, and we continue to be careful to say this isn’t about asking for new laws or changing laws. We want to see industry do its thing. But actually information is a gap. We are somewhat in the dark, and at the moment I’m getting asked a lot, what’s the picture and what’s the state? And it’s like I can’t tell you on an individual basis, and I certainly can’t tell you on a system basis, because we don’t have that level of transparency.

Transparency is so powerful, and again industry are increasingly wanting it. If we get transparency of this sort of information there could be more confidence in where private credit’s performing. Also if there’s this sort of transparency then big and small players will innovate, and actually allow there to be benchmarking comparison which opens up more retail offer as well. It has an actual commercial value to it as well.

Moderator: Does that take us back to where we started this conversation in terms of stress indicators? If there’s stress in private credit, and you don’t have that sort of transparency –

Simone Constant: It is harder, yes.

Moderator: – where are you seeing early indicators of it here?

Simone Constant: So that’s absolutely one of the reasons we’re doing this end of year survey. We did a survey earlier in the year when there was stress in the US, and some of the sectors Mike was mentioning, we said we should have a look here.

And we asked, we kind of went over eight weeks to see if there was change. We had that as a baseline, and we certainly identified it’s different here, because we’re a lot more property, less software. Interestingly Mike’s domestic fund is infrastructure, so it’s different again. But this time we’re doing it as a one-off to look at where they’re up to on the principles, but where are they up to on liquidity and where are they up to on some of these indicators. It’s voluntary, but it’s going to be a very powerful information set.

Moderator: Richard, I can see you’re trying to get in –

Richard Brandweiner: No, no, no.

Moderator: But Mike, I just wonder if you could give us your insight into if there is a significant downturn, where would you see the stress markers in private?

Mike Dorrell: Are you asking me?

Moderator: Yes, Mike.

Mike Dorrell: Again I think this is pretty obvious. I think in Australia you’re going to see it, and you are seeing it in real estate, just because we’re such a real estate heavy market here, interest rates have gone up so quickly by so much. And when I talk to our private credit guys in Australia, they say there’s a real flavour of, to some degree, maybe not the most reputable property developers going and raising money from retail folks, and then investing that into things that we would ourselves probably have a bit of caution around. I think that’s quite a bit different relative to what’s taking place in the US.

That’s probably the biggest distinction I can see between the US and Australia in private credit markets. And it’s funny, I was thinking a lot before this panel about how do you guard against and regulate that? It’s a tricky question. I actually don’t know the answer to it. But anyway, I’d highlight real estate as one.

But the biggest one will be where all the money is going at the moment, which is in and around the AI space. The money is so massive. The valuations are dot-com level valuations. I want to be quite clear, we all have our own opinions on AI, it seems very real to me. It’s obviously world changing. But that’s not to say that you’re getting good returns on capital, and I think that’s going to come home to roost at some point.

And you see some early signs that the market is choking on just the amount of capital required in that space. There was no distinction between high and low quality AI companies six months ago; there is now. The Firmus thing here in Australia got a lot of press internationally as one of the examples of an AI company that didn’t get away, which is not typical. Anthropic’s been delayed a few times although it looks like it’ll have quite a successful IPO from what I read this week. OpenAI has had to push back its IPO. Some of those neoclouds have shown some strain.

So I’m not sitting here predicting we’re on the precipice of it, but you are seeing some signs of choking on the amount of capital needed. And the valuations are such that it’s hard to believe they won’t come off at some point.

Moderator: So how is that shaping the way that you’re thinking about the infrastructure investing in that space?

Mike Dorrell: I think it’s pretty simple, in that you can break infrastructure assets into those with big moats, like a toll road or an airport where we just know Sydney Airport or the M4, you don’t need long term contracts on those assets, because you know that people are going to turn up and use them. There’s those style of assets.

And then on the other side of it there’s infrastructure assets that don’t really have a big moat around them, they need a contract that gives you certainty around your cash flows. I would put data centres into that, and I’m using data centres because that’s the big category of stuff that we would invest in, in AI. AI is really data centres, gas infrastructure and power infrastructure. All three of those you need contracts to really make you feel good about your cash flows.

So it’s a pretty easy question; you just say to yourself if I have a 15-year contract on my data centre with say Google, is Google a good counterparty? I say check, yep. 15 years is the length of most of these contracts now, and you say to yourself, I have no clue what a data centre will be worth in 15 years’ time, like not a clue. Because the requirements of these chips change so quickly, therefore what a data centre looked like 10 years ago is so different from what it is today. You just don’t know, you have no clue. So the only thing you can rely on is that return you’re going to get under that 15-year contract.

So it’s sort of like what your kid would say to you if your kid was trying to come up with the answer. They’d say, well, what’s my return from that 15-year contract? I think it’s that simple. And you will get a bit more return, because it will be terminal value, you just don’t know what it is. So I think it’s as simple as that. It’s going back to your university your high school math and saying, what’s my discounted cash flows that I know I’m going to get, which is the contract, and if that’s all I got, am I OK? I don’t think it’s any more complicated.

Moderator: I think your high school maths was pretty ambitious still, talking about that amount of money.

Richard Brandweiner: Brother B would have expected us to know that, at Joey’s.

Moderator: By the way, we’ve only got a little while left on this discussion, so if you’ve got a question do get in now. You can use the QR code to do that. Richard, I’m mindful you were trying to weigh in on something Simone –

Richard Brandweiner: Oh no, it’s long gone now.

Moderator: The thought has passed to you has it?

Richard Brandweiner: No idea.

Moderator: I mean, we were talking about difference between the regulatory framework in the US versus Australia, the need to balance the opportunity that’s here, but also the point in the cycle. How are you listening to what Simone is saying in terms of we’ve been really clear, we’ve said what we’re doing next year, does that shape your thinking at all?

Richard Brandweiner: I think the work that Simone and ASIC have done is fantastic. And the whole point, just to make it really clear, and it’s self-evident in the name, but these are assets that are not traded and therefore there’s no market price for these assets. Therefore if you do a loan that’s secured by a building, you do a $7 million loan secured by a $10 million building, that’s a 70% loan to valuation ratio. If the value of that building falls by 20%, you still may not lose money. And in the funds people are in, that won’t be reflected at all. The unit price will not change. If that was a traded instrument, it will fall, but it’s not traded so it doesn’t change.

So in the absence of the sort of transparency that ASIC are working on, there’s no way for an investor to form a view on what the genuine underlying credit quality actually is and how that’s changing over time. And this is a function of the fact that they’re not traded.

Moderator: And so how do you approach trying to think about that then? I mean, presumably that would weigh heavily.

Richard Brandweiner: Well, I mean, the issue is that most retail investors would struggle. As you said before you need a – it’s quite a complicated area to understand the nature of those loan to valuation ratios, whether the interest income is accruing and not being paid out, whether there’s other payment in kind, it’s a litany of things.

Obviously as institutional investors we do that for a living, and what we try and do is look at lending across the entire spectrum from real estate, through to asset-backed, through to infrastructure, through to corporate lending, and trying to find those places where we can get the best risk adjusted return by understanding what the underlying risk is. It’s a lot easier for an institution than a retail investor.

Simone Constant: And part of that is they understand they’re looking after someone else’s money. A lot of it starts there. Some of the things Rich was talking about then that are really worrying, is when it gets stressed and bad the fund manager decides I’m not going to call a default, I’ll capitalise the interest, or I’ll take some payment, or I’ll move it over there, or hold the value but change it to a different type of fund. Which is when you’re taking those sorts of decisions, you’re really taking some risk with other people’s money. I think if they start with the mindset, oh, I have this on trust holding for the investor, I have to have the investor’s interest at heart, that’s a big part of it.

Richard Brandweiner: There is one other thing I’d love to add, which I think is important, and that is to your question about where or how problems might manifest themselves. The reality is that globally we have had a glut, until recently, of savings going into private credit structures. And it’s exceeded the demand for those loans. What happens when that happens is everybody’s desperate to get money out the door and lend it, and suddenly the terms of those loans become much more favourable to the borrower than to the lender. So that has happened over the past few years.

Now that’s slowed now with some of the issues happening. But what that means is that when there is a downturn, recoveries will be lower than they have been in previous cycles. Because the security embedded in the contractual terms is not as strong as it might have been in different cycles, so that’s something that the whole market needs to be mindful of.

Mike Dorrell: Can I add a point to Richard’s point? Because I totally agree with that, and I’d add one more to it, which comes from one of our guys in the US said to me, which is historically when we go through a cycle, a downturn, debt was traded. Historically it’s been mostly traded debt. And so the debt immediately trades down, and so people sell out of that debt, the distressed funds come in and buy that debt, and you have a renewal. Like that situation gets identified and picked up quite quickly because it is traded.

What’s happening in this market is that when you have problems you don’t have a price signal, and so what generally is happening is that the lender doesn’t want to trigger a problem or a crisis. And so to Richard’s point, instead of charging interest they’ll flick it over to payment in kind, meaning that you accrue the interest, you don’t pay it, and they’ll extend the loan and they’ll find ways to work it out. But what it means is that often the problem can get kicked down the road a long time without being identified, and you don’t have that same renewal situation. So you can get these zombie companies out there as well. So I do think that’s a change in markets to be aware of that for better or for worse is taking place.

Moderator: There’s a question that’s come in for you Mike. Redmond Dobson has sent this in; “Given the concerns you’re outlining about the capital being invested in the AI build and your funds heavily focused on infrastructure, are you concerned about your exposure? If so, what industries are you looking to for counter-cyclical investment?”

Mike Dorrell: Again I think it’s a pretty simple one to approach. On the AI side which is, in my world, in infrastructure, is data centres, it’s gas infrastructure and it’s power. And the reason it’s gas and power is because they’re the pinch points of AI at the moment. If you can get access to power then you can build a data centre there, and that’s where the value is, and to get power you need gas. So that’s why gas, power and data centres go together.

I think those categories, it’s much, much better to build than to buy. So at Stonepeak, and we’re not the only ones doing this of course, but we’re building over $100 billion of that stuff today. And to give you an idea, we just signed a contract with Nvidia, it’s the most recent data centre thing we’ve done, it’s in Houston, it’s a 15-year contract. What it means is that we will build a data centre at 11 times EBITDA, we call it, or 11 times earnings.

Whereas if we bought that same data centre once it’s up and running from someone else, we’d pay more like 20 times earnings for it. So it’s a huge premium you get to build as opposed to buy. Now it ain’t so easy to build because you do need to find the power, but that’s the magic in it. But we build in those categories as opposed to buy.

Outside of AI, which is mostly transport and logistics in our world, are the things not so much affected by AI, maybe oil infrastructure as well, in those categories, interest rates are up so much in the US, I know you say the same about Australia, you can see great value there at the moment.

So to give you a little bit of an idea, I’ll talk generically; I would have said, generically speaking, I’m not talking about our funds, but generically speaking, for core infrastructure when interest rates were lower, so in that 2012 to 2022 period, core infrastructure was returning 6 to 8% levered equity returns, I would say that’s now 11 to 13% in today’s market. And core plus infrastructure, which is essentially everything that’s not core, core plus infrastructure was returning I’d say around, call it 13 to 15%, I would say that’s now 17 to 19%.

Simone Constant: Wow.

Mike Dorrell: So that’s all because rates have gone up. Not true of the AI stuff. The AI stuff has a real sheen to it and everyone’s chasing it, and so I think it’s a little bit of a different story there. But for things that are truly reflecting the current state of interest rates, which is mostly transport and logistics and some oil energy, returns have changed to reflect interest rates, in my opinion. So buy non-AI and build AI, would be the quick summary.

Moderator: Well, that’s a really interesting note to end on. They’re going to serve some afternoon tea for you over the next five minutes or so, and the next session will get underway immediately after that. There is, I’m told, a dietary table to the side if you’re looking for options that are not being served. But in the meantime, would you please thank Simone Constant, Richard Brandweiner and Mike Dorrell.

Gallery

Plenary session 10: A focus on productivity

  • Sarah Court, Chair, ASIC
  • Jenny Wilkinson PSM, Secretary, Treasury
  • Andrew Irvine, CEO and Managing Director, NAB
  • Cosima Marriner, Editor-in-Chief, Australian Financial Review

Full audio (MP3 32 MB)

Transcript

Moderator: We’ve got one final session for you to enjoy this afternoon and a terrific lineup. I should let that there’s a QR code on the screen right now. The folks at ASIC are very keen for your feedback, so please do jump online whenever you’re ready. Just scan that QR code and answer some questions about the week. We’re hopeful of good ratings, but obviously it’s an opportunity for you to let us know what you think.

We’ve got as I say one final discussion. It’s a focus on productivity, arguably one of the more important discussions for Australia to be having right now. The government has made lifting Australia’s productivity a key priority as we know. Government, regulators, businesses, each expected to contribute to the conditions for sustainable growth. Easier said than done though, you might argue.

So joining us to discuss this for the next little while, Kate O’Rourke who is an ASIC Commissioner; Jenny Wilkinson, PSM; who’s the Secretary of Treasury; Andrew Irvine, the CEO and Managing Director of NAB; and Cosima Marriner, the new Editor-in-Chief of the Australian Financial Review. Would you please give all of them a very warm welcome.

Andrew Irvine: Is there anywhere you want us?

Moderator: Well, I think the intention is to sit in order, but it doesn’t really matter. Just sit where you are.

Kate O’Rourke: We’re already going off script, and we haven’t even started.

Moderator: I think people know who you are and can figure out based on the names above, so I think that’s all right. Obviously we need improved productivity, Jenny Wilkinson, and I’m sure every time you turn up at Senate Estimates they ask you about this. As we round out the year, are you feeling hopeful in that space? Are you feeling optimistic? How’s your mindset on the productivity question as we speak?

Jenny Wilkinson: So I would have to say in my role I always have to have an optimistic mindset as to what the future holds. And the productivity agenda is a hard one. It’s a hard one because achieving improved productivity growth is all about lots of little things happening across the economy; happening in business, happening in government, happening for individuals, and all of those things have to come together to deliver at an aggregate level what we’re looking for, which is better productivity growth.

I don’t think that I have been – I mean, I’ve been working in government for a fair time. I don’t think that I have been in government in a period where it has received so much focus across so many different portfolios. So when I think about the productivity package that the government introduced at the last budget, the breadth of changes which were announced were pretty striking. It wasn’t just the financial sector, it wasn’t just environmental approvals, it wasn’t just housing, it wasn’t just energy. It was actually really across the board.

And one of the things that we did in Treasury to support that agenda was actually to really do a lot of pushing across the bureaucracy, but also to engage broadly across the corporate sector, frankly, to get a sense of, in a very specific way, what are the sorts of things we need to do to improve productivity? Because that’s I think the other thing that’s challenging about the productivity agenda. Everyone says we need to improve it, which of course we do because that improves living standards. But you then have to get below that to the specifics of what we have to change, and there’s a lot that we need to be working on in order to improve productivity growth.

Moderator: So if you get there, or if you’re well on your way to getting there, how are Australians feeling differently, how is their life different because of that?

Jenny Wilkinson: So the way I would think about it, Hamish, is that it’s an ongoing challenge. I don’t think – we will never be in a set and forget world. I mean partly because technology is always changing, and there are structural changes which are taking place across the economy all the time. But also because we always need to be thinking about things like how we regulate better, how we regulate differently, how we respond to whatever the latest policy issue is that comes up. So I don’t think I will ever sit on a panel like this and say we’ve solved the productivity problem, tick, we can move on. I just don’t think that will be the case.

What is it that people will feel if we have better productivity growth? There’s a few things. I mean ultimately the objective is to deliver higher real wages and higher living standards. In a practical sense what does that mean? Well it can mean a range of different things; cheaper goods and services, better quality goods and services, better wages, higher profits, more investment. At an aggregate level it means that you can grow the economy at a faster rate without generating inflation. That’s at the bottom line of what we’re trying to do here.

Moderator: Cosima, I’m wondering how you view that in the context of the way you are covering these stories, right? Because there’s the data, there’s the targets, there’s the agenda that the government’s setting, with the help of Jenny and Treasury. But then there is the existence that everyday Australians are having. Do those things match?

Cosima Marriner: Well, it’s interesting, because obviously the Financial Review has great interest in productivity, and we really care about improving productivity in this country. But when you try – it’s quite an amorphous concept to the everyday Australians. So they keep hearing it, but it sounds like blah, blah, blah, jargon. How do we as a masthead make it relevant to our readers who aren’t policy makers and business leaders? And that comes back to how people feel, and it’s the feels.

But I think at the moment how does low productivity translate to people’s everyday experiences? They basically don’t feel like they’re getting ahead. They feel like they’re going backwards. And it might be real wages going backwards, it might be declining living standards, it might be I keep working hard but it doesn’t feel that it’s really getting me ahead.

And I think that’s where the productivity debate hits the road for most people, in the sense that they don’t feel that their lives are improving in a material sense the way they might have felt it did for their parents or their grandparents.

Moderator: Is there a particular feature of the debate at the moment, given that so much of it involves AI and discussion of AI, that people actually fear that?

Cosima Marriner: Yes, definitely.

Moderator: And fear what improved productivity means for them?

Cosima Marriner: Well, often we talk about using AI to create efficiencies, and therefore create improved productivity. But people often hear that as, that just means it’s going to take my job, the robot’s going to do my job, rather than it’s going to help me do my job more efficiently so I can do more higher value tasks, more higher order tasks rather than the boring admin stuff. I should let the robot do that. But instead they just think the robot’s going to take my job.

Moderator: So Andrew, what’s the positive story that might exist on that score? How would that look if it’s done well, if it’s not taking everyone’s jobs?

Andrew Irvine: Oh look I always say to all our colleagues at NAB, to my kids, I was speaking at my son’s school last month, and I tell people that the best thing that you can do is run to the technology, learn, understand how to prompt, understand how to leverage it in your personal life and in your work life wherever possible.

I’ve heard the phrase coined that I like; it’s, AI isn’t going to take your job. People using AI are going to take the jobs of people who don’t use AI. I think Australia needs to get a bit more balance around the narrative around AI. My observation is that too much of the conversation is how AI is going to be negatively impacting society, and there will be some and we have to have an honest debate around that. But AI also will have extreme positive implications to how we all live and work.

And getting a bit more balance is important. Because the history of humankind is littered with technological leaps and the outcomes that societies had as a result of those. And I think it’s unambiguous to say that in any technological leap societies and economies that ran to the change got far better outcomes than societies and economies that ran away from the change.

Moderator: But Australians at the moment are seeing the bosses of those AI companies warn us explicitly that the technology could destroy humanity. There is that possibility. So how do you balance that?

Andrew Irvine: I mean it’s true, but it can also create incredible impacts in medicine and human health. So I think ensuring that we have the right safeguards, the right guardrails. I think this is a really good example where the right type of regulation can make a really positive impact on outcomes. So I think we need to push into it.

Moderator: Kate, I suppose that’s where you come in.

Kate O’Rourke: Yes.

Moderator: We have already heard this afternoon even about the difficulty of this moment in time for regulation keeping up with the pace of the technological change.

Kate O’Rourke: Yes, thank you, Hamish, and hello everyone. So one of the things we talked about yesterday was at the discussion about responsible financial innovation, and we talked about this idea of a trust inversion, about how if an innovation runs too far ahead of trust in society it flips, and so that level of uncertainty and that absence of trust can make the situation much more difficult.

And I think one of the things, that was one of the ideas that came from the FCA when we were talking to them, and I think that idea of then OK if you step back from that inversion of trust and confidence and knowing what’s going to happen in relation to this technology, what can we do from a regulatory perspective in the form of guardrails or in the form that helps address some of that gap or that inversion?

And that idea that we spoke about included really clearly mapped accountability. If we don’t know, who will be responsible for the unknown outcome? Like who is going to take accountability amongst the different AI agents or otherwise? And some of those guardrails just being about you may not know what it is, but you will know that there is someone who’s responsible, and we’ll have to learn together. And there will be some changes that are really successful they’re running towards, some of it’s going to be better than others. But having some guardrails to help us all manage the uncertainty and that lack of trust.

Moderator: Are we clear on what the principle is about there being someone, a person that is ultimately responsible when an AI agent for example acts?

Kate O’Rourke: Well, I think that question goes to both recognising that to the extent companies are choosing to roll out AI, whether they be banks or otherwise, then yes, that accountability rests there. It does get more complicated when it’s an AI agent speaking to an AI agent, and so who’s the accountability that rests on the customer’s agent, and indeed the customer. So there’s complexity associated with it. But to the extent it’s a one-way thing, then it is more accountability with the company that’s at rolling things out. And it being to give confidence, more confidence.

Moderator: Cosima, you can you can observe the friction that’s inherent there in our daily politics, right. You’ve got government on the one hand saying to voters we’re the tough operators when it comes to this tech, we will regulate; at the same time really making the case for the investment that would come from, for example, data centre infrastructure. So how do you see governments navigating that right now?

Cosima Marriner: It’s interesting to me, I think the Albanese government has been on a bit of a journey when it comes to AI, and I think there was probably – and data centres, I think there was a bit of a, oh, not sure about this. But I think they’ve come a long way. I know that the Prime Minister now has a view that AI is coming for us whether we like it or not, and Australia needs to get ahead of it and set the rules of engagement so we can take advantage of the benefits and hopefully minimise the negative impact.

So that’s why he embedded this AI office within the PMO and they’re now trying to, to Andrew’s point, set the rules of engagement. Whether it’s around data centres and their use of renewable energy, whether it’s copyright, whether it’s national security, they are trying to. Last week we had the Minister talking about AI in the workplace and how employers and employees need to negotiate about that.

So I think the government’s now recognised that they probably need to lead on AI, and they’re trying to do that where they set rules of engagement without so much regulation that you clamp down on the innovation and the experimentation that needs to happen, and we don’t go into the crouch position when AI arrives.

Moderator: Yeah, and to be clear, are they rules or guidelines or frameworks?

Cosima Marriner: It’s a little unclear at the moment. I mean, they’ve obviously got legislation they’re drafting, and I think they’re hoping to introduce that either next week or early in the new year. Because it’s moving so quickly that – and this is always the problem with government when it comes to tech, that government, the wheels turn more slowly, and the tech is racing ahead, so how do you not let the tech go too far ahead?

Moderator: So Kate, you might end up with a country, a hypothetical country that has very clear policies on boosting productivity, but also regulations that protect consumers, particularly in spaces of innovation. Are those things cohesive?

Kate O’Rourke: I think, well, from ASIC’s perspective they absolutely are. We can have objectives that are consistently – we can have multiple objectives and they’re not necessarily opposing, they can be complementary. So for us coming back to that idea of trust, having a system that’s got clear rules and has consumer protection built into the foundations I think gives the opportunities for innovation. It gives consumers that sense of what will happen if it doesn’t work or there is a problem, that that accountability or the systems, the complaints handling or remediation, whatever it might be gives frameworks from which innovation can be and productivity enhancing changes can come.

So we have a Statement of Expectations that’s new and it’s very overt about our role as ASIC. It’s not even a hypothetical, it’s us. We have that responsibility to think about enhancing productivity. We’re taking it really seriously about what we do, how we regulate, the sorts of things that we do in a way that can reduce regulatory burden, but in no way diminishing the protections associated with it. Like some regulation is more efficient and effective than others. So which are the ones that are not so good, and how can we start to chip away at those ones so that the protections are still there.

Our statutory mandate has lots of different elements to it. We’re fine with multiple objectives. I think in designing what to do you can have trade‑offs associated with the complexity of it, but it’s not inconsistent for us.

Andrew Irvine: Hamish, if I could just jump in, because this morning I went on Instagram, I don’t spend a lot of time on Instagram just so you’re all aware, but I went on, and interestingly if any of you others went on today there was a big advertisement to say Muse has launched in Australia. And Muse is Meta’s new personal productivity agent for people that literally can buy stuff for you, can help book your travel, like literally it’s a personal assistant. And from financial services perspective, Muse can help you manage your money. And there are other agents like that that I’m aware of in the US that may come to Australia.

You could quite easily say agents like this will have real benefits to consumers, because it will help them improve price transparency. It will help them potentially optimise where they put their money in their deposits and savings and those types of things. But this is a good example where the legal framework and possibly the regulatory framework hasn’t also kept up. Because our terms and conditions as a bank were never made with the idea that someone may give their personal credentials to a third party agent. And so you would I think be compromising the terms of your bank account were you to do that.

Then what’s the legal framework in this specific example if Muse actually didn’t do what you had intended it to do, and it put your money in the wrong place, you lost your money, God forbid, or you were scammed, or an agent like that were hacked and you’ve lost your data, who’s liable in that case? Is that the consumer who gave away their credential? Is it the bank?

So this is a really complicated area where it’s I think a terrific example of needing to think through the legal environment and the consumer protection framework, while ensuring that at some point these tools can be used safely by Australians.

Moderator: OK, can we assume you’ve signed up?

Andrew Irvine: I did not sign up, no.

Moderator: Jenny Wilkinson, that’s an example of what opportunity there is for consumers. When you’re thinking about this productivity question there must be a lot from an economy wide perspective that’s tempting to run at. I’m wondering what, given all the pressures that you’ve described in terms of the public conversation, what are the influences that are holding you back, or that are making you pause for caution?

Jenny Wilkinson: So in an area like this we’re very conscious of both sides of the ledger. The huge opportunities, but also the significant risks. And in any regulatory framework that’s really what you’re thinking about. You’re thinking about how you can work out what the net benefit is, and what are the right sorts of guardrails to put around whatever it is that you’re looking at.

I think we should be honest; I don’t think that we have ever worked with a technology which is evolving so rapidly, and so it’s Muse this week, it’s something else next week. So we need to be very clear about what that means in terms of what government can do, but also we need to I think have a broader conversation about the responsibility that individuals need to take, and individuals of course are accountable for decisions that they take, decisions that the corporate sector takes.

I mean what one of the things that I think is very clear for me when you have a technology which is evolving so rapidly, is that we need a bit of a Team Australia moment here. Because it is the case that we need, for example, the banks, the corporate sector to be thinking really carefully about what is the responsible use of this technology within their space, rather than sitting back and waiting for government to provide some rules and guidelines around what that should be. I think that we all should be able to bring those judgements ourselves. At the same time we do need to think about what are the right sorts of regulatory frameworks that help, as Kate said, maintain trust in a technology which we think has a lot of upside potential.

I’m pretty sure that over the course of the next several years there will be a lot of debates around whether we’ve got the regulations right, and we’re going to have to come back and revisit what those regulatory settings look like. And we’ll never quite know what were the opportunities that we missed. We will know where bad things happened.

And one of the experiences you have within government is that there is a lot of pressure on government to respond to things when they go bad. That’s the sense in which I think it’s really important for the business sector in particular to be thinking carefully about how they manage some of those risks, rather than setting up a situation where things don’t go right, and then you end up with potentially regulatory overreach.

Moderator: But in those circumstances you’re describing presumably there would be competitive advantage within sectors for those that embraced the innovation first.

Jenny Wilkinson: In the short term. There could be longer term costs of doing that if you’re not embracing it in a responsible way. So it’s getting that balance right, which is going to be, I think it’s going to be hard for boards. It’s certainly it’s certainly hard for government. But we will be on this journey for the next several years as we see how this evolves.

Just one other thing I would say. I’m sure there’ll be a lot of discussion about whether we’ve got the regulatory frameworks right. That’s just inevitable that we’ll have that discussion over these next few years. I think we shouldn’t lose sight of the fact that even if the technology as it stands today – so let’s put aside agentic AI – but if the if the generative AI as it stands today was implemented across the economy, there would still be very significant productivity benefits that would flow.

So I think we want to be a little bit careful to make sure that that we continue to embrace, if you like, the technology in the way in which it can be embraced in I think a very responsible and safe way, and think about that slightly differently from the frontier, where there are greater risks which are almost certainly going to have to be managed.

Moderator: Kate, I’m wondering, because this has come up in previous panels that we’ve had when we’ve talked about technology or innovation advancing faster than the regulation can adapt, where the conversation has come back to occasionally is that there actually other there protections there in terms of obligations to consumers, stakeholders, shareholders etc. Can that be applied similarly in this circumstance we’re talking about here?

Kate O’Rourke: Yes, I think that it can to the extent that that’s been our approach so far in relation to AI. And I take Jenny’s point there’s different categories, and once it gets to agentic, and the Muse example does raise additional issues. But at least to date we have been thinking about, from ASIC, we’ve got a lot of rules that apply to companies, whatever automation or tools that they use, and to the extent there’s issues that result in consumer harm, then we can already use them in the sense of their being available.

So whether it be about if you’ve got a financial services licence, honestly, fairly and efficiently providing those services, unconscionable conduct. There’s different aspects of the rules that already apply. And we spoke yesterday about how we’ve had to adapt that idea of whether crypto is a financial product, a little bit of a different topic, I’m not suggesting that’s the source of productivity. But it’s that question about well, what have we already got?

For us when we’ve been thinking about regulatory design, because of the simplification work we’ve done, we do come back to this idea that simpler principle-based laws do have flexibility. They can adapt to different types of technology, they can adapt to different circumstances. Sometimes in situations like that they do need to be complemented by quite technical standards, like that idea of interoperability and standards and protocols needing to be part of the story as well. But they’re much more flexible and often industry designed or industry co-designed.

So getting that regulatory design that has the principles about consumer centricity and accountability at the highest level, and then getting the complementary technical piece is one way of thinking about it, rather than very extensive legislation on every development. Because you’re right, Cosima, it lags, like it just can’t, we can’t do that.

Moderator: Cosima, like most developed western democracies at the moment Australia has a pretty messy and complicated politics. And I guess one of the things I would observe from recent years is that not only is there broad fracturing of the politics, but even within the parties can’t necessarily predict where they’ll fall or different factions will fall on questions like productivity. Is it easy to describe where our politics sits today on this question, other than most of them agreeing we need improved productivity?

Cosima Marriner: Yes, but everyone, again, there’s wonderful consensus that we need improved productivity, but where you get the disagreement is well, how? How do you get improved productivity? Do you get improved productivity by replacing a lot of workers with AI, or offshoring jobs, or bringing in more workers? And depending on which part of the political spectrum you sit on, you’re going to have a different answer for that.

Also we might say yes, productivity is important, but does that mean lots of little bits of regulation fixes and getting rid of what Jenny was talking about earlier, or does it mean big bang reform? And there’s a different views on that about what you think is more effective or less effective I guess.

Moderator: And I suppose there’s also been this increased focus on things like sovereign capability, particularly since COVID, as the world’s become more conflicted. Is that also injecting it into these conversations?

Cosima Marriner: Definitely. Well, that’s – to be honest it seems like the argument around sovereign capability and national security was what really made sense to government about having frontier models trained in Australia. It was very much around we need to have this capability onshore, we need to have it for national security reasons. And that trumped the energy discussion and the social licence discussion. There is a feeling that it’s better to have these models being trained here than elsewhere. And if they’re looking to train outside the US, let’s make it Australia.

Moderator: But there’s also factions within the government and within the coalition that go beyond that and say you actually need sovereign AI, as in you need Australian-based LLMs etc, not just training.

Cosima Marriner: Well, yes, that’s true, and even the training, there’s an argument around copyright, right. Like some parts of Labor are very worried about what it means for content creators, and other people are like, it’ll be fine, and we’ve just got to tweak the rules to make that happen here. Then you come back to Andrew Charlton is much more, there’s no point trying to create a new LLM. Let’s leave it to the OpenAIs and Anthropics of the world. Let’s more look about what tech we can build ourselves that then feeds into that or adds on top of that, rather than trying to beat them at their own game. Or even the Chinese with their open weight models that are rapidly catching up to the US.

Moderator: Andrew do you see the productivity and sovereign capability arguments dovetailing, or are they opposing forces?

Andrew Irvine: Look, I think it depends. I can see them dovetailing and I can also see the polarity where it may be a different answer. I think it’s going to be very hard for Australia to compete on LLMs with two behemoth jurisdictions like China and the US, with the scale of their data, the scale of their AI competence and skill sets, capital and workforce. So I don’t think that’s necessarily where Australia can get the best outcomes.

So we’re going to have to look up and down the value chain around AI, and there’s going to be a lot of areas in around resources and energy that will be fuelling what the AI needs to be successful. So energy demand, metals and minerals that will help with the conduction of energy like copper. So they’re rare earths, they’re all areas I think Australia can have big impact.

Then maybe looking down the value change from LLMs, it’s around I think looking at particular sectoral areas where Australia has deep expertise where we can add value. So maybe use cases in agriculture, where we’ve got one of the best agricultural verticals in the world. Or use cases in biotechnology, where we can then have applications that leverage that capability to have really strong outcomes. Financial services as well. So that would be my sense. And then creating ecosystems where people want to invest in Australia, both domestic capital and foreign capital, because this is the best place in the world for particular applications to grow and thrive.

Moderator: Jenny Wilkinson, I mean, you clearly serve governments of all persuasions, and they often make arguments in multiple directions simultaneously. Are these opposing forces? How do you consider this?

Jenny Wilkinson: So I think the world has gotten more complex. So we are thinking more about these, the intersection between national security issues and economic security issues, than we used to in the past. So that’s definitely the case.

I actually don’t think that these are opposing. I think there’s a couple of things. When I look back over the last six or seven years, I mean Australia has faced a number of significant shocks, right? COVID, the energy shock following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Trump tariffs, and then more recently the fuel crisis. One of my observations is that we in Treasury have been surprised in each of those episodes at how resilient the economy has actually been, how quickly we’ve been able to adapt to the new circumstances.

I mean in COVID as you probably all remember, or maybe we’ve all actually completely forgotten, but how quickly we could actually find PPE, or produce hand sanitiser in a way that where we didn’t have sovereign manufacturing capability of those things. Why could we adapt in all of these different situations? It’s partly because we have a pretty good market-based economy which is flexible, which has a lot of ability to adapt to the circumstances as they evolve. We need to retain that. We need to make sure that we maintain that fundamental element of our economy. And that goes alongside strong and effective regulators, so having those things.

Now, have we also learnt though that we need to think about supply chain vulnerabilities? Absolutely, we definitely do, and that’s been very clear in the last couple of years around things like critical minerals and rare-earth supply chains. Australia will never be able to produce all of those things ourselves. That’s just not, that is not a future we should be thinking about. But we do need to be working with our allies to make sure that we have good and effective co-operative relationships, and we jointly are thinking about how some of those supply chains can be shored up. That’s really important. So I think it’s a point of getting the balance.

Moderator: But when you hear a politician, whatever their persuasion, making the argument, well, we need greater capacity to build these things, make these things here, that’s less productive isn’t it than the status quo?

Jenny Wilkinson: So I won’t ever reveal the advice the Treasury provides within government. But what we think about in those circumstances is what are the trade-offs? What are the opportunities that you’re getting from having that manufacturing or whatever facility here? What does that mean that we won’t be doing? Those are the sorts of things that you have to think about carefully.

And how do you then weigh up the benefit of having that capability, whether it’s because you need some of that stuff domestically or whether it’s important for some of the allies that we work closely with. How do you think about all of those things together? I mean for the most part, thinking in a pretty targeted way about what are those sorts of investments that support and build resilience, it’s sensible, but you’ve got to do it in a targeted way.

Moderator: So you mentioned the resilience, the capacity of the Australian economy to bounce back. But as those crises have accumulated, has our resilience diminished? I guess when you describe that, well, I think about the state of the economy today, what are we, eight months in from the Iran conflict, are we bouncing back less quickly, less effectively than were during some of those earlier crises?

Jenny Wilkinson: I don’t think there’s evidence that we are. I mean we still have a pretty fully employed economy. There’s no question that in a cyclical sense we’re managing a supply shock. Supply shocks are hard for energy, so for economies to respond to. They do lead to the sorts of pressures on households that Cosima was talking about. That’s challenging for households, that’s challenging for government. I don’t see evidence that the economy has become less adaptable to these sorts of shocks. These sorts of shocks just require a lot of adaption.

Moderator: OK. Do you see it like that, Andrew Irvine?

Andrew Irvine: Yes, look, I think Australian economy has been very resilient through some of those big shocks. To give you an example we would be the highest per capita user of diesel on the planet. That’s just because the geography that we have, and are skewed to metals, mining, big resources and agriculture. And the fact is that we had pretty limited supply of refined products on shore, and yet to be honest I think we managed through a potential supply shock really, really well.

Now we also, because we’re a wealthy country, were prepared to outbid anybody for diesel or crude on the ocean, and were buying at spot prices that sometimes were stratospheric. But at the end of the day we did not have a fuel shortage. I think that’s really something that we should be applauding. And most of us would have not thought that was going to be possible in the dark days of March and April.

So I think that adaptability that we have is real, and I think that’s promising. Where we need to work, and I had commentary last week when I was in the House of Reps, is on increasing the productive supply capacity of our economy. That is fundamentally the biggest thing that we need to work on as governments, as businesses, as regulators.

I think labour, organised labour also needs to come to the party. Because if we don’t address the challenges that we have as a country, we will not be able to grow at the levels that we have become used to as a country, and we are going to be forever in this stop-start cycle where the minute the economy starts to kick on, it’s inflationary, because we have poor productive supply, and the poor Reserve Bank has to start increasing rates.

So it will feel like going to the country or the beach and you’re in a traffic jam, and the minute you start getting at a decent level of speed you’re having to slow down. And that’s the country we are going to be doomed to if we don’t address this.

Moderator: Yeah, your comments made a few headlines; how do we get out of that? When you say everyone needs to come together.

Andrew Irvine: There are three things that we have to do, and one is we need to address the lack of productivity in construction and housing. And there are all sorts of issues for that; the tax burden on construction is too high. Labour productivity is too low.

To give you all an example, today we have 50% less labour productivity per hour of work in the construction sector than we did in the 1990s. Some of that could be very well-intentioned health and safety regulation. It could be well-intentioned environmental legislation. We know that we’ve got an issue with planning. We know that we have an issue with not using enough modern methods of construction.

But we’ve got to get at some of this stuff, because until we can build more homes, we’re not going to be able to attract the right type of migrants, and we’re not going to get Australians into homes, and that’s the dream for any Australia. So that’s the first thing.

The second thing is energy and having lower energy costs. We are a high-wage economy, that’s a fact, and I don’t think that in any time soon we’re going to aspire to want to be winning on a global basis because we’re a cheap labour economy. But when you’re a high wage economy, to then also be a high energy economy is problematic. And so we need to be a country that has low cost, reliable and I think also renewable energy. Those things are not inconsistent, we just need way more of it than we have today.

Then the third thing that we need to do is we need to unleash the private sector. In the last decade far too many jobs have been created in the public sector, and far too few jobs have been created in the private sector. And it’s the private sector that drives the dynamism in a country. It’s private sector that creates wealth. It’s the private sector that pays taxes.

So thinking about what are the things that we’re doing that make it hard for businesses to scale, to grow and to be successful. And anything that gets in those ways I think we need to prosecute the why, and what is it that’s getting in the way? And we’re Australia’s business bank, we have more than a million business customers. When I talk to them up and down the country, to a person they would say, we make it too hard for business people to be successful.

Moderator: When you talk to Premiers or Commonwealth politicians and you talk about that, I assume you talk about payroll tax as one example, do they tell you a different thing privately to what they say publicly about that?

Andrew Irvine: I think everybody today understands this as an existential issue, and that’s a real positive. Because I don’t think that this was viewed unilaterally amongst all levels of government as importantly as it actually is, and I think today everyone gets it. The challenge then is what to do about it. Because some of the things that you’re going to have to do about it might not actually be popular.

I’ll give you an example. What ultimately is productivity? Productivity is working smarter and/or working harder. Now working harder is likely not something that sells well to a democratic population. But it’s unambiguously true that if we all worked a little bit harder Australia would be more productive.

So then what are the things that we could do to work smarter, so that we actually increase the quantum of output per hour worked? And that’s more capital investment, more automation, working together with our very smart talented people. It’s getting rid of friction. It’s having more appetite for opportunity, for business, or for positive outcomes.

Moderator: Cosima; easy.

Cosima Marriner: Yeah, totally.

Moderator: Because, I mean, that that can all be delivered, right?

Cosima Marriner: Well, I think there has to be appetite, and I think it goes back to what I said earlier. To Andrew’s point about unleashing the private sector, like we do need this. Like productivity, often we blame the government and say you need to do this that and the other, but that’s 50% of the story. The other 50% is business, right. So we have to get the settings right, that then unleash the private sector. And that might include a bit of tax reform, it might include a bit of tax incentives to get them to lean in as much. Because business investment has been waning, so it’s not just a regulation.

I think probably it feels that we’ve got to a point of being a little bit over-regulated in this country. Planning approvals is the perfect example, which gets in the way of house building, data centres, etc. Energy projects as well are really held up, and that’s why our energy transition is stuttering a little bit at the moment.

So you’ve got to get both sides happening, and it’s good that I think in very recent times we’re starting to see more business leaders like Andrew stand up and say there’s a role we have to play, as much as there’s a role that policymakers and government have to play. But you can’t have one without the other they both have to be working towards that, and with a very concrete view of what needs to be done and actually enacting it.

And as Andrew said, some of these things can be unpopular, and then it comes back to the government to make the case for it, and with the help of business leaders as well, making the case to the broader population about why these things need to change, and making it real to people about how their lives are going to improve.

Moderator: Kate, do you want to respond to the bit about the point of over-regulation, at the point of over-regulation?

Kate O’Rourke: Well, I think the planning example makes it easy for me to rebut on that one. Energy regulation, sorry, that’s not us either. But it is about, we talked a little bit about how you do design for new regulation, but I think it’s also about how we administer existing regulation, and look for opportunities to take out the sufficient ones that I referred to earlier. So that continual process not just of engaging with the new issues, but also engaging with our settings to get the burden down without compromising any of the objectives.

But I also think it’s a mindset about how we administer it. So Sarah’s talked about us as a regulator being easier to deal with – harder to avoid, we can leave that for the moment. But being easier to deal with is for our team members thinking about to the extent businesses are just doing the right thing or going about the business, like getting a licence or registering their company, the things that we do do, how can we make that easier? Like what’s really annoying about what we do? Let’s change that. So it’s a mindset about how we apply the regulations that we do have, as well as how we think about best designing new ones.

Moderator: Are there particular features of it that you’re thinking about when you describe that, the annoying bits?

Kate O’Rourke: Oh yeah, we did this simplification project, and so we did make it a very open process. So we had roundtables, we’re like, how are we the most annoying? Gosh, we had some good, we had lots of suggestions. Anyway, so no, they really were.

Moderator: What’s stakeholder engagement? How are we annoying?

Kate O’Rourke: Yeah, that’s what we did. And people were really – it was constructive. They’re like, can we please email you things instead of posting them to you? We’re like, yes. Can we please use an electronic signature instead of a wet signature? Yes. So look, some of these examples are smaller, we’ve talked about them, but there are bigger ones as well. And it’s a mindset, it’s an open mind.

Moderator: When we talked about annoying, Andrew put his hand up, so I assume that –

Kate O’Rourke: Have you got an idea?

Andrew Irvine: I was just thinking – it’s not an idea, it’s well trodden ground. But a good example, we often talk about productivity from a labour productivity perspective, and I think primarily the opportunity is in that space. But there are areas in the productivity of capital that I think are also worth public policy discussion and debate. And again, there’s probably no right or wrong answer here, this is a setting question.

So Australia has what’s called an unquestionably strong framework around capital settings. and so we are if not the highest, one of absolutely on top three most highest capital jurisdictions in the world for banks in terms of containing capital.

To give you an example, if went to the other side of the spectrum, the US is probably the loosest. If NAB was a US bank, we could lend 50% more money for the same amount of capital that we have today. And then therefore think about well, what consequence would that have on this economy? 50% more lending without one extra dollar of capital. I think it would be significant.

Now, it’s not consequence free. The reason banks hold capital is to protect depositors. And an Australian bank hasn’t gone bankrupt in 100 years, like a very, very long time. In the US banks get bankrupt kind of all the time.

Moderator: You’re not making the case for it?

Andrew Irvine: I’m in no way making a case for it. My point being though, maybe a conversation should be had to say, well, do we have to be the most conservative in the entire world? What about being at the 90th percentile? Do we like that setting? What about being at the 80th percentile? What about being at the 75th percentile of global market peer groups? Is that setting the right balance between conservatism and protecting depositors, versus being able to lend on the margin a little bit more?

I certainly don’t think I would want to be America. They’re a much bigger capital market than we are, and I think there’s a lot to be said for having a safe and sound banking institution.

Moderator: I was going to say, couldn’t you also argue in in moments of stress in the global economy that that certainty within a banking system has meant that Australia’s built a reputation as a reliable and safe destination for investment?

Andrew Irvine: Totally, totally. And if Australia and Australians think the setting that we have is actually the right one for us, then fantastic, great. But there are there are benefits and consequences from every setting. And having clarity around is this the right setting for us at this time I think is a worthy set of conversations to be having.

Moderator: Jenny Wilkinson, there was a very interesting case made earlier by Andrew about a range of different things that could be done to improve productivity. When you listen to it like that, amazing, simple. Why doesn’t government just get on and do it, because we talk about it so much?

Jenny Wilkinson: Well, some of the things that Andrew was talking about are things that businesses need to do. Some of the things are things that government can do. Some of the things are things that regulators need to do. So this is where I say you want to think about the system as a whole.

I certainly think that there are always opportunities to think about how you can regulate better. And one of the challenges that’s been thrown out to in fact regulators across all sectors over this past year, has been to think about how you can deliver the outcomes that we’re looking for you to deliver, that government wants you to deliver, but at a lower regulatory burden. And that’s been a very active discussion amongst regulators including – I think the Treasurer actually spoke about it yesterday – a lot of different ideas actually about what they have within their gift to do, to change.

Within my own portfolio, I mean, there are things that we are doing around things like foreign investment screening, to really be very clear about what are the sort of applications we get which are low risk, which should be able to be approved very quickly. And from 1 January next year the aim is that low risk applications will be approved within 30 days.

Andrew Irvine: That’s good.

Jenny Wilkinson: On the other hand we have to think about the national security consequences of some of the investment opportunities that come forward, and we need to put a lot of resources into thinking about those. So thinking about regulating with a really risk-based framework is at the core of what you need to do, rather than having a cookie cutter approach to applying the same rules to everything that comes across the table.

Moderator: I suppose if I consider what you’ve just said in the context of the broader public discussion we have when it comes to technological innovation and regulation, it seems that there’s almost two speeds. There are some spaces in which we can’t keep up, and other areas in which it’s too heavy-handed.

Jenny Wilkinson: Yes, and that’s just what we always have to deal with. So I think you have to be looking at the way regulators are working. You have to be looking at what are the existing rules, and as Andrew said, how do you revisit whether you’ve got the policy settings right? That’s partly just reflecting how things have been set in place in the past, and whether those are fit for purpose. But it’s also looking at how technology’s changed, or what the evidence is that’s emerged which suggests that you can actually deliver outcomes in a different way.

I mean part of what Andrew is putting on the table is just thinking carefully about what the trade-offs are between tighter and looser regulatory settings in some circumstances. all of those things I think are critical in thinking about both the stock of existing regulations, and also then thinking about the new regulations that governments are always under pressure, frankly, to be thinking about implementing.

One of the things that we do in Treasury is spend a fair bit of time working with government on what the ultimate outcome or objective is, and thinking about whether there are different ways which potentially have lower regulatory burdens of achieving those outcomes. And that’s just an ongoing conversation.

Moderator: All right, I think that’s a good note to end it on. Folks would you please thank Kate O’Rourke, Jenny Wilkinson, Andrew Irvine and Cosima Marriner.

Gallery

Closing remarks

  • Sarah Court, Chair, ASIC
 

Annual Forum 2026: Day 2 gallery

Plenary session 5: Enforcement priorities

Plenary session 6: Meet the regulators

Past Annual Forum galleries

ASIC Annual Forum 2025

Download photos of ASIC Annual Forum 2025 - Australia in a dynamic world - Melbourne

Opening address and Keynote

Plenary session 1: State of the economy

Plenary session 2: Consumer trust in dynamic times

Plenary session 3: Structural transformation in Australia's financial services sector

Plenary session 4: Cyber security and operational resilience

Elective session 1A: Designing for good

Elective session 1B: Unlocking the potential of distributed ledgers in financial markets and payments

Elective session 1C: Investing: Not all fun and games

ASIC Annual Dinner

Keynote (Recorded address)

Plenary session 5: Enforcement priorities

Plenary session 6: Meet the regulators

Plenary session 7: The future of capital markets panel

Plenary session 8: Global deregulation and simplification

ASIC Annual Forum 2024

Download photos of ASIC Annual Forum 2024 - Bridging generations - regulating for all Australians - Sydney


Our people

Download images of ASIC's leaders